We did takeout from this relatively new spot and it met our expectations. It's definitely tasty, just not the best pizza you'll have in Chicago. The salad was just okay, but they know what they're doing with their combinations for pizza. Highly recommend getting some of their garlic butter too! Service was really quick. read more

See all

Burnt crust on the pizza yet very soggy. I took a picture cause I can't believe this mess would actually be served to a customer. Their oven seems like it needs to be calibrated. Skimpy toppings with hardly any cheese. Very disappointed. I'll never order from them again. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Burnt crust. How can I serve this to a customer? - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

delicious. the salad, the breadsticks, the pizza, the chocolate fucking muffin brownie thing. love the staff, and love the options on the menu. sooooo affordable. chill atmosphere too, you can totally wear sweatpants. read more

See all

We've had several wonderful deep-dish pizzas in Chicago over the years. But for whatever reason, the last few--including pizzas at stalwarts like Pequod's and the River North Malnati's--have been lackluster. This particular evening was working out to be a let's-stay-nearby-for-pizza night, and Crushed Pizza gets more positive Internet reviews for non-Chicago-style pizza than you can count. It deserves them. The pizza has crust of medium thickness in a bit of an East Coast style. It was terrific: sturdy, with great chew and good yeasty flavor. The best we can remember having in a long time. Toppings (mushroom and spinach on our half) were fresh and plentiful. Only complaint I can muster is that the sauce could use just a little more zing. Side salads--only five or six bucks if I recall correctly--were huge for the price and surprisingly good, although mine (the Charlie, with spinach, walnuts, fig, red onion, Gorgonzola) was heavy on the balsamic vinaigrette. Although Crushed has tables for dining in, it is very much a carry-out joint and doesn't have too much in the way of atmosphere. Our young server was pleasant enough, but we kinda got lost in the shuffle among all the folks standing around waiting on carryout orders. Also, no alcohol, at least not yet. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Half mushroom/spinach, half pepperoni/sausage - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Our favorite pizza in the area (and we did a taste test on the ten closest). Great crust, great specialty pizzas: the Venus is top of my pizza list but they're all good. The cheese used is great, the char and crustiness and chew on the crust is satisfying. Admittedly, it's pretty hard for a real pizzeria to make bad pizza, but you should give Crushed a try and see what you think. 8 out of 10 pizzas in my life come from Crushed. read more

Amazing people. Amazing food. They gave us free rice crispy treats after WE made a mistake!

East coast vibes. Sauce is fantastic, subjective but it's fruity with a light zing. Could drink cups of it. Would like to know what the recipe it...please. Great sausage. Love the roasted garlic. Salads are great too. read more

First time visiting crushed pizza and I enjoyed it! We ordered for pickup and everything was still hot when we arrived about 30 minutes after placing the order. The interior is pretty small but there are a few tables and tv if you show up wanting to dine in. We ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pizza and the house crushed salad on the side. I typically don't love the salads at pizza restaurants, but this one was really fresh mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, freshly chopped basil, and a nice vinaigrette. I loved it and have enough left over to have for lunch tomorrow too! The pizza was tasty too. Although the crust is thick and crispy, center of the pizza is kind of floppy. While that isn't my favorite I know there are a lot of people who enjoy that. It's a good size, reasonably priced, and super flavorful! I can definitely see us ordering from here again. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Phone was suppose to eat first but we got too excited! - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I am a self-proclaimed pizza snob and this place is very solid! Almost new-york like but less greasy and more saucy/bit thicker. It was perfectly cooked and the sausage/pineapple combo was fantastic. Will definitely order from here again! read more

The service was incredible and so was the pizza. It's family owned and they offered us a free salad while we waited. Highly recommended the Louie. read more

We live in the neighborhood and we've been customers here for a while. I went in tonight because I had ordered a pizza from DoorDash and went to pick up. They were very busy and very overwhelmed and I understand that one of the systems was down. I'm very willing to give grace for that. What was frustrating however, is that they kept telling me they would look for the order and then proceeded to take care of all of the customers behind me without updating me on anything about my order. After I stood there for a while they just told me that they didn't have it, and I needed to take it up with DoorDash. I was very disappointed that it was done so dismissively. I understand it was ordered with DoorDash, maybe DoorDash is having an issue. But I had stood there for a while and waited for someone to answer me about what was going on and to be dismissed so quickly was very disappointing. I know that it was a rough night, I don't fault anybody for the fact that it was a rough night. It could've been handled better. Unfortunately, we won't be going back. read more

Salads were great (we had the spinach salad w figs) and the pizza was super. Nice crust! Great service.

I love this pizza! I have ordered many times and never a disappointment even when it shows up cold. Not their fault as they don't deliver to us and we have to order through a different party. read more

Love the pizza - great ingredients and always on time! I'm in the minority, but I wish they had anchovies.

Too bad, I used to be cool with this place but about a week and a half ago, I put in an order. Was told it would be 30-40 minutes, waited, went down there. They said it wasn't ready. They asked me my name for my order several times. After ANOTHER 45 minutes, they said "they lost my order." HOW DO YOU LOSE MY ORDER WHEN I AM SITTING FIVE FEET FROM YOU AND YOU KEPT CHECKING IN WITH ME EVERY TEN MINUTES. They offered me a free side salad and said it'd be another 30 minutes! That would be TWO HOURS AND FIFTEEN MINUTES FOR A PICKUP ORDER. I said nah and made them refund me in front of me. Went home to split a side salad with four people. I was quite upset and couldn't shake it. There so later I called and left a message for the owner to call me about this. Never got a call. It's too bad because the pizzas really good but the customer service was absolutely atrocious. read more

Always great pizza & salads. They accommodate any add-ons or changes to the pizza. The staff is kind and the restaurant is very comfortable. read more

I tried it tonight and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. I picked it up at the location and the staff was very nice and pleasant to deal with. I believe I have found a new pizza place. Highly recommend. read more

We ordered carry out pizza on a Saturday night and had exceptional service and loved the two pizzas we got, 16" pepperoni and 16" cheese for the kids. Both were a big hit with the perfect amount of pepperoni to have meat in every bite! We got a surprise, complimentary sweet treat on the way out the door! Thanks Crushed Pizzeria for a great dinner! read more

They completely messed up my order and the quality of the food overall is poor. Will not be trying again. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - The Garlic Butter Sauce came cold and solid. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We used to LOVE this place. It was great pizza, and we kept ordering even though they literally almost ALWAYS forgot something on our delivery order. It was okay because they were super sorry and worked hard to make sure we were whole again. But last night, we got a pizza delivered and they forgot our two desserts. Fine, I called as soon as I saw they were missing to make sure we didn't pay for them. Whoever answered the phone was DEFINITELY not the owner because he was short and dismissive and instead of saying he was sorry, he just kept saying it wasn't his fault because he just got there. I wasn't mad, but expected the great customer service we used to get. The driver later called to say he would drop them off, but my ringer was off. That wasn't the point. The asshat on the phone who could have apologized and made things better was the point. Horrible customer service. Then we opened the pizza. FREEZING COLD and TERRIBLE. Literally, some of the worst pizza I've ever had. I'm not sure what happened to the place. What a shame. They were our go-to for pizza. Now, they are our "never again." read more

I wanted to love this, but mediocre at best. Claim of fresh ingredients did not come through ( maybe because I ordered on a Wednesday 5pm?). Crust too thick. Lacked seasoning ( ie. salt, pepper, anything). The brownie cake lava thing was weird. Trumped by good 'old Dominos' lava cake, quite honestly. Hate to say it because I want to support local, but Coalfire is a better version of this. Will not be ordering again, sadly. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Crust was amazing with just the right amount of bounce and crunch. (And no corn meal!) Topping amounts were perfect, though I wouldn't add more than two items to a pizza because it might get overloaded. Sauce was perfect and not too sweet. The free lava cake was amazing. This is my new go to when I need pizza. read more

See all

Very nice service. They accommodated 8 of us very well in the small restaurant. Pizza was really good.

This is my neighborhood go-to spot. Not sure how I have not left a review. It's a robust crust and the toppings are so flavorful. Get the victor salad. Yum. read more

Crushed Pizzeria is one of my favorite pizza shops in Lakeview and I was truly blessed to live within walking distance from them. My favorite pizzas were the Louie and the Cliff. The sauce is very good and has a distinct tanginess. I am also a big fan of their crust because it's that perfect ratio for flat pizza where there's the right amount of doughiness/chewiness without feeling overly bready (very scientific, I know). Don't sleep on the desserts either--grab the chocolate brownie (which is more like a muffin shaped, lava cake) or the rice krispie treats. read more

Someone said blink and you will miss this place. Yeah they are 100%. I know what the address is, but man I have no idea where it is. But I don't need to since they deliver. And deliver Crushed Pizzeria did. I ordered a Classic Margherita and a "Create Your Own" pizza. For the create your own, it was cool that they let me do a customize half and half: first half was sausage, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and mushrooms. The second half was Pepperoni and Spicy Capicola for The Queen. She and The Doctor loved it. I am not a fan of Pepperoni, so I didn't try it, but with the two meats on it, there was grease, but in a good way according to my loved one...drippy and delicious. I have to say the Crushed Pizza Sauce was amazing! It had a very fresh taste and wasn't sweet. I agree with Seema S's comment that the pizza would have been better with more toppings, but the flavors were great! I am not a big crust person, never have been. Crust is just a vehicle for holding all the good stuff I like on a neat pile. But I have to say the crust on the pizza was flavorful and eatable. which for me as a non-crust eating person is saying a lot. I am that person that cuts the end crust off of pizza before I even start eating it, but this crust was fresh, chewy at the end crust and aromatic. The rest of the base was very thin, but very good. We had some leftover pieces and I was wondering how well they would hold up the next day. The Doctor said that the crust was fine, not hard at all all. The thin parts of the crust were a little soft he said, but the flavor was still good. Delivery was quick and the person was very nice, and was most appreciative of the tip and the fact that I presented it in a sealed bag for him. Overall this was a most wonderful discovery for pizza and we will be ordering from them again. read more

See all

This has become a go-to for me and my girlfriend when we order pizza. Great tasting pizza and salads with quality ingredients. Plus, if you're looking for something sweet, their chocolate lava brownie is so good. read more

Best pizza on the north side! Awesome crust and sauce! The Venus is my fav, but also love their cheese pizza with mushrooms and caramelized onions. If you love chocolate, treat yourself to their chocolate brownie!! It is super unique and decadent. read more

They have the best pizza and salad delivery in North Center, Lake view, Ravenswood, Andersonville, and uptown. Not really a place to eat in, but is great pick up or delivery. Pizza travels well and everything is super consistent and the orders are always right! The service is friendly over the phone as well! read more

Sunday night, ordered, ready for pickup 30 minutes, delicious. Nice people. Blah blah blah 85 characters

We got 2 pizzas and breadsticks and it was more than enough food for 4 people! Super yummy!!

Outstanding pizza. Crust has a nice chew. Sauce is authentic and the cherry tomato toppings are sweet and delicious. Not overly salty like a lot of takeout pizza. Tastes homemade esp with the fresh mozzarella. read more

Great and tasty! Ordered the Les and it was a hit after moving all day! Will definitely be back to work my way through the menu.

First and foremost, this place has the NICEST staff!!! Kudos to this team who clearly work well together and go above and beyond to take care of their customers. We actually saw two or three different employees come out from behind the counter to open the door for people as they left with stacks of salads and pizza boxes. A close second is the absolutely incredible pizza that has an outstanding crispy bottom crust, perfectly flavored sauce (not too sweet), and an outer crust with just the right amount of chew. Our family got a half sausage and half pepperoni, and we couldn't stop commenting about how delicious every bite was. We will be back soon!! read more

I've been searching for YEARS for my "new" favorite pizza place. My old tried and trues have been going downhill for years, but I've never found a new pizzeria about which I could be passionate. This pizza is AMAZING. Hand tossed, crispy but not too crunchy, perfectly caramelized cheese... I got the ROSE specialty pizza and it was DELICIOUS. Even now, a week later, I am craving more. With a little pizza sauce on the side for dipping, it is PERFECTION. My partner got a standard 1/2 sausage + 1/2 pepperoni. He enjoyed his pizza as well. The brownie was AMAZING. It's not a normal brownie. It's a mini lava cake. The only thing I would say is that on their website, it advertises the pizza as being thin-crust. In my opinion, they are definitely more of hand-tossed pizza. SO delicious, SO mouth-watering. I will be a regular customer from now on. Cannot recommend enough, especially if you've been on the hunt for your "new favorite" pizzeria. read more

Delicious! Have only ordered pickup or delivery, but this pizza is tasty! Always very fresh with great ingredients. Salads are amazing and very affordable. Have made this place a regular for Sunday pizza nights. read more

I can't help but echo all of the other east-coast biased pizza reviews. After telling my husband I just desperately wanted "normal pizza" (NY style hand tossed), he found Crushed Pizzeria on Yelp and it did not disappoint! Crust, sauce, cheese, and seasoning was exactly what I wanted. I only wish there were more mushrooms. We also split a spinach and fig salad that was very good! We will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Half mushroom half pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Crushed is our go-to thin-crust take-out! The last few times we've ordered it's somehow gotten even better with a crispier crust and the meat toppings seem less greasy. Highly recommend giving Crushed a try! read more

My favorite pizza in the city. Crazy how no one seems to talk about it. Love the margarita and my husband gets a pepperoni pizza.

I ordered two pizzas for a party. As I finished my first slice, I bit into something hard. I pulled it out and it was some small piece of metal, like a deformed staple. I called the place and asked to be put on with worker's boss and he said he was too busy. It's obvious that the boss didn't believe me and assumed I was trying to pull a fast one or something. If I owned a food business, I'd want to know if one of the cooks was being irresponsible and unsafe. For the record, the pizza was tasty I was able to get a refund from GrubHub. However, literal metal in your food is a priority, so it doesn't matter if it's "never happened before". My friends or I could've been seriously injured and gone to the hospital. Overall good food but the boss is unprofessional. read more

Crushed Pizzeria - Metal in pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all