It's been around so long, the booths were designed in the 1950s. The hostess greets you and hands…read moremenus, and the waitresses know most of the people in their section. Our family especially like the pasta: lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs, and ravioli. The daily specials are also very good. Parking is in a free lot behind the restaurant.

First time here. Definitely the last. Walking in. The place looks like it hasn't seen a remodel…read moreafter opening day in 1965. The ceiling tiles look like they are ready to fall on your head. The Italian banner running around the seating area appears to have never been washed. Caked with years of dust literally dangling from the edges. They have computer screens in the booth. ‍ They don't really work. The decor is so out dated it's ridiculous. Service, our waitress was very polite and nice. Took our orders. Dinner order was a pepperoni / mushroom calzone, and chicken parmesan with a side of onion rings. Each meal came with salad. Salads up - nothing fancy, your typical ice burg lettuce, with chick peas, giant slice of tomato and mini croutons. Onions up - truthfully very good "best part of the dinner" other than the dipping sauce. 99% sure it was thousand Island dressing mixed with something, definitely not good. Calzone up - OMG where to begin. Seriously, by far the worst calzone I think I have ever had. Undercooked pepperoni, and mushrooms, all thrown together on one side of the calzone. Other side doughy and undercooked, with zero seasoning. Soggy crust. The sauce was horrible. Chicken Parmesan up - pasta noodles, strait out of a box, with zero taste, chicken way over cooked / burnt "could have used it for a hockey puck", the sauce, simply not good. So to rap it up. I would never recommend Dejohn's to anyone. The place is run down and the food is horrible. We doggy bagged it home and fed it to our dogs. So now my last thought, oh-no ! Am I going to get in trouble for animal cruelty, for feeding them horrible food.

Pizza sauce tasted like Chef Boyardee, and there was too much on my sub. Asked for hot peppers, got…read morejalapenos, 2 different things. Fries were cold. Steak hoagie was over seasoned. Generally like their pizza, but won't order subs again.

HOLY MOLY THEY DO NOT MESS AROUND. These pizzas are HUGE, we needed up with a couple sheet pizzas…read moreand OMG. I couldn't believe it, they weighed like 10 pounds each! For the price, these are a steal. They are huge and totally loaded down with toppings. They are not stingy. We got the Buffalo chicken with bleu cheese sauce and it was a HIT. The chicken finger pizza was also the bomb, I couldn't stop eating it. It wasn't too greasy and the crust was cooked perfectly. I'm super impressed and will definitely be ordering again!

Great place for pizza and subs to go. Unique flavors. Nice workers. Perfect ambiance for a local…read moreto go only spot

Fredonia: a village so small that you can guess someone's last name just because of what they look…read morelike. Where the people that grow up there know each othe, like the Bar Cheers on TV, Fredonia is the place where everyone can know your name. Fredonia and Dunkirk were a good chunk of my childhood. Mary's Deli was a tasty part of that childhood. I have since moved away and have had the displeasure of eating other pizza elsewhere. once one has sipped (or on this case supped) from the Holy Grail, all else is inferior. This is so with Mary's Deli Pizza. Whenever we come back on a trip, we get a pie and some chicken fingers along with a big cup of Bleu Cheese. This last time, during the Summer of 2023-I cried when into my first slice. It was so good! All the lies that other pizza represent became small betrayals when compared to the mightiness of Mary's Deli! The place it is made is getting older and more worse for the wear as time winds on. The insides of the place look more dilapidated each year that goes on, but that man who owns it and runs it daily--he knows what he is doing. what a treasure he and his pizza is. I fear, along with other things in Fredonia like the Caboose, that Mary's will one day fade away. it's so good that I want my children to taste it and my grandchildren and so on. It's that good. Whoever gave it a low rating is less than a neanderthal that probably likes the Miami Dolphins and is a horrible person.

Whoa.... Maple…read more Latte. Strong coffee, mapley sweet. Super good! Blueberry Cloud! Like a soft biscuit loaded with fresh blueberries, drizzled with icing. These were both so good, & so special, that I'd bet there's lots of other amazing things to try here.

Just went to the Upper Crust and got my favorite sandwich, turkey on eight grain. It was absolutely…read morehorrible. The bread just fell apart as I was eating it, it was stale and just tasted gross. The prices are extremely expensive. This place really went downhill. I won't be back.

I had the pleasure of purchasing a couple pastries at the Fredonia Farmers Market. They were…read moreAMAZING!!! The quality and care that went into the baking was obvious. The strawberry and cream pound cake (Schaffer cake) was phenomenal. And it's gluten free! I recommend you treat yourself.

ALWAYS delicious! I always thought gluten free meant tasteless and boring but I was wrong! Jess's…read morefood is spectacular!

It's an honest 12:30/1:00 PM, and that is when we start thinking about it... food I mean . …read more lunch.time. Dinner's at 6:30 (earliest) and probably closer to 7:00/7:30 PM so what are we going to do until then? Sullivan's CB answers that question. Burgers (the char broil) obviously other worldly. Also the fries are quite nice, and you can get a really great fountain soda, not to mention the sweet treat offerings (in the form of frozen cream) One thing - there is a robust condiment bar at the back, and when they say push lightly for the beef gravy they mean it. I splattered it all over my shirt (after what I thought was a light pump) and had to walk out with beef gravy all over myself. The good thing is it came out easily in the wash. Really top notch in terms of food, service, and overall char broiled goodness.

Great burgers and the best ice cream. Service was quick and counter help was very professionalread more

Poor customer service, low quality food…read more We paid for our call ahead order and as we waited to be handed our order; the employee proceeded to give another persons order to them, when they came in after us. Then said "oh here is your order which they had put on the counter in front of the other person. Apparently you don't get Marinara sauce with your cheese sticks anymore. It's an up-charge. They don't ask if we wanted sauce when ordering Enjoy the heart burn. Only come here bc the kid loves it and it was their turn to order.

Dunkirk, New York If I could give this place 0 stars, I…read morewould. I would like to tell customers to NOT BUY GIFT CARDS for your family ! They DO NOT HONOR THEM !! My daughter bought me a gift card last year for $50.00... I went to use it and it would not take it !! I immediately contacted not only the store(they wouldn't do anthing but tell me to contact the company) Well I did that and they told me they would send me a new card... They did send a new card for a whopping $7.49 !!!! Well I went to use that one and it said "INSUFFICIENT FUNDS !! Needless to say I WILL NEVER DO BUSINESS WITH THEM AGAIN !!!