Absolutely delicious! This time was just antipast with Jimmy's homemade dressing along with pizzas...Bee Sting pizza highly recommended!!!! Dough is so good, everything homemade and out of this world!!!! read more

Should not be a pizza place. But if you want the best Italian food this side of the Atlantic, go here. All the pasta and sauces and well everything is made in house and sourced locally. The best Italian food I've ever had outside of Italy itself. I've had many dishes here and it's my go to spot on date night. I don't know why they try so hard to turn into a pizza place. It doesn't make sense to me when they should stick to what they are best at. Highly recommend the lobster Mac, beef stroganoff, gnocchi, and anything with the homemade pasta. The chicken parm is out of this world and the portions are huge! read more

Ordered the eggplant parm. Flavorless, watery "sauce" and a not-so-winning combination of soggy eggplant and breading. Utterly inedible mush. The waitress was personable and attentive at the outset. Didn't bother to ask if the food was okay but did comp the portion once she was told. I give her credit for that. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Updated review: Service has gotten so much worse. We sat down at 6:15 and at 7:59 we decided to get our check and leave. We were waiting on 2 pasta dishes. It's extremely disappointing to not even be told they are busy today or having issues. Just left in the dark :( We would like to come back but are unsure. People came in ate, got there food ate and left with us sitting. We understand that you're having issues that day. Just please tell us. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Lobster Mac - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Service was awesome however the food while not bad failed to stand out. Pizza was just OK.

Great food and great service. Supporting local businesses! Would definitely go back!

The food is amazing, Service is the best, and the inside is a vibe, the restaurant is the best!

Wow!!! What a find for an afternoon lunch on a snowy day. Highly recommend the Bee Sting pizza. 5 star. Fantastic flavors together. Also ordered the Italian greens. Also impressed. Small loaf of Italian bread they bring.. soft and crusty. First time visitor - I will definitely be back. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Bee Sting Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Was in town for the night and stopped in. Had high hopes. Place was crowded and it seemed they only had one waitress which slowed things down. Food and drinks took a long time to come out. Waitress was very nice but she was overwhelmed. I ordered the chicken parm and when it finally came out something seemed off. The dish had a burnt odor and taste to it....but it wasn't burnt. Was very weird. Overall the sauce wasn't good and was watery. The chicken was good and tender. It was served in a small bowl which seemed odd and there was only one piece of chicken. Seemed rushed and half assed. I will say their pizza looked good. I probably should have went with that. Was dissapointed overall. read more

We made last minute reservations for 8 people and they were very accommodating. We were quickly seated in a nice side room and greeted by our waitress. I wish I remembered her name because she did a great job the whole meal. To make it simple everything was very fresh and cooked perfectly. The table enjoyed very fresh salads or antipasto. All with generous portions. For entrees there was perfectly made pizza, large raviolis, and Frutti di Mare, clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops, and calamari over our homemade fettuccini which was a huge serving. One reason we went here was we have some gluten free people. Their new gluten free Cauliflower pizza done with chicken bacon ranch was a hit along with the chicken riggies. One has very sensitive celiac disease and she had no issues. They did a good job with the GF. We had a time crunch to get to a concert and they were very accommodating to help us on our way asap once we were done. Sorry no pics as we dug right in to eat. We will be back. read more

I highly recommend the food and service at DiCastro's! We had family visiting from Oregon and it was wonderful to have them enjoy great food , atmosphere, and an excellent waitress! read more

Disgusting food and extremely rude owner. Not only will I never set foot in this establishment again, but I'm telling g everyone I know to avoid this horrible restaurant. read more

Great food!!! Chicken Marsala is awesome. Highly recommend supporting your local businesses.

Passing through New York State and saw their advertisement of homemade pasta. The food did not disappoint. Something unique to the area is chicken Reggie's is worth the try. Fabulous atmosphere and food. Reasonable pricing. read more

See all

I read really good reviews on this restaurant so we gave it a try and it was really good. The service was also good. Our waitress was attentive. Our food came out piping hot and fresh. I'll definitely make my way back here again for dinner. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Shrimp and broccoli Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

See all

Been here twice now. Excellent service (cheerful and attentive wait staff); fantastic atmosphere; and awesome wood fired pizza. I've been here both with and without my 7 and 9 year old boys. Both times had an excellent experience. Reading through some of the negative reviews, doesn't sound like many of them are the restaurant's fault (group of 30 plus didn't get amazing service at a small restaurant- big surprise; knocking off stars for not having draft beer- how is that poor service? Things like that lol). The place has excellent pizza and great service. I'll be back again soon. read more

See all

One of my favorite restaurants in Rome! Absolutely love the atmosphere, food and staff. Lindsey is usually our server..and is phenomenal each time! Never a bad meal. Highly reccomend if you're in the area read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

See all

Met family for dinner on Sunday. The rice balls were a special appetizer (not on the regular menu). They were two types. One filing was green and tasted of broccoli & pesto and the other was white and tasted of cheese. The Chicken Reggie's had a good amount of chicken with a sauce that was creamy. It did not have any hot peppers in it but you can ask for them if you like your Reggie's to be spicy. The food was of good quality and the service was prompt and attentive. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Chicken Reggie with olives and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

I ordered a take-out 16" Margarita Pizza. It seems like they use a dough that is for a 12" pie and stretch it out. Bottom of the pie was charred and looked like the oven baking surface was never cleaned. Also ordered a Capricci salad which was mushy and tasteless. Service staff friendly, nice atmosphere in the restaurant. Food, not so good. read more

Went on a whim after bowling as we were celebrating our grandson's birthday. We went for the pizza which was good. However, the other meals were disappointing. I had the Braciole special which was tasteless, pasta sauce as well. Alfredo was weird and some of the shellfish in the Fra Diavolo was suspect. I am so tired of going out to eat and being served crap! Server was very pleasant and attentive. read more

Ordered a pizza on a Friday night for the family, only to get the pizza home, open the box and find a burnt, literally to crisp, pizza crust and bottom was burnt up also. Had half a slice because I was starving and had to spit it out because it tasted like an ashtray! Manager tried playing it off saying "sometimes the flour gets a litte char from the brick oven" the laziness and ineptitude from this management to actually put a burnt pizza in a box and sell to someone shows the low class of this establishment. Horrible experience, do not recommend to anyone (not even people I don't like) read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Found this place while exploring the area. What a great find! Staff were friendly and helpful and the owner spent time talking with us. The pasta is all made on the premises. My husband had the pizza and it was exceptional! My lasagna was truly delicious with layers of perfectly cooked pasta and lots of cheese and meat. The owner explained that he uses 4 different cheeses in it! We couldn't have been more pleased with everything about this place! If you're anywhere near here make it a point to stop in and have a real great meal! read more

How have I missed visiting DiCastro's before? A friend suggested them so my husband and I stopped in on a rainy Saturday night. We had a bit of a wait but had a friendly bartender who showed us pics of his cute puppies he had for sale! Once seated we started with the antipasto. A basic selection of lettuce, meats, etc, the dressing was the star of the show and made the whole dish! The freshly baked bread was fantastic and worth the drive over from Sylvan Beach for the bread alone! Continuing on a carb fest after our yummy loaf of bread we had one of their wood fired pizzas that was also very good. Nice crust and delicious toppings but after our antipasto and bread, we couldn't even finish the smaller size! Most folks around us had pasta entrees that all looked great and we were pleased to see a large gluten free pasta selection that will please our niece with Celiac's as she rarely has a choice other than gluten free spaghetti. We will definitely be back to try more items on the menu! read more

After hearing family was no longer satisfied with the food and customer service, we ordered a pizza anyways since we had found a coupon on Yelp. We have eaten here our entire childhood, and were excited for the brick oven pizza we were so fond of. The employee informed us (after asking 2 other coworkers) that he had never seen the coupon before but would give the discount stated a price. Then the owner sent the employee a text message saying would be no coupon because it was an "unapproved coupon". On top of that, there was a $3 card fee (not due to a minimum price but because all transactions with cards have a $3 card fee). The owner then called the restaurant and and the employee asked if I wanted to talk to the owner but at this point I did not want to be told by yet another person that I was unable to get a $3-$4 discount on a pizza due to a technicality I had no way of knowing. The inflexibility of the owner is inexcusable and must be the reason for the completely empty restaurant we walked into when we came to pick up the pizza. Pizza was okay, but the experience was soured by our encounter at the restaurant. It's a shame that we will no longer be coming here due to repeated lack of customer service. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - An active coupon that was "unapproved" by the owner (which we were only informed that it was unapproved after the payment was made). - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Waited in a Normas amount of time for our entrées once again like many places in Rome and Utica the sauce is just bland. pizza was undercooked crust was not crispy. Service was OK we didn't see our server too much and we had to wait a while to pay. read more

So the food was good when it came out. We had a reservation for 6pm and just got our food at 7:35pm. It also didn't all come out together. The service was bad. I'm thinking we might not go here again. read more

Best brick oven charred wings! Pizza is amazing and I love the cheese. Try everything! You won't be disappointed

So I got takeout. I really liked the pizza! I think it's a bit pricey ($20 for a large) but it was delicious. The staff was welcoming and friendly. I would definitely eat there sometime to try it out. The medium pizza was pretty small and I actually thought it was a small. If you do takeout, they don't have two liters so you have to go across the street to fastrac. Even though I only got pizzas, they were really good and I would return as long as I wasn't watching my budget. read more

Absolutely delicious Chicken Riggies! The time before last I wasn't a huge fan of their pizza but I'm picky about my pizza. They had a very nice atmosphere and the staff were incredible. read more

We were in Rome dropping my kids at camp. it was also my birthday so we looked for a restaurant nearby. We saw DiCastro's and, despite some of the negative reviews, decided to give it a try. Aside from not knowing how to get seated (there was no hostess station), we had such a lovely time! Our waitress was AMAZING and the food was divine. The atmosphere was cozy and lively. We would totally come here again!! Loved it. read more

I had the chicken Parmesan which was pretty good except I did not care for the sauce. It was very tart, not to my liking. The bread was bland so I did not eat that. Other family members said their food was satisfactory, but a few others had issues with their meals. Nothing was done to remedy this. The restaurant and bathrooms were clean, and the wait staff was exceptional. I doubt I'll return mainly because I felt the overall experience was just okay, nothing to write home about. read more

Last night's horrible incidents have led me (and all of my paying colleagues) to the unfortunate decision to never go here again. I'd heard of other guests' experiences being poor but didn't quite believe them because I've only had positive experiences in my previous visits. I often got pizza to go or have dined in several times a year. The pizza and our bartender were great. The way our group was treated by management was unbelievable. After our group of 30 people purchased $400 worth of food and numerous drinks, some people sat in the adjacent dining area which was empty because there were only two tables available in the immediate bar area. (All of the pizzas that we ordered were placed on a table in this empty room.) Just as people began to eat their meals, we were informed by a waiter that we had to move immediately to make room for the impending dinner crowd (at 4:30). We were forced to gather up our plates and drinks and eat crowded around the tables in the bar. There did not end up being a dinner rush. Three couples ate in that area between 4:30 and 7:00 (when we were not so politely asked to leave). Our group condensed to the bar area, where we continued to have drinks and finish our food. After about an hour or so, we were approached by one of the owners and were told that we needed to quiet down because they were a family restaurant and there were other patrons in the adjacent room. Then, asked when our group would be finished. No one in our party was being belligerent, but they still felt it necessary to make us believe that we were putting them out by being there. read more

With CNY being the hub of pasta and pizza, there are so many places to choose from. DiCastro's is one of my favorite places to have authentic brick oven pizza and their pasta is to die for. Way better than choosing a pizza chain. I recommend trying their Bee Sting pizza. Their house salad comes with a delightful in house made balsamic dressing which I can't find else where. As for pasta, I really enjoyed their florentine haddock that comes with a cream sauce and fresh pasta. read more

The owner had an attitude when I asked to be seated in another section of the restaurant as no tables were clean, waited 20 mins for drinks to be brought to the table. No bread was brought once seated. Antipasto was brought with dinner. One meal was brought before all others. Bread came out after all dishes were served. This is not the first time. This place has great food and horrible service starting with the owner. She is absolutely miserable. I wish I could give less than 1 star. read more

Fair meal and good service at a reasonable price. I wasn't particularly impressed with my meal, but it wasn't bad. Several of our group had lunch sandwiches and they were short on meat with rolls that were too big. Flavors were ok, but not super impressive. No draft beer options seemed a little odd to me. We did like their pasta salad, which can be selected as a side with a sandwich and the homemade chips, which are also a side option. They have quite a bit of background and history of Rome both on display and in books you can look through. Interesting, but not a reason to stop in. Not sure I would come back again. read more

Seated by hostess in back room although there were several tables open in main dining room. Waited for almost 15 minutes without a menu, drink order, anything while waitresses stood at bar talking. Frustrated and left. Poor customer service. read more

This place has the best brick oven pizza! It is a little more on the pricey side but the food tastes very good!

Disappointment is an understatement. When this place first opened a few years ago it was a fresh new establishment with great pizza, decent Italian, and competitive prices. Flash forward to today. The general consensus of our party was the food was average to poor, depending on what you got. The prices... outlandish!! Especially for Rome NY!! We got a 3 topping pizza $21, plus $1.80 for extra SAUCE(?)...NOBODY else charges for this!! Manicotti $17, plus meatballs $4.50 Coffee, Water. Gratuity auto added and $1.75 fee for using a debit card $61 meal for two with no beverages but coffee and water...and it was pasta and pizza. Not surf and turf!! Admittedly, the service and staff were great. But the bottom line is the food and the prices were not. No thanks. I'll stick to LaRomas... The Franklyn... hell I'll drive to Camden and go to Avicolis!! One place I'll never go back to is this place. read more

Stopped in while traveling through new York. Wonderful find. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. They had plenty of options on the menu including homemade pasta. The wood fired pizza was amazing (the bee sting was our favorite). Great atmosphere, very clean and cozy. read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven - The bee sting. " Who knew honey would be so good on pizza" - the tiny human that travels with us. - Pizza Near Me - Rome, New York

Worst customer service I've ever dealt with. We ordered 3 pizzas and one was extremely burnt to a crisp. Owner was rude when I called said it's the type of oven I said no this pizza is burnt. I was kindly asking for a new one to exchange and he hung the phone up on me. Drove there to get a refund and was told to never order from them again. No problem I will never speak kindly of this restaurant ever again! read more