I've found Dean's professional to be predatory nickel and dimers.
I originally started with Dean's because my sump pump wasn't working. I have pipes wrapping around the house to drain at a lower elevation, and I didn't know that I was supposed to take off the cap in the winter to let it drain in a short path instead of the long. So the long path froze, and the pipes didn't work. Pop off the cap, no more problems.
Dean's wanted thousands of dollars to reroute those PVC pipes, but never explained why they needed to be rerouted. Remove the short route cap in the winter, put it back on in the spring, lesson learned. They also tried to get me to replace my sump pump, and pipes leading outside, which he described as professional grade, and in good condition. When trying to understand their reasoning, he was saying, "just to be safe".
At this point I wasn't yet convinced that Dean's Professional can't be trusted. The plumber managed to convince me to get their membership which includes visits to inspect things like the furnace, air conditioner, and plumbing. Not being an expert in any of these areas, I thought it was a good idea to have them routinely checked.
My first routine checkup comes around, and here's where I'm now fully convinced never to do business with them again. I won't say his name because I don't want them to get fired, I just want to warn others to be warned, and I want companies to know that this behavior won't be tolerated, and they will lose business from it.
I'm not claiming that Dean's has been untruthful, or even incompetent. What I am claiming, however, is that they do not do business with your best interests at heart.
Here were their recommendations, each one of them was conveyed to me like it was a critical life or death issue.
Replace weak draft motor - $954 -- This was because it was reading 3 amps instead of 2.8. This is nominal.
Replace weak flame sensor - $405 -- Again, because the reading was under 5-10% outside of perfect.
Clean dirty blower wheel - $465 -- If I could get paid 465 dollars to spray something for 5 minutes with canned air, I'd change my career.
Clean drain tray - $115
Reconnect dryer vent - $115 - Wow... he's not even here for the dryer. It took me literally 5 seconds to put that back on and tighten it as soon as I noticed it came loose.
Replace filter cabinet - $389 - Because it got dusty. That's what filter cabinets do, they collect dust. I'll clean it myself and keep the $389
Replace heat exchanger - $1075 for labor only - So this one is why it's important to get furnace inspections. My furnace was putting out 220ppm of carbon monoxide, and that number should be below 100ppm. He then 'red tagged' my furnace, turned off the gas, powered the furnace off, and disconnected the flame sensor. After some research I found that yes, this isn't good and should be taken care of promptly, but it isn't at all as dangerous as he described. The carbon monoxide is vented out, and there are safeties in place to make sure the furnace shuts off if the vents get blocked. It has probably been running that way for years, and I have CO detectors. What's more dangerous is going without heat in the dead of a Minnesota winter.
So because of that high price tag and the list of other bull he's trying to sell me on, I decided to get a second opinion. I had another company come and inspect. I didn't mention the list of recommendations, I wanted to see what he would come up with independently.
The second inspection came in:
- the draft motor is good
- flame sensor is good
- gas pressure needs adjusting
- burn test for the heat exchanger did come in high in CO. He adjusted the gas valve pressure, which brought it down from 220 to 140. This is still high and he did recommended replacing it. He gave me an estimate of $500 labor, not $1100
Getting a second opinion has just saved me a total of $3118. It's definitely worth the extra trip fee to get a second opinion from elsewhere. read more