Great service and amazing food! We had a party of 6 adults…read moreand everyone raved about their meals! The nachos as an appetizer were spectacular! We will most assuredly be back soon!!!!

I order a pick up order. The food was ready at the time I requested and service was great. I…read moreordered the two meat combo and it did not disappoint. The amount of food was fantastic as I was able to save some for the next day. The brisket and sausage links were everything I was wanting when looking to find a BBQ place in Mystic.

Mixed review for us Start with the good. Sat at the bar,…read morebartenders were attentive and were super helpful in helping us make decisions. Both of us loved our drinks and dinner (I had the pork chop - out of this world). Cool bar setup too. Cozy spot on cold night. 5 star experience and we will be back. Now the bad. Had reservations and noted in the reservation that we didn't want to sit next to the garage doors/windows because it was single digits outside and those tables are cold. The place was empty when we arrived. Hostess noted our reservation request and said the system is showing a table near the window. I said "there's 15 open tables away from the windows, can't we sit someplace else." She said "the system is saying to sit there". What happened to customer service? so we sat at the bar - see above. And over half the open tables when we arrived were never occupied before we left?? Very odd experience there.

I am absolutely glad I celebrated my Birthday at Milestone. I had so much fun with my sisters and…read morefriends. I love their happy hour menu. Their pizzas remind me of Rome. Every time I come here I try something new, but still order my usuals. I tried their wings and everyone devoured it. Our bar tender keeps us entertained as usual and making amazing drinks for everyone.

Came bace 2 years later and I got the 6oz fillet ($28) and salmon jerky ($15). Salmon jerky was…read moresmoky and savory. 4 pieces that had about 2-3 bites each. The fillet was unfortunately overcooked to a medium well instead of medium rare. I did not send it back due to it being busy. The potatoes and greens were delicious! Staff was friendly! Overall still a good restaurant, if the steak was cooked to the correct temp it would get that fifth star. Food(50%): 6.7 Staff/service(25%): 7.0 Value(25%): 7.5 Overall: 6.9/10

We went for lunch and were told right away that they were out of several menu items, which was…read morefine. One person in our group has multiple allergies, and while the staff assured us it would be fine the service didn't reflect that level of attentiveness. It ended up taking over 45 minutes for our food to come out. We were told there would be a 30 minute wait for rotisserie chicken and that salads with chicken would be substituted with crispy chicken, but we didn't order anything that should have required that kind of delay. During that time, we watched several other tables come in after us, get their food, and leave before we were even served. After our drinks were dropped off, our server never checked back in to update us on the delay. However she did check in after we got our food. I completely understand that things can get busy, but the restaurant was empty, and multiple staff members passed by our table without acknowledging us. Overall ambiance was very nice... the exposed brick, the cozy booths. But we won't be rushing back any time soon.

Went to celebrate birthday the food was delicious, service was excellent did not have to wait long…read moreto get served. the atmosphere is upbeat. the staff is great and professional Great place to go for any event

Jeramiah's is serving main‑character energy from the moment you walk through the door. This place…read moredoesn't just do dinner -- it stages an experience. Think elevated steakhouse meets coastal charm, wrapped in a vibe that says, "Relax, you're about to eat very, very well." Let's start with the amuse bouche, because honestly, more restaurants should bring this level of ceremony to the table. A tiny, perfect bite that sets the tone -- thoughtful, flavorful, and just indulgent enough to make you lean back and say, "Oh, we're doing this tonight." The drink specials? Dangerous in the best possible way. Creative without being gimmicky, balanced, and clearly crafted by someone who knows their way around a shaker. You can tell they're not phoning it in -- these cocktails have personality. And then... the prime rib. The star. The reason you cancel your other dinner plans. Tender, deeply seasoned, and cooked with the kind of confidence that only comes from a kitchen that knows exactly what it's doing. Every slice feels like a small celebration. Service is top‑tier -- warm, attentive, and genuinely invested in making the night feel special. The staff strikes that perfect balance between polished and personable, and the whole place hums with a relaxed, upscale energy that makes you want to linger. Now, the one critique -- and it's a real one: no kids' menu. I love a good Wagyu moment, but a $28 Wagyu burger for a six‑year‑old feels... ambitious. Delicious, sure. Practical? Not so much. A couple kid‑friendly options would go a long way for families who want to enjoy a great meal without taking out a small loan for the under‑10 crowd. But even with that quirk, Jeramiah's absolutely earns its five stars. It's a standout dining experience -- thoughtful, flavorful, and confidently elevated without ever feeling pretentious. A must‑visit for anyone who appreciates great food, great service, and a night out that feels like an occasion. Cheers

The first time I asked for no mayonnaise on my grinder. They put so much mayonnaise on it I…read morecouldn't eat it. Yesterday was the second time. I opened up my grinder and there was a type of bug crawling around the top. There won't be a third time. When my husband called the manager didn't seem to care.

A great pizza. Good atmosphere and decent prices. Great cheese and sauce. This place is a great…read morestop after a cruise on Argia and/or a trip in/around Mystic. Staff was friendly and personable as well.

I had a great experience! We were seated quickly! We had a…read morechoice of inside or outside. We chose inside and there was plenty of seating in both places! We ordered two 12 inch pizzas. One regular cheese and one vegetarian. They were both good. They had an IPA that I enjoyed. And the Caesar salad went perfect with the pizza. Danielle provided great service! If I am at the aquarium, I would eat here again!

Mango's Wood Fired Pizza in Mystic, CT is definitely worth checking out if you're in the area…read more Located within a small cluster of shops, it's a lively spot where locals and tourists gather to eat, shop, and hang out, which adds to the overall charm of the experience. It's the kind of place that feels relaxed and welcoming--perfect for a casual family stop while exploring Mystic. My family and I ordered the Cranky Yankee pizza along with the Shark Bites. While the pizza wasn't the best I've ever had, it was absolutely respectable and enjoyable. The crust was well done--not too doughy--balanced nicely with the right amount of sauce and cheese, and thankfully not soggy from the vegetables. Overall, it was a tasty, well-balanced wood-fired pizza that hit the mark. The Shark Bites, however, didn't stand out much; they tasted similar to the frozen chicken chunks you might grab from Costco. What really saved them was the buffalo sauce, which was flavorful and genuinely good. All things considered, Mango's Wood Fired Pizza delivers solid food in a fun, high-traffic location, making it a good stop whether you're local or just passing through Mystic. Overall rating: 4 out of 5.

Charming. Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. Everything was cooked to perfection. Service…read morewas on point. Everyone was super nice. FYI-Parking is in the back! You gotta pay, but it's convenient What else could you ask for?

We made our way to The Mariner for a late lunch after spending much of our day at the Mystic…read moreAquarium and the Olde Mistick Village. I really liked the ambiance of the space, it's quite comfortable and has a nautical aesthetic. We were sat in a cozy little corner by the window, a great spot for watching the bustling of the little seaside town. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable of the restaurant's offerings, noting in their introduction that the focus of the menu is on fresh local seafood, and that everything on the menu is freshly made in house. I was very eager to try a cup of the clam chowder for an appetizer since many other reviewers have said that it's some of the best they've ever tasted, and after trying it for myself I'm more than inclined to agree with them; it had a perfect consistency and excellent flavor. Boyfriend wanted the fried mozzarella so we got some of that, and that was pretty tasty as well. Boyfriend got the chicken parm sandwich for his meal and I got the fish and chips. I didn't end up trying the sandwich, but he said he liked it. My fish and chips plate was pretty good; the fish tasted just a tad under seasoned to me, however the flavorful tartar sauce helped with that and I could tell the fish itself was great quality. The hand cut fries were good, but I wasn't really a fan of the coleslaw. Overall we had a pleasant experience at The Mariner. A very good choice for fresh seafood and a relaxed vibe. I'm sure I'll be in town again at some point; if I come back to The Mariner, I'll make a point to get a bowl of the clam chowder instead of a cup, because that alone is absolutely worth returning for... but until then, I'll be dreaming about it.

Delicious food, efficient staff, and a beautiful yet cozy environment! Rita, our server made it…read moreall the better! Warm, friendly and so available to all of our needs! Huge portions...the fish and chips barely fit on the plate, delicious tender short ribs, and perfectly cooked steak! Can't ask for more!

burger was okay, a bit dry and lacked flavor. fries were nice though! mac and cheese was very plain…read moreand the combination of bread crumbs with watered down cheese did not pair as well as we recalled from former trips. while we had stayed at the hilton mystic before and ordered the same dish with lobster, it actually brought us back to the same hotel a year later for more, hoping to recreate the experience! unfortunately, to our disappointment, they did not have any lobster so we went with the standard house mac n' cheese. my fiancée and i had the pleasure of having an attentive server; however, certainly wish they'd had lobster mac and cheese when we went this past weekend. it can be loud in the restaurant earlier on in the evening so i would recommend waiting a bit and returning if it seems too busy!

Vegans..... head over to Dog Watch and try the Harvest Bowl...PERFECTION!!!…read moreDelicious lunch with family passing through, waitstaff did an amazing job. A delightful wait on the patio enjoying the cool breezes on the first of what I am sure will be many hot summer days.

December 2025 A…read morelocal recommended this for a good afternoon lunch. The place is small but is right on the pier and you have fun views of the boat yard and water. The menu offers everything from soups and salads to scallop meals and sandwiches. Extremely well priced. There are about a dozen tables and a few high tops as well as a bar for seating. Parking is across the street. The staff is extremely friendly and attentive. I wish they had brewed iced tea, but they said it only comes from the fountain. Ick! Ordered a bowl of clam chowder soup. Very creamy and good flavor. The clams seem to be gritty. Probably could use a good rinse before they are cooked. But overall, the flavor and consistency our clams and potatoes with each bite was nice. Ordered the cod sandwich with onion rings. The cod sandwich is quite large. Served on a brioche bun with tomatoes and lettuce and a lemon wedge It was served piping hot. The fish, although large and presentation was nice, it lacked flavor. The batter was not completely cooked toward the meat of the fish. You get your choice of side and we had onion rings. They were standard side, but cooked to perfection. Overall, I was pleased with this restaurant. I would give the ambience a five out of five, the weight staff service was five out of five and the food would be a solid four. I would definitely come back to this restaurant.

Mystic Pizza holds such a special place in my heart. This was one of the last places I visited with…read morea group of my girlfriends during a weekend trip to Mystic, and it meant a lot to finally experience a spot tied to one of my favorite movies. We ordered onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and, of course, the pizza. Everything felt so nostalgic from start to finish--the atmosphere, the food, even getting a picture with the Julia Roberts poster upstairs. The staff was incredibly kind and welcoming, and seating us at the top of the restaurant made it feel even more memorable. Looking back, this visit is something I'll always carry with me, especially in memory of a dear friend who has since passed. It's a bittersweet feeling, and while I may not return because of that, I truly cherish the experience. The pizza itself was enjoyable--crispy with a buttery flavor and a nice layer of cheese. Some at the table thought it leaned a bit standard, but for me, it exceeded expectations and made the moment even more special.

The ambiance is perfect! The original restaurant is still in tact from the movie AND they've added…read morea bar upstairs just recently. It's welcoming, the staff is great, and it feels like home. Where else would I go for pizza in Connecticut! They have their own beer too. So, "fanboying" a bit here. I loved the movie, so keep that in mind when you read this. The pizza would have to be pretty bad to get less than 5 stars from me! Already love it! I ate the pizza, and: If there was a 6th star, they would get one here! The pizza was fantastic! I can't say enough about the hospitality! The owner stopped to say hi and talked for a bit! Great person. I will be planning a trip back to Mystic very soon! Wonderful place!