Well, they are amazing. The Corsica is worth the trip. I just wish they would update their online hours. I used Apple Map that said they were open til 2. I drove a long way. The Corsica loaf and stix that they sell in stores don't taste the same. FYI. read more

Baked goods here are among the best I've had anywhere. The Corsica rolls are out of this world. Stuff here is a little pricey, so bring your extra large wallet. read more

Hidden in the nearly norther tip of Peninsula is the Door County Bakery. Judging by the license plates on the cars, many of the FIB"s from the State Below us have already found this place! I found it funny that they actually advertise on WGN Radio in Chicago! Well for those of you who have not found this place it is located a few miles south of Sister Bay on HWY 57. Not easy to find but well worth the stop when you do! My favorite reason to stop is to buy the Corsica Bread. Somehow this "to die for" bread has olive oil baked, absorbed or infused into the bottom of the bread. It is literally like having great bread with oil without having to actually dip it! No fricken clue how they do it? Don't care... Just glad to eat it! They also have food, pastries, hard to find alcohols and an olive/cheese bar. So as you are driving around looking for your next orchard or winery to stop at, make sure to include this place. You will be so glad you found it! This place also has a soft spot in my heart because it is were I fell in love with Hendricks Gin! Bought my first bottle here! read more

Door County Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

I really wanted to love this place.... My husband and I stopped in on our anniversary weekend and got a small raspberry cheesecake, a peanut butter cookie and a crocodile bar. I also had a vanilla latte. First the good: the gentlemen working were very friendly and the atmosphere was nice and cozy. My latte was expensive, but fine. The crocodile bar was delicious! The not so good... The cheesecake was literally inedible. The raspberry was a thick paste with no flavor. The cheesecake itself tasted like it had gone bad and there was barely any crust to speak of... We didn't even swallow our first bite. The peanut butter cookie we *thought* we bought (and were charged for) was the one that has peanut butter inside... Nope. Got a plain old peanut butter cookie that you could get from any grocery store... Meh. Really very disappointed. read more

After trying it again a couple years later after my first few rude experiences, stopped in with my two daughters one sat. When asked for help I pointed at the two doughnuts left in the glass and said we will have those, but I'm going to keep looking for a second, and the counter person said OK and acknowledged. 90 seconds later when I was ready to add something else on to my order, the donuts were gone and the person behind the counter said I gave them to someone else- you weren't ready. The someone else was a big adult standing right next to me who of course looked at me look at my daughters who were standing there and didn't offer to give them to them. And the counter people were just total assholes about it and said it didn't matter that I had said I would take them. WTH!?!? I have had the most ridiculously rude experiences there! Like surreal. read more

We have been coming here for over a decade, and I was kind of disappointed to see the turn the owners are taking with it. I might understand trying to do outdoor ordering just because of COVID, but it sounds like these steps are permanent and the charm of the bakery is gone. Prices were significantly higher than in the past. We like the Corsica bread but we used to get other stuff too (menu was limited). I just came away feeling like the quaint bakery I always knew was no more. read more

With all the great places to go in Door County I'd say skip this one. We bought a few items in the store after our meal and realized after the fact that they were expired. Not recently expired, I mean the exp was mid 2014... When we went back the next day we were told that they wouldn't accept returns since we couldn't prove when we had purchased them (lost the receipt) but we were literally there the DAY before for almost 2 hours and it was not busy. Finally after some back and forth they offered us a discount. This is totally unacceptable. The food is mediocre and overpriced, and the service lacking. Don't waste your time and money. read more

Was closed during our visit two different days during the week, so we had no opportunity to taste the various bakery or food

We love this bakery, unfortunately y'all need to get your ack together on your hours, open one day a week, really??? We tried to visit you two times this year and hours constantly change, I give up, your voice mail says you supply the commercial business, but we can't find stores that carry your full line of bakery goods. Sorry but will no longer try to visit your store! read more

Way too expensive. Terrible service. Great looking space. Food is good and tasty but The cost and turtle slow service ruins it. We even bought bakery items to go...all hard and stale. Total let down. read more

While the sweets in the bakery cases looked sinful and the plethora of other items in the deli were great, I'd avoid dining in unless you have lots of time and lots of patience. Our party of 4 entered and while we had seen a menu online, it wasn't evident how one would go about getting a table. The staff was very friendly and told us about three different areas we could seat ourselves for breakfast. Given the great weather we chose the patio; which had nice, comfortable chairs and tables to choose from. The menu is minimal, but has a little something for everyone. Everyone selected drinks and beverages, though we had a small hiccup as 3/4 of one glass of orange juice was all the restaurant had left at 10 a.m. on a Sunday; a real dilemma when two of us asked for OJ! The food seemed to take a slightly longer time than usual though three of us did receive our food at the same time. The fourth had to wait about 5-7 minutes for her meal, an error in timing that wasn't explained. Though to be fair, her bread and cheese plate was excellent. Getting plates cleared and the check delivered also took longer than usual and the patio was not overly busy. I think the real issues were a lack of control in seating (if you have only 2 people playing the role of hostess and waitress, you need to limit the places you will have to go to serve those folks) and ineffective planning.(no orange juice after 10 a.m. on a Sunday; meals coming out at wildly different times). All that said, my cinnamon cherry oat french toast was very good and the Black Forest Mocha beats anything I ever order from Starbuck's. With so many choices in Door County, I'm not sure I'd give Door County Bakery another shot when I may be missing out on something better down the road. read more

My husband and I actually used to really like this place. While the service has always been mediocre at best, the food is usually quite good as well as good ambience...and like other reviews state, the corsica bread, oh my god. I recently found myself driving around the pennisula on a beautiful winter day craving an almond milk latte. I drove well out of my way to Door County Bakery because, frankly, I just like it there and hadn't been in a while. While waiting for my latte, I scoped out the menu. $20 for FRENCH ONION SOUP. $18 for a bowl of CHILI. Are you friggin kidding me? I seriously had to read the menu a few times to be sure I was reading it correctly. Those prices are insulting and so was my $7.50 latte. We will never be back, on principle. read more

We used to love this restaurant for breakfast. Unfortunately on our most recent visit, the prices had been raised at least 30%. Even having lived in New York and Chicago, I have never seen a piece of French toast for $20. We found an old receipt from 2016 showing the salmon mousse for $16 -- in August 2018, the price was $22. You can now also have the pleasure of paying more than $7 for a cappuccino. The food here is good, but not that good. Although this used to be a staple of our Door County visit, since the restaurant itself is very charming, I think sadly we will not be back. (That said, the Corsica bread at the bakery is amazing so we will continue to come for that.) read more

Door County Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Delicious goodies. The Corsica bread is to die for (buy the breadsticks and not the loaf because it's only good for a short while before it becomes a rock hard weapon). One minor annoyance, there is only one place to check out which means when it's busy and people are buying coffee drinks as well as deli stuff as well as bakery stuff everyone is funneled into one spot. It's impossible not to be in someone's way. read more

I have been using Door County Bakery since they opened. A pricey bakery but I always thought it was worth it for special occasions . Custom cakes were always so special. We make a point to get a Corsica Loaf at least once for entertaining. I understand changes that had to be made due to CoVid but this last weekend we were so disappointed. We waited in the long line and bought a Corsica Loaf that I'm pretty sure was not fresh. It may have been frozen earlier in the week to be sold on Saturday. I was embarrassed to serve the bread to guests who had never tasted it before. I wish the owners well with their new business model, but maybe it's time to close door before too many customers walk away disappointed. Sue VZ read more

Worth the drive! We went for breakfast and tasted lots of the bakery treats: cherry cheese danish, cinnamon roll, cherry turnover, cake doughnut, oatmeal raisin cookies, chocolate glazed doughnut. The doughnuts weren't anything special, but the danish and turnover were excellent! Go with the cherries when it Door County!!! And they use a real espresso machine for mochas, cappuccino, and Americana coffee drinks which tasted really well. There's a larger breakfast menu, but since it's a bakery we just wanted to try their expertise. Also it's owned by genuinely nice people that work really hard to deliver exceptional quality. We talked to them for awhile to find out more about their story, and they do everything natural from scratch with real butter!!! You can taste the quality. Take the drive and taste the quality, even if it's just for carry out - is a really great bakery experience. read more

See all

We drove out on Monday; found out they're closed on Mondays. Then we tried again, and drove out on Tuesday. Sign said they had to close due to an "emergency". So then today, Wednesday, we drove out once more. It's a good half hour drive from where we stay in Egg Harbor, but my dad was dying to get some of their amazing bakery... Unfortunately, we left disappointed, and as much as my dad loves their bakery, he vowed never to return. The main issue is the service. The woman serving us (older, gray hair, round black glasses) was very impolite, and inattentive. She couldn't care less about getting us what we asked for, and she acted very inconvenienced by us. The other issue is the prices. As others have mentioned, the prices are outrageous, to the point of actually being insulting. I noticed that there is no menu available to view online, so I snapped pictures. The bakery is delicious, but not worth the insult of the poor service and the ridiculous prices. Buyer beware. read more

See all

The food is delicious, the sweets are quite tasty. They have a beautiful outside patio with a sweet family owners. The food is great, but theres a few things with it that could be troublesome. The food takes a little to get to you, and my meal came to me at room temperature. They have one waiter. The food is amazing! But the kids menu is very small also- you get a choice of pb&jam or grilled cheese. The bakery is amazing though! read more

Door County Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

I've heard about this place but I haven't been here in a long time and everyone I know had said the same. Now that we live right down the road we wanted to try it but we unfortunately will not be back. When lattes (only one size) is $7 a piece, with pastries being expensive as well the bill for two people for lattes and a pastry was $25! I know it's Door County but wow! The pastries were good and lattes were just that, lattes very average. NOT worth $25. read more

We love to come to Door County Bakery for some amazing pastries. They are always fresh and delicious! We have had great interaction with the people behind the counter as they work hard to get everyone taken care of in a friendly and timely manner. We have never sat in the restaurant.... read more

September 2019 - this was our last meal in Door County in 2019. Our breakfast was good, but not great. The standards in Door County are very high and considering the price we paid for two breakfasts ($56 with tax and tip), the food was OK. Now, the bakery was good and the wine and liquor section was excellent. Check it out, you might like it. read more

This place has always been a staple of the neighborhood. While pricy, it's well worth it as everything is made from scratch. We always go for the Corsica loaf which is a delicious meditation on fermented French style bread infused with a heavy dose of olive oil. Best to eat this fresh and we (in typical unhealthy fashion) love to smear it with butter. Highly recommend getting this in a half load or (if you're feeling up to the challenge) full load. read more

Corsica bread- let me count the ways I love you. There isn't anything bad here but the Corsica bread is the greatest carb you will ever put in your mouth. It's reason alone to make the drive to/from Milwaukee. Once you are there - no need to limit yourself to just this bread. Load up! You won't be sorry. read more

Please fix your service issues. Your food is great, but eating at your establishment is almost intolerable. We will just get to go food from now on. Behive under a patio table? Nephew was stung, you should have picked up his breakfast. Shouldn't have to beg for coffee refills and cream. read more

Door County Bakery - Quiche - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Between a 4 and a 5. The bread was okay (3) but the sweets were awesome. Had a cherry chunk cookie that was one of the best cookies any of us had ever had. Also tried a crocodile and a cherry turnover. Both were exceptional. I'd say skip the bread but its still fresh bakery bread (in other words better than any brand sitting on a grocery store shelf). Definitely stopping here again. read more

I was SO excited to receive a delivery of my FAVORITE Corsica Bread today! Thank you for shipping during this difficult time. I've loved every visit that I'm able to make to this AMAZING Bakery/restaurant! read more

Door County Bakery - Delivery - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

We passed by The Door County Bakery on our way in to Sister Bay. Once we got settled into our inn, we decided to make a trip back to their store for a look and perhaps some snacks and let me say that we were glad we did. What an amazing little business. On the bakery side, they have fresh breads and baked goods which we sampled and loved both the Danish and coffee cake we had. The coffee was made fresh to order and was the best coffee I may have ever had. Like others mention the Corsica Bread draws an audience...there was a line forming 15 minutes before the last loaf came out of the oven. In addition to the bakery, they also offer a small deli that has a great little selection of fresh cheeses, meats, and other assortments of frozen/fresh pasta, etc. More impressive was the beer selection on hand - offering a number of world beers and a decent selection of wines. Prices were quite good. I would strongly encourage you to take a look. read more

This cozy little respite was a perfect stop for our Wisconsin drive. The cabin was made from reclaimed wood over two hundred years old. They not only had the freshest and best tasting Oatmeal Raisin cookies, but they offered a great selection of wines and other tasting treats. The staff was as warm as the atmosphere. We will definitely be making this one of our regular coffee stops--Door County Bakery definitely 'aint no Starbucks! The only complaint I have is they don't carry Splenda. That's not good, guys! Who eats the pink stuff? You earn one more star if when I return this major snafu changes. read more

This place has the rudest people working there and the most outrageous prices. I've paid less for coffee and a pastry in downtown Paris France. This bakery is only open 5 hrs on Saturday! That's it for the whole week. Their food is awful as expected as they are not open long enough to have fresh food. It's obvious the owner is not interested in serving customers in Door Cty anymore. I hope they go out of business and someone who cares about running a good bakery and being kind to customers takes it over. read more

The Corsica bread is good, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it. The sourdough bread is NOT sourdough. There is nothing sour about it. read more

Why you so good, Door County Bakery? 'Cause you is. I've eaten a lot of lunch at this joint. And breakfast. But mainly lunch. I've had a few menu items, all have been good to great. Get the Italian Beef sandwich. It comes on a soggy slice of Corsica - amazing - and topped with a crispy slice of Corsica - also amazing. Staff is great and bakery is too but exactly one thing keeps me coming back, or two, and one is soggy and the other is crispy. read more

Awesome place. We have a place close by and have been in a few times for wine, bread, etc... Today we tried breakfast and were treated to an amazing meal. What sounded simple (eggs, ham, fruit, etc...) was prepared so well we were practically licking the plates. The eggs were so creamy and the ham steak was juicy and cooked perfectly. What's funny is that we drove by about 20 times before stopping in. We won't drive by once in the future without stopping now. Cool place for sure. read more

To say we were disappointed is an understatement. We actually threw out the pastries they were that bad.....tasted stale.....they were so expensive it was a sinful thing to do but they had the most rancid taste......what has happened? They were always expensive but a treat when you were on vacation. It would be better to close the door than tease your old customers with this bad food....make up your mind about your business plan. If you don't want us as customers than close your doors...if you do than return to your old delicious pastries........I have a feeling that what you are selling are not even made in your bakery but out sourced......they were horrible. read more

Sweet Treat with Bitter Staff I have not idea how this place stays in business. Maybe because there is no competition in the area. The staff behind the coffee bar is arrogant and dismissive. The coffee guy (not qualified to be called a barista) with the Harold Lloyd glasses was too busy being catty to bother with customer service. He was nothing but rude. The bread is god here. Everything else (all pastries) taste like the bread with icing on it. Buy the bread and then go to the Market in Egg Harbor and buy your pasties. read more

Good food get Wisconsin farm one. Varies fruits with coffee and juice. Not crowded like that goat roof one. read more

See all

Yelp really needs to add a 1/2 star option. Would have liked to give 4.5 stars for Door County Bakery. Was a pleasant surprise on our trip to Door County. We stopped in one morning to get a coffee and a danish or two for breakfast. We didn't realize they had dining available. We took the tour of the place. What a great shop. Excellent selection of breads and pastries. They have a fantastic selection of wines, deli items, and assorted jam, jellies, and sauces. After walking around we grabbed a table on the patio. I had the breakfast sandwich and my friend had the cheese blintz. Both were fantastic, especially the blintz. Huge portions, almost too big for breakfast. The blood orange Mimosa was ok, but the bloody mary was fantastic. We went back the next morning to grab a pastry and coffee to go. The pecan roll and bear claw were outstanding. Their coffee is excellent. You must try the Corsica Bread. Out of this world good. Really expensive, but worth it. The reason for the .5 star decrease is the prices. A little high for what you get, but I don't feel it's insanely high. The quality and selection are really good. Cheers! read more

Posting what I think is the first yelp review for the dc bakery's new sushi bar called barracuda. I don't see it listed separately, but it should as it is rather distinct from the bakery and deli. First off, I know what you are thinking, sushi in dc? What is this place coming to??? True, but there are a lot of urban types up here jones-ing for it. We had two youngsters in tow and we got the obvious looks from a few patrons, however the staff was very welcoming to us. First the highs - sushi was good!! Truly. Very tasty. The surroundings are nice. Overall pretty authentic experience for a sushi bar far off the beaten path. The lows. Service was terrible. It really was. Took forever to have our orders taken, get beverages (including water) and get our food. In fact, our two kids were so squarely, we nearly left. Fortunately some edamamme appeared and we quickly put in an order for more. usually sushi is a quick hit which is good when you have two little kids. Not so here. In their defense, this is relatively new and I am sure they are working out the kinks. The server was sweet and helpful, just not fast or thinking ahead at all. Overall, give this place a shot if you need your sushi fix on vacation! read more

This bakery was once known for it's beautifully laminated pastries. I observed during this visit the prices were dramatically higher than previous visits, but as covid had affected many businesses, I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. However, pasties were bad - dense & some were a dough with no laminations at all. All the choices were disappointing. This makes me sad, this was one of my favorite places in Door County. read more

We love going here every time we visit Door County. My wife ordered half a loaf of their famous Corsica Loaf to have shipped to the Chicago area for my birthday. FedEx screwed up the order and when we finally got the bread, it was old and stale. My wife called the bakery and they said they'd ship a replacement out right away. This time the package arrived and to my surprise instead of a half loaf they had sent us a full loaf of the bread, which if you've seen it firsthand is HUGE. Now I just gotta figure out how to cram it all in the freezer (what a great problem to have). Thanks for going above and beyond though to make a customer happy and satisfied! read more

Very nice place and don't be fooled by the curb side appearance. When you walk in the little counter top and baked counter to the left grab your attention, but do look to the right where you'll see the entrance to the restaurant which is very nice. I'll admit, my rating here is for the baked good and we did not order off the main menu. We did however sample a good number of items during our weekend stay in Door County and we were not disappointed with anything! It all had that fresh baked feel and taste not to mention it all smelled so good. Clearly we'll be checking in here again next time we visit Door County! read more