Creno's Pizza

Best pizza around! Thank you the owner(sorry we didn't…read moreexchange names) we spoke in length about Gluten intolerance/celiac disease. I had a real concern about the handling of their products for preparing a gluten free pizza. The biggest offender with gluten for me,is pizza. Pizza has sent me to the er too many times. He explained how they handle and prepare and I felt good he took the timeI LOVED IT AND HAVE HAD NO PROBLEMS! My husband also got a pizza regular and again I'll say, BEST PIZZA EVER! The owner also explained crust/dough and they use the best of everything going into their pizzas! So if your buying pizza anywhere else, you not getting the real deal! We come from California to visit and VILLA PIZZA is a must!!! Thank you again!

This local pizzeria is a must try if you stop by Johnstown, OH. I wish they have a few tables or at…read moreleast somewhere to eat, you can only order take out, but the food is really good. Give it a chance, you won't regret it.

Chicken bbq

Pepperoni, mushroom, onion and banana peppers

See all

Pepperoni

Johnston's Lakehouse Pizza

4.0(22 reviews)

6.1 mi

Top Shelf Ohio Style pizza. SMALL, not large peperonis and good sausage.. Great fam…read more ily owned business...they deliver to Granville and locally around Alexandria. Delivered to us(2 miles away) on THE coldest night last winter. That says it all. Pizza was hot steaming when we opened the box!!!

This Pizza place is a hidden gem. I ordered a mushroom pizza light sauce and it perfectly cooked…read more I believe it a takeout type of place.

Pizza :)

Thin crust available upon request. Firm square cut with a thin chewy dough layer. #UpCloseSavor

See all

Exterior entrance and parking. #UpCloseSavor

Plaza Pizza - Johnstown

3.2(6 reviews)

1.1 mi

Very slow and very rude staff. Definitely will not return. So many better options in the area. And…read morehonestly McDonald's would be a better option which is sad. I've no idea how this place is staying in business!

Saying this is the prize winning pizza of Licking County, has me questioning the taste of people in…read morethat county. The only reason this is not one star, is because I used a free XL Pizza coupon. An XL, barely fed myself & two children (4 and 10 years old). Aside from being small, the taste lacks flavor & was a bit overcooked. The subs are pathetic & are not even worth ordering. If you want pizza in this area, choose VIlla.

The Other Guy Pizza

4.7(18 reviews)

5.7 mi

Ate here last night. Fantastic pizza. Good quality toppings. Fresh made dough. The sauce reminded…read moreme of Italy or Youngstown(Very Italian). Nice fresh bright sauce, not over complicated. It's a small shop, but you can eat in. They have a pretty large beer selection, everything from IPA's to Peroni's from Italy. Local owned and owner operated. The beer was probably 31-32 degrees. Ice cold. This is better than JT's or Hound dogs in my opinion. They also have many other options like Stromboli, subs, and wings. I will be going back!!!

Great pizza and subs always friendly Rocco and the knots are great too along with the saladread more

Italian Sub

Cannoli

See all

Domino's Pizza

2.2(21 reviews)

1.2 mi

Horrible place, tasted like soap, must not clean the best. The bathroom was horrible overall as…read morewell. The service was very slow at first but only picked it up the slightest after I ordered. 1/5

The staff at dominoes is always friendly with me and helpful! Johnstown dismisses this location but…read morethey are always busy as hell and under appreciated! I live close and eat here more than I want to admit so I have a lot of experience with different ways to order Domino's!

See all

Fiesta Del Rio

4.0(77 reviews)

0.4 mi

We loved the Fiesta Del Rio on Polaris Parkway and were sad to see it close permanently last week…read more So, today, Cinco de Mayo, we decided to head out to Johnstown to the original Fiesta Del Rio and we found it to be as good as our old favorite on Polaris Parkway. The interior decor is very pleasant and bright. And while it is Mexican-themed, it is a more subdued interior than most Mexican restaurants. The service was EXCELLENT and the food was GREAT. It being Taco Tuesday, my wife had a selection of tacos and all were great. I went for my go-to, a burrito, and was not disappointed. The pulled pork in the burrito was exceptional. It was served with rice and a salsa like salad on the side -- it was great. This location is a bit of a drive compared to their former Polaris location but it was worth the drive.

We love celebrating or just having a good time at Fiesta del Rio! One thing we love is they support…read morethe community and the staff are always nice. They highly recommend the margaritas. Food is made fresh and has a good spice on the salsa. Not too hot just right. Sometimes you see the staff walk by with a taco that looks so good, you need to come back. Plenty of room outside and inside. We often have parties of 2-10 people and they are very accommodating. There is a bar as well. We are so thankful for the hospitality.

Mushroom quesadilla

See all

Outside view

Subway

1.4(7 reviews)

0.9 mi

This is supposedly under new management.. however.. went there yesterday and then went there…read moretonight.. rates went up 20% overnight. When I asked why, I was told it was because of management, BE CAREFUL! If they can't be honest about their rates.. I have to question everything else about this location..

I agree with the majority of the reviews. The management of this place, does not seem to have a…read morefirm grip on the location. I have had coupons that were not expired, not honored. The food is Subway & is pretty much what you will expect you will get. I do not feel the place is cleaned as normally as it should. The biggest issue I have, is with the hours. It is normally open till at least 7pm but I have seen it close routinely before that time. Closing before the posted closing time, is not a way to run a business. I generally no longer go here.

See all

Hawks Nest Pub

3.6(29 reviews)

5.8 mi

Hawks Nest is under new management and it's evident. While the inside of the gas station has…read morereceived some updates (even tho it's always hot now and occasionally Smokey), it seems like some overall service AND customer service is now severely lacking. My recent take out was 50% jacked up. The poppers looked like someone threw them against the wall before putting them in the box. Enter at your own risk.

Well, surprise surprise surprise.. I have heard about this place from friends. Not a place I would…read morenormally go to or stop by to try. It's located by a gas station, no its connected to the gas station. Very shocked to see how well designed it was and clean. Greeted as we came in and all three bartender's were nice and had so many opinions on what to try...very friendly! The beer choices were awesome! I like cider and they had alot to choose from. The food was good, had one of their specialty sandwiches, which was made with pizza crust.... YUM This place will shock you so try it out for yourself...

Great place, good food, amazing beer.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Steve S.

6 years ago

Great Pizza - my kids love playing the claw machine

Creno's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Things to Do near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Restaurants near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Desserts near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Shopping near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Coffee near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Parking near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Thrift Stores near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Breakfast near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Burgers near Creno's Pizza

BEST of Johnstown, Ohio Dinner near Creno's Pizza

Best of Johnstown

Things to do in Johnstown

Browse Brands

Creno's Pizza

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Creno's Pizza also viewed

Donatos Pizza

3.2

(36 reviews)

Huge fan of this Donatos location!…read more I frequently find myself ordering a pizza through this location due to the consistency and great taste. My orders are always correct and ready in a timely manner. The staff is AWESOME, whether it be the drive-up window employee with a flashy smile or the timely and respectful delivery driver. When I'm feeling lazy or unable to leave the house, I opt for the small delivery fee and tip for easy and timely service. My order has ALWAYS been on time or earlier than expected. I have received my pizza in less than 25 minutes before with the delivery service. The pizzas and subs hear ROCK. Pataskala is a pizza goldmine. You turn a corner and you're bound to find a pizza place every where you go. After trying many different pizza places, I have landed on Donatos as my go to. Their pizza cannot be beat. The prices are easily affordable for small groups or for personal pizzas. My favorite is a classic thin crust cheese pizza with extra sauce on top for more yummy flavor. I have ate in store a few times and have had no issues. The restaurant is clean and well put together. The staff in the kitchen will double as waiters/waitresses and do a great job of managing everything and keeping drinks full. Thank you Donatos!

Nice and easy drive-through window for when I have a craving for Donato's. I've always liked their…read moretoppings and variety of the pizzas. I like the ease of ordering online and picking up my order at the window. Friendly employees and the line moves fast. I've seen several Donato's like this around town. I'm sure they're similar.

Plaza Pizza - Johnstown

3.2

(6 reviews)

Plaza Pizza - Heath

3.7

(19 reviews)

Ever since I came to Plaza Pizza last year I have been absolutely craving the Torpedo Sub and their…read moreShirley Lou! As far as I'm concerned the Shirley Lou is still thee best dessert pizza on the face of the earth! Someone has yet to change my mind? Word around the campfire there's a new location in Johnston opening soon.

Ordered a meat lovers pizza for a family dinner. Drove home in 7°F weather and opened the box to…read morefind a veggie pizza. Drove back immediately. At that point, instead of fixing the situation, I was told "the system shows veggie" and offered a 30-minute wait for a remake after nearly an hour already wasted and a second trip in freezing temperatures. Because of this, my dinner turned into eating leftovers separately instead of eating with my wife. What's truly wild is that neither pizza was refunded. No money back just "credit next time." I won't be back. Last 45$ I spend with this organization. Mistakes happen. Refusing to take responsibility when they disrupt customers' time, money, and plans is unacceptable. Should have checked pizza on site.

Pizza Cottage - Newark

3.2

(63 reviews)

A must try when in Newark! Grew up going to Pizza Cottage out at Buckeye Lake and was thrilled to…read morerealize that the Pizza Cottage was in Newark. Restaurant was very clean and tons of seating, small bar up front. Had breadsticks, cheesy garlic bread and pepperoni pizza - JUST as delicious as I remember it from 20 years ago!!! Server, Alex, was outstanding! Great experience!

The person at the window was really rude and snarky and I didn't like the tone or attitude, she…read moresaid she couldn't hear what my wife was saying so it came off super rude and I was dissatisfied with the tone of the service I feel really angered by it

Jet's Pizza

3.6

(34 reviews)

Pizza was ready for pickup on time and was very good. Happy with experience. No more to add!read more

Admittedly I'm a bit of a pizza snob, that being said I just don't get what the hype is over this…read morestuff. It's the same processed assembly line junk you get from Papa John's or Dominoes, except it's square cut and cost twice as much. Nothing about the taste of this pizza justifies the cost. I ordered maybe 2 pies and breadsticks for 6 or 7 kids, nothing was even close to being finished.

Pizza Burg

3.9

(15 reviews)

Being new to the area, you're always going to find yourself in need of something quick. And who…read moredoesn't love a fresh local pizza?! Well I've tried the other pizza competitor and wasn't a fan. But Pizza burg's pie is pretty good. I gave them 4 outta 5 because I generally don't like a sauce that's a little sweet, but the spice of the pepperonis tends to help balance that. Also not a fan of the crumbled sausage. But will order again for sure!

This is the very best pizza in this area and has been for years!Service is always great and they…read moreall are super friendly! Judy and Bill are truly great people and support community functions well! You will never find two greater people! My grandson loves Miss Judy and says"her cheese pizza is the best!" Keep up the great work!!

Marco's Pizza

3.4

(47 reviews)

I would like to recognize an awesome associate by the name of Hope at the Worthington Center…read morelocation. She is very pleasant with a smile on her face when she greets you. She makes you feel special. She sure can make a pizza I say this because there is hardly any grease. Holly thank you for your exemplary service Paul

The person taking the order was the most rudest person I have ever met. Store was called and spoke…read morewith manager . I won't be back. I spoke with a manager at that store, not sure if he was listening and I also called your number and left a message .

Little Caesar's Pizza

3.3

(22 reviews)