We tried the Elody Restaurant for the first time. We were greeted and seated quickly by friendly staff. Our waitress arrived fairly quickly and was friendly. She got our drinks started and a short time later brought our drinks over. We received some bread before ordering. The bread was good, but a little heavy and could have used just a touch more cook. The presentation of the bread on a board with garlic butter and cinnamon butter smeared on the board was a really nice presentation. While we were waiting to order some appetizers, Larry came over and explained the restaurant to us. He was friendly and personable and it was nice chatting with him. Our waitress came back over and we ordered a Wedge salad and a crab cake to start. We put in our dinner order at the same time. A little while later (about a perfect amount of time) the appetizer and salad arrived. My wife said the crab cake was one of the best she's ever had, and she orders them often at nice restaurants. My wedge salad was excellent. Our waitress came over and got another glass of wine for my wife. I was still working on my wine, but my water glass was about half gone. I moved it to the middle of the table so they could see it to refill it, but it went unfilled for quite a while. After they cleared our plates, we waited for our meal. It took longer than I had hoped for our entrees to arrive. I would estimate close to 35 minutes or more. This was a little too long. I like a little time between my appetizer and entree, but this was too long to wait.
My wife got the special which was a 10 oz filet, with a blue cheese sauce on the side (they gave her too much, it could have had 1/4 the size and it would have been enough, which means waste for the kitchen) and it had shrimp and I believe scallops. Her steak was cooked perfect, was a very good size, and she said all her food was very good.
I ordered the 16 oz ribeye. Larry had said they custom cut each steak in the kitchen and the sizes were generous from the chef. I noted on their menu that they had listed the cook temperatures along with what the actual temp is. They had rare listed as 125 and medium rare as 135. This is a big range based on my being a steak connoisseur. I don't prefer my steak rare, so I ordered it medium rare. I was expecting a warm red center. When the steak arrived, it was a lot thinner than i had anticipated. I checked the cook with the knife and it looked a little over cooked. I cut into it and to my displeasure, it was overcooked. It was pink on the center and on the outer edges it was brown. I don't like sending food back, so I decided to just eat it. I will say, that even overcooked, the flavor of the steak was excellent. I think their temp range is slightly off based on the writing in the menu and I think the thinner cut had part to do with it overcooking. My baked potato was cooked perfect and the cooked carrots were also cooked just how I like them, a little firm and not mushy. It wasn't until after I was finished with my meal that I had my water glass refilled, which was by Larry, not the waitress or other staff. I don't mind paying good money for a great steak. If your business claims one of their best things is a steak, you gotta do a little better. As far as overcooked steaks that I have eaten, this was one of the better overcooked steak I have eaten, but still overcooked.
Overall impressions: the staff were all friendly, the food was very good (next time I will ask for rare + instead of medium rare), the steak was overcooked and the service time was my main drawback to this dining experience. I do believe we will go back. The inside was a really nice modern, clean and relaxing feel. It did get a bit loud while eating, not sure if that was due to larger parties or just the acoustics. Overall I gave this 4 stars. read more