A nice little joint. Just moved to the area and ordered chicken fingers and fried for my kiddo. It was ready on time and exactly how it should have been. My bride has ordered consistently from them over the years and they have been very attentive to her no gluten requests. That seals a five in my book as a lot of places don't or can't accommodate that. (Say they do but have zero cross contamination policies.) Will be back - no BS, just a solid little pizza joint. Plus pinball. Real pizzerias have a video game or pinball machine in my book. read more

Pizza was fast and easy to order. I thinks the best pizza in Eden. The inside dining area is only like three tables but they also have an outside area. The outside area is only a bench and couple chairs. read more

Eat'sa Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eden, New York

See all

I grew up near here and ate this pizza all the time. I moved out when I was 18 and spent the next 20 years travelling all over the world, and to this day, after eating pizza in hundreds of cities around the globe, I've never had better pizza than what I got here. Absolutely perfect pizza. read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 18 EAT'SA PIZZA N MAIN ST. EDEN, NY SCORE 6.2 Odd name for a pizza place lol. This pizza had a good balance of ingredients. Cheese was good, sauce was sweet, but the crust was delicious. An average taste all in all but it didn't blow me away. I do prefer Eatsa over its competitor, Eden's Seafood & Pizza. read more

Eat'sa Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Eden, New York

Just moved into the Town and wanted to try out local businesses. Got a menu from Eat'sa Pizza. Tried to get one from Eden Seafood and Pizza but was told that they don't have them ( weird?) Decided to order the Garden Pizza. Ordering over the phone was quick and easy. Order was repeated back to me before we hung up. I liked that. Pizza was hot and ready when promised. Staff was friendly. Small pick up area but it was very clean. Pizza tasted great. Lots of toppings, fully cooked and a crispy crust. Can't think of anything better. I will definitely be returning! read more

Good pizza and subs. The staff is extremely friendly. Everything is reasonably priced as well.

The staff is friendly, the prices are good and the food is top notch! Tried their Hawaiian special and you could barely see the cheese there was so much ham and pineapple! Great bang for your buck. Definitely grab some wings to go with your pizza when you're in town. read more

I'm a girl who loves my veggies, and this pizza did not disappoint. Crisp crust, the dough was not overwhelming and overall was not over sauced. All a perfect ratio to let the toppings shine. Made fresh, service was great, and pizza was fantastic. We will make the 45 minute drive for this pizza. Great job ladies! read more

Eat'sa Pizza - Carnival pizza w/ added broccoli and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Eden, New York

Food and service was excellent the chicken finger pizza was out of this world we will definitely be going back

Pretty good pizza most of the time. I wasn't crazy about the sausage on my pizza last time-too spicy. The crust is light and well baked. Lots oof sauce. Not skimpy on the cheese but not over board either. I love their mini pizza just a nice size for one! read more

This restaurant is so bad. Never get anything right. Food burned or under cooked. Do not recommend

My favorite pizza place. This time I ordered a delicious calzone with mozzarella with pizza sauce (i always order an extra one)and ordered ricotta, spinach and banana peppers. It was big enough to share! I always order my wings medium, tasty, just the right heat, extra, extra crispy. Ummm! Ask for an extra blue cheese because you will want more for your carrots and celery. read more

Eat'sa Pizza - My go to place for pizza, calzones, and wings! - Pizza Near Me - Eden, New York

Quite possibly the best pizza joint in the United States. The pepperoni pie is solid but for a real treat try the philly steak pizza with a side of wings. Sandwiches are great, as well. Every time I'm back in the Buffalo area I gotta be sure to hit this place up. A true gem of my hometown. read more

If I could give them 0 starts I would. 2 times now I had a pizza with raw dough in the middle. Last time I gave the benefit of the doubt and tried it again, raw again. We called for a refund this time and I was made to bring the pizza back to the store to prove it. Also we tried to get it well done to fix the problem after the first time and the pizza was black it was burnt so bad. read more

First time I ever ate here. We got the chicken Slovaki salad. The price was 9.20. I could not believe how heavy it was when I picked it up. The to go box was packed to capacity and it wasn't mostly lettuce. The chicken had a yum grilled flavor. Well worth the $$. read more

Eat'sa Pizza - Chicken Slovaki salad weighed like 5 lbs - Pizza Near Me - Eden, New York

We love Eat'sa Pizza! One of the best places around for pizza and wings. The pizza is always excellent and the wings are done right with a great classic Buffalo sauce. The prices are good, the food is great and the service is fast and friendly. read more

They have the best mozzarella sticks around defiantly to die for! and the chicken fingers are great I love the bbq sauce they use on them. will continue to go here. read more