This is one of my favorite bars in NY. Love the nights when they serve 10 cent wings. Great wings at a great price! Plus the selection of beers that they have would make me feel like a kid in a candy store! So many to choose! The bartenders are very nice and serve your drink fairly quick. I would definitely recommend checking out this bar. read more

Top 5 wings ever! Great beer selection! If ur stuck in Strong Island get here!

Fried pickles! Soo delicious! The are whole spears and not chips. Comes with a delicious dipping sauce. I ordered my favorite Blue Point Blueberry beer and sat happily in a booth with my friend enjoying quesadillas, fried pickles, chicken fingers and a few beers. Always a good experience at Croxleys. read more

Now, I just reviewed the LES location. I went to this one first with my friend who lives in the area and he knows I like a good beer. I will say I enjoyed the atmosphere and food at this location a LOT better. Service is great, beer list is great, and wings are delish. But the set-up is nice; you can be in the table area with tvs, around the HUGE bar, or tucked away for a quiet convo. read more

The food here is always great. The wings is what people come here for. Any flavor, any style and you wont be disappointment. The prices are reasonable too and they have random special items for a discounted price, i.e the mountain high of tortilla chips smothered in various toppings. read more

I always have such a nice time here. The waitstaff is friendly and warm and the managers Dean and Janine are awesome. Sit at the bar or a table, it doesn't matter you'll have a nice time. Decent food great beers tons of tvs and friendly atmosphere. Ask for pica she's the best. read more

Sorry I used to like this place but the wings are so small and always fried to death! They don't have half the beers they say they have on tap. Last time i was there i picked 8 draft beers and they didn't have one on tap! Definitely would NOT recommend if you like craft beers! read more

I have been to this location many times. I live nearby, I was there just a few days ago. It's always been a pleasurable experience. Very friendly bartenders and waitresses . Tonight was not a good experience. We were seated and our waitress took some time to come over. When she did we placed our orders, apps and entree with drinks. We got our drinks in a timely manner and after that the we waited over 40 minutes to get any food or even the waitress asking if we needed anything. She walked by us many times to serve others, some who came after us and received there food. Eventually I flagged her down and asked for the bill for our drinks because we wanted to leave due to the service. She said she will go check on the food and my friend told her if the food is ready now we will take it. She comes back minutes later with the food and had an attitude. The plates were cold and the food was warm, clearly she forgot about us even though she walked past us many times to serve everyone else. Never asked if we wanted more drinks or anything else. She left the food and ignored us until we asked for the bill. We had to go to the bar to pay cause she never came back to take the payment and when she handed me the receipt to sign she gave me a nasty look, I still tipped because it's the right thing to do. While we were walking out she walked past my friend and I and gave us both nasty looks. I enjoy going to croxleys and it's always been great, I live blocks away. This review isn't to bash croxleys but to speak of the service. This female waitress who was fairly young and served on the back end of the bar in the front was terrible. No customer service, no attention to the customers and made us feel unwanted. What turned out to be a night of celebration for my friend sons for making the honor roll was ruined. We had friends coming to meet us and I told them about the service and they chose to go somewhere else and we left to meet them. If the owner or manger would like to contact me to speak about this matter they can freely do so. I'm not looking for anything free or discounts. I won't be going back to croxleys after tonight and no longer taking friends there. There are too many local places nearby I can support and I will not get treated like this. Just my experience at this location. I will say on my earlier visit this week the waitress who said she also works at the Rockville center location mostly was amazing. read more

Wings!! Who doesn't love wings!! The BBQ wings were delicious, the hot wings were really good and on the cheap on a Tuesday night. It wasn't too crowded and the service was really good. Good beer and fun times, looking forward to returning! read more

It is a nice spot .If your going to get wings, get the Regular mild or hot wings because they're awesome. I ordered the Jamaican jerk sauce and gotten so disappointed because that wasn't really jerk sauce and idk what that was, taste like molasses or something. Food took forever to come and the appetizers, probably because it was busy that day. Overall I still like this place, I'll go again. read more

It's MNF arrived at 9pm. It's busy and had to wait to be seated, which is not an issue. I sat at the bar to watch the game and order drinks. I asked the female bartender for an "Old Fashion", and her response was not right now!?!? It wasn't that busy. Perhaps they need to hire faster more efficient bartenders that can handle volume and/or some what busier nights. Now that's bad for sales since I always frequent the Croxley's establishments. I may have to find another wings and booze spot. It's quite a disappointment. read more

I haven't eaten here in a while. In the past I swore by their wings. Today the wings were on the drier side. The mac and cheese was eh. They slabbed on a square slice of cheese on top of it that was barely melted. The fries were the best thing we ordered. The quesidilla was also nothing special. I hope it was just our batch of wings that was dry because I definitely used to enjoy coming here. read more

Went here again yesterday with my dad. Sat at the bar, not busy. There was only one other party at the bar. Service again was not up to standards... Food was good. read more

This place has been a Franklin square staple since I can remember and I've been in the neighborhood for 20+ years. Great beer selection (since well before that was trendy), great service, great food and reasonable prices. Always happy to come here and watch a game, catch up with friends or just come and kick it when I feel like having a few beers in a laid back situation. Keep doing what you do!! read more

This place was a favorite hangout of my fellow coworkers and we came here quite often. They have an excellent selection of beers from the UK to satisfy quite a few palates. One night of the week (I believe it's Wednesday but I could be wrong,) is wing night, when this place gets packed to the nines and it may take an hour to get seating since the wings are a lot cheaper than usual (I can't remember the price.) The food is standard bar fare; it's not wholly memorable and for some items, the portion sizes don't seem to justify the price. There are plenty of seats for a regular week night, and there's a plethora of flat screen TV's and bar space to watch games. If you have a large crowd and want to just have a good time, this is a great place to go. read more

Love the wings! But you have to have some kind of PhD. in menu-reading to understand all the rules regarding when there are specials and how many wings you can order. read more

Great beer selection, food was good and their wing special is awesome. Very quiet for a saturday night though.

The wings were okay. It might have been due to the takeout, but I wasn't that impressed.

The wings and drinks are good. But getting seats is extremely difficult. When coming with more than four people it's tough to pick this place because seating is limited.. read more

Nice place - excellent barkeep Karen knew her beers. Pointed me to several that is never had and are now memorable (in a good way). Was skeptical on 10 cent boneless or 20 cent boned wings, but it's the real deal. Got the hot boneless (I'm a cheapskate) but I'd go for the regular next time and for a might warmer next time, and there definitely will be a next time. Great selection of beers, and local ones which I'd never had before. Gonna have to visit the Great South Bay and Barrier breweries soon. Parking wasn't too bad. On street, but coven tuner to the front door. read more

Went here for St. Paddy's Day with a couple friends. There were some college and NBA basketball games on, and the wings were flowing. Great little sports bar with friendly service and plenty of spots to eat/drink, considering the size. I was just visiting, but I would definitely come back again. read more

We went for their Monday wing special. It's a great deal and the wings are tasty. The service was good. It wasn't our first time there and certainly will not be our last. read more

Awesome late night spot for a beer, wings, and watch the big fight on a big screen. Several screens all over the place. Wings are amazing!!!Also 65 different beers on tap. read more

I normally come here all the time but tonight I arrived at Croxley's and stood in front for a while as three employees looked at my party from tables, the bar and walked past us to serve her guests. Not sure if they were having a bad day and/or if there was no host/hostess. Either way, I don't take well to stuff like that. So. You've lost a very loyal customer. read more

My wife and I love this place. The chicken pot pie and shepherds pie are great, after years of coming here I still forget they only take AMEX but they have an ATM. I drink the Croxley Blond my wife loves Goose Island IPA. Great place for a pint when your team is playing. Oh the parking stinks my only negative. read more

Definitely not what it used to be! Used to come here once a week (every Sunday). They used to have great specials, those are gone. Service is the worst. Everytime I come here now there's only a few tables and yet it still takes the waitresses forever to service your table. I give up on this place. read more

Let me begin by saying I have some pretty high standards when it comes to any sort of chicken wings, particularly if they are hot wings and i plan to review a lot of wing places in the future so i want to set the bar with the most amazing wing place in long island. I came here just after my 21st birthday because my friend thought i would like it. Boy was he right! This place has at least 50+ different types of beer to choose from and a truly amazing appetizer called Irish Nachos. These cheese-covered french fries are also generously covered in scallions and bacon, this is an absolute must each time we go, i recommend you try them. For the main attraction you have the wings. The first thing you find out is that during certain days of the week (back then it was something like Tuesdays and Thursdays) there are wing specials where you can get wings for 10 cents each, which requires that you spend something like $5 on drinks. Basically you can come here and eat 20 wings and have a beer for $7 (Plus tax and tip), which i figured was probably because the wings would be just "okay" or super small or something of that nature. To my surprise when my order of 20 "crybaby" wings came (i'll cover the crybaby sauce shortly) i received a plate of 20 large, beautifully cooked wings. The wings were cooked to have a slightly crispy skin and also maintain a nice juicy and meaty chicken inside. I am dead serious when i say these are some of the best wing's I have ever eaten. As I said previously i came here just shortly after my 21st birthday and I have returned here at least once a week for 2 years straight (and i have my card statements to prove it!). As i mentioned in previous reviews i absolutely love spicy food as well as hot sauces, when i found out that Croxley's has a sauce they call "cry like a baby" I had to try to eat 20 wings coated in the sauce (the chef doesn't always make the "cry like a baby" sauce so just be aware it's not always an available choice). The "cry like a baby" sauce is made daily by chefs using habanero peppers and is the spiciest sauce they have. I remember eating the wings and saying "wow these are actually hot." My girlfriend, who was the person i was telling this to, caught a whiff of my wings and her eyes burst into the tears from the spice, and from that moment on she has referred to them as "mace wings." The crybaby wings were definitely spicy considering they were made from habanero, more importantly they were also delicious. There was a sweet tang to the sauce and the great balance of pepper flavor to vinegar. Going down from the Crybaby wings you have Hot x2 (or hot-squared as i order them), Hot, medium and mild. Normally when hot sauce for wings are made there is a balance that is reached between pepper, vinegar and butter. Usually at cheaper wing places they tend to be very butter heavy with their milder sauces (as sauces get milder, then usually tend to include larger quantities of butter, just like hotter sauces are comprised of lower quantities of butter and a greater quantity of pepper), Croxley Ales tends to start their mildest sauce to be more spicy than what people are probably used to as they use very little butter. This allows for a much tastier sauce that just gets more delicious as you turn up the heat. I still visit Croxley's frequently and this is still my absolute favorite place to go have dinner with my fiancee or my friends or even to have a party. Croxley Ales is a well Deserved 5 stars and is well worth the 30+ minute trip out there! Give it a try! read more

Not a bad spot. Came here to meet some old friends. Pretty similar to the EV location. Except it's the LI crowd. Beer should be cheaper. I'd repeat if craving wings. read more

Great selection of beers - Knowledgeable bartenders - And really cheap wings. What more can you want !!! We had a great time hanging out here and I look forward to doing it again read more

The best wings I've ever had! Their irish nachos are soo good too. They also have a very impressive bar selection. Just sometimes the wait can be long, but for the wings, it's worth it! read more

The ale is plenty! try the cider on tap. it sneaks up on you. gotta love the 10 cent wings on Monday and Wednesday. Definitely try the sweet potato fries with the gravy! I am a frequent patron! read more

Rockin' wings :) Great place to catch an afternoon game. Night crowd is a bit young and too "on the hunt" for me so I pass on evenings. Parking stinks, its on street so good luck. Take out wings are just as good as in-house - the perfect addition to your Superbowl party! read more

Not a bad place, but for some reason I never really want to eat there. Wife likes the wings. I really don't. Not my cup of tea.

Greatest mozzarella sticks! And their desserts are pretty delicious :) great hang spot with great friends!!

Wings for a great price. Staff is very rude ! As soon as I came in to the place the hostess was not friendly. My friend left her ID so she was unable to drink. The hostess told the waitress we couldn't have drinks at our table.. Are you serious?!? People bring kids here so I know there full of shit. Then the waitress left with letting us know and we had as several ppl for our tab. These people service who they want to service!! I will not be here ever again! read more

This is a great little pub, with a huge selection of hand crafted beers. You could spend quite a while getting familiar with all of the brews that they offer. The food is also quite good, if not somewhat basic pub fare. Try the wings, they are twenty cents each most nights, and they are about as close as you get to the real Buffalo wings, as made in Frank and Theresas Anchor Bar in Buffalo. Croxleys has several locations, I can't vouch for the quality at the others, but the Franklin Square location hits the spot. Go for it. read more

THE best wings on LI and a huge selection of pretty damn good beers on tap and in bottle. Nice place, always a friendly atmosphere and always seems to be full of good friendly fun people. Staff are always nice too. A fave spot. read more

Good time. Went with a large group, nice drink selection and good food for an ale house.

Not a good bar for you if you think Budweiser is real beer (it is good for putting out a campfire, though). Great selection of American micro-brews to tempt any palette. Monday to Wednesday, they have ten cent chicken wings from 5pm. The place is usually packed on these nights. The wait is usually 45 minutes to an hour, but it is well worth it. Parking could be an issue, but I usually get lucky on the private streets around the bar. read more

Ingredients for a good bar: - Good beer - Good bartenders Check and check. But wait, there's more! Despite being a chain bar (and let's face it, a chain-anything is lame), Croxley's has a great atmosphere. The crowd is what you'd expect (this is Long Island after all, not the West Village) and the prices are fair. It doesn't hurt that the food is pretty good as well. Nothing to blow your socks off, but you know after your 5th Blue Moon Belgian White Ale you're gonna want a little something to fill that stomach with other than beer. (And if you're a liquor or cocktail person, choose your bartender right. Some make drinks waaay stronger than others.) read more