I highly recommend Sandy Kakes! We have ordered 8 cakes from her. We order 1st birthday cakes for…read moreour grandchildren and they are always beautiful.

Sandy Kakes comes thru. I reached out short notice asking g for a simple 12 person round cake for…read moremy moms 70th birthday celebration. Sandy opened on Monday for us to pick up the cake, a day she's normally off work. The cake was perfect and tasted just as good! We communicated all thru email and she was prompt and very response with clear direction and nice suggestions for cake decorations.

The best bakery around!! You'll never regret stopping here. The staff is so friendly and lovely…read more They make amazing baked goods and cakes. Everytime I'm in town I make sure this is my first stop!

A yummy, independent bakery just off of the square! Neat-O's has unique sweet treats all year long,…read moreeither behind the counter or prepackaged items like cookies/puppy chow to grab in the front. There is a ton of variety from in-house decorated cookies, pastries, bars and cake slices available. The prices are great for a local fresh bakery. A dozen chocolate chip cookies baked the same day for $10? Yes, please! Neat-O's does custom orders for cakes and other baked items. They catered my niece's party with lots of sweet, frosted, buttery donuts that tasted so fresh and upscale for a reasonable price. There is usually only one staff member working but they always are polite and efficient. They close relatively early (2pm) so I'd consider it weekend spot unless you're off for the day. It's a smaller shop and there isn't much seating so it isn't a place I'd plan on bringing family to sit down. If you have 5 bucks in your pocket, pop in while you're hanging on the square and treat yourself to something sweet!

I've never had a bad experience here, but I have a major sweet tooth. The thick frostings and fact…read morethat a lot of the cupcakes they make are filled inside with frosting and a ton on top can be a lot for an average sweets consumer even with the more sour or fruity flavored items. They also make other bakery items and beautiful custom cakes for graduations, weddings and such. It's a little more expensive for the area, but the quality of the items, freshness, and service are worth filling a box every once in awhile to treat yourself. Their pink boxes have become a recognizable object in Oshkosh! In a larger city the lack of no lot and further away street parking might be a hindrance, but being younger and able having to carry items halfway down a block hasn't impeded impulse stopping to buy. There is 1-2 spots of short term (15 min) parking in front, but every time I've been there they've been taken. The Lick the Bowl cupcake is my favorite option!

Cutest bakery I've been to in Oshkosh. The atmosphere was friendly, and there were many customers…read morein the store. I ordered a gluten free wedding cake cupcake and it was delicious! They also had really adorable Taylor swift cookies too.

I was here to order a birthday cake. I was here only because of the beautiful pictures of the cakes…read moreI saw in Yelp and other platforms. I ordered a cake in the shape of a dump truck. I thought they noted down the order correctly. The day before pick up I got a call asking what decoration I want. And when I picked up the cake, it was just a plain round cake with balloons drawn on top. It was a big dissappointment. It was a vanilla chocolate cake. I thought the cake was ok, nothing to complain about.

Two Sisters made my daughter's birthday cake. I filled out a form online about a week in advance,…read moreand they called me 2 days later. My daughter wanted a "math" birthday cake, and they did a fantastic job with decorations (see pictures). I love the equations they used, including the joke equations (3-2=2). Tasted amazing too. Will definitely be using them again.

We stumbled upon Buttercream Bakery while in town for a basketball tournament. If the review were…read moresolely based on service and selection, it would be 5 stars, hard stop. The service was incredibly friendly, and amazingly fast, given we had a larger order and the place was fairly busy. There were plenty of options; from drink options/flavors, to bakery and breakfast items, etc. If you can't find something to order, that is completely on you because the choices are plenty. We opted for a couple of seasonal lattes, which were, unfortunately, very lacking in flavor. I typically order my coffee drinks half sweet, but this particular day I was wanting something sweet and flavorful so I skipped that directive, and was still disappointed. Bakery items and other drinks were good. There was some sort of market happening in the front of the store, which could have caused for more crowding/chaos elsewhere, but overall it felt like there was a lot of "stuff" everywhere. The seating area seems really crowded, but also didn't appear to have been cleaned in a while. There was a messy desk back by the bathrooms, and while I understand this is probably a busy work area for someone, it all just made me feel a little stressed out. Not a place I would feel relaxed to complete any work.

We have been ordering cakes from Buttercream Bakery for a few years and have always been extremely…read morehappy with the service and the cakes. This year Buttercream Bakery offered sides and rolls for Thanksgiving. I ordered the Brussel sprouts, Squash, and a dozen rolls. I am so very happy with all of it! The squash was AMAZING!!! One of the other things I like is they have a Facebook page and you can order through Facebook messenger. Very convenient. I highly recommend Buttercream Bakery!

Heirloom Bakery made beautiful, delicious vegan cupcakes to order. Quick and easy to work worth…read moreover Instagram direct message with lots of flavor options for both cake and frosting. I ordered chocolate cake with cookies and cream frosting and carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. Pickup and payment were easy. Everyone at the party was raving about them. Highly recommend!!

Outstanding bakery with stunning and delicious pastries and cakes. Don't miss out on their cookie…read moresandwiches - best I've ever had!

Update: This address is their actual address (side building of Cleo's)…read more The wedding I was at most recently had featured Fat Girlz Bakin mini cupcakes in 3 flavors. They were all very good but carrot cake was the crowd favorite by far. I have a wedding coming up and I plan on stopping in soon to see what they can offer!

Really are the BEST cupcakes I ever had! I think everybody's idea of a good cupcake is different…read more The reason I LOVE these is because they are NOT over the top sweet! They are full of flavor...and you can tell quality flavors! But not so stinking sweet you need to take a drink of water to wash it down. I love the wrapping the baker choose to bake these cupcakes in. Makes eating it so much easier. I have had 3 flavors so far. Carrot cake, Vanilla Bean with Mascarpone frosting and Caramel Macchiato. Although it was the best carrot cake I have had..........I still think the vanilla bean was my favorite cupcake from here (so far!). I doubt any of them are bad...can't wait for my next trip to cupcake heaven!

Good food and terrific owner I can't imagine anyone not enjoying the food and loving Anna…read more The dining room has always been nice and cozy but I'll admit I have not been a dine in since before the pandemic. But I would think it would be the same. I usually do Take out only.

Wow ! Make a trip off the beaten path and come to this place …read more I don't like sweets that much and I find myself craving these cupcakes ! The flavor combinations at this place are out of this world ! The cupcakes themselves have amazing texture ! Each cupcake is topped with its perfect frosting companion for the ultimate finishing touch ! If these cupcakes were ever entered into a contest they would win every time. They sell both big cupcakes and smaller bite sized ones . Prices for these are spot on ! They are only open Friday , Saturday and Sunday . They cater for events ! My sister used this place for her wedding and it was a huge hit .

We used to visit iSparkle when we lived in the area. What makes it great is the enthusiasm of the…read moreyoung owner...she is awesome! The regular sized cupcakes are fantastic (and she does many flavors, but on different days to mix it up). The large, cake-size, cupcakes aren't as tasty -- but they look great :)

Very cute shop! First visit we purchased 5 "pretty" cupcakes and only 2 were tasteful and only 1…read moretasted like the name it was called. On visit 2 (a few weeks later) we asked the owner about the flavors that were not in the cupcakes we purchased. She said it should have tasted like the names. We expressed our disappointment with how she names them vs the flavor because 4 out of 5 did not reflect the name. Blueberry cupcake....Not only did the cupcake not taste like blueberry but the "blueberry" on top was not even a blueberry. The mint cupcakes are vanilla dyed green and the only flavor we could taste was the chocolate chips. The cookie dough is more of a sugar peanut butter blend (very grainy). Our favorite cupcakes to date.... Cookies and cream, salted Carmel and maple bacon. Our last visit was last week and we have to travel to get to her location (we are opposite side of town) and she was closed.....during the week. We follow her on Facebook as well and nothing was posted on that site (this is not the first time that we have traveled to find her closed). We ended up stopping at a new bakery in town. We now have 3 sweet bakery's in a 15 mile radius (2 just opened) It will be interesting to see how I Sparkle is impacted. She's got the "pretty" look but the flavors are up for grabs in my opinion. Overall we will continue to visit I Sparkle because the cupcakes are cute. My recommendation to new customers..... ALWAYS ASK what the cupcake tastes like vs the name and if you are traveling there CALL ahead since she closes without notice.

The ladies that helped me were amazing. I had so many questions and about the cupcakes and they…read moreanswered all of them! Before I go into detail about each one I had, I want to say that all of them were good and have a filling! If that isn't reason enough to check out this bakery, I don't know what is. Red Velvet: This one was my favorite! The cream cheese frosting, red velvet cake, and chocolate ganache-like/pudding center should be proof enough. I would eat this cake until I got sick. It is fantastic! Lick the Bowl: The lady that was helping me said that this is the best seller. Its oreo-flavored icing is light and tastes like it was whipped. This cake is moist and bring the flavors of the cupcake together very well. Lastly, a mini brownie and cookie dough piece both garnish the top. Peanut Butter Cup: A good choice if you like peanut butter. The chocolate cake is either dry or overcooked. However, the icing has a rich flavorful taste and the center is a chocolate ganache. Cookie Dough Craving: Perfect if you like cookie dough. The buttercream icing is my favorite. However, the chocolate cake is either dry or overcooked. It is garnished with a piece of cookie dough and the center is the same. I recommend going to this bakery if you're in or around Appleton!

Tamara's baked the most magnificent birthday cake for me. I gave them a wedding cake inspiration…read morephoto and they did a perfect masterpiece for me. Cake was 2 tiered and both the almond tier (lemon curd/raspberry filling) and chocolate tier tasted wonderful. Staff was easy to communicate with and made collaboration a total joy. This is the second time I've ordered a custom cake and I highly recommend hiring Tamara's to you. The cake was made on time and packaged so I could transport with ease. Casaloma location is easy to get to. Thank you for making my weekday birthday during a pandemic extra special. This team is a true team!