Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Crosby's

    3.5 (4 reviews)
    Open 6:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Crosby's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Crosby's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Linda C.
    39
    93
    119

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Nicholas at the Fredonia Crosby's made me the best pizza I have ever had at a Crosby's! He killed it

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Kelly M.

    Kelly M.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Crosby's

    Crosby's

    Crosby's

    4.2
    (5 reviews)
    3.2 mi

    Okay so this is just another convenience store as far as I'm concerned, I drive by this place twice…read morea day 4 days a week and it's about 3 and 1/2 hours from my house so I never really stop here. My job as a medical courier has me out this way and a few nurses in Gowanda New York told me that Crosby's has really good breakfast pizza. So now I got to stop and find out. The building itself is really small in fact I never would have thought to even stop here as even though it says Pizza on the sign out front typically it didn't look like a large enough building to even have a kitchen but... I went inside and grabbed a couple of slices of breakfast pizza anyways. Holy crap it was good. First thing I noticed was there's about a half inch of egg on it which was considerably more than other places I have purchased breakfast pizza. I ate two slices and I'm pretty full. I also couldn't help but notice the crust when I picked up the first piece was firm enough that the pizza slice itself didn't droop down so all of the toppings fall off. I didn't really have to fold it in half to get it to stay out straight and even with that being said the crust itself was very soft. And I didn't really notice until I got down to the end pieces of crust where there's no longer any toppings, but there's a really good buttery flavor which I'm pretty certain is why the whole slice tasted incredible. The only thing that kind of bummed me out which isn't a bad thing but in my case it kind of did, these peaches are not frozen solid and just warmed up in an oven on site. The nice lady behind the counter said the dough is frozen but they put the rest of the toppings on it before they cook it. The reason this bummed me out is because if it had any frozen product in its entirety, The option would exist I could buy a couple of them right out of the freezer and being that it's currently averaging around 20° here in New York, I could get home with it still frozen and cook it when I arrive. But anyway, I definitely recommend stopping into any Crosby's location if you have one nearby and try a slice.

    i bought the pizza deal 2 for $22, taste was phenomenal, explosion of italiano herbs & spices a…read morelong with an incredible wait time less than 10 mins. ~ have to try!!!

    Seneca Hawk

    Seneca Hawk

    3.0
    (9 reviews)
    14.0 mi

    Is it the best place? I"m not sure if it's the best, but in my opinion it isn't. I also always…read morethought if I had the most check ins I'd be the "duke", but evidently that's not how it works (has nothing to do with the Seneca Hawk though) - note to Paul I will gain the duke back soon! This location is pretty easy to get to on two sides of the traffic circle really and they have full service pumps and "you" pump pumps! However, there is no difference in price and full service only means that they pump it for you - PLEASE don't confuse full service to mean that they will check anything for you! On the Indian Reservation they almost all have self serve as well as they pump it for you - on a cold, windy, snowy, rainy or very hot day (yes we have a few in July) it's nice they they actually pump your gas for you! I guess that's another reason to come here for gas - service - something you won't get at most places you fill up at! Ok - the problem with the Indian Reservation in this area at least, is the fact that there are perhaps about 10 places to fill up at an they are not all the same price. However, when you get to one - just fill up and don't worry about it. Chances are the cost per gallon difference between any of them might be up to 5 cents. What does this mean? Well if your tank is 20 gallons and you are on empty - if you found the cheapest gas price and saved 5 cents per gallon you actually saved $1.00. However, you will have wasted most if not all of those savings in either time or gas looking for the cheapest - be smart - just fill up! Also - there is a Seneca Hawk gas station AND a restaurant - this review is only on the gas station part of things. However, there is one other place that serves as gas station and restaurant - so I'd recommend the other!

    Service quality , value the restaurant isn't what it use to be staff isn't very caringread more

    Photos
    Pot roast/turkey panini. Sharing!
    Pot roast/turkey panini. Sharing!
    Seneca Hawk
    Seneca Hawk

    See all

    Convenience Food Mart

    Convenience Food Mart

    2.0
    (3 reviews)
    46.7 mi

    We were at a basketball tournament for our daughter nearby, and this was the closest convenient…read morestore to grab some drinks and snacks between games. This store is definitely a throw-back to my 80s youth, including a candy aisle with 25-cent boxes of Lemonheads, Red Hots, Boston Baked Beans, and more. It was early, so coffee was a must. The hot coffee here is drip-coffee prepared one pot at a time. My cup from the full pot that was sitting there was just okay, but for $1.25 for a large, can't complain. We purchased my coffee, three cold drinks, and a variety of seven or eight snacks (chips, cookies, nuts, a Cliff Bar, etc.) for about $23. Not too bad in this day and age. The cashier who checked us out was very friendly. Checking out, she hand-typed in each item into an throw-back cash register, with the chunky keys that make that satisfying chunky-key-plunk-sound. And then when I paid with my card, the old-school credit card machine came complete with that old-school dial-up screechy sound to process the payment. For a place to grab reasonably priced convenient store drinks and snacks, this Convenient Food Mart was a good, and nostalgic experience for me! :-)

    I wouldn't go into this store if you paid me, I walked in thinking how cute! It reminded me of my…read morehometowns local store, but I was met with such a surprise as the cashier was super rude. There was a man asking for help at the deli, I waited for him to finish in the line. The woman tells me to come to the counter. So I do, there's a 10 dollars minimum for card so I quickly start looking for other things to add. She looks at me and goes honey I don't have all day I have to help that man. It took me 10-15 seconds to grab a candy bar. I put it on the counter she then adds in the mans food onto my order. I said no we're not together. She goes you put this soda here, I said no I put the juices and the candy bar here. She goes I thought this would be quicker and takes my card acting like for some reason I was the rude one. Go to a delta sonic at least the employees are nicer.

    Photos
    Convenience Food Mart
    Convenience Food Mart

    See all

    Crosby's - servicestations - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...