Overall, this is a great gym - not perfect, but scores well on most dimensions. My 4/5 rating is based on 5 months of membership, and breaks down as follows:
COACHES - 5/5
The coaches are the best part of this gym. Paolo, Alan, and Catherine are all highly effective (and fun!) coaches. Catherine (my regular weekday morning coach) in particular is a huge stickler for proper form and technique -- in her hands I've made great progress in a short time, and most importantly, I've remained safe and injury-free throughout. I highly recommend training with Catherine, particularly if you're new to CrossFit.
FACILITIES - 3.5/5
The gym is sizable well-appointed, BUT the ceilings are low, which means 1) only a few spots where you can do muscle-ups without hitting your head, 2) to get 10 feet on your wall balls, you have to throw the med ball straight up and ricochet off the ceiling, which is awkward, and 3) no climbing ropes or other implements that require more height. Equipment-wise, things get a little unwieldy once the class size gets larger than about 10 people - at that point, you're sometimes running multiple heats in your class. Adding a bonus half point for having showers, even though I don't make use of them.
PROGRAMMING - 4/5
I've generally found the programming to be good, but the strict divide between "Beginner" and "Experienced" becomes limiting when you're somewhere in between, or looking to learn a new skill. I've found that I've learned some of the more advanced skills (e.g. handstand push-ups, ring dips) elsewhere, like when I've dropped in to other boxes that have mixed-experienced groups. Adding a point for having TONS of classes and time options, even on Sundays, and offering a range of specialty tracks (Endurance, Oly, Barbell, etc.)
VALUE - 5/5
Their monthly, 6-month, and 12-month packages are well priced, particularly if you get them discounted at the conclusion of your Fundamentals sessions. I also appreciate that they offer "Off-Peak" membership for those with more flexible schedules. I did some comparison shopping and found that CrossFit NYC offered the the most economical membership options vs. others in the area.
COMMUNITY - 3/5
The downside to a large gym is that it can get somewhat impersonal, as it runs like a machine and classes become a bit rinse-and-repeat. While I've met some great people and members are generally friendly, the community is nothing like a smaller box where everyone knows each other and it's like one big hysterically fun #fitfam.
Overall, CrossFit NYC is a great gym that offers good bang for your buck along with excellent coaching! read more