Wow. Great Pizza in Spearfish SD. Outstanding beer selection as well. Salads were done very well. It's one thing to be able to deliver a stellar hot 'pie'. It's a whole other level of skill to do it with a unique cold beer and a great salad - that at least makes me feel healthy eating it. But, be sure to bring CA$HOLA.... They don't take plastic. Fear not however, they have an ATM on site. Grab a beer & a Build you own pie, and slow down and enjoy life in SD... Right HERE! read more

We stumbled across this place by complete accident and were pleasantly surprised by this unique little restaurant. The food was delicious--definitely on the pricey side, but worth trying. My son still asks to go back because he loved his pizza so much! The reason for the 3 stars is the service (and fly in the beer). Our server wasn't the friendliest. When my husband's beer arrived with a fly in it, she just grumbled something and took the drink away without an apology, making us feel like we were the inconvenience. I was a bit worried about how the rest of the evening would go, but thankfully, it turned out fine. All in all, a memorable find with great food--just hoping for a better service experience next time. read more

Top notch sourdough crust/ hint get the balsamic drizzle on your pizza. You won't regret it! read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

See all

If you are in Spearfish, you don't want to miss this amazing sourdough, stone oven pizza! It has the most unique, cozy atmosphere, but there isn't a lot of seating and it's usually pretty busy! I have never been disappointed in the pizza here, and we have enjoyed a lot of them. They have a lot of wonderful combinations or you can create your own. We had the Pompeii and it was delicious. We also ordered a Bacon Beets Goat Cheese salad and it was so so good! The staff is friendly and truly you can't go wrong here! It is a cash only establishment and they have an atm machine if needed! read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Pompeii Pizza... olive oil base, with bacon, feta, Roma tomatoes, cheese blend on top! - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

Our favorite place when visiting Spearfish but last night they were way off their game. Server was marginal, extremely slow service. It took 45 min to get our cheesy bread appetizer & another 15 min for the pizza. It was cold in the dining area and the staff didn't seem to care, so we moved closer to the fire place to warm up only to be told that the server put the reserved sign on the wrong table and we'd need to move back to the table we were at. We'll take a few years off before going back. Lots of other places to eat in Spearfish. ​ read more

Very bland pizza with minimal toppings. If it was just a bread place it would be good as the crust was very nice. Inside was fine. Spent $85 on pizza and then they wanted to charge me $1 a piece for small containers of ranch! No service as I got it to go. I will try somewhere else as the was a yelp miss for pizza read more

The beet salad is to die for! There is a good selection of pizzas (my favorite is King Leonidas) using delicious sourdough crust. Service is friendly and prompt. Eat outside in the Summer and enjoy the atmosphere that is splendidly Spearfish! It is cash only; they offer an ATM on site. A+++++ read more

The pizza is great. I would recommend calling in and getting a reservation as it gets crowded. Fun atmosphere that a picker would appreciate. Bring cash. read more

We ordered a pizza to go and it was very mediocre but expensive. Very scanty on toppings, crust paper thin. Not worth the money for sure!

Delicious pizza! The sourdough crust gives the pizza the perfect chew factor that I crave. The staff is friendly and attentive. This is a great option for dine-in or carry-out, neither disappoints. Such a tasty spot for when that pizza craving hits! read more

Our third time here. Perfect crust, sauce needs some attention. Still, this is the best pizza in western South Dakota, bar none. read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - The cornicione is amazing. - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

We stopped in a Saturday afternoon. one table was occupied inside and three tables were occupied outside. We were told by the young lady at the door that we needed a reservation. The website says reservation recommended. She explained that there was a sign posted outside (there was not). So I asked to make a reservation for thirty minutes from the time we were there. She said no, that reservations had to be 24 hours in advance. When stopping from out of town, not knowing we needed reservations and there being a total of twelve people eating at the time, we thought it was ridiculous that we could not get a table. We left and went down the road to Sawyers where we were greeted kindly, had a table and ate wonderful pIzza. Would not recommend Dough Traders again even though we had eaten there many times. read more

We got the pizza to go. Funky place with fun atmosphere. Pizza was great and generous.

Can't say enough good things about this restaurant. My wife and I each got a beet salad, and wow! So delicious! My wife got a "dances with goats" pizza, I got a "veggies are for lovers". Both were excellent! And the service was top notch, and the waitress was extremely nice. Very eclectic decor. read more

See all

The best crust I've ever had and I've had a LOT of pizza! Had to search a bit to find this little hideaway but what a gem! Friendly, affable staff, great ambiance. And don't skip the salad with the house ginger dressing, all the flavors work together and it was a treat in addition to the great pizza. We'll definitely be back when we're in the area again. read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

I talked to the folks at Dough trader today.... The guy who says it's closed or closing is mid informed... This place is open and slinging great Za! The building behind it is going to be a new restaurant... Support this place or eat bad food at your own peril... read more

Best pizza in the Black Hills. a hidden gem! This is crave worthy pizza! Service is very friendlY A little pricey but worth it!

Best pizza we had in years! Recommend this place if you are anywhere near Spearfish. We were traveling through town and stumbled upon this place. read more

This is really, really good pizza. Good ambiance, they have a fireplace inside with a fire going on colder days. The best reason to eat here though is the pizza, star of the show for sure. read more

Quite delicious actually - had a small margarita pizza (and salad). Nice crisp crust, great flavor - absolute must stop! The service is also great - super pleasant to talk with! Definitely coming back! read more

Mitch is a stud, he nailed it for me! I had to get the pepperoni and sausage pizza for $18 didn't even take them 20 minutes to have it ready walked in grabbed a slice of heaven and walked right out this pizza is absolutely delicious I can't think of a better place to go 18 bucks can feed at least two people. Is your drug? Well one will be very happy. read more

See all

We were looking forward to visiting this place as the reviews about the food were so positive. Unfortunately we never were able to make it to the food. We arrived about 2:00 PM and waited for about 15 min to be greeted and told it would just be a few min. There was only one other customer in the restaurant. A couple were taking on their speaker phone that could be heard throughout the restaurant. We were finally seated at a table, we asked if we could have a booth. The hostess looked flustered and said, " I can put you at this one". Which was right next to the loud people on their phone. Part of the problem was that most of the booths hadn't been cleared from lunch and the place was a mess. We apologized and said, can we please sit back at the table since it was farther away from the loud phone people. We again sat there for about 20 min. No drinks, no acknowledgment, nothing. Again, it was just us and the phone people in the restaurant. The two servers were standing behind the counter just talking, seemingly unaware of what was happening in the restaurant, which was odd since the restaurant was a mess. We decided it wasn't worth it anymore, got up and walked out. They saw us but couldn't care less that we were leaving. It was a very strange experience. Needless to say we won't be going back. read more

I love eating at Dough Traders! I also love ordering their salad with their house dressing. It is amazing. But make sure you have cash because they do not take credit cards. They do have an ATM there if you do not have cash. read more

The food was amazing! We ordered the Betty Rizzo & I was very impressed. The waitress was so sweet & did a great job at making sure we were taken cared of. UNFORTUNATELY, one of the workers friends were sitting at the bar talking and singing OBNOXIOUSLY loud that we couldn't hear the conversations going on at the table. I wouldn't have mind it so much if she had been a little more mindful to the fact that this is a restaurant and not a college lounge area. I'll definitely be ordering pizza to go from now on. read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Left over Betty Rizzo - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

Quaint little spot in Spearfish, great pizza, salads and beer selection. The "Best Pizza in SD" Greatest ever read more

Was told this was the best pizza in town and I can confirm this is true. While not cheap pizza it's really good. Kristian was a great owner answering questions and suggestions We are here for another week so we'll be back read more

Pizza was great! Crust has a good texture but could use a little more flavor. The service is great. Just fyi they are cash only but have an atm on site read more

foods good. service it terrible. always gets something with your order wrong. if you get it to go make sure to look over all of your food before you go. read more

The best pizza in Spearfish! I drive in from Wyoming when a pizza craving hits. It's definitely worth the trip! The crust is heavenly and lots of fresh toppings. The staff is great! Always friendly and they have accommodated my handicap by bringing the pizza to my car. read more

Best pizza ever! Came from Colorado for Sturgis Bike Rally but like to stay in Spearfish. This pizza was fantastic... our only disappointment was we didn't order a larger pizza! read more

Pizza is awesome! Fresh and homemade! Cash only is a bummer but worth every penny!! So good!! read more

Awesome pizza I did not see the type I wanted and did not order any. Everything on the menu was perfect for her so she ordered a small one. I ended up eating half of hers. It was awesome! That was our first visit. The second was just as good, but we ordered two large... perfect and worth the wait, bring cash. read more

Best pizza I have had in years. If you skip eating here you made a mistake. King Leonidas Pizza. read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - All I have to say is eat here it is the best pizza I've had in years. - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

Excellent pizza and excellent service! Fresh ingredients and a reasonable price! The menu pizzas are all very unique.

Great pizza and service. A must if in Spearfish South Dakota! Recommend the beet salad! read more

Expensive but good. The pizza is the best in town but my kids can't afford to eat there so once in a while I buy & we get from there. P

What a find,fabulous pizza and salad! Was super busy and understaffed but the gals working g hustled and took great care of us. I would definitely go back! read more

Must stop in Spearfish!! We were super surprised to see they have vegan and vegetarian options (traveling in from out of state) so we were totally happy just to find pizza and fell in love. The pizza itself is out of this world!! But the adorable chill atmosphere and great service puts it over the top. Would recommend! read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Adorable patio setting! - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota

See all

Spent a few days in Spearfish on a cross-country trip. Ordered 2 pizzas and a salad as take out. It was 104 that day, but inside the restaurant was cool and cozy. The staff was friendly. They had a selection of craft beer/cider in cans. Pizza and salad (goat beet bacon) were both delicious. Crunchy crust, flavorful marinara sauce, and quality toppings. First time having sourdough crust, and it added a nice layer of flavor. As we started driving west, wished we had ordered more to take with us for the drive. Great pizza is hard to find. But you'll find it here! read more

Such a great find! Very cute interior and the friendliest service ever. The pizza is to die for and don't pass on the beet salad. It was amazing. We were traveling through and made sure to stop again on our way back. read more

Dough Trader Pizza Company - Beet salad - Pizza Near Me - Spearfish, South Dakota