I have been going to Eaton Pizza for many years. It is a classic small town everyone in town eats…read morehere and everyone knows each other restaurant! I went there for lunch this week and enjoyed a great pizza with a good friend! If you don't live in Eaton it's worth the drive to enjoy a small town experience with fantastic food!

Every time I come up to Eaton, I always order a pizza Been here several times it's always been…read moregreat. Highly recommended.

Antonio's is insanely good! They have some unique, award winning pizza options. I got to try their…read moregarlic knots, spicy pizza (the one with ricotta, sweet peppers, balsamic, tomatoes, etc.), and their homemade NY cheesecake. I've had a lot of pizza over the years and I can honestly say this is the best pizza I have had in a long time. The flavors worked so perfectly together. The spicy, the savory, the cheesy! As someone who had never been to Estes Park before, I'm so sad that I will probably not get to have their pizza again. But, gosh, I'll tell everyone about it! The pizzas are also delivered by robot which is super cool. The cheesecake was top tier too.

We did take out, and I had heard about this place as a must go to at some point. I was honestly…read moresorta disappointed. The process for picking food up was not very good. The actual pizza was fine but nothing special and had gallons of oil and grease on it. The cheeses bread was good! But also soooo greasy. I'm not one to complain about grease but it was a little crazy The Godfather Prosciutto di Parma, spicy Capicola, Genoa Salami, pepperoncinis, provolone, parmigiano reggiano, roasted red peppers and garlic. ---- at first, we were unsure if they gave us the correct pizza because we couldn't see or taste any meat Garlic Bread / Cheesy Garlic Bread Real house-made Garlic Bread, choose between cheesy and regular! You get the whole loaf of bread just like you see in the photo. ---- this was better than the pizza in my opinion

FANTASTIC gnocchi. The sauce was perfectly done. Not overly seasoned but enough to be flavorful…read more The portion was enough to have two meals out of it. The Italian sub was also good and I don't know how they did it, but their French fries taste just like a well-known Golden Arches restaurant. They were great!

Very warm and kind staff. I enjoyed an arugula salad followed by spaghetti and meatballs and…read moretopped by a creamy homemade creme brulee! This is a home away from home.

It's an easy meal to have when yo I don't want to cook. Always tastes good. Time to pick up is…read moregreat.

Absolutely the most disrespectful ownership I've ever encountered. Rude, demeaning, belittling, and…read moredown right unprofessional. They should be ashamed.

If you're looking for a decent steak in the Eaton area, this is about it. I asked for my 'McCartys…read moresteak' medium rare and it came out exactly as requested. Couldn't finish it all, had to take some home. Sides are good and their salad bar is a welcome plus. Soups are hearty with the ingredients-not thin gruel. Drinks are generous pours. The servers and bartenders are friendly and attentive. Crowd is a comfortable mix of golfers and non-golfers. Will return to try their prime rib, burgers, perhaps some fish as well. The one thing they might consider doing is expand their draft beer selection to include something dark and local.

I'm writing to follow up on a dining experience at McCarty's in Eaton on July 27, 2026, at 11:25 AM…read more(Table 17). During my visit, I signed up for the rewards program. Since my server, Jennifer S., used a paper bill instead of a POS device, I provided my phone number on the receipt for her to enter manually. Unfortunately, these points have not been credited to my account. I reached out to the team via email at mccartys39ecc@gmail.com on July 30, but I have yet to receive a response. I would appreciate it if someone could look into this and help me get my rewards points updated.

Wow! This was my first time eating here and it was so good!! The crust was absolutely perfect. Just…read morethe way a pizza should be. And I'm so so picky. We won't be getting pizza anywhere else from now on. And their specials are pretty good!

I've eaten here a few times over the last decade or so while staying in g Greeley. The pizza is…read moregood, thin crust style pizza. At some point, they eliminated Hawaiian from their menu, so if you like Hawaiian style, you're SOL. It used to be one of their best pies. We ordered some large orders of 8 or more pizzas a few times for business meetings and they got our order wrong every time. Calling to resolve issues was tedious, but they did get is taken care of. They're ok in a pinch, but I wouldn't recommend them

We were in town visiting our adult kids and had the younger two with us, and my rule when traveling…read moreis simple: no chains. We wanted a good locally owned pizza place, and Arte Pizzeria fit the bill ... so well, in fact, that we went back a second night. The pizzas are handmade and really good, and the prices are fair. Everything came out fast both nights, which matters when you've got a 13-year-old and a 9-year-old at the table. But the thing my wife and I kept talking about afterward was the staff. It's mostly young people working there, and they were friendly, upbeat, and clearly invested in making the place feel welcoming. That kind of energy doesn't happen by accident ... somebody's running this place well. Great pizza, quick service, easy location, family-friendly. If you're in Loveland and want pizza from people who care about what they're making, this is the spot.

Amazing pizza, good prices, and friendly staff. Can't complain…read more Annoying for a pizza place where I am just picking up a pizza their default and lowest tip % is 15%, but a small gripe I suppose.

We have been here a few times. Great pizza and must get the bread roll as an appetizer. I know a…read morelot of carbs but definitely well worth it. The service has always been good every time we have been there. Very friendly. You can eat inside or outside depending on the weather.

Cute little Italian restaurant hidden away in a neighborhood. Party of 4, we walked in and were…read moreseating right away. We started with the Herbed Burrata, 1/2 Wedge Salad, and the Brussel Sprouts. The Burrata is a MUST order, for all future visits!!! For our entrees we ordered the Spicy Mushroom pizza, the Sausage & Mushroom pasta, and the Vodka Cream Fettuccine with Salmon. Sooo delicious! And our sweet waitress kept our drinks full the whole time.

Stopped in to the Greeley location to order a few pizzas to take home…read more We were looking at the posted menu board and one of the items listed (a pizza) was way cheaper than the others so we asked if that was accurate and the guy had a snarky, rude tone and said give me a break - isn't it obvious that is an error! Actually no, I would expect the business to have the correct menu and prices displayed and that they would correct it if there was an error. So condescending and rude! If this was the only pizza place available, I'd never have pizza again because I don't like being treated poorly when I'm spending my hard earned money.

I have eaten pizzas from at least 10 states, each from at least five cities in each....this pizza…read morewas about as lack-luster in flavor as most any other, eaten. Not close to flavor quality, as anticipated, therefore not worth the money. May be that this location missed the flavor train.