The staff are always pleasant. I don't do food delivery anymore from here cause the order was always wrong or missing iced coffee. Not sure what brand they brew but you can taste the coffee. Bagel selection is ridiculous and they have many special spreads. The bagels with meat always have a generous amount. I'm still a fan! read more

See all

We ordered delivery from Craft. I was so excited to see they had not just a gluten free bagel, but an everything gluten free bagel. Even more exciting news is that it was actually really good. Their customer service is great, as well, always reaching out if any more information or changes are needed. My family liked it so much they ordered again the next day when I wasn't home. read more

Great food, great service and great staff . I highly recommend the everything bagel to start your morning!!

Bustling bagel shop with a wide variety of bagels and sandwiches. Bagels are pretty good, fresh. Generally not as plump as I prefer, but all in all tasty! Other baked goods and sandwiches also available. Parking on street in front, or at adjacent side streets. read more

See all

We made an intentional stop here from Manhattan because Craft Bagels was our favorite stand at the NYC Bagel Fest 2026! However, the bagels in the store were not good... The bagels looked plump and great but turned out to be extremely dry! We enjoyed the apple french toast special but it also seemed like it was sitting out for too long when we stopped by around 12. No place to sit. No bathroom inside. read more

See all

One of my favorite spots to hit up when I am in the area. Their bagel maker has been doing it a long time and used to be at Bagel Cafe in NP. Same owners of the place next door - Fable & Flame. Anyway - always fresh bagels. Especially enjoy the jalapeno. Their coffee is no syrup brewed flavors. My favorite is Jamaican Me Nuts. Worth a stop in if you are in the area. ENJOY! read more

The bagels are always fresh, fluffy and have the right chew always. Service is great from the chefs to the front staff and the girl at the register is always are so nice about giving our lil one a ducky during our visits :) it makes his day The inside is always kept clean and they decorate for the different times of the year. Berkeley Heights definitely found itself a gem and permanent Bagel staple for downtown which we're pumped about. Thanks to all the staff there, they always hustle and pump things out quick! read more

Craft Bagel - Perfection (Hashbrown,Egg,Cheese,Hot Sauce) - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

We split two bagels. She loved the everything bagel bacon, egg and cheese. Also she likes that they gave you the "right amount " of cream cheese on the second bagel. Enjoyed the Nice variety of coffee choices and bagels flavors like the blueberry and French toast. Good and fast service. " A nice place" overall. read more

Bagels are great but in-store service is very bad. This bagel store has a great product but sadly its operations and staff hasn't kept up with their growth. Unorganized teenagers trying their best to keep up with a line out the door and DoorDash drivers yelling over the counter in a cramped standing area isn't a recipe for long term success. read more

This is the best bagel shop around Always delicious bagels great shop hands down ! Great staff too !

Appreciate that they have been putting more butter on lately! It's usually just the right amount for me. read more

Craft Bagel - This was the amount of butter given on my bagel, and this is common practice. Should I ask for "extra butter" just to get a normal amount? - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

Been here a few times. They make the bagels on premises and often have unique flavors such as sea salt rosemary which I loved. A take out place but worth the trip. Friendly staff. Street parking is available. Check it out. read more

It's really a hit or miss at this point to order from here. Today's experience 02/12/2026 was by the worst. I'm adding a picture to show you why. read more

Craft Bagel - Fresh avocado ???? - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

See all

One of my favorite bagel places in the area. Pork roll egg and cheese is the way to go! The cheddar jalapeno bagel looks and tastes different here than at most places. read more

Craft Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

See all

Stopped at this location as I was in the area. Ordered a THEC SPK, coffee and pumpkin French toast bagel with butter. The service was decent. The bagel was excellent. The coffee was Jamaica me nuts and very good. The ambiance was that of a bagel shop. No place to eat inside. The THEC SPK was mediocre. The Taylor ham was cooked well with char which is good. There were 2 eggs on the roll but the cheese wasn't melted. The SPK I could actually taste pepper. The roll was too big for the egg sandwich. It tasted good but there a lot of room for improvement. I'll be back only for the coffee and bagels not for the egg sandwiches. I'm on the fence if I should recommend. I recommend for the bagels. read more

See all

Three and a half. Excellent service by a trio of high school/college age young women who were friendly, efficient. Fairly good bagels, not great. Typical bagel joint with a small space and self-serve coffee machines. I got a medium container of cream cheese and lox spread: good cream cheese, but the lox is AWOL. Street parking on busy Springfield Avenue. I gotta go looking for that lox ... where could it have gone? read more

Craft Bagel - Cream cheese with a hint of lox - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

Craft bagel has to have some of the most mid bagels out there and they STAY messing up my orders. I ordered a bacon and egg on a plain bagel online pick it up and come to find out they put cheese on it too. I'm not a picky person but i'm LACTOSE INTOLERANT and will get sick if I eat it. There's my money straight down the drain and I had to go to my job hungry this morning. read more

Clean, quick and good for a fast bite to eat. We had 2 bacon, egg and cheese bagels. Solid. Not overstuffed but definitely sufficient! Service was efficient and fast. read more

Had to call to place order because app was not working. Their online menu needs to be fixed cause you can't see parts of it. Ordered my fries well done and they were practically raw. Glad I opened the container before I drove all the way home. When I brought them back, had to tell the girl taking orders "no you can't put those back in the oil, I want a fresh batch". Also, I had to tell them to pack my fries since I was standing there waiting for them...they were out of the fryer and just sitting there. After ordering ahead and having a quick transaction, I was not thrilled about waiting because of their screw up. Don't serve raw fries. The bagel sandwich was very good, but I still won't go back when there are other bagel stores nearby. read more

The bagels are amazing and unlike what I am use to the toppings are on all sides. Try the Taylor Ham with Swiss on a sesame seed bagel. You will not be disappointed. read more

Walking into this place in the morning is amazing, the smell of fresh bagels being cooked in the back is the best thing ever. Their bagel sandwiches are always fresh, and the quality of the bagels themselves are unmatched. Certainly my go-to and favorite breakfast sandwich shop, and it's not even close. read more

Let me start with one word...Amazing! Crunchy on the outside fluffy light on the inside. These are not your average hockey pucks you get at those two overcrowded mosh pit bagel joints in New Providence. They don't stop at bagels they also offer a dozen different CC's. Try the Bacon Jalapeño! I pass three different bagel shops to get here but it is worth it.....not all bagels are created equal. Next time I'm gonna hit up an egg sandwich.... to be continued read more

Craft Bagel - a variety of bagels in a basket - Bagels Near Me - Berkeley Heights, New Jersey

Wow, the bagels here are amazing and delicious, I've tried many bagels before, but this place is truly bagel heaven.I've been there when they have a line out the door, and when I head to the counter when my order is complete, whoever is there always greats me with a smile. Customers sometimes think that when they order when there's a line a mile long, they think they are the only one in the shop. 5 stars to all of you thst keeps this place moving. read more

Ordered breakfast ahead of time (bagels, coffee, and fruit tray) for our company meetings. Bagels and cream cheese were delicious, coffee was hot, and the fruit was fresh. Service was great, easy to order over the phone and delivery was on time. Would definitely order from again. Thanks! read more

Good selection of bagels and spreads, and fast service. Great t local bagel shop if you are in the area.

Now these are some good looking bagels! I have to say the 1st time we ordered from here we were super impressed by the quality and size of the bagel. Definitely a go to breakfast spot for us. To get messed up and we get the wrong bagel or the wrong spread. Everything is delicious but it's a bummer when you don't get something you want. I think this is the best cinnamon raisin bagel I've had in New Jersey. They actually put a decent amount of raisins in it, haha. Same thing with all of their other baseballs they really don't skin on skim on the flavor or extra in that bagel. I love that we have a local spot that's so great! read more

I've lived in NJ my entire life and it might be the best bagel you can find. Great sandwiches and a hard working staff. Can't ask for more.

The gluten free bagels here used to be good but they must have changed which brand they use. The new gluten free bagels are flat and tiny. Super disappointing and it seems like they put less on them because they are smaller. read more

It was first time there and the service was great! I picked up a sausage, egg and cheese & hashbrowns. the bagel was so fluffy and I truly enjoyed the freshness of the bread. the hashbrowns were a tad too crispy and oily for me. Regardless, I would definitely recommend & come back! read more

I work in Berkeley Heights and we go here a lot. Specially when we have parties. The bagels are so good and very large. You will not be disappointed. They are the best bagel I ever had. Please try them. read more

They Always get the order wrong! They don't take care to read the order. I Order no cheese and get cheese! Order 8 bagels and get 6. Thats $8 mistakes out of 24. Very disappointed read more

Bagels are good, but they can't get an order right to save their lives. Way overpriced and the staff is beyond rude.

Really great traditional bagels. Crunchy outside and perfect texture. A large variety of flavors and a full sandwich menu. Several homemade cream cheese mixes, all of which are quite good too. Very friendly service rounds out a great experience. Loyalty program too! We go least once a week. read more

OK bagels but terrible service. I ordered a dozen bagels plus one with lox and cream cheese. When I got home, the one bagel with lox and cream cheese was missing from my order. I updated my review because I have subsequently received a refund on my whole order, which was a very nice gesture. read more

Great bagels and cream cheese. Very fresh. Had some specialty flavors too like pumpkin bagels.

The best bagel around ! They get people in and out really quick. Use their awesome online ordering to skip the wait, especially on the weekends read more

went for the first time today with my boyfriend. i ordered a hashbrown, bacon & cheese on an everything bagel, i saw the attendant write my exact order down perfectly which she certainly has no fault for and was very sweet. After waiting a few minutes, we get back to the car to start eating and my bagel is completely missing the hashbrown. I should also add that prior to getting our bagels, another attendant had recited my order word for word. the bagel being mediocre and on top of that missing the best part of the entire sandwich due to lack of interest or care of the cooks makes me not want to go back. read more

Great bagels and really good breakfast sandwiches! So far i've had plain, blueberry, and cinnamon raisin bagels and they were all

Great bagels and sandwiches but the last few times I've placed a phone order my items were wrong. Today I ordered a BLT on rye toast with mayo and a bacon, egg and cheese on rye toast with SPK. I got the right BLT but also got another BLT but with ketchup. Very frustrating. Not sure how someone would even make that sandwich without re-reading the order. Really hope this gets better because I'm considering going elsewhere. read more

Our new go-to bagel spot. Great bagels, croissants, coffee and friendly staff. The supreme critic in our family (7yr old) insists that we get her rainbow bagels here from now on. Can't argue with that! read more