Walking in really reminded me of old school pizzerias from the '80s. Don't misunderstand. I'm not…read moresaying it looked outdated. It just had a true pizzeria vibe that I remember growing up. The wood on the walls. The floors. The red bench seats. All old school pizzeria. None of this new fancy art Deco stuff. I was simple. I ordered regular cheese slices. There are so many specialty slices offered. If you go. Be adventurous. I didn't go old school and get a fountain drink, I got a bottle Snapple. The pizza had a slight snap of the bread when folded. I miss thin crisp Pizza with a snap. The pizza good flavor in fact I had two slices and went back for a third. The other thing I noticed is the breading didn't have added sugar. It's not easy to find a pizza place that doesn't add sugar to their dough. I had to ask to confirm and I was told no sugar. I really appreciate that. The slices were served hot without any burnt or hard parts of the pizza. It was crispy warm gooey where it needed to be and chewy. Delightful slice

What's with all the hate for this place? It's an old school NY pizza place that has some…read moreinteresting slices with different flavors that actually work. The cheeseburger slice is done well and tastes like a cheeseburger. I actually love it. Their garlic knots stuffed with prosciutto and motz are good too. The pizza is thin and the dough is flavorful. Even though it has some flop, I'm ok with it cause it tastes good. The pizza is better than most of the other places in town that all the townies rave about. This place is my second favorite spot in Huntington!

Wow! This pizza was amazing ! That's a big statement on LI & around NY we have a lot of pizza…read morejoints! Dough & Co tho offers one of the best slices I have had in a very long time. Thin crust / no flop / the best cheese taste / delicious sauce / and they do a pepperoni small cups crispy mmmm sooo good. Comfortable seating, good music @ the right volume to have a conversation. The Guys behind the counter were great too ! I highly recommend this place as some place to come once a week or more! Everyone must try this place!!

Eggplant parm was terrible, mushy too much bread crumb burnt hardened cheese, Caesar salad just…read morelettuce and bagged shredded parm, soups were meh and our $47 Dollar Pizza was below average but the added bonus was the small piece of plastic I chewed up and nearly swallowed. $47 dollar pizza is bananas! I guess I'm the idiot

We went to the dead chefs society supper club event at this restaurant…read more Wow. Mini preview of lasts night. Dead Chef's Tasting Menu at At 1654 Pizza Company - A Gold Coast Supper Club Experience Last night on Long Island's Gold Coast, I had the pleasure of experiencing something truly special: Dead Chef's tasting menu at At 1654 Pizza Company in Huntington. What unfolded wasn't just a dinner, but a full-on culinary performance that transformed the idea of a neighborhood pizza spot into a hidden gem supper club. The evening unfolded course after course, each dish layered with creativity, bold flavors, and a touch of surprise. From refined takes on comfort food to plates that made you pause and savor every detail, it was clear that this wasn't a typical night out--it was a carefully curated journey meant to linger in memory. The atmosphere matched the menu: intimate, buzzing with energy, and elevated by a sense of discovery. Every dish felt like a conversation, and the storytelling behind the flavors was as captivating as the food itself. Outstanding is the only word that fits--yet still feels like an understatement. This wasn't just a meal; it was an experience that makes you excited for what's next.

Wow! I was here for…read morea private event/party on 9/16/25. We were served a selection of different bites; both on the menu and some items that were made special for the evening. Everything was absolutely delicious! Each bite I had was a "wow" of flavors and kept me intrigued for the next course. As soon as I got home I told my fiancé how delicious it was and we will be coming for dinner! Owner Frank was great too. He stopped by our table a few times and also saw me leaving and was friendly and personable. Our sever for the evening was Caitlin and she was great too. Super on top of everything and consistently asked us if we needed anything and if we were good on drinks. When she found out we didn't get one of the courses for the evening she fixed that and brought it out in under 5 minutes. The bathroom was clean and cozy. When is a bathroom ever cozy?! There were candles and the decor is nice. It's always nice to sit on the throne by candlelight! Great experience and delish food!! Can't wait to return.

The cold cheese pizza, a conundrum that's quite hard to understand but very easy to enjoy. What…read moremakes this slice so sought after and a stable of it's location is the cold cheese on top of a hot slice, creating extra enjoyment of mozzarella while also providing three different textures. The top is the flaky, cold mozzarella shreds. The middle features a gooey texture as it's melting with the heat of the slice. And the bottom is just more enjoyment of melted cheese. I recommend this spot.

Their cold cheese slice is perfection. This 5 stars is solely for this slice. Seasoning, cook…read moreand crust are too perfection. Is it the best cheese slice ever? No, but is it the best slice for this kind of pizza? Yes! Bring cash and order 2 cold cheese slices

I was pleasantly surprised. Growing up in an Italian family from Brooklyn I'm pretty spoiled my…read morewhole life with great Italian food so I'm a tough critic. For appetizers we had baked claims and the eggplant rollatini. The eggplant rollatini was cooked perfectly. It was light and the breading didn't fall apart. The baked claims was incredible that I had to dip the bread in that delicious oreganata and I usually don't do that in restaurants but it was too good. My main course was the spaghetti bolognese and I was relieved that there wasn't some sort of vegetable in there to give it a sweeter taste like peas or carrots as they do in some other restaurants. If I have one critique is that there was a lot of meat and I would of liked to taste more of his sauce because every Italian cook needs a signature sauce and I wanted to taste more of his. The restaurant is a little pricey but the portions are generous and the food is fantastic. When you sit down in a nice place with great food in a bougie area that has linens you have to expect to pay but in my opinion worth it. Will definitely go back and I will make sure to make room for the tartufo!

I do recommend Sal D's for the comfortable atmosphere, interior design and convenient parking…read more However, I'm not completely certain of the food and aspect of late dining. We arrived about 7:15 with numerous tables occupied. Greeted nicely, we were asked where we wanted to sit, which was great. Water was eventually brought to us and our waitress was pleasant. I ordered a dish that is normally in a red sauce, but white sauce was also offered. I chose the white, but it lacked flavor. The calamari appetizer was tasty, but rubbery as calamari can be. The other fish dish, I was told was tasty. Soon after we finished, dessert was offered, to which we declined. Then the bill came. We continued to sit and chat. I started seeing unhappy faces and came to realize we were the last diners. Perhaps the restaurant should inform late diners prior to seating that it closed at a certain time. It was only about 8:30. I think I need to re-visit Sal D's at an earlier time and try other dishes, hence the three star rating.

my wife and I went down for a family event found this place out of the blue absolutely perfect the…read morefood was perfect had their salmon the best dish I have had well worth the trip can't wait to go back

Pesto gnocchi is to die for, the spicy rigatoni sauce is so good it HAS to be mentioned, and their…read morecutlets are THE BEST in Huntington. It's hard to go wrong at a place like this the food is so damn good!

Amazing once again pasta, Primavera with pink sauce and chicken…read moreA favorite !!! I could literally eat the whole thing in one sitting it's a big dish. A must try !!!!!

Have taken out / delivered a couple times now and I can confidently say from top to bottom their…read morefood is consistently very good. Easier to find a pizza joint that makes a good slice, harder to find one that can deliver on everything else. Nonna's does the former. From their salads to their mozzarella sticks to their slices to their chicken parm heroes and pastas - everything is really good.

My go to pizzeria when I am in Huntington. Great variety of pies and great quality ingredients.read more

Heavy on the toppings, greasy, no crisp, and a lot of flop. I'd say this NY style pizza might have…read morebeen top tier decades ago, but not in today's pizza game. That being said, it is better than a few other places in town which are just down right terrible. Also, the guy behind the counter was not a friendly dude and seems like he can't wait to get you out of the way for the next customer. I won't be back just based on that alone.

My husband and I were at the movies in Huntington this evening and we knew we were going to get out…read moreof the movie at 9:30. I called around the town of Huntington to find that every restaurant was closing at 10:00 P.M. I looked on my around me app and found Junior's pizzeria and restaurant at 142 New York Avenue in Huntington. When I called a gentlemans voice answered the telephone and I asked what time will they be serving until? The gentleman asked me what time would the movie be over and what time we wanted to come in and eat. He blew us away. When we came into the restaurant he greeted us at the door and we found out that he was the owner and his name was Anthony. Anthony immediately asked how our evening was and told us the specials on the menu and proceeded to help out in the kitchen to prepare our food. Now, I ask you so far is this an amazing, awesome experience? We ordered an Italian salad and by the time my husband and I took our coats off the salad was on the table.I ordered the shrimp marinara parmesan and my husband ordered the eggplant parmesan. The food was out of this world. It came out of the kitchen hot and delicious.The presentation of the salad was as appetizing and beautiful as we have gotten in restaurants where we have paid five times the price of our bill. When the bill came I was shocked how reasonable the prices were for what we ate. We ordered the cannolis for dessert and they were most delicious. All I could say is that if you are looking for a neighborhood clean, comfortable, nicely designed and decorated neighborhoodItalian restaurant I would highly recommend juniors. Happy New year to one and all!!! Stanley and Sandi C

This place is a gem. Anthony's 'Grandma' pie is so great, I would suggest moving to Huntington, if…read moreat all possible, so you can have it a few times a week. Although I live in LA (retired screenwriter), I know LA is not the top city for pizza, but I am originally from New York, and I believe New York is in that top slot, and I feel that Junior's Pizza, on New York Ave in Huntington is about as good as pizza gets-- anywhere. I used to drive 75 miles from Manhattan with my friends to Trenton, NJ to eat pizza at DeLorenzo's which was our #1 spot for years. When it closed, Junior's in Huntington became our #1 spot. This is a simple, warm place with an owner who knows how to bake a pie. He has studied his craft, and has perfected it. I don't get to NY too often, but when I do, eating Anthony's 'Grandma' pie at Junior's makes the trip worth it. No place like it.

These sandwiches were SO good! I live pretty far from this place, but I happened to be in the area…read moreand decided to stop by. I wasn't even that hungry, but I'm so glad we did! I ordered the Desi Boy sandwich, and my boyfriend got the Hot Chick both were delicious. I'll definitely be making the trip back to try some of their other sandwiches. The server was also incredibly nice and friendly, and the service was great from start to finish. Definitely worth checking out!

Dishonest. I was charged $10 for two plain slices. $5 a slice is pretty steep as a walk-in. They…read moretake advantage of the out-of-town crowd coming from The Paramount after a show. Also, the 3% credit card surcharge added to the $5 slice confirms they're predatory.