Came here because saw online that they stocked "Liquid Fables" cans of mixed cocktails which I had tried and recently liked. Bought several of the vodka and gin based cans. Guy at the counter was friendly and they were doing some sort of tasting of a coupe of bottles of wine. read more

I would leave zero stars if I could. I placed an online order for a fairly expensive bottle of bourbon I've been after. They asked for my address and zip code to form a shipping and total price quote. I place my order and minutes later I receive a cancellation email stating that it's illegal for them to ship spirits. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to remove the shipping option if that's truly the case. Either way, no sincere apology, nothing but a headache and a large sum of money tied up likely for days. Thanks Eastside Cellars for the nightmare before Christmas shopping experience. Get your shit together. read more

Eastside Cellars - order confirmation - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - New York, New York

This place is a joke and always disappointing. Continuously rude people who seem to think working in a teeny tiny wine store with no selection gives them a reason to have some sort of attitude. Honestly. There are so many options in the area, it's difficult to believe why anyone at all would even bother shopping here. Stick with the professionals like Mister Wright, Wine Story and Yorkshire. read more

Great selection, good prices. There were bottles of wine you could taste. All in all simply good! We walked out with a couple of nice and affordable bottles of vino, and a Jameson. Nice! read more

I live right next door and go here all the time. I've been super happy with all the wines I've got here. There are some workers who go above and beyond to make recommendations . Just be sure to explain what you are looking for. read more

Great selection, great prices and great people (who are extremely knowledgeable about their wines & spirits). Our go-to in the neighborhood

My family and I love Eastside Cellars. Over the last few months, we've purchased several cases of wine from the store and had it delivered. Each time it was a genuinely pleasant, easy and seamless experience. We got some excellent advice in choosing a great variety of wines, and payment was quick and convenient. Delivery to our apartment was then lightening fast. Thank you to the Eastside Cellars team! read more

Look no further than Eastside Cellars to peruse, taste, and purchase a delectable variety of wine and spirits. My husband and I stopped by Eastside Cellars recently to purchase wine, following rave reviews from a local friend. We found the selection to be impeccably curated and wonderfully varied, with a wine for every taste and price-point. The staff are extremely friendly and knowledgeable, and are clearly all wine enthusiasts themselves. They guided us until we found just the right Muscadet and Médoc. The store itself displays carefully-selected wines from a wide variety of regions, and is well-organized and easy to navigate. This makes the experience very pleasant. Eastside Cellars is truly a gem. read more

Oh how convenient right around the corner from my apartment. Nothing like easily accessible booze. Bottle Market is small and compact but well organized, clean and with friendly staff to boot. Plus the prices are surprisingly fair and a great selection of wines and spirits. What more could you ask for? read more

Nice little locals wine store a few blocks away from my place. Nice staff and decent selections with some occasional sales. Close to the video store I use so always good to swing by after picking up a few movies to watch and get a bottle or two for an evening in. read more

I have been going to Eastside Cellars for about 6 months now. This is a wonderfully curated wine store; it carries wine from small producers and from many regions not just the famous ones. The staff is deeply knowledgeable and I have always been pleased by their recommendations. If you visit this store, take a moment to speak with the staff and tell them what you like or what you are cooking and watch them guide you to a wonderful bottle. The store also has a wall of "interesting wines," which either come from lesser known regions or are made from lesser known grape varietals. I like the interesting wines wall because it satisfies my desire to experience new wine. read more

Made a pit stop here on the way home for some alcohol for an impromptu drinking session. My friend and I wanted Skyy vodka, but they only had flavored Skyy. We opted for the Skyy Blood Orange and a bottle of Svedka. The two guys working there were really nice and friendly and mentioned that the Skyy was on sale, which was a nice surprise. I'd definitely stop by here again. Very pleasant experience. read more

Although it's not an extensive selection, they curate a great selection of liquor and wine.

So very pleased that we found Eastside Cellars while visiting from out of town. We walked in and were greeted by friendly staff who asked us what we might like. Once we described our preferences, we were given a few suggestions and I can say they were spot on. The prices were more than fair, but the staff were what made the Eastside Cellars experience a real welcome to our visit to NYC. read more

Great place. Helpful guys. Feels like a friendly neighborhood store. Will be back!

Eastside Cellars is my absolute go-to for wine on the UES. Their diversity and quality of options at amazing price points can't be beat. I live near other liquor stores and consistently walk the extra mile to Eastside. Matt in particular is super knowledgeable, kind and always makes the best recommendations! This is a place you return to time and time again. read more

Just had my first (and amazing) experience at Eastside Cellars! The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and were able to help me pick a few bottles that were exactly what I was looking for. I am a brat when it comes to super dry red wine and they nailed it. I was also super impressed with the precautions they are taking during the pandemic and I felt so safe while shopping in the store. I will definitely be back to pick up more wine! read more

MY HEROES! I planned a last-minute wedding over the holidays and Eastside Cellars shipped a case of the bride and groom's favorite champagne and got it to Texas in under 72 hours - on the morning of the wedding! The customer service I got over the phone was thoughtful and kind, and they absolutely saved the day. I will be ordering from them from now on! read more

I had an amazing experience today. I arrived not knowing what I wanted to pick up. I knew I wanted a sweet wine. And I was pleasantly surprised to see such a great selection of wines from different parts of the world. I am Very impressed with the staff from today and their customer service. Will be coming back. read more

Great shop, (some) great prices, great service, educated sales staff who care about what they do. What more could a person want? I'm pretty comfortable around wine, because I worked in the trade for years, but I understand how it can be intimidating. Don't be afraid to ask questions...these people are excited about what they do, and they'll talk to you! I spend some time in NYC every year, and because I live in Texas, where wine distribution is pretty much a terrible monopoly, when I go to NYC I like to check out wine shops and pick up things I can't get back home. Eastside Cellars was a great find! I'll never understand people like Sally H. who give the lowest possible rating and engage in name-calling. I get the impression that it's the way the salesmen looked that caused her to do this, and not really the wines. Maybe the "no name" wines are expensive (not my experience, by the way), but the "with name" wines are definitely not overpriced, and there's always a deal to be had. read more

Abigail's is everything you could want for a local wine shop. It's a nice place with a decent selection of wine and liquor and helpful counter help. I'm glad to be so close... read more

This is my new favorite wine store. They have the most extensive collection of wine geeky bottles that you don't see everywhere. They have the classics too. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly. They don't just know about the wines, they often know about the winemakers. Oh most importantly, they are not snotty about it like other wine stores. I've never had a bad recommendation here, so tell them what you like and let them guide you. read more

I haven't had a wine from there I didn't like. It seems each bottle is hand selected, and most wines are from biodynamic vineyards, which is a huge plus. If you're looking for a good solid bottle, go here! I've gone through almost the entire California/Oregon/Argentina reds section and I've yet to be disappointed. read more

Abigail's wine shop is under new ownership and what a great difference that has made! I stopped in to get some wine for company that is coming tonight, but wasn't sure what to get. The staff made some great suggestions and I got to taste their featured wine. I ended up getting a bottle of that (a Portuguese red) and some Skinny Girl Margarita (it's difficult to find in the City). The cashier was very friendly (she had blonde hair and glasses) and she even had a biscuit for my dog. What a good (re)discovery! read more

I'll agree with the other reviews of Eastside Cellars. This is a small place, with a great selection and good prices. Customer service is excellent. It is a pleasure to shop here. read more

From a tourist perspective this place is great. A great selections of wine with a wide range of prices, but many were very reasonable! Loved the Malbec I just got. read more

Everything is great about this shop - from quality-to-price ratio to hours. The wines are very thoughtfully selected. We've purchased many wines here , from the cheapest $13 to the exquisite ones and we've never come across a bad or mediocre bottle. I love this shop for having its unique character. No other wine store in the neighborhood compares. read more

I want to like this place! It's cute, everyone seems knowledgeable and the clerks certainly help the other customers... But all I get is wine-snob attitude. Perhaps my taste is too lowbrow? I'm not sure what their problem is but I'll take my money elsewhere. read more

Sent a PostMate here to pick-up. They were out of what was listed on the site I ordered from but the guy on the phone made some awesome recommendations. I was so pleasantly surprised with his choice of Cabernet from Paso Robles and a really awesome Garnacha. Great wine. Great value. Super helpful. My new go-to. Keep up the great work. read more

a nice friendly liquor shop on the upper east side, 1st ave between 90th and 91st street. the place is compact and well organized with a large assortment of wines , spirits and all other booze that folks enjoy. the staff are friendly and helpful especially for folks who are clueless about booze like me. i needed a few bottles of wine for a dinner event i was invited to and the worker set me straight with a couple of top notch selections at really fair prices. when i happen to be inside getting some wine they had a table all set up for some free wine tasting from the france region and i try a bit which was not bad at all. a decent liquor shop for the locals in the area . read more

My girlfriend and I are frequent customers of this cozy wine shop. It is our favorite on the upper east side. They have a great selection at a very reasonable price. The staff is extremely knowledgeable, friendly, and courteous. Christian + Allie read more

I have been purchasing wine and liquor from Eastside Cellars for almost half a year now and have never been impressed with their selections or their suggestions. I am not a picky wine drinker, however, I did grow up on the central coast of California, and have a true passion for good wine. Tonight, I purchased a bottle of wine that was suggested by a seemingly knowledgable and confident staff member, and unfortunately, found this wine to be oxidized. Like I said, I am not a picky wine drinker, but I do know when a bottle has turned based off of its vinegar-y taste and smell. This was also confirmed by the 5 people I was sharing this bottle with. 30 minutes after purchasing, I went back to the store and apologetically informed a staff member (who didn't sell me the bottle) that I believed the wine to be oxidized. He then smelled and tasted for himself and concurred that although this wine was "racey" to being with, it definitely did not taste normal. He politely started looking for another bottle to exchange, until his colleague came back into the cellar. Unfortunately, his colleague (who sold me the bottle) was not remotely as friendly or accommodating as he was. I understand returning a bottle of wine is uncomfortable, but this woman made this experience SO unfortunate. Without smelling or tasting the wine, she condescendingly told me there was no way that bottle could be turned. Without looking at me or stopping to have a genuine conversation, she went back to the fridge, grabbed a different bottle, and shoved it at me. She didn't apologize, she didn't listen, she didn't ask me what I would rather have, but she DID create a hostile environment. Feeling incredibly awkward and uncomfortable, I then apologized to HER, saying I have never returned a bottle of wine before in my LIFE, but this was truly un-drinkable... Instead of listening or looking at me, she defensively told me I was free to go and that I could leave her store. I have worked in customer service, and know that this is not the way to approach an uncomfortable situation! She made me feel stupid for coming back into the store and stupid for attempting a dialogue with her and her fellow employee. I left the store stunned and, quite honestly, heartbroken. I love supporting local wine shops, but will never again purchase wine from an establishment that condones this type of behavior towards their customers. Let alone, a loyal customer who has purchased wine from them countless times. Mr. Wright is an avenue away, and well worth the walk! read more

Excellently-curated selection of wines! The young gentleman that selects and orders the wines is very knowledgeable and helpful and knows how to get to the bottom of what customers are looking for, in their own, sometimes-hackneyed language. I've found some wonderful Pinot Noirs here, that I've never seen elsewhere. read more

Today I decided to take to Yelp to see if there was an answer for my frustration with Upper East Side / Yorkville liquor stores. I can say that I'm thrilled to have stumbled upon Eastside Cellars, and will now make it my go to wine and spirits shop. First off, the Eastside Cellars layout is appealing. Upon walking it it is wide open, well organized, and clean. It is easy to find the section you are looking for - but hard to choose from all of the excellent options. I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff who were ready to help me find what I was looking for. We migrated to the whiskey section, where we discussed various Bourbon's and Rye's. After a few tastings, I found the perfect bottle I was looking for, and left happy. I signed up for their email list to keep in the loop about upcoming tastings, sales, and other special events. This is much more than a corner liquor store, it is a destination and note able upper east side fixture. I am looking forward to my next trip. read more

Tons of organic wines all clearly labeled! Very friendly staff. Delicious wine. Exactly what I want in a wine store.

Hipster "friendly" salesmen selling no-name, overpriced wines to the unknowing. Many wines selling for $20-30 that are worth $8.

The new management has done a great job of bringing in high quality product at a great price. The store is much cleaner and the staff is much friendlier. If you were turned off by the previous management, give it another shot, you won't be disappointed. If they don't carry your favorite brand, just ask, they are very receptive and willing to please their customers. read more

I echo the sentiment of Chris m's review...it is a year later and the look and selection have only gotten better...while those same owners are still as helpful and knowledgeable as ever read more