Thank you for making my lasagna and veggie pizza with sausage 10 minutes before closing!…read more Such an amazing meal after a shitty day at work!!!

In town, stopped for something different based on rating…read more Once inside, it's a neighborhood joint - familiar awards, faces, smells. It's consistent. I got a walk in medium pepperoni with sausage. In & out in 20 min. Who I assumed to be the owner came over and stopped in to check on my order and went to the back of the house and asking what the delay was in my Pizza, and it suddenly appeared in less than 30 seconds later. Customer service is noted. In my opinion, the pizza was good, but the pepperoni was way too salty for my liking. I actually had to peel many layers off to make it palatable. Just for me, not you.

Trying these dishes for the first time. Meatball Casserole had tons of sauce and cheese. Gioninos…read morebread was perfect pairing. They have so many options that you could eat there every day for a month and not get the same thing. Highly recommend. Staff is fast and friendly.

The service was good, I was greeted at the door when I came in…read more The pizza was actually good. We got the very veggie and it was loaded with veggies. When we went to heat it up the next day it, the crust stuck to the cardboard. I made sure that it was completely cooled before putting it in the fridge, as instructed on the box. So I'm not really sure why it stuck

Absolutely amazing Pizza!!! The Mario is my favorite! Tried the sub and it was OUTSTANDING!read more

Wonderful experience at the Nerds! I've always been a thin crust lover, but this pizza is so…read morecrunchy and still soft inside. I don't know how they do it! Also, the guy up front was really wonderful! Very kind and helpful. Will be back!!

Always love the pizza I get here. The pepperoni and banana peppers as well as your house salad…read more Service is always great and your staff members are all super friendly and helpful. I wish you had more seating though. Keep up the amazing service and food - A Westerville favorite!

Placed an order for one pizza & said order would be ready in 25 minutes, got there 25 minutes later…read more& was told my order would be ready in 25-30 minutes Very disappointing customer service.

My go to spot and yes worth the wait.. I get the meat lovers extra sauce double cut done well and…read moreit's amazing every time. Go online and order trust me. Ok get to it the service is usually great and the sausage is homemade

Terita's Pizza - (Stays in Rotation)…read more North side classic that stays consistent. * Thin crust, square-cut * Sausage is the standout (slight kick, not heavy) * Toppings stay balanced--nothing overloaded First time: Sausage + pepperoni pizza (keep it simple) Best experience (this matters): Eat it fresh--this is at its best right out the box Keep it to 1-2 toppings max so the crust and sausage still come through Ask for it well-done if you like a little extra crisp on the bottom Once you know: Sausage + banana peppers or mushrooms What to know: * Better for carryout * Menu is straightforward * Known for consistency over time Atmosphere: Casual, no-frills, more takeout than dine-in Parking: Easy, on-site Price: $10-15 Wait: Usually quick Good pick when you want something reliable without overthinking it.

Serving from Studio 35 this pizza place is the real deal. All are 12 inches and the chewy, doughy…read moredelicious crust. We had the Fig-a-ma-jig which is Garlic EVOO base, house cheese, goat cheese, prosciutto, organic Smyrna figs, organic arugula, fig glaze. Also did the Hot Swarm which is House red sauce, House Cheese, Ezzo cup & char pepperoni, ricotta, pepper flake, Triple Hex hot honey. Both delicious though I'm more savory so preferred the Hot Swarm. I would have liked it spicier. But overall delicious.

We came to Grandview Theater to try Fibonacci's pizza while seeing the new Michael Jackson movie…read more We ordered a pizza and one of their sandwiches, which is made using the pizza dough. The sandwich was honestly the highlight of the meal. It was delicious, and the pizza dough as the bread was such a unique touch that you really don't find at many Italian sandwich spots around Columbus. The pizza itself was just okay. As you can see from the picture, the toppings weren't distributed very evenly, so some slices had mostly sauce with barely any cheese while others had way more toppings and cheese but less sauce. I also wish the pizza had been cooked a little longer overall because it was pretty floppy and doughy. One thing that makes it tough is that once the movie starts, it's hard to go back and ask for changes or anything since the theater is packed and getting in and out of the seats feels disruptive. We'll definitely be back to Grandview Theater because we love the experience overall, but next time I'll probably stick to the sandwiches and popcorn and skip the pizza.

Wanted pizza while in town and I hate chains. So I dugouts this place and glad I did. The pizza was…read moreway better than the decor lol. Go Blue!!! Awesome pizza and service even if they pull For the team down south.

Pizza was average. The place was between a dispensary and liquor store. Lots of people hanging out…read morein the parking lot with loud music. I did not feel safe. That area needs cleaned up. Would never go again!

Pretty solid pizza! Sauce was gently sweet, and not too acidic. It seriously needed some peppery…read moreflavor, but the sausage just happened to be super peppery, so it was perfect! Hot and fresh and tasty. Cozy comfy atmosphere. Minus 480 stars because "Never Gonna Give You Up" started playing (this is a joke)

Good pizza, not bad interior. Pretty fun to eat at with a small group of 3 or 4. Service was fine.read more

Let Jess Tell It ‼ Brenz Pizza Co. - New Albany, OH…read more 1/2 -- Great basil. Mid chicken. Manage your expectations. Visited: Aug 2025 Heritage Honey pizza sounded like a win -- hot honey, basil, ricotta -- but only the basil came to play. Hot honey was too syrupy, crust was super doughy, and I couldn't taste the red sauce or garlic butter base I asked for. (I saw it. My taste buds didn't.) Loaded Pep & Cheese had more flavor, but still not craveable. We debated the wings... then got the Hot Buffalo BBQ. Ordered them extra saucy after seeing those dry pics online. And yeah -- still a letdown. Even cook, no crisp, no seasoning soaked in. Just chicken being chicken with sauce sitting on top. The vibe? Clean, modern, great staff. The flavor? Flat. Good if you're already nearby. Not worth a trip. That basil, though? Still thinking about it.

Got many recommendations about Brenz being the pizza place to try and it definitely lived up to the…read morehype. Many options to choose from a traditional pie to something more unique. We got the 14" Rustic Pizza, Personal Spinach Artichoke and Garlic Parm Jumbo Wings The 14" pizza looked huge and more than enough for 3 people. Lots of toppings and a great sauce. I do wish the dough was cooked a little bit more but everyone else said it was great. The artichoke pizza did not disappoint since there was an abundance of it. The wings were good because they weren't the traditional breaded then fried. I do wish there was more garlic parm flavor but the ranch sauce helped make up for it. Tip: Sign up for their loyalty program. I already of $5 off my next purchase!

I received a flyer for a free 12" pizza from Brenz, otherwise I don't think I would have bothered…read moregoing. I mean, we already have our favorite local pizza place. My wife and I ordered the classic. It was ready in about 20 minutes for pickup. The pizza arrived hot and all of the ingredients were of excellent quality. What really stood out were the mushrooms! They were thick cut and obviously fresh. The sauce tasted perfect. It wasn't too sweet like a lot of other pizza places. Brenz has pretty much perfected pizza making. I'll definitely be a returning customer.

I had never been to a Brenz Pizza before. The food was premium ingredients. My friend and I shared…read morethe Spicy Citrus salad with Mandarin oranges, new Brenz Bites, along with the Pizzas was the medium Midwest Duo with cupped sliced sausage with Ricotta cheese and banana peppers, and personal Classic Pizza. The pizzas were delicious and very tasty. They do not have fountain drinks because they do more with carryout and delivery. I had a Diet Pepsi and she had a Starry. Also, we share a yummy cookie with red velvet, and different chocolate chips. Vinny and another guy took great care of us. I will be going back to Brenz Pizza soon for the great service and excellent pizzas with fixings.