Overall I had a good experience except when my year ran out and I couldn't get one last script written because my year ran out. So I had to go off my HRT cold turkey since they wouldn't fill one last script. Not really a great endorsement of how they treat people if you haven't given them $5,000 Just so you can have a script written. read more

Can't be bothered to answer the phone. I've called several times two days in a row to make an appointment and get voicemail every time. So disappointing. read more

I had a positive experience with my tummy tuck at Dr Donaldson. I had reached out to a few other plastic surgeons and felt like Dr Donaldson gave me the personal experience I was looking for. My healing process was smooth and Dr Donaldson called me after my surgery to check in. I'd say the only negative I had is that you really only meet Dr Donaldson the day of surgery. It would have been nice to have a follow up with him post surgery. I was also told that there was some sort of "graduation" ceremony during your last post surgery appointment with the surgical staff but that wasn't actually a thing. I'm also a bit disappointed that I never received a follow up when I expressed concerns regarding my scar tissue. read more

After 2 years of having consults with plastic surgeons all around Columbus, I found Donaldson, and they absolutely changed my life. I had been wanting and considering a plastic surgery procedure since I was a young child, and finally saved up enough money to do it when I turned 27. I had several consults with other surgeons where I did not feel comfortable. Dr. Donaldson and his team were able to address all of my concerns and made me feel like a part of their family. I had amazing results from my procedure and I have more confidence now than I ever have had in my entire life. I loved their team so much, I have become a customer for life. I went back for a facial with Manhaz and then with Tatjana. I cannot recommend their aesthetics services enough. I am even considering trying some anti-aging treatments in the future now. If you are thinking about visiting; stop. Don't think, just do it. Their new office is just gorgeous and I love going there every single time. I keep making excuses to go back. I finally chose to prioritize my personal appearance, it's improved my confidence in every way, and my outlook on the future has never been better. read more

Absolutely love this place. From the attention to detail and customer service from the front desk to the service providers, this place is a 10/10 for cleanliness, aesthetic and professionalism. Thank you Donaldson- you delivery amazing results every time! read more

I visited Dr. Marguerite Winslow Weston for a routine check up and per what was written in my file, there was a significant error placed in the EMH/EHR from this clinician that was not previously in my file until I saw this clinician. Prior clinicians did not annotate such egregious errors that has become a major concern. Avoid this doctor and practice at all costs. Currently weighing legal options against this practitioner and practice. These mistakes should never happen and is a direct result of failure to pay attention and rushing. Recommendation: Revoke/suspend medical license. read more

THANK YOU to Dr.Donaldson & team for making my experience better than I could have ever imagined! I had a breast augmentation June of 2020 and the entire process was easy, empowering & professional. I had been incredibly self-conscious about my body for years and always dreamed of being able to get a breast augmentation. When the time was finally right, I was still very nervous! Dr.Donaldson & his team of fabulous nurses made me feel SO comfortable. They are incredibly professional, kind, and my biggest "hype girls." I genuinely loved going to all of my appointments at his office. Everyone working there made me feel SO confident and put my mind at ease. Not to mention, the office itself is beautiful! The surgery itself was quick & perfectly executed. Recovery was so much easier than I anticipated (but just as easy as they assured me it would be). My scarring is SO minimal and not even noticeable in most circumstances. He truly is the best of the best! I am so thankful I had such a positive plastic surgery experience. Thank you, Dr. Donaldson & team, for instilling so much confidence in me! I will genuinely miss coming into the office and conversing with the intelligent, kind & empowering professionals that work in this office! I can not recommend Donaldson Plastic Surgery enough! We also found the pricing to be very fair for the work that was done. His quote was slightly higher than others in the area but his work was noticeably better than the rest! It was definitely worth the extra money. All post-op appointments, scar creams, etc. were included in the surgical cost. Once I paid for surgery, I never had to worry about swiping my card again! All appointments were solely focused on my healing & personal experience ! read more

See all

I had 2 previous gynecomastia/vaser lipo surgeries at another clinic and the surgeon missed fat while doing lipo. So I decided to give Dr Donaldson a visit. I was really confused by my consultation. Because when I flex and I have a lot of muscle disguising my fat.. I don't need surgery? I think that's very flawed logic. He said that is just the shape of my chest. Then he tried to point out stretch marks on my biceps (had nothing to do with my chest). Brought in another one of his co-workers and tried to manipulate/confuse me further. He still offered to do the surgery but thought it wouldn't make a difference. He told me he would expect little to no improvement. He then quoted the surgery at full price approximately $7500. So decided to give Dr. Shah a visit at Columbus institute of Plastic surgery and decided to book surgery. He only charged $3700 for level 1 lipo and he took out over a liter of fat from my chest! Also Donaldson's clinic charged me $100 consultation fee for this consultation. In a way I am thankful you led me elsewhere. read more

I cry tears of joy as I write this. I researched plastic surgeons and read 1 million reviews and ended up at Donaldson. My niece had a tummy tuck here many years ago and is still very happy with her results. Dr. Michelle Sieffert was my surgeon. I am amazed at how it went and my results. AMAZING! Everything is exactly what I asked for, size & symmetry and even at three weeks, the incisions are almost completely healed. The combination of meds given post-surgery covered any issue I could possibly have. The whole experience was pain-free, only a touch of nausea and no risk of blood clots. I've been on every online support group and none of the issues other people have were even possible with the skill of Dr. Sieffert and the preventative measures in place. Even over the holidays I had a phone number to call if I had ANY questions or issues. I am so glad I did this and I'm so glad I did it with Dr. Sieffert at Donaldson. She gave me exactly what I wanted and more! Importantly, there was no "nickel and diming" The price quoted included everything. My tummy tuck with muscle repair, Lipo and breast reduction we're 100% satisfactory. She removed my C-section scars and scar tissue and I have the cutest belly button ever. Thank you thank you! I feel stronger every day. With the core muscle repair, I believe I will be stronger still and not have the backaches due to the BR. read more

Dr. D, Adrienne, Carrie, and Bobbie are amazing at what they do! For several years, I have been thinking about liposuction for my abdominal area. However, for some reason, I thought liposuction was too aggressive or major of a surgery for the small amount of fat I was dealing with. For the last fifteen years, I have worked-out and maintained a healthy diet. However, prior to that my diet was horrible, but I did workout. During my years of unhealthy eating that's when most of my abdominal fat developed... About five years ago, I decided to get back out into the dating world and to do that I wanted to have more self-confidence about my abdominal area. So, I started to look into many different procedures for my abdominal area; surgery and non-surgery options. Overall, I felt surgery was not necessary for my focus area. Around the same time, I started with electro slim body sculpting; I did not enjoy this type of treatment and I felt it was waste of time and money. Next, I moved to Coolsculpting treatments. I saw some great results from a few treatments with Coolsculpting. After those treatments, I lost 2 inches from my abdominal area. I took a break for several months from any form of treatments. I wanted to adjust to losing the inches. My goal was not to lose weight or to have defined abs. It was for my abdominal area to be more symmetry with the frame of my body. By this point, I was pretty happy with the results and just needed a little fine-tuning. I continued working-out and eating healthy. However, still not on point yet with my abdominal area. At this point, I was still thinking that I did not need any type of surgery to achieve my goal. I tried and looked into Kybella, SculpSure, Sono Bello treatments and procedures, and a few others... I still did not see any new results. So, I decided to schedule a Lipo consultation with Dr. D., OMG! Let me tell you - best thing I ever did! I had my surgery about two months ago, and I am extremely happy with the process and results. The process was completely different from what I thought. In short, if you are thinking about Liposuction... Have your consultation with Dr. D. If I could go back in time when I started this journey... I wish, that someone directed me to a Lipo consultation... read more

Still happy after 6 years! I had my BA done by Dr Donaldson and am still so happy with the results. Dr Donaldson is not only caring, but gave me exactly the results I had hoped for. His staff was amazing throughout the entire process. read more

Dr Donaldson and dr sieffert are SO nice! They are very thorough, answer all your questions, explain everything in detail, and really care about you as a person. Very thoughtful and caring staff, absolutely come here! read more

I chose Donaldson Plastic Surgery because of the great reviews and the doctor and his staff are very nice and professional, office very clean. Had a great feeling going in, but unfortunately cannot recommend. Ended up being a huge waste of money for me. First I had rhinoplasty. Wanted the bumps in my nose smoothed and the tip less pointy. $6000 later my nose looks worse as the bumps are still there and now my nose is crooked. Of course you sign off on papers before hand stating that you understand results are not guaranteed, so what can I do? Can't afford to fix it so now I walk around with a crooked nose. Thanks. Before the swelling came down on my nose it looked okay because you couldn't see the bumps or crookedness at that time, so during that time period I returned for lip fillers and Botox on my eyes. I told Dr Donaldson I wanted Botox to soften my crows feet and fine lines and he recommended Juvederm around my eyes instead. I trusted him, and ended up leaving with my lines and crows feet PLUS bags under my eyes since Juvederm is a filler. When I expressed displeasure the doctor said he must have misunderstood what I wanted. Botox for crows feet is pretty standard so I'm very confused how he misunderstood. Why would I have wanted to add bags under my eyes? As for the lip filler (done at the same time I had my eyes done, so I hadn't yet realized the doctors mistake) it was my first time getting it done and, as I said, I trusted that he knew what he was doing. He injected the filler into the inside of my mouth, not my lips. The result was that my lip stuck out like duck face, but the lip itself was not any plumper. I now have my filler done at The Skin Center and they inject into the lip and do a good job. They were very confused when I told them how Dr Donaldson had done it. Such a nice guy. I hate to leave a bad review, but my crooked nose and I very much regret ever going here. read more

Phenomenal. I have been a patient of many plastic surgeons all over the world for injectables and fillers and have never had an easier appointment. My fear going in was that my lips would be swollen and puffy for weeks (as I have had happen in the past) yet Dr D and his staff assured me otherwise. I am most pleased with the result and it's not even been 24 hours! Minimal swelling. No puffiness. Dr D has the magic eye and magic touch! I will definitely be a return customer! read more

I have been a patient of Dr. Donaldson for over five years. Dr. Donaldson and his staff are wonderful. I have been more than satisfied with the results from my visits. Dr. Donaldson has a special gift at making you look younger without anyone knowing you just had some botox. Dr. Donaldson always takes his time with you to ensure precision and your satisfaction. The experience does not end there, after he is done the office staff do a great job at quickly touching up your makeup, providing advice on skin products and makeup. Dr. Donaldson and his staff genuinely care about their patients and your satisfaction is their #1 priority! Once you leave the office you can expect a phone within a week to ensure you are happy with your recent visit or to answer any questions you might have. I highly recommend Dr. Donaldson and plan on being a patient for many more years! read more

If it takes weeks for a response to just schedule a consultation then I have zero confidence that this office nor the surgeon will be able to provide me with what I need. The lack communication and service for something that's elective and expensive is scary. On top of all of this, they charge you for a consultation, which should be free - but you can't even get one person to actually schedule the consultation. If this is such a rough starts, I highly doubt it could get better. First impressions count, already a horrible one. read more

I had a breast augmentation done, and am very satisfied with the results (and I'm not even a month out from surgery). He, and his staff, are very professional, responsive and friendly. I was nervous the day of surgery but both Dr. Donaldson and Bonnie put me at ease. Dr. Donaldson called me the evening of my surgery to check up on how I was doing, and Bonnie was very quick to respond to my email questions. I would highly recommend Dr. Donaldson to anyone who is seeking out cosmetic services. read more

about 5 years go I went to Dr. Donaldson. and it was a horrible experience. it would take too long to go into all the details as I'm trying to move on with my life and I do not have the patience or strength to relive it again. but I would NOT recommend him. In fact, I would beg anyone to not go to him. he caused me so much turmoil and I lost so much money just to be even more unhappy. Please remember this... Not every doctor graduates at the top of his or her class...there are doctors out there that had barely passing grades that still graduate mediocre students and allow them to be called "surgeons". Just because he's a doctor doesn't mean he's a good doctor, ethical or even a good person. Obviously, I'm still pissed about it after all this time. If you don't want to take my word for it and you are researching plastic surgeons, I highly recommend joining the FREE website REALSELF.com and look up any doctor you are considering. It's an eye-opener. Do your research. read more

I've been a patient of Donaldson Plastic Surgery and always extremely happy. I've decided to also use the threading services they now offer by Mahnaz. She is fantastic. I am also extremely happy with her services. She is very knowledgeable, easy to talk to, takes interest in your needs and takes her time when working with you. I highly recommend Mahmaz for your esthetic needs. read more

Although (about a year later) no follow up or check in with me. To me, would have been courteous of them. Because this is a life altering/changing positive event in someone's life. read more

I had a tummy tuck, breast reduction and arm lift done at the same time. I had absolutely NO pain and the results are awesome!!! On occasion, there was some discomfort but that was it. I later had Botox and juvederm and got great results!! I highly recommend Dr. Donaldson and his staff for all your needs!! read more

Though I believe Dr. Donaldson means well, he is really not that talented as a surgeon. His bedside manner was great but he nearly destroyed my friend's body. What's worse- when we asked for solutions, he said he could no longer do anything. I would not recommend anyone go here. read more

I received breast implants with dr Donaldson and the whole process was seamless. This was four years ago actually and I still love my implants, I was able to breastfeed as well just like he said! I highly recommend this office for plastic surgery and will probably be going back for other procedures. read more