Excellent and efficient service. Mechanics were…read moreaccommodating and went above and beyond to assist me with quick and easy service.

Please avoid this place if you can. My car had 0 engine issues, and had a fresh oil change…read morecompleted by Firestone 11/5/2025. During my inspection I was notified that I needed to change my right rear tire. I could not afford $300+ at Firestone so I trusted Tire Guys. Huge mistake. I went to the Selden location in 11/5/2025 to get a tire. They charged me $125 +tax. Everything went smoothly. On 11/11 I was driving on the LIE headed east to a Drs appointment and my car kept having engine issues and my tailgate sensors and engine sensors were going off at an alarming rate. I made it to my appointment. After I left the appointment I drove slow and got my car home. I take my car back to Firestone in 11/12 and they tell me they noticed I got a tire replacement and I acknowledged. They told me to go back to Tire Guys immediately because Tire Guys put the wrong size tire on my car and that caused issues with my All Wheel Drive system. I went back and the Manager was not professional. He did not want to believe that the tire was incorrectly installed and refused to initially go outside and check my tire. I told him that he was being crazy towards me and I'm the one that should be hostile and angry yet I'm calm. He sent another young tech out to verify the tire was incorrect and it indeed was. The tire was changed free of charge but it didn't matter because the damage was already done. Now my car is not repairable due to a high cost. My car now requires cylinder replacement and a new engine which is not a reasonable repair. Now I have to replace my vehicle 2 weeks before Thanksgiving. The part that upset me the most is the lack of accountability. How can this shop completely install the wrong size tire on my AWD SUV and not even want to be responsible? I wasn't making it up and I had documentation and photos to back my claim. For all this I could have just paid the $300 and gotten my tire fixed at Firestone. This was the worst car experience I've ever experienced in my life. And this car hardship is now in is ruining my holiday season. Please avoid this place at all costs. It's not even worth the risk, I don't care how affordable it is. I worked with Richie and Taylor on this replacement. Richie's demeanor completely unprofessional and uncalled for.

Very friendly environment and punctual with wait time…read more Professional and I had a pleasant experience as a returning customer.

Great place and super nice customer service! I was hesitant on coming here due to the reviews but…read moreSO glad I did. Mike & Darnell went above and beyond to help me price match my tires for the best price possible. If you need your tires changed let the help you! Great people. Thanks for the help!

This place is excellent! This shop can handle any automotive repair or problem. They don't…read morecherry-pick what they want to repair like some shop do. They usually have three or four full-time A class technicians while other shops most of the time have only one. Excellent place if you have a problem that no one wants to help you including dealerships. One time I had a problem in 2014 with my fathers 2012 Toyota Rav4. The break pedal was soft with engine off and felt weak. I went to two Toyota dealerships since the car had a warranty and they said it was normal while I knew that there was a problem. I finally went to Middle Country Automotive. They confirmed that a break pedal can not be soft with engine off and diagnosed the problem to be ABS pump probably needed bleeding since it was probably not done at the factory. They connected the diagnostic computer and activated the ABS solenoids to bleed the trapped air in the pump. After 15 minutes the brake pedal was nice and firm. I filed a complain at NHTSA and I think it triggered a recall that Toyota hid under some other problem with the ABS pump. At Toyota dealership when I went for the recall the dealership techs only connected the computer the same way the Middle Country Automotive techs did!

They dropped my gas tank to fix a leak and put the gas tank on too tight. Which prevented the evap…read morevalve from opening and I wasn't able to fill up my gas tank. I took it back and they lowered the tank slightly so the valve could open. Not long after my check engine light came on and codes P0442 and P0446 popped up. The mechanic admitted they put the gas tank on too tight, which led to the solenoid malfunction. They offered to fix it for $500! I don't recommend anyone take their vehicle here. They have a pattern of creating more problems for their customers than solving them.

Thought I needed a new tire because I had one going flat rather quickly after airing up. Spoke with…read morethe owner and even agreed to buy 2 tires if needed. They looked at all my tires and told me the tread and rubber looked solid on all of them and patched up my tire that had 2 screws in it and insisted on not charging me! These guys are always my first choice for tires and I can't say enough nice things about them. Great people.

I was recommended by my coworker and next door neighbor. So I went and met Bob. He said he can get…read moremy size and offered me a very good price. I waited a few weeks went this Saturday and Jonathan Said he can have them Monday. And Bam they were there I was in and out in less the. Two Hours. The crew were very professional and kind. Good job awesome out come

John did a great job on my daughter's new tires for her car! Great price and great installation!…read moreSee you guys next time! Thanks John!

Went to this "tire" place on Sunday for something in my tire and needed it plugged . The guy was…read morelike ok no problem can you leave the car till Tuesday!!!! For a plug!!! WTF

great guy... very friendly, prices good, did it immediately.. can't ask for anything else... he…read moreeven went out of his way to clean crud off the wheel. thanks,

Horrible tire place!!! They will steal your money and they will lie and tell you they will return…read moreur money but not honor ur refund do not trust this company with your credit card information.

My car started to overheat out front, Will helped me push it in and diagnosed it almost instantly…read more It was later in the day on a Saturday, he called me Monday morning that it was ready. Fast and reliable. Thanks again!

Very great service and very nice people. cars go in get fixed properly and are out. well deserved 5…read morestars. They are very thorough, and know what they're doing and how to do it.

I went in for an inspection, UNBELIEVABLY friendly, helpful and fast. I had no appointment! I could…read morenot ask for better service! Nobody tried to "sell" me anything extra, and as a female it's so refreshing to not be taken advantage of. I will be returning should I have any issues with my vehicle. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!

Jeremy & his team have always treated us like family from day one. We take all our vehicles to them…read moreand recommend them to all our friends and family. No matter what the problem is, they are always extremely honest and never try to take advantage of you, like other shops. We wouldn't take our cars anywhere else, from their professionalism and knowledgeable staff we always can count on Middle Country Automotive.

I'm glad they were opened late. Cash only for $50 used tire... decent tire that got and service was…read morefast. Glad i found you guys to help me. I have new tires now but this one i kept as a backup. Great service thanks

Fast service, decent customer service, would have like if they accompanied my disability more but…read moreoverall decent work

Fixed two flat tires one with a slow leak and one fast. Did a great job. Will return!read more

I had a great experience. They were very helpful and patient over the phone since I don't know much…read moreabout cars or what I needed. He didn't try to upsell me on expensive tires that I didn't need which he pointed out thankfully since my car is a lease that I only have for another year. As well as not pressuring me for any extra services. It feels like a nice trust worthy small business that really appreciates their customers.