The nicest hotel we stayed at during our weeklong tour of Scotland. The staff are incredible, they…read moremake a superlative effort to make you feel welcome and taken care of. The building is stunning, the setting is spectacular (take a walk across the dam), the rooms beautifully appointed, the meals 2nd to none. I recommend this hotel without reservations... Oh, almost forgot the bar is huge with an incredible view of the loch. Have a drink up there!

Great location and ambiance. Service top notch. Walk around the lake to pitlockey cute town have a…read morebeer at the old mill.

By far my best dinner in Scotland. Seafood, Steak pie, Indian Curry, and pepperoni pizza all on one…read moretable down by the river. Oh, and the Gin and tonics were solid too.

If you get lucky like me and its a warm sunny day in Dunkeld, make sure you check out this Hotel's…read morebeer garden along the river Tay. You just order your beer and food inside the hotel bar and wonder down to the picnic tables to enjoy the day. The fish and chips was solid and they also have specials after 5pm. Simply a picturesque spot with solid food and beer.

Unfortunately, while touring, we only had less than an hour in this quaint town and bus crowd went…read moreleft and we went right. As we walked and looked in all of the various business windows we ducked into the hotel lobby for a libation and coffee. The decor was welcoming, with the reception desk and bar immediately inside. The bartender was cheerful and straightaway made our drinks. We sat in a comfy couch, chatted, refreshed and people watched until it was time to meet our group. Enjoy!

This place should be condemned. It's absolutely filthy and so outdated. I have never stayed in a…read moreplace as bad as this.

The grounds are very nice and beautifully kept. The rooms are small, but clean. The shower is…read moreterrible, no water pressure at all. The beds are comfortable and the bedding nice quality. The staff is friendly. The service in the dining room is OK. The breakfast buffet is typical with all the essentials. The hotel is old which is part of the charm.

Beautiful grounds and exterior is quite photogenic. Inside…read morethe rooms are under maintained, dirty and just bad. From dirty linens, dust and stains everywhere to yellow/brown water from the faucets and holes in walls. Go ahead and skip this one. Breakfast buffet was pretty good, but we shortened our stay and had to go elsewhere after one night.

easily the nicest hotel I may have ever stayed at! We cannot wait to plan a trip and return. The…read morehotel decor is truly one of a kind and so authentic to the region. The service is white glove in that the staff is the highest caliber of service. All of the drinks and food were delightful. We had a few pre dinner drinks at the pub attached to the hotel (the flying stag) and then had dinner at the restaurant. One of my favorite parts of Fife Arms was them reaching out right after we booked our room asking if we needed any help with reservations or travel arrangements. Worth every single penny!

To be honest I only went here for the free wifi and sat in the bar. They had this beer called…read moreMonarch of the Glen and it was good. They also had a good selection of Scotch too . The bar man was friendly . The atmosphere was perfect too with no loud TVs bothering me. Cool place and I hope to actually stay in this hotel next time in Scotland.

The restaurant/pub is open to all, not just guests. We had such a good dinner the first night, we…read morecalled ahead for reservations to be sure to get a table to eat there for a second night! Between the two evenings, we had their Scottish stew pie, hunters chicken, fish and chips, Mac and cheese, and chicken ham and leek pie. And two helpings of the mega chocolate fudge cake. All super tasty after a day out on the highlands. Or thirst was well quenched with a nice selection of local craft beers, including several cask ales, and a good range of speyside and islay whisky to boot. (They have other drinks too but I couldn't tell you about them.) Very friendly service, great quiet pub atmosphere. They also have several curries and pasta dishes if you're looking for a change from traditional fare.

Our accommodations were roomie, clean, yet somewhat basic in-terms of furniture. The restaurant I…read morewould give a five star rating. The menu was creative and the food was excellent. Staff was professional and attentive to details.

The Pine Trees Hotel is an absolute gem filled with antiques and very comfortable rooms. Breakfast…read morewas superb as was the price fixe dinner. Wifi throughout. No ensuite fridge though. You could walk to the commercial district from the hotel but you likely drove to Pitlocgry anyway. Grounds of the hotel are pristine and perfect. The staff was a bit of a disappointment. I appreciate the restauraunt manager correcti ng the absence of abread plate at our table (not a big deal to ms) but then she dressed down the waitress in front of the whole restaurant. The staff seemed put out if you had even the smallest request. i ignored the staff and concentrated on the fabulous hotel and accomodations. Staff appeared to be seasonal workers from elsewhere in the EU so one would think new workers would be there after the fall 2015 season. Id stay here again especially at fhe price.

We chose to try this restaurant as it came highly recommended by our B&B host - so, we would like…read moreto clarify that this review is not for the food as we never had the chance to try it. We also chose it because it had decent reviews, was one of only a few restaurants in the area, and the pictures of the food looked good. We arrived around 7:45 PM, an hour before closing, but didn't have a reservation. Although we are accustomed to places that are full and completely understand if no seating is available, this Sunday evening was exceptional. A hostess greeted us and asked if we had a reservation. We said that we did not and she promptly stated that they were completely booked and that there was no room for us without a reservation. I asked if we could simply attend the bar for a drink instead and she again shut me down by saying "No, we're fully booked." Generally, I'm accustomed to a bit of politeness. Perhaps apologizing or offering to make a reservation for me on another night may have been nicer. Alternatively, why not let us at least have a drink at the bar? I think what put us off was the stern tone and shortness that the hostess took with us. Her quick ability to deny us twice in a matter of seconds was surprising. We wouldn't recommend going here without a reservation. Instead we had to travel 9.4 miles to Pitlochry and enjoy Victorias Restaurant instead as no other restaurants were open in this area at that time. Victorias turned out to be quite good and we would definitely recommend going there instead of this Inn on the Tay. We also post more reviews on our EatWanderExplore travel blog.

Great location beside the river Tay. Modern restaurant with traditional Scottish touches of…read moredesign. Separate bar area with leather and velvet couches and chairs. The Inn decoration and style warrents a higher star rating but the overall experience brings it down :( The waitresses were efficient but lacked personality or warmth, little engagement before, during or after the order for food taken, disappointing. The steak and mushroom pie was full of chucks of beef with a good flavoured gravy. The sweet potato chips delicious. What a shame, a fab looking place but I wouldn't rush back. Xoxo