The best of everything. I've never been disappointed with anything they serve and sell. From cakes…read moreto breakfast rolls right up to the sandwiches! Service is great too

I've always wanted to visit this place but the hours are limited (early morning to 2pm or so. When…read moreI walked in another customer was just being told he had to pay with cash or check and I was like "ohhh noooo!" Because after waiting so long I was bummed since I only had a credit card. A clerk asked what I wanted and I said nevermind, I didn't have cash. The other guy heard me, asked if I was getting something small, I said a cookie, and he very kindly put it on his order! I got an adorable snowman cookie! It was super tasty. Prices are very affordable. I will definitely return - with cash!

The cookies are my personal favorite....the M&M are the best! My hubby's favorites are the cinnamon…read morerolls and the donuts with vanilla frosting. We don't get to come this way very often, but when we do it's such a nice treat!

Cinnamon rolls much too heavy and icing way too much. Gingerbread man was good. Prices were on the…read morehigh side. Had much better at other establishments. Tips on top of high prices,won't be a regular customer. It's changed since management changed hands.

Fresh, soft, and amazing donuts! Fast and friendly service. Nostalgic and classic on the inside.read more

Donuts are delicious and fresh! Service is friendly. Ambiance is the Midwest donut shop. This place…read morehas been around for quite some time. Hope it stays for many more years.

Many, many choices! Great smells. The doughnuts are tasty and the pies look great! We came for the…read moregiant sugar cookies! Great with a steaming cup of Java! My wife used to visit this bakery for cinnamon rolls when on the way to visit her grandma in Kingsland fifty years ago. She claims it has not changed a bit! We were in town to check out the Filipino carry out joint ( Egg Rolls and More) and had to have dessert! I hope some new restaurants sprout up in town so we have a reason to visit Heyerleys for sugar cookies!!!!

As for me the last three or for times I bought donuts thy taste like 1 or 2 day old donuts…read more Service is always great.

Payton's customer service was very poor in our visit. The way that she carried herself and spoke to…read moreother customers was by no means professional. To publicly belittle and disrespect them is not acceptable and should be addressed. Otherwise, the food and coffees we got were tasty.

Service was horrible the first lady was incredibly rude but the second lady was nice. However as of…read morefood we went at 11 this morning and they're out of 80% of their menu, even donuts because they didn't make half of it they said today, and on top of that the food we did ACTUALLY receive it took forever and we were the only customers.

The donuts here were so good! I had a coconut donut, a plain glazed, and a blueberry donut. The…read moreservice was good and the place had a casual vibe.

I love Fort Findlay Coffee & Doughnuts! Their doughnuts are incredible and so affordable. My staff…read moreis thrilled anytime they see me walking in with one of their boxes. Stopping at Fort Findlay is one of my favorite Sunday morning traditions and I get so excited when they have the mocha cake donut, although they're all delicious. Favorites include the mocha, red velvet, apple cider, and blueberry. It's a fairly small shop and they no longer allow counter seating so be prepared to take your coffee and doughnuts somewhere else to enjoy.

We decided to try out this donut place after church one Sunday. It was almost empty at around 10:15…read moream, but it filled up slightly a little later. We placed our order on the paper and received our to go order in about 5 minutes or less. Pay when you order, then wait for your name after they prepare your donuts. The menu is a little confusing, but we figured it out. Not too pricey! Happy helpful workers, and a clean store. Give them a try! Cake donut base, lots of toppings to choose from. No gluten free, in case you are wondering. I nibbled the topping of my husband's donut... don't tell haha

Kids had been wanting to try, so we tried. The atmosphere of the place is nice, very spacious for…read morelarger crowds. When we arrived the lady behind the counter explained everything to us & gave us a pad and pen to mark off what we wanted. You get to pick 1 item per section (ex. 1 topping, 1 icing, and 1 drizzle). I was under the assumption you could put a bunch of toppings but only 1 is allowed. That was fine but with small children who can never make up their minds, this could be an issue. They also have an extended drink menu with different coffees & teas. Here's what i ordered: -DIY 1/2 dozen donuts: kids picked their choices of donuts, bunch of random stuff put together lol. The donut batter/plain donut is just okay.. wish they were larger and softer. Need that yeast! Lol. -Beaker Blenders Caramel Frappuccino with added Vanilla: it was tasty! I'm not a coffee fan but this was yummy. Not as smooth as I'd probably like but the flavor was there. If you just cannot choose donut types they also offer pre-selected boxes for you. They also have specials and other fun things for you to try. Great concept for sure, just wish the donuts were better. Oh, and I think it's family-owned which I love!

Man, these are so good donuts! I got a half dozen to try a variety of the flavors. The donut itself…read moreis exceptional. Yeasty, pillowy and ever so chewy. Wonderful. The cinnamon caramel dust is beautiful. The young lady behind the counter called it Amish crack. I could easily eat a dozen myself. The chocolate peanut butter cream blew my socks off. It was like eating a "fluffernutter" in a chocolate frosted donut. Get it, you'll thank yourself. The others I tasted were delicious as well, the above two are the standouts.

I used to get their donuts when I lived in Carmel all the time. I was so happy to see a location…read moreout here by my friend. I got a cinnamon caramel Bavarian and it was delicious but very messy. The custard was very yummy and creamy. I do wish the Bavarian cream was a bit more dispersed throughout but it's still delicious. I also got a blueberry cake for later and I'm excited to warm that up and eat it. My friend got a cinnamon caramel donut, which is the OG. Their donuts are always fresh and soft. Their jams are good too if you like that. The staff were all very friendly. If you haven't been, GO! You will be addicted!! The boxes of donut holes are really good to just grab and go or for a party too.

Overall a cute idea but lost my appetite due to the lack of hygiene. We got 13 donuts to go and…read morewill not be eating them. The girls working the counter ran to the basement to get more boxes and came back without washing their hands or putting on gloves. One picked out our donuts with dirty gloves on and got sticky mess all over the box that is now all over our hands and car. The other girl came straight from the basement and didn't put gloves on to grab the other half our donuts with her bare hands. Immediately lost my appetite and will not be eating them due to lack of cleanliness.

Great fun place. Only open for walk in orders on weekends only but worth the trip…read more Note most of what they do are cake, not fried donuts.