I admit, I stop here anytime I'm going up 17. The diner next door is great, and you can see that…read morereview. But the Twin Cone wins for the best ice cream place I've had roadside like this. Quality ice cream and even the small is massive. Excellent service and very nice folks. I've waited in line maybe 5 minutes but it's so nice outside I do not mind. Now, they took maple walnut off the menu. I always get that when I see it, since it's harder to find. Well now it's harder. Guess I need to go to Stewart's for it (iykyk). But I like Twin Cone so much, I can't even hold that against them. I'll get coffee Oreo instead. Goddess help me. Delicious.

One of the best, easy access, accessible parking seasonal ice cream shop. Well run shop with many…read morefriendly employees. Delicious ice cream with great servings. Multiple flavors available in hard and soft serve. Enjoyed by multi generations. Portions commensurate with price. One drawback is no indoor bathroom but they have portapotties. Great for after shopping or going out to eat as they're very close to Middletown off rt17

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the…read morewinter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by.

We stopped in on a Monday night after finding this place on yelp and reading the reviews. The…read morecommon review is the price compared to the amount of ice cream you get or don't get, which we found to be true. Overall, the ice cream was good but nothing that blew our socks off. Also, the kid behind the counter just looked like he hated his job.

Closed out of business no longer there gone for good if you want soft ice cream you gotta to a…read moredifferent town.

Great service, delicious ice cream & lots if choices. There's a huge indoor & outdoor seating area…read more We'll be back!

Staff is friendly and helpful. Very patient with kids and their delays when making an order, super…read moreplus! Ice cream is great and with a park across the street it makes it a family establishment!

Haven't had great ice cream in a while but this is definitely one of the best ice cream shops I've…read morebeen to. Cotton candy ice cream and Coffee Cookies and Cream was 100/10!

Frank has been making the most flavorful ice cream anywhere! I have gotten all my ice cream cakes…read morefrom Frank for over 45 years! His cookie crunch is the best!

We stopped with three girls after a late gymnastics class. The older gentleman (looked like an…read moreowner) was not very friendly. He didn't smile and didn't say more than 5 words total. The place looked very outdated and gave me Soviet Union vibes. I didn't have ice cream but the girls loved it, so hopefully the products are worth it.

We made a random stop for milkshakes as we often do and this place checked all of our MUST. Good…read morethick straw - most do not. Delicious flavor and wasn't too milky. Great consistency. Good service and great prices too!

Very tasty ice cream. Cute place and friendly service. Right in the middle of town, and we had a…read moregreat time sitting outside with out ice cream. Will go again.

We love their chocolate ice cream. It is delicious. Not too sweet. The staff were very polite. It…read moreis a small ice cream place with only 2 tables. Definitely worth stopping by.

Went to this place while out in new paltz. Sign on the door states they are open and so does…read moreYelp/online. Turns out they were pitch black and closed. Very disappointing.

I was a bit lost and came upon this old fashioned ice cream stand. I ordered the Mickeys burger…read morecombo with fries and a bottle of water. Everything was delicious, freshly made and fresh. The fries were crispy and incredible. The staff were beyond helpful and gave me good directions.

We've been coming here for years and it's always been amazing but since the new owners took over…read moreit's definitely has gone down hill. I got the hot Texas dog and it was the cheapest/worst hotdog I've ever had in my life like the cheapest dog you could possibly buy.. and there dressing they put on top taste like they took the hotdog water and ground beef juice mixed together and called it sauce. My husband got the pulled pork burger and he said it tasted of fish! Do they even have fish on the menu?! Our daughter got chicken nuggets and fries the only thing semi edible and she got a handful of fries and two nuggets for $10!! What a damn rip off. Service was slower than crap and it was slow! We waited 10 minutes before they even started cooking anything! Also they need to do something with the seating area wouldn't cost much to level out it out with how much they charging for shit food.