I'm not going to rave about Dusal's in Milltown, but I'll give the three stars on behalf of my wife and a family friend, who are deeply enamored of this place. My experiences there have been limited to (because of aforementioned wife and friend) the Mashed Potato and Bacon Pizza, and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Call me a purist, but I like my pizza to taste like pizza. Neither of these things do. The former tastes like mashed potatoes, and the latter... eh, neither fish nor fowl. It's not buffalo wings, and it's not pizza. It's more like a deranged gordita. Now, when I'm hankering for a big pile of bacony mashed potatoes on a bed of slightly undercooked pizza dough, Dusal's is the place. But since I have yet to actually experience that craving, it's some other place altogether. Not Hell, exactly - maybe Limbo. Personally, I'd skip it, but I'm outnumbered. read more

I was craving pizza, came to this place, got some pizza, and life was... good! Great pizza, speedy pick up, and good times eating. read more

I've been coming here for a long time, but my memory seems to fail me on past visits. It's been a while. Stopped in Dusals the night before Thanksgiving, so very hungry. Tried going to a bar to eat, HA! The night before Thanksgiving! and that proved to be a huge mistake. Needless to say, by the time we made it Dusals I was HANGRY. Rather than getting a quick slice, I decided to get a chicken Parm sub. Second bad decision of the night. It wasn't a long wait, just bad planning on my part because I needed food right away. When my sandwich came out, I was really pleased. I devoured the whole thing in about 10 seconds flat, but what I remember of it was delicious. Thin, sliced breaded chicken, a nice hearty sauce, and a thin crispy bread. I'm always worried that my chicken Parm subs are going to be dry, this one was not at all. Did I mention the bread? It was so delicious. Also stopped in the day AFTER Thanksgiving for two, quick slices. Plain and Grandma. Pretty good. The plain slice was nice and thin. Could gave used a bit more sauce, but still pretty good. Grandma slice was bangin' Front counter guys are very welcoming and the space is always clean! If you're in the area, it's a good choice for Italian. read more

Consistently great pizza, short wait time for takeout and very conveniently located!

AMAZING grandma pizza, both regular and vodka (though I find the vodka to be overpriced for just a change in sauce). Good eggplant parmesean pizza. The staff is efficient, but not super friendly. Wish they were more so and acted like they recognized us when we come in as we're regulars. But still, when the craving for a grandma pie hits, I know I just have to venture down the street for my fix. read more

Standard strip mall Italian pizza joint. All pasta dishes what we got are not recommendable - just pasta with some sauce.

I've been coming here for years on and off. The food is very good and the dine in service is excellent. The wait staff is extremely professional and attentive. A favorite of mine and my daughter is the Grilled Veggie Focaccia. It's great for lunch or a light dinner. Their pizza is excellent as well. They make a wide variety of specialty pies to fit almost everyone's desire. The dining room decor is very inviting and warm. read more

Dusal's Restaurant - Grilled veggie focaccia. A favorite of mine for years. - Italian Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

BYOB, very good entrees and the best pizza in Milltown by far. Service is excellent but the price point is definitely a little high but hey..people still go, including me. Buffalo Chicken pizza and calzones here are to DIE for read more

This pizza is the best in New Brunswick. Their BBQ chicken pizza is soooooo good!! Always a treat!

Very depressed. Stopped in on a wednesday before we were heading out for drinks at the Robins Nest blues club in linden. Never made it to the club food was so bad got into fight with girlfriend over who decided to eat here. Eggplant looked like scrapings from a all you can eat buffet,to boot came out cold then so steamed hot turn to a big pile of mess glad I didnt order that.My chicken florentine was just as bad pasta was so hard could not pick it up with fork. White sauce was like pasta water and spinich juice no flavor at all. This place has a local following that makes it twice as bad. Cheese steaks I love but was so turned off by this dinner may not come back. Very depressed. All I cant say is thanks for a bad night. And stains on shirt from so called white sauce.And trough those forks in the garbage they $#&% too. Sorry for bad review but Im out 50 bucks. read more

This is the best pizza I have had outside of New York. The regular pizza is pretty great, probably the best in town. The pasta dishes have large portions and are done well. Their penne al la vodka is fantastic, the salads are good, and the subs are better ( they get good bread). Also love the chicken marsala, they really nail it. But the best item on the menu--by a country mile- is the grandma's pizza. So good. Words cannot do it justice. I have also used them for catering on a few occasions. The owners (Brian and Vito I think) know what they are doing. They always have good recommendations on what dishes to get and how much, and the prices are reasonable. They also understand that the food needs to be prepared right and set up at the right time to maximize enjoyment. The owner sat with me and we talked about how many people would be there, when they were arriving, whether they liked seafood, poultry or red meat, or salad, and then we came up with a perfect menu. I appreciated the attention and advice. They also have a nice dining area in the back, and when we went there recently for a small family birthday they allowed me to drop off the ice cream cake earlier in the day, the waiter brought it out with candles after everyone was done eating, and they gave me all the plates and a knife in hot water to cut with (even though they do dessert in house and could have refused). These guys know how to run a business and I appreciate it. Only downside is lack of home delivery (though they have delivered larger orders for me). read more

We've been to Dusal's many times and consider it our "neighborhood" Italian restaurant. We have never been disappointed with the food or service. Although it looks like a regular hole in the wall pizza joint when you first walk in, the back room is very pleasantly decorated and makes you feel like you're in a traditional Italian restaurant. This is a high quality full service place, not just pizza. Their Veal Parmigiana is among the best I've ever had. My wife and daughters love the Shrimp Parmigiana and the Pesto dishes. The Chicken Francaise is excellent. We all love their fresh baked bread. It's BYOB, and we often go with friends with a couple of bottles. Prices are very reasonable. We'll get 2 dishes for under $30 (plus tax and tip). You won't go wrong here. read more

It felt like a scene out of goodfellas. The place was too busy for the two servers working there. Half way through our meal someone in the kitchen got into a fight so we heard the whole thing. This place is BYOB so I had a nice buzz going which helped since we got our food a little late. So the quality of the food is alirght. The portions are big but the foods was not extrondiary. It was just like regular around the corner type of food. read more

I recently had Dusal's cater an event for an organization to which I belong. We only ordered a 6 foot sub and 10 pizzas but from my first stop there to the night of the delivery everything was great. When I originally inquired about the catering menu someone came out to speak to me. When I placed my order it was easy and pleasant. The food arrived on time and everyone enjoyed it - there was nothing left! I will definitely use them again. read more

Great pizza with a lot of variety. Staff is friendly, and prices are pretty reasonable. Definitely a cut above a hole in the wall pizza parlor, I recommend the quesadillas Italiano, which is out of this world tasty. read more

What a surprise! A little pizza joint in the front and a full dining room in the back. Food is good, service is good, AND it's a BYOB. If you ever need a place to stop by for a quick slice of pizza or delicious hot lasagna-- go here. Did I mention the huuuuge portions? read more

I'm a HUGE fan of their grandma pies and the eggplant parm pies. The crust is just enough crunch and just enough chewy. The sauce and cheese is so good we end up stopping here for an 'appetizer pizza slice' on our way to dinner... Or on our way home we stop here for a 'dessert pizza slice' ... Lol. The guys who work there are also very friendly :) read more

Have been going here since my college days and even order catering for my work events. The grandma pizza is to die for, the vodka one is amazing and so is the white pie! It's the old school pizza taste that is not too common anymore! Friendly service and I encourage all my friends and colleagues to eat here! read more

This place is my second home. I love the food. I eat two loaves of bread and garlic knots with my Chicken Marsala and leave stuffed. Love it here. Now I am hooked on the grilled chicken salad or the Chicken Portebella. read more

This area has an overabundance of Italian eateries. I would have to say this is my go to place and has been since it was opened in 1983 (or '84). I have seen it change hands over the years, but the food has been consistent. Rarely eat in, but seating is adequate. Typically take out. I pass at least 3 other pizzerias on the way, just because, in my opinion, I think is the best. read more

Since I just moved to the area, I've been casting about for my new favorite quick Italian/Pizza place. Dusal's is it. Great pizza, and very good lunch/dinner choices, including pasta, subs, etc. The front of the place is a little minimal, but when I'm there for dinner, I go to the dining room in the back. A bit quieter, and very nice service! read more

I ordered a grilled chicken salad that took awhile to get to my office. By the time it did get here it was wilted and not really attractive to eat. There had been significant traffic and back up in the New Brunswick area I assume. I called them on it and they had the best customer service. They replaced my meal within 10 minutes. I really appreciate their expressiveness in trying to make my order right because things do happen. I ended up getting a Chicken Ceasar wrap that was AMAZING. Thanks for taking the time to fix this for your customer in a NICE and RESPECTFUL way. read more

Food was pre-cooked, quite disgusting. I ordered a lasagna and the pasta was hard inside, the meat was pale as it was sitting in the freezer for too long and it was also too watery. Service was average. I will never go back. read more

Looking for a quick dinner on our way to an evening soccer game, we stumbled across Desal's. Only looking for slices, but the barbecue and margarita slices that I had were very good. My son's plain slice was fine, too. The staff was very friendly and respectful. I would come here again, but it is almost an hour from my house. read more

I have to say staff is very nice and food is really, when I go there I always get the Chicken Ala Dusal over spaghetti which is delish never disappointed when I go :) read more

Best pizza in the Milltown area. A littlI pricey, but so worth it. The crust is thin and delicious. Really good white pizza too. Only been in the back for italian food once but my meal was great and the price was right. Wish they had delivery. read more

I miss NJ pizza so when I came back to visit my dad brought me here said its been around for awhile and the pizza is great! It was! Best pizza I had in NJ everything was perfect! Wish I could have a slice now.... read more

The eggplant parm sub was two generous scoops of sauce away from something delicious. The eggplant was tender and ample. The bread met the perfect combination of softness and chew - a great platform to carry a heavy filling. However, the sauce was lacking. The little given was immediately absorbed by the ample bread. I could tell it had great depth of flavor with perfect seasoning. It was disappointingly close to what I was looking for. Please don't skimp on the sauce as I literally scraped it from the bread with my teeth. read more

This review will only get 4 stars simply because it is based solely on their pizza. I have not explored the menu or eaten in their dining room yet but when I do I will be sure to update. Simply put, this is very good pizza. I worked in a pizzeria from the ages of 16-23 so it's something I feel I am a qualified authority in. Dusal's is extremely consistent. The sauce is flavored well without being too sweet or bitter. The cheese is always good quality. What a lot of people don't know is that cheese prices fluctuate so heavily throughout the year that many pizza places will just buy according to cost rather than paying more for the same cheese they usually use. I do not know for a fact if Dusals uses the same ingredients but if I had to take an educated guess I would say that it is they key to their consistency. Also, the owner was s loyal patron of the place I worked at before he had this place and he doesn't seem the type to cut corners or sacrifice quality of his product. The regular pizza like I said is phenomenal. Always on point. The Sicilian pizza though is probably one of the best Sicilians I have ever had. Everything about it was right on. The rise and airiness of the dough, the amount of cheese, the abundance of sauce... I was really impressed. My girlfriend loves their calamari and I must agree. It is fantastic. Not soggy or greasy which is a good indication that they change the fryer oil regularly which many places will neglect to do. The ratio of tentacles (my favorite) to rings ( hers) is good too. I am going to make it a point to eat in the dining room soon. Trust me though, the pizza will not disappoint. Also, the slices on the counter are delicious too. The Grandma varieties are awesome. One small criticism. The Sicilian they slice up for the counter is cut in 12s like it is to go. I prefer that it is cut into 9 even if I have to pay a little extra. I feel like a fatty when I order 4 slices lol. Otherwise you can't go wrong with Dusals. read more

We've been ordering pizza here now for a few months. It's the best in the Milltown-East Brunswick area. I could eat just their plain pizza and nothing else. A little more expensive, and they don't have delivery, but it's so worth it for the incredible increase in quality you get with their pizza as compared to other local pizza places. Would be back! read more

We just left the pizza restaurant. Although we love their grandma pie we felt that something was different not the usual pie maker. We ordered our pie and sat down. there wAs 2 women at counter chit chatting behind counter. We waited 40 minutes & finally interrupted their conversation only to find out they never made the pie. Needless say we left. I guess it was more important talking to friends than taking care of customers. read more

Vito, Brian & the rest of the Dusals staff helped to make our daughter's graduation party fun and easy. Our guests complimented the food, service and beautiful party space. I highly recommend Dusals for lunch, dinner & your next event. Looking forward to more great food & celebrating the class of 2018 at Dusals. read more

Love, love, love the food. We have itv delivered. Two stars because the web application sucks. Had a good size dinner order ready to go and could not order because of a password issue. I reset it three times and still would not go through. Had issues twice before in the past month when it takes paypal but order never went through. Ordering dominoes. read more

Dusal's was one of the first pizzerias I went to when I moved to town. I've tried all the others but I always come back to Dusal's. I can always count on them to make a great pie. Their specialty slices are very well made and are excellent as a lunch meal. They have a nice big flat screen tv and a quiet side area away from the commotion at the door/register. I'm just surprised that they don't deliver. Oh well, still worth the drive. read more

Have only tried thin crust Brooklyn Pizza and it's the best. It is pricy but very tasty. The pie is large and can easily feeds 4 people

Amazing Food!!!! Eggplant was so tender I was able to eat it days after a dislocated jaw. Love!!!!

I went it with my family and it was absolutely amazing. The food was great, the prices were awesome, and Vito, the owner, is by far one of the nicest people I've every met!! read more

This is the goto neighborhood Italian pizzeria for sure. Very consistent food and the service is always friendly. The owners are great guys looking to provide a great meal for a very fair price. Best pizza in town by far. read more

Best pizza this side of town. Try the garlic knot sliders.

Good pizza and take out but diner menu lacking quality.Just average meals that you find in most shopping center pizza places.