I needed a little sweet something, and I saw this cutesy shop as I was crossing the street with the…read morewarm colors. I was looking for a brownie, not too sweet. And to my surprise, it was more than I was expecting. It was an old-fashioned brownie with the edges--you know, the chewy sides with a touch of burnt edges that we all loved. Also, they make cakes, and I loved the pretty green one. So I got a bit nosy, asking questions, and found that this is a full bakery. Yes, you can stop in and get a slice of cake, pies, and all kinds of delicious treats like brownies and cupcakes. But you can also order a whole cake. I like to say specialty cakes because they have flavors like the pretty Key Lime Cake with cream cheese icing on the outside and green on the inside. Another one that stands out is the Butter Pecan Cheesecake, Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake, or the Sweet Potato Red Velvet Custard Pie. It's truly a dessert paradise. One more thing: they cater to the holidays. If it's Labor Day, there will be treats dressed with the holiday decorations.

So y'all know umma be real. My sis wanted to take a trip to visit this shop. I looked at the…read morereviews and saw bad customer service so you know I didn't want to drive an hour for mistreatment. My sis purchased a red velvet from Shoppers Value when she saw they were sold in stores. She knows I'm not big on red velvet and am partial to the one cooked by Patricia Lyman. So to get me to purchase it, she said it's like Patricia's. The color was spot on but taste wise it wasn't to me. The cake was a little on the dry side. I even lifted the cakes to get the expiration date that was furthest out which was 9/30/25. Even if the cake had been freshly cooked today, there is no way I would even keep a cake in my house for this long. It's lucky to sit a whole week. I will upload locations in Macon these can be purchased from. I ONLY went to Shoppers Value because it was closest. But with the 10% extra charge I do not frequent here at all. My thing is you are not giving me a discounted rate if you charge 10% on top of the other tax. Just charge me regular price off the bat. Back to the cake...there are other flavors such as key lime and strawberry crunch so I recommend you try it for yourself. It would probably make a difference to try these when they are freshly baked. The review scores are as follows: My score: 3 Sissy Pooh: 4 The highest score was allotted as I try to be fair.

I have never tasted such a delicious cake from a bakery. we got the strawberry cake and it was so…read moremoist and good!!! we all kept waiting for that terrible sugar rush with the crash to hit us but it NEVER did. we didn't get that yucky feeling you usually get after eating cake or sugary sweets at all. I don't think I will ever buy from another bakery because I don't think it could possibly get any better than this. this bakery set a very high bar and I'm HOOKED! we also got a dozen of their cupcakes and they were just as good! try this place you won't be disappointed!!

What an adorable shop! We finally had the opportunity to drop in and purchase two mega cupcakes -…read moreCarmel and red velvet- and a strawberry banana smoothie. What a treat! I'm a cake snob and gluten intolerant but I had to have a tiny taste of the cupcakes, especially of the icing. Excellent quality and taste! I can't wait to taste another. Yum!

After three failed attempts to contact another baker for a request, I came to another one of my…read morefavorite sweet treat spots. There are unlimited combination choices, but I'm here to tell you the carrot cupcake is hands down my favorite. The cake portion incorporates raisins. Those I do not share whatsoever. I did pick out some for my sissy pooh. I know she is a strawberry girl, so I definitely got some of those. I wanted lemon raspberry. However, it was not available. I also purchased an oatmeal raisin cookie. I can't say that the cookie was super soft, but it was good. My carrot cakes were coming out of the oven. Omg! They are so soft and just as delicious as I remembered. No, they will not last until tomorrow. I've already eaten two. Now I have inquired in the past if she bakes whole cakes and she said no. But if that ever changed, carrot would be the cake of choice without any doubt or hesitation.

Was craving some cupcakes and Yelp directed me here. Yelpers have never let me down - the cupcakes…read morehere are seriously delicious. I ordered 2 Key Lime and 1 Blackberry Lemon. Yummy yummy yummy! They are smaller than a cupcake you would get from Publix/Kroger, but somehow they are perfect. The owner was incredibly patient and kind. I will be a return customer and next time I'm ordering a dozen!

She was so easy to order from.the rum cake was outstanding for a Christmas gift. I would order…read moreanother one from her.

Had my sons birthday cake made here and it was beyond perfect. I sent her a picture to go off of…read moreand it was spot on if not better! Also everyone at the party complimented how good it tasted. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for some beautiful and tasty treats!

Tried Jessicakes after tasting her cake at a friend's party -- it was so moist and flavorful I had…read moreto order for my son's graduation. She delivered again! The cupcakes and ombré cake were super cute, perfectly moist, and delicious. No complaints at all. Highly recommend and would definitely order again

Great customer service, delicious cake and beautiful decorations. Jessicakes is a custom cake shop…read morethat has it all! If you're looking for a special cake or cookies for your birthday, wedding or anniversary, call Jessica! White chocolate raspberry is my favorite!!

I had a five star experience here at The Sugar Mill, as soon as you open the door you're hit with…read morethe sweet smells of goodies in the cake case. I ordered the Lemon Blueberry Cake slice and it was delicious. It's not easy to find lemon and blueberry in the same slice. Now I know exactly where to go when I feel like it's time to have the two inside one slice. I will be back here again soon.

I was in love with the history they put into the business, I felt a part of a real mom and pop shop…read morelearning about how the skill was absolutely passed down on the plaque they have next to the counter. I found out about them via DoorDash maybe a month ago, but everything looks so much better in person. I've already ordered the slice of lemon blueberry cake twice, I tastes so good.. the mix between the fresh blueberry flavor in the middle and the pop of lemon on the icing both mixes so well with the fluffy cake. It's not too sweet, it's also a VERY nicely sized slice. If you're not sure what to get, I'd recommend that. The owner is very kind and you can tell him and his team put a lot into making sure every cake is made with the same level of care! I will definitely be back!

I was traveling through McDonough and looking for a small owned business bakery. I wanted to…read morepurchase some sweets for my husband for Father's Day. I found this one a little out of my way but the reviews looked very promising, and I was excited to try it. I walked in and the baker was in the back I could see through the kitchen doorway. She looked up and saw me. I waited for a very long time with absolutely no acknowledgement. I understand being a small business you are wearing all of the hats and might be very busy and can't serve every single customer the very second they walk in the door, but at that point you say "hello" at least and let the customer know you'll be there shortly... or some thing. I got nothing. It was end of day and they were getting ready to close I'm sure. I saw 3 maybe 4 cupcakes left in the window. Even if that is really all there was left, I would've bought every one she had left and I'm a good tipper. Also, I strongly support small business especially if this is a woman owned business.... But no. I got completely ignored. There was a police presence in there too and they were staring at their phone. They saw me and then went back to staring at their phone. I wish I could say I got to try the wonderful items I see in these other reviews, but I was completely ignored. I am very disappointed.

Very good indeed! Was visiting GA and my friends insisted we stop at this place after our delicious…read moreMexican dinner. Moist, tender cakes. The perfect amount! 12-29-2025

When you outside, it looks great. The girl was very helpful. I have a bad sweet tooth and couldn't…read morewait to try Smallcakes, so my daughter and I stopped by. Everything we got was soooo sweet. We didn't enjoy it. Sugar on sugar. We won't be back.

Easily the BEST cupcakes in town! The cakes are moist and full of great flavor and the perfect size…read morefor the price. Most of the week, they have a pretty diverse array of cupcakes and rotate them everyday. And the employees are always so helpful and nice! Parking can be an issue, just depending on the time of day but that's mostly due to it's location in the mini strip.