Lovely place with beautiful cozy decor, great service and amazing food. I had the broiled flounder…read morew brown rice and Cole slaw and yes it's pricey at $40 but was a generous portion. Simply cooked, not fancy but the fish was like butter. Amazing!

All these places up here are a bit dicey in the best way, slow service but fine, expensive food,…read morebut fine, decent everything, enjoyed my shrimp sandwich just fine. Not enough stools at the bar, I had to stand to fucking eat and another entire human or two could have fit comfortably

Foods great. Service is awesome. Shagwong IS Montauk. The people are like family. Some actually…read moreare. Definitely a must-go.

Classic Montauk spot we've been going to for years and years. I think the food was better years ago…read morebut they are still doing pretty decent bar food. Drinks are good! Nice to stop in for a drink, service is typically good. Turns into a big night out destination at night so keep that in mind.

I have dined at this establishment many times. I have been here with family, and several others…read morewith friends visiting. I especially like that I can customize my meal to make it Gluten Free (GF). This Bar & Grill does not GF bread, and that's fine. I have been here in both the summer and winter months. The service and ambience are great. The many TVs throughout gives you an opportunity to watch a game or two. I am looking forward to my annual visit in May.

Cute dive bar, good drinks and good food. Can watch almost any sports game that's on. Can stop in…read moreand sit for a meal, or, sit at the bar. Food is good - your standard bar food, something g for everyone. Staff is always friendly.

positive is they have been around forever and in the middle of influencer heaven, maintained being…read morea total dive bar. and cover to get in is only 20$. w that cheap cover place should have been rocking. but ..... negative. when asked if anyone was in the bar on a friday nite (holiday weekend at that) and was told yes so you pay and enter only to find out there are only 3 other people there. basically empty and zero/flatline v lame vibe. so walk out immediately and ask for the 20$ back only to be told no. slimy. thx but no thx for the memory. other places close by that def have a better vibe. or actually have a vibe.

***** COVID Review****…read more ***** Bar Review****** - appearance of the motel rooms is kinda cheap - within walking distance of the beach - no walking up to the bar, bartenders come to you - it takes awhile for them to get to you though * at times, they don't pay much attention - The plus side is that they are one of the only places with night life and music, in the area * The music is decent, too - Drinks are relatively inexpensive

This place is an absolute dive but so fun. Came here for karaoke on a Thursday night and the place…read morewas popping. They charge a cover to get in, but it was worth it to be entertained as hard as we were by the people taking the stage here. Drinks were actually not as expensive as I thought they would be. The bartender here was super fun and in a great mood which really added to the vibe. Karaoke here is on a stage which adds to the performance value in my opinion. They have lots of songs to choose from, and everyone was really supportive. It's definitely an older venue, so don't come in here expecting things to be pristine. That said it has a lot of history to it and I'm glad it's still around. My only complaint was that karaoke ended so abruptly - I wish we had gotten a heads up that it was the last chance to sign up for a song when it was closing down. Lots of fun at this place.

EJ rocks so friendly and great service really the best. he waited patiently while i ordered…read more !!!!!!!!!

Food is great. No lines. Outside appearance not the greatest. If you're looking for a jewel in…read morethe rough, this is the place. My compliments to the chef.

If you're looking for good food in Montauk keep looking…read more My girlfriend and I recently decided to take advantage of a deal for a hotel in the offseason in Montauk. We were looking for dinner Saturday night and of the limited options this place looked potentially good. I was terribly wrong. We walked in to see one other table occupied. Sure, it's the offseason, whatever. We ordered a couple of frozen drinks and the problems immediately started. The bartender used way too much ice in the blender. The drinks were obviously undrinkable but served anyway. The drinks did not melt by the time we left. Maybe the food would be good. Wrong again. The lobster in the lobster pasta was tough. I almost hope it wasn't fresh because it would have been a waste. The linguine with clams was no better. At the end of the meal my girlfriend remarked that she had never seen me not finish my dinner. We both knew why I hadn't. Awful restaurant. The owners should be ashamed.

Highly recommend the Montauk Cycle Boat. We booked the boat on a Saturday Afternoon for a…read morebachelorette party. Due to COVID, we had to rent the whole cycle boat (which can hold up to 16). It was worth every penny. Joe and Dillon were the best crew and made the trip so entertaining for us. Bring your favorite drinks and cycle to local dive bars and eateries. We played cornhole and ate appetizers at our first stop and had mudslides and green tea shots at the next. The locals are fun to interact with and some even followed us from bar to bar. If you're looking for a great time, book this cycle boat!!!

We reserved this place for my bachelorette and they were amazing!!! Joe and Ian were so friendly…read moreand chill and we were able to go to 2 really cool bars along the way! It's byob and we were able to dj too. Would honestly come again all the time if I lived out here, but would recommend must do for a bachelorette or group event.

Murph's is the real deal -- the only true bar in Sag Harbor. No frills, no scene, just cold drinks,…read moregood people, and a vibe that feels untouched by the rest of the Hamptons. It's dark, divey, and perfect. There's even a cigarette machine, which feels like a relic in the best way. The kind of place where locals and visitors blend, the jukebox is always playing something decent, and no one cares who you are -- just what you're drinking. An absolute gem. Long live Murph's.

This is the coolest dive bar in all of Sag Harbor featuring an air conditioned interior, the famous…read morering game, darts, jukebox, and even an old school cigarette dispenser should the mood strike you to light one up. We didn't order any food so I can't attest to the quality. Bartenders were efficient, yet personable. The crowd was mixed but filled with mostly locals.

Some of the best food you can get in Montauk. The clam chowder was AMAZING and the mussels were the…read morefreshest I've ever had. Come early to have a drink and watch the sunset! Eat dinner on the beach! This might be a new staple for me in Montauk

Recently attended a wedding here that was truly magical. The cocktail hour was delicious. All of…read morethe past apps were amazing. Cocktails and dinner were amazing. You can't beat the view at sunset. An amazing venue overall!!

I can't speak for the food as we went on a Saturday day when the place was basically like a club,…read morebut the vibes are UNMATCHED. Decor is absolutely stunning. My frose was delicious. We had a great time!

Cover to enter was very overpriced. Bar and the floor were way too overcrowded, not enough…read morebathrooms for the size of the bar, and poor crowd management. The bathroom is located at the front of the bar by the DJ booth (which is also ALWAYS the most crowded). My friend who was pregnant was pushed aggressively by two patrons and received no help from security trying to use the bathroom.