Highly recommend this place!! More ppl need to come here! - Great price - Great pizza!!! - HUGE portions! I came to this shopping plaza for a dance class nearby and spotted this pizza place with the same name as a great pizzeria in Staten Island that I have a soft spot for. Brought my partner here and I'm so glad we came!! There's a handful of fun arcade games as soon as you walk in and the ambiance in here is so delightfully and whimsical while still being very intimate. I really miss visiting casual spaces like this with friends and I think more people should find spaces like this to hang out and help support small businesses! We grabbed a slice each from the display case and were so pleasantly surprised by how HUGE the slices were! We were even happier with how delicious our food was! The crust was perfection and my barbecue chicken slice was so good that both my bf and I were gushing over how good it was. An even bigger surprise was that our dine-in pizza was only $8 for both of our slices which feels like an experience out of 2014. When we visited they had around 8-10 options in the display case. I wouldve liked to have had a few more options but I'm also SO happy with the choice I made in the end. They have some really interesting deluxe pizzas like a chicken Francese pizza and a mango Habanero one so I'm positive this won't be our last visit! read more

See all

Just ordered fries and mozzarella sticks. The have regular mozzarella sticks but they gave me Buffalo mozzarella sticks. . Combining Buffalo sauce, cheese and marinara sauce-- why didn't I think of this before-- so freaking delicious. The fries-- they were crunchy but fluffiness inside-- like eating a fried jiggypuff -- and savory. I can't wait to try their other food read more

Nunzio’s - Buffalo mozzarella sticks - Italian Near Me - Spotswood, New Jersey

See all

2nd time ordering from here and honestly my last. Food was not what I expected. Large plain pizza with extra cheese was a sloppy joloppy and the sauce was watered down. Wasn't thrilled. The marinara sauce was watered down too that came with the garlic bread. They don't even have garlic knots on their menu. read more

See all

My family decided to try this new pizza spot for delivery. The pizza is good, but very rich. My mother and I tried their Monty speciality pie, and my is it a lot. My father liked his tortellini despite the enormous portion. It is big enough for both a lunch and a dinner over the course of two days! Next time we will try a plain round pie to compare to their speciality pies. I would also like to try their Neapolitan pie as I am always down for a Neapolitan pie. We will likely be ordering here again. read more

First & last time ordering from here. I ordered directly from their website for delivery. They omitted an order of curly fries and when I called and asked about it, they said they ran out. If you run out, call the customer to let them know before you deliver so maybe they can pick something else. They were so rude about this whole situation and told me they would deliver me regular fries, which still do not cost the same, and still did not deliver them. Ultimately I am the one who lost money & they lost my respect. For the food, the pizza was ok. I like mine a little more well done. This has a major "flop". My son loves the chicken fingers. Wings were good also. Anyway - poor customer service and first time experience. Will stick to my other regular local pizza places. read more

I'm so happy that this is run by the same owner as Nunzio's 2 as we were in love with their pizza and were shop disappointed when they shut down their restaurant on Old Forge. When we received the menu in the mail with the same name, we just had to try it out. We were pleasantly surprised to find out it was them and we placed a large order of pizza, wings, and pasta. Everything was just as before. Their pizzas are so good, our favorite being the pizza with fresh garlic. One thing to keep in mind though, or at least for now during the covid19 time period, that it might take an hour to receive your order. They are super busy right now. So plan accordingly. The last 2 times we ordered, it took at least an hour. But definitely worth the wait. read more

I walked into Nunzio's and the tv volume was so loud I could barely hear myself think however I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with broccoli raab, roasted peppers & fresh mozzarella. It was a good size but the bread was stale and they put spinach on instead of rapini so will not be going back. read more

We now live in North Carolina and came to town for a wedding. We had to get our fix of NY style pizza and were not disappointed! All 4 slices were awesome. The crust was crispy and had a great texture! The sauce had a very nice flavor, and cheese was perfect. The atmosphere is that of your usual pizza parlor. The service was very good and everyone was very nice. If it is pizza you desire don't pass this place up. read more

Nunzio’s - 2 regular slices, 1 Sicilian and 1 Vodka sauce. - Italian Near Me - Spotswood, New Jersey

the best pizza!!!!!!!customer service is super. i take it to go. the owner is very nice and remembers you. try it .

So now I'm convinced they only have cheddar poppers, because I ordered cream cheese again, and again cheddar came. The wings I ordered were sloppy and soggy. Also, I ordered off grubhub and the pizza was delivered with all the cheese and toppings slid to one side of the pizza. I know that is on the driver, but writing this update will remind me that it can happen with this pizza so I don't order it again and run that risk. read more

This is the same restaurant that used to be in Helmetta on Old Forge Rd. I am so happy that he opened at another location! We absolutely loved the original place. The food is still the same, amazing! We had the broccoli Stromboli, which was huge, enough to feed two to three people. Chicken Cesar salad was enough for two, so much chicken. The wraps are huge as well. And my favorite, disco fries and fried mushrooms. Can't wait until the quarantine is over so I can go in and talk to the owner. We will definitely order from here again! read more

The staff needs to be retrained. My niece and wife ordered a whole fat sub and a bleu cheese burger through the Slice app and instead got half a sub and a burger with American cheese. When called out on it by the people at Slice and the staff said that the order was correct and basically insinuated that my niece was a liar. That's a great way to lose repeat customers. read more

Our party of 6 stopped in last night around 5:30pm. It was super quiet in there & we were a bit concerned that the service & food would not be too good. Well we were totally wrong!! The food was so good! Delicious, hot, fresh & good sized portions. The fried calamari was so good! We will definitely be back! read more

Just tried this place for the first time and it is amazing!! It is definitely my new pizzeria. The Monty pizza and the pepperoni pizza is a must try. The staff is so kind and made my day. Highly recommend this place for anyone who enjoys fresh tasting pizza. I cannot wait to try more things from here! read more

Nunzio’s - Monty Pizza - Italian Near Me - Spotswood, New Jersey

See all

Great Restaurant, Great Service , and Great food. They have a variety of everything. My favorite is the barbecue wings, pizza and chicken cutlet sandwich! Its priced greatly and tastes delightful. I am here every other day and love it. You should definitely come here read more

Nunzio’s - a sandwich and french fries - Italian Near Me - Spotswood, New Jersey

Awesome cheese pizza made to perfection along with the tuna fish sandwich and the turkey sandwich. Take out was smooth and everything is made to order. Will be back soo to try other items on the menu. read more

We ordered 4 dinners to pick up at a certain time. Everything was ready and hot. The eggplant parmesan was perfect. Too often, the eggplant can be undercooked...not here..it was perfect! All dinners were delicious. We will definitely be back! read more

OMG, this is a hidden gem. We got a flyer in the mail and figured we would try it. First experience was was with pizza and Stromboli . Top notch. My son ranked the grandma's pizza as a top 5 and we he has had Brooklyns best. A few days later we ordered 8 meals. All of them were perfect and extremely plentiful. We had leftovers for dinner the next night. I was afraid that we would not have enough do I ordered two more meals. Now we have dinner for another night. This is my new go to spot. It is family owned and run. Highly recommended read more

The food was high quality and quantity. Best eggplant parmesan I've had in years! Thinly sliced so no undercooked pieces and good amount of cheese and sauce. It was our first visit and we will definitely be back for more. Mike was very concerned that we enjoy our meals, too. Good luck! read more

First time ordering. Busy or not, the order was completely wrong. Ordered a buffalo chicken cheesesteak (was told they could do this) and a roast beef and provolone sub with lettuce, Tomato, and mayo. The cheese steak was plain... fine my husband ate it. My sub was delivered as a sandwich on a stale Kaiser roll, no cheese, limited roast beef that looked old, lettuce, 1 tomato slice and onions. No mayo even. With the slew of pizza options around, this is not the best. I get you are all going crazy but so are plenty of other restaurants who haven't gotten it so so bad. Sorry, but I won't be back. read more

DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY ON THIS GUY OR HIS BUSINESS! I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM HERE AGAIN! I ordered online, and over an hour later with nothing from the restaurant called for a status, they claimed they never received the order (but I received and email confirmation and my CC was charged immediately) and I had to reorder. Another hour goes by and still nothing, call again and I am told the driver is on their way. I live within 15 minutes, no calls or anything that they cannot find my place. I call back 30 minutes later and tell the owner to cancel the order and refund my CC, which he then proceeds to yell at me that he will issue me a refund once I hang up. When I ask him to lower his voice, he continues to yell that he is not yelling at me. I said I was not hanging up until I received confirmation of a refund, which he refused to give me. I am now cancelling the charge with my CC company and filing an incident with the BBB, I have confirmation of the online order and charge and the SINGLE WORST customer service experience of my life! If Yelp would allow for 0 stars that is what he would get! read more