The best pizza around, this pizzeria quickly became a family favorite. The restaurant is casual with a game room off to the side. Service is always top notch. If you are in the mood for pizza or Italian this is the place to go. read more

Thanks for CHARGING me for extra cheese...except, you forgot (?) to put it on...Very disappointed...after a generous tip, no Thank You...obviously I was in the way obstructing Gwendolyn's next cash customer... read more

The pizza was nice and we loved the service - fast and courteous. Salads were predictably forgettable but would definitely return.

The food is over priced for mediocre food. the chicken parm is just chicken fingers and marinara sauce. It costs 14.89. not worth it. couldn't buy the bottle of sodas and bring it to the table because they want to charge you for a over priced pitcher. they ripped us off cause instead of even offering the pitcher, they wanted us to all get small drinks. A burger is also 14.89 with no fries included. Everyone in my family is miserable cause this food is awful and overpriced. the pizza "sauce" is also marinara and the veggies aren't even cooked with the pizza. the arcade is overpriced but at least the air hockey is free. that's why it got a two star. Overall, terrible service, EVERYTHING with pasta is replaced with marinara sauce making it overpriced slop. read more

See all

Owner is not available for constructive criticism! Order was taken, cooked and told to pick up from same person.

We found this place on Yelp while in the area. We ordered a large plain pizza & cheese fries. I'll start with the service that was mediocre, the girl at the counter seemed like she did not want to be there. Now with the cheese fries, it was a packaged cheese cup that was terrible, it smelt like feet! $10 for cheese fries that were not even edible! Now to the pizza, it wasn't terrible but wasn't great either, it was just pizza! Needless to say we will never go here again, save your money & do the same! The place seemed clean. read more

What happened to the size of the Sicilian? It reminds me of school pizza, small and soft. $30 for a pie is ridiculous! read more

Dominic's Pizza - Notice the size compared to my hand. - Pizza Near Me - Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania

See all

Always great food, good service and very accommodating. Been going there for years. Nice family business b

Great pizza and wings! Cool arcade, nice beer on draft and more for take home. Nice subs and massive Stromboli. And the online ordering is really good. You can add and delete items as you go. I get extra garlic (fresh) but I don't like the green peppers...they're roasted, I like fresh. Note some items aren't available on weekends (green dots on the menu). They now take credit cards. read more

See all

5 stars for how great your whole process was for Super Bowl Sunday! I ordered take out of wings and pizza to pick up at 5:30. I spoke to Nicole, who was the manager or owner? Unsure, but she was terrific. Just what you want.. someone who is nice and helpful... answers questions kindly. We pulled out to go pick it up on Sunday, and I got a surprise text to my phone, informing me that my order was ready for pick up! Then, when we walked in, and I gave my name, they proactively had people's orders in hot pouches on the counter right behind the registers, and everything went smoothly and perfectly! Also, I'd like to say thanks for having customer appreciation on Super Bowl Sunday! Amazing deals!! read more

Dominic's Pizza - Buffalo garlic Parmesan wings! - Pizza Near Me - Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania

See all

Went on a weekend getaway with some friends about a week ago. Got pizza on our last night and everything was perfect. We picked it up and when we walked in we were greeted right away by a very friendly girl. We got 4 pizzas. All cooked perfectly. 10/10 read more

Solid pizza stop near arrowhead lake/ tobyhanna. Just got a plain pie it was ready in 20 and still hot by the time we got home. They also sell beer and wine coolers etc. read more

Great pizza, clean with nice arcade and friendly service and staff. Thick fries and ok chicken fingers...

Pizza was ok. Maybe a little more than ok if there is a handicap for being in the Poconos. A little greasy for my taste. The kid behind the counter was friendly. read more

Excellent Calzone and pizza I also love the meatball hoagies. I live just down the street this is my go to local pizza place.

Had the pleasure of stopping here for dinner with my family the Friday before memorial day. Food was delicious, and Pizza was to die for. however, I've never written a review on a restaurant before today, the reason I am writing this is because of the handsome young man Max. He made our trip special and made all of my family feel included. Not only for my table, for everyone dining in the building. Msx made our trip memorable and is the main reason we will be coming back. If you're choosing pizzerias locally in the area. I would choose this one and I would thank Max's kindness and sincerity for that. read more

If you like eating cardboard, tasting pizza, this is the place to go and plus it's all over priced.

I ordered a pizza and a few other menu items from here. The garlic knots were really good. Super light and fluffy covered in garlic. I also had a pizza with Italian sausage as a topping. When they use Italian sausage, they crumble it. I thought it was really good. I also ordered 8 chicken wings. I am going to try them dry rub next time. My food was great. However- nobody preparing food is wearing a masks, or gloves at all. They do have a strip of plastic up separating themselves from us. But it's clear and not one person making pizza, Cutting pizza, or boxing the pizza had a mask on. read more

Delish! Was staying in the area as a visitor looking for some good pizza and wings on Super Bowl Sunday... highly recommend if you're in PA!

The pizza wasn't that good. The service was good and the ambiance was ok. The staff was friendly

I have a vacation home nearby so for the last 9 years I have been making Dominic's a regular stop. The pizza is definitely good. However, I feel like lately the pies have been getting smaller and smaller. I have to eat 3-4 slices and on average I would eat 1-2 slices from anywhere else. I do not know if they are stretching out their product but come on this is a bit ridiculous. To feed my whole family I would need 5 pies at least. read more

Dominic's Pizza - Large Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania

I am not sure what I am missing about it this place. I read back through the reviews to see if I was wrong on my experience. It sure seems like people in the area like this place with 4 stars from 80+ reviews. BUT I really bad swing and miss on our experience here. Maybe we ordered bad or caught them in an off night because 4 stars on that many reviews would make me believe this place is good. So feel free to ignore my Maybe Pocono people don't have a clue about good food, which is highly likely. We got a Stromboli and I am not sure what was actually inside it. It said "sausage" so I will believe it was that, but it was so ground up and bland it could have been cardboard and would not have altered the taste. The tiny pieces of mystery meat kept falling out everywhere. I am not sure how this would be a good ingredient in a Stromboli?? We also got wings and we ordered 1 order plan for my niece who just east plain chicken wings (weird, I know) and the ended up not putting sauce on any wings. They all were plain. Which I am not sure how you make 2 orders of plain wings.??? Clearly sauce was suppose to go on one set of wings! The pizza was just ok, nothing to write home about. But I just can't shake this mystery meat in the Stromboli. Who puts lots of finely ground up anything into a Stromboli? It's like serving water in strainer! Maybe I need to give this place another try. I don't know! We got take out and when we went to pick it up my kid liked the tiny arcade, so that's something decent if your there with kids....maybe I should give up on pizza in the Poconos? read more

I have been coming here for years back to when the Dad and Mom had the place. Every time I order the cheese steak sandwich it is a different price than the sign the menu a few weeks ago they tried to charge 27.00 for two of them! No way ! This is why I am not returning. They will always get into an argument with you about the price who needs it. Not me read more

Awesome food , great service friendly,there vegetarian pizza was so good yummy, most of all the owner gave me the slice for free ,I went I for a menu and walked out with a pie that tasted as good as any in NYC read more

Great place , good food. Reasonable prices. Arcade is fun for the kids. And they have alcohol

Honestly 46 wings for 80$ u gotta be high for those prices 5 stars tho w pizza place soooo goood

Delicious pizza. Thicker than I expected. Wings are good. Not the best but definitely good. The arcade room kept the kids busy while we waited. They close by 8pm so get there early. read more

First time visiting to use a gift certificate generously donated to a fundraiser. Even during the stress of cocid, the staff was amazingly friendly, food was prepared quickly on a Friday evening and it tasted really good! Bought a pizza and two calzones. And I loved all the mushrooms! If I lived closer I would be back. Prices were not expensive for what we received. read more

Family favorite! Actually had the privilege of being part of their construction decades ago! Definitely a place you gotta go! Great Pizza, great wings, and their loaded fries are OMG! You won't be disappointed! read more

Wonderful people and staff. This place has a cool game room for kids to keep themselves busy while the food comes. Order their garlic knots, they're huge! read more

While visiting Split Rock Resort for 3 days our family wanted to get out and try some pizza from a local place. We saw that they had games and it was a family owned restaurant. The ratings were pretty good and they claim to have "The Best Pizza in town" So I was like sure, I'll try it, being I'm a native New Yorker born and raised in Brooklyn. They peaked my interest. So I took my wife and 3 little girls over to play some games and eat some pizza. The place was extremely dark and dingy. Extremely dated and dirty looking but the family there were nice. We order a white pie and a plain pie plus a pitcher of iced tea (refills are 4 dollars FYI!!! Huh?) No waiters or waitresses, you walk back up to the counter and you have to get back up to get it which was rather inconvenient. Pizza comes and the large looked more like a medium. The pizza was FARRRRRR from best. Honestly, I enjoyed chuck E Cheeses pizzas better! There plan cheese pie was doughy and had almost no cheese! Sauce was way too sweet! The white pie was worse! That had even less cheese and barely any ricotta cheese as I paid extra to have which many white pies include it. Very doughy as well. Then we decided to spend 20 bucks at the "Game room" it was filled with dated games, many broken and some are 1 dollar or more a pop! The prizes that were available for those who won tickets were insulting. I hate giving ratings like These to family own businesses but I came with my own family and we all left disappointed! read more

See all

Oh my gosh, best pizza I've ever had! The sauce was perfectly seasoned. Highly recommend

What a fun find! After a long day of snow-tubing in the mountains, we worked up quite the appetite and wanted to just relax. We found this highly rated super casual pizza joint on Yelp, but of course. We were surprised to find it was so much more! The place all to ourselves on a Saturday night? How good could it be? Really, really good actually! We pretty much ordered one of everything... boneless hot wings, veggie Stromboli, fried pickles, pierogies, fried clam strips and house minestrone. Everything was delicious! Sometimes it's totally ok to just pig out right?! The minestrone soup was so hearty, filled with veggies and tasted homemade, as it was. Yum! It even had baby star pasta I thought was the coolest. Everything was cooked just right. Some of the best fried pickles we've ever had! Portions were very large leaving us with entire meals for the following day! Prices were fair. Service was very prompt. Vibes were super laid back. The especially cool part was the game room with old school games like Pac Man and air hockey, to newer games like Guitar Hero. Some games dispense tickets for the littles to exchange for a prize at the redemption booth! The kids loved this! We did too! They also have an entire wall cooler filled with a decent variety of cans and bottles. The usual suspects as well as few gem crafts! A great stop!! Games, great food, relaxed atmosphere and brews. What's not to love?! read more

See all

Ordered a personal cheese pizza. Great pizza, zesty sauce. Also got a steak Stromboli that was also delish. Thank you!

Complete rip-off. $30 for a large veggie pizza is blatant price gouging. The website does not list prices and says "prices subject to change without notice", which is a good indication of a business that has no intention of charging fair prices or being transparent with customers. The paper menus we had said $22 about a year or two ago. I know inflation is real but I've never seen a $30 pizza anywhere even in big cities like NY, or at fancy craft pizza places. What a joke. read more

We called in two large pizzas and a medium pizza last night for pick up. The pizzas were ready soon after we called them in (maybe 15 minutes), but holy cow is this place expensive; our total was over $50 - BEFORE getting beverages! However, the pizza is very good. I would come back here again for a quick and easy meal next time I'm in the Poconos. read more

Canned mushrooms on a pizza..... that's really upsetting and disgusting. Should be priced as a free topping. So disappointed. read more

Dominic's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania

Their food is delicious and fairly priced! The only downside is everything in their menu is not offered everyday. They have a nice sized dining room and a small game room off to the side. One of my favorite places to eat at when I am in the area! read more

This is a very pleasant Pocono Pizzaria. We especially enjoy the vegetarian pizza. The square Siciliano pizza is delightful. The bar is well stocked and there are many craft beers available for eat in or takeout. If you are lucky you might be there for Kareoke night. Great food and great talent in a family run atmosphere. read more

Love, Dominic's Pizza, great food, period.....We frequent Dominic's every time we visit our cabin in Arrowhead Lake in the Pocono's. We highly recommend Dominic's........ read more