If you're anywhere near Green Bay and craving incredible food, do yourself a favor and stop by…read moreOlive's Pizza and Sandwiches. This place is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, welcoming atmosphere, an open kitchen, wonderful smells, and the kind of friendly service that makes you feel like a regular, even on your first visit. The staff is upbeat, attentive, and genuinely seems to care that you're having a great experience. The pizza is phenomenal! It's perfectly crisp crust, generous toppings, and that ideal balance of sauce and cheese. Every bite tastes fresh and thoughtfully made. We had a pepperoni pizza with hand tossed crust, and a mac and cheese pizza with a thin crust! Both were fantastic. We also had the balsamic chicken and arugula flatbread; another winner! Hands down one of the best places in Green Bay for pizza, we look forward to trying some of the sandwiches next time. Five stars all the way! We'll definitely be back!

We were running errands down in Green Bay recently and searched yelp for a high rated sandwich,…read moreshop and landed at Olives. What a hidden gem, a half mile off the highway, but you may need your GPS to navigate to it. Being from New England originally, I was delighted to find what they carried main lobster rolls for a limited time, so I had to order one of those and then we ordered a spicy Italian sub and split both for variety. Both sandwiches were superb, and the lobster rolls were significantly less expensive than the small handful of places that you can find them here in Northeast Wisconsin. The place was fairly empty because we got there well after lunch hour, but we were surprised to not see anyone else in there because this place is far better than most other options, including, but not limited to the corporate franchise options like subway, Jimmy John's, firehouse, subs, etc. Nothing beats Local small business owned restaurants like this! The staff was very friendly, and although the place was empty, they were processing a bunch of phone orders and we've watched a bunch of people come through for pick ups. Our sandwiches were prepared within five minutes, and they were absolutely delicious! We highly recommend this place and plan to go back next time we're off the Door Peninsula and down in that Green Bay area around lunch.

Absolutely magical experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm, friendly , and…read moreinviting . Every dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented -- especially the homemade pasta and the pizza !! . The staff was attentive, friendly, and made us feel genuinely welcomed the entire experience . You can tell this restaurant truly cares about quality and customer experience. Easily one of the best Italian restaurants I've visited, and I can't wait to come back. Highly recommend to anyone looking for amazing food, great service, and a perfect night out! Thank you for making my trip to Green Bay memorable  Wendi and Linda

Good service. Old school family restaurant ambiance. Decent pizza. I think this area overall is…read morefood challenged considering that several locals raved about Sammy's. I guess just not what I'm used to. The staff was very friendly.

Stopped by and was a very nice pizza joint! The service was good and the pizza was pretty darn…read moregood. We got a veggie pizza. I like the sauce and cheese but the crust could use a little something. Had a good crisp but taste was okay. I would stop by and check out Riverside. We enjoyed it overall.

Service was ok, the waitress/bartender got one of our orders wrong so didnt charge the add on that…read morewasnt. Ambiance was nice and relaxing. Beer was ice cold. Pizza was subpar. The crust was crispy, which was the only good part. Sauce was too heavy, toppings were minimal and the cheese was nonexistent on some pieces. I didnt dig their pizza slicing into small kid pieces. Salad was good but definitely not worth $6.95. Pizzas are over priced for the small portion.

Great place for Pizza in the Green Bay Area. Service was prompt and attentive and the food was…read moregreat.

We just had Rustique Pizzeria catering our post-elopement reception, and could not have been…read morehappier! Everything was so easy to coordinate! They went above and beyond to make sure we had options for all our guest despite having allergies. They had amazing communication and on the day of, hardly needed a thing so we could have a great time! Afterwards had so many people compliment the food! So grateful we found them and would highly recommend them for your event! Much love from the new Theado's!

Waitress was great, food was perfect. Did not take long to get, we waited for a table longer than…read moreit took for our food. The food is made fresh to order with an open kitchen to watch them make the dough and a pizza. The bread basket is HUGE, only had a couple pieces and had plenty left over. The prices are very decent for the amount and quality of the food. Very clean inside and out. You can also buy souvenir shirts, and some other items.

We came here for lunch. It was so cold inside the restaurant that I kept my winter coat on…read more Overall, the pizza was pretty good but overpriced. Our server was friendly but never gave my water a refill.

We had Oley's cater our daughters wedding rehearsal dinner at our home and it was fabulous! The…read morepizza was great! The Service was excellent and would recommend 100%! Thanks Oley and Jennifer!

We had them cater for our wedding and it was the best decision we made! They were able to get pizza…read moreout for 150 people in a timely manner and quality was not lowered at all. Their pizza got great reviews from our guests. Would totally recommend them for any wedding or large gathering!!

Lunch at Il Ritrovo in Sheboygan was outstanding from start to finish. The house made bread alone…read moreis worth the visit ... warm, fresh, and absolutely spectacular. We ordered everything that was on special today, and every dish impressed. The smoked trout salad with arugula was bright, flavorful, and beautifully balanced. The four cheese pizza ... featuring Taleggio, ricotta, mozzarella, and one other cheese I can't remember ... topped with speck ... was truly to die for. We also tried the mortadella ravioli in a rich brown butter sauce, and it was nothing short of phenomenal. Service was absolutely incredible ... attentive, friendly, and genuinely welcoming. Highly recommend Il Ritrovo ... a must visit in Sheboygan! And, one of three certified Neapolitan pizza places in the whole state of Wisconsin!

Il Ritrovo has never disappointed me - i love all their pizzas and salads. They are all super…read moreflavorful and I love the crust. Their staff is all super nice - there may be a wait on weekend nights, so be prepared to wait. There is bar seating and a waiting space available if you have to wait. Street parking is available, and there's a parking lot in the back.

Delish! Thin crust pizza was delightful - chicken, bacon, pineapple, mmm. Garlic knots were the…read morebest I've had in as long as I can remember. Only complaint is that I wish we had more marinara but besides that.... A post tailgate Heaven.

Im a regular customer and my brother and my dad went to get a pizza and they are new with ordering,…read morebut they accidentally called the wrong place even though the number did show being Bellevue but for some reason it reached the other locations number. Anyway, they tried to go to the Bellevue location to pick it up, but they said they won't make us one because it's a waste of food and time. Never coming back .

It was so insane and super good with pizza! I love it so much I rated 5 stars! ! It so tasty!read more

The new owner has run this place into the ground. Gone are the days when Jon and Anne owned it. He…read moretreats his employees like garbage and works them to death. The quality of the food has gone down so far that it no longer tastes like it used to. They seem to be using premade crusts and are using cheaper ingredients. It has lost most of the flavors.When the owner works, he's clueless and just gets in the way of the employees who are trying to do their jobs. They shouldn't have to be training HIM in his own restaurant. If it closed down one day, it would be no surprise.

Another terrific meal at Wild Tomato! Pizza and family style…read moreCaesar salad was yummy! We will be back soon

Wild Tomato has two locations in Door County, and we visited the one in Sister Bay--a very popular…read morespot! When we arrived, we were told there would be a 1-hour wait for a table and a 1-hour wait for takeout. A wait that long is a bit much, but Door County is super popular in the summer, and we used the time to walk around the marina and explore the area. Their wood-fired pizzas are $23 for a small and $27 for a large. We ordered takeout, and our food was ready right on time after about an hour. The pizza was great, and I would definitely go back next time I'm in Door County. There's also free street parking nearby, which makes stopping in even easier. Just remember to go early if visiting in the summer to avoid long wait times!