Great customer service. The food needed a little bit more flavoring. I'm guessing because since it is near the hospital, it's cater to more of a healthy approach. The Spaces narrow. Did not like the booth towards the back that are really hard sit on. We ordered one margarita one lemonade, guac, and chips, a fish taco steak taco and two chickens. read more

Came here today (Sunday) at noon and the place was completely empty, which maybe should have been a sign for us to try somewhere else, but we were hungry and already here. The breakfast burrito was $18 on the menu but when I got my receipt it turned out to be an extra $3 for Chorizo even though that surcharge is not on the menu (it just says choice of bacon or chorizo). At that price it's quite expensive, especially because it was a pretty small burrito. It was also a bit bland and the home fries were not as crispy or flavorful as they could have been. read more

Conmigo Madison - Breakfast Burrito with Chorizo - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

ConMigo Madison love love love this place. Mostly go when I'm celebrating an accomplishment and want a nice drink and tasteful Mexican food. Their fully loaded nachos is always good. Freshly guacamole heaven. I love how fresh everything is in this restaurant. Happy hour is always my favorite time to go lol Staff is very attentive and friendly. Restaurant is spacious and always clean. A lot of inside seating read more

I've been here 4x in the past 2 months. Love their Yorkville location & was happy they have a new location on Madison and 96th. The $15 lunch special is truly the best deal & their tres leche cake is to die for. Always good service, nice ambiance and decor & the food is always top notch. 10/10 read more

Conmigo Madison - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

The food and drinks were good. Hostess was nice, she found us a table even though we didn't have reservations. I gave it 3 stars because our waiter was super slow and not as attentive as he should've been, especially since it was a slow Friday night. read more

Conmigo Madison - Short Rib Nachos - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

This place is SO cute and DELISH!!! We were shocked at how empty it was, especially because it's such a cute and clean restaurant. The chicken tacos and brisket burrito were both to die for, can't wait to come back and eat the same meal again!! Reasonable prices too and great service. Highly recommend!!! read more

Conmigo Madison - Inside beautiful dining space - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After a long day working at the hospital I had ordered food from the restaurant . I had walked into an empty restaurant and had to wait a long period of time for the food and the front server or bartender had refused to allow me to eat there as he said it would be a hassle since my food is already in box's even though I had told them I can just eat it as is. definitely not the first time I have encountered their rude behavior towards people. read more

Excellente! The food and service are wonderful. Normally have the lunch special but today had the fajitas which were outstanding and so wonderful! Have a margarita and enjoy! read more

A delicious set for lunch, would definitely pop in again. The service was attentive and friendly and the ambiance was relaxing. read more

Conmigo Madison - Chicken Tacos, Sirloin Tacos, conmigo mojito and a watermelon Margarita - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

Have been here several times since they have opened. The food has been overall, fine but they seem to have gotten rid of a lot of good items, ie their calamari, potato coquettes and fajitas. The revised menu has much more limited options and frankly nothing particularly interesting. At my most recent visit I and my coworker ordered the chorizo tostadas which we both agreed was pretty salty. As an entree I got the seared salmon that was fine though a little bland. read more

Food was ok Nothing special the other location was great. Which is one of the reasons I came to this one. The front person was not friendly at all. He looked like he didn't want to be there. My guess is that its better during the week. When they have their lunch special. read more

I've been here twice and never been disappointed. The ambiance doesn't appear like a Mexican restaurant, it could be any cuisine. However, the margaritas are excellent and the tacos are really good. A little more tex-mex style, but really comforting. The burrito is available as a bowl and is very large and flavorful. The tacos are a service of three. Tried fish, chicken and steak (not as a single order) and they are all good. Friendly staff. read more

Came here for happy hour. $29 for 3 tacos and unlimited margaritas/wine/beer for an hour is an amazing deal. Our waitress refilled our drinks without even asking, was able to get 3 drinks in. The margaritas were refreshing, tasty, and had a respectable amount of booze in them. The tacos are also legit: good portion of protein, flavorful, they allow you to choose up to 3 different proteins. The restaurant is clean and new, not high end / sophisticated but aesthetic and fun. read more

Conmigo Madison - Assortment of tacos - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I had the Barbacoa taco with cheese on top. It was not bad, but had little flavor. The margarita was not bad, but had no real draw as well. This is basically one of the only "nice" restaurants near Mount Sinai Hospital, so they get traffic from there. The staff are nice but inefficient and the service is slow and prone to errors. We waited quite a while for the 8 taco special. They also didn't split the bill correctly so I paid a lot more than I should have. I would avoid it but some times there is no choice. read more

Another pleasant prelude to the weekend! It's always a pleasure to start the weekend off right, thanks to the very pleasant and attentive staff at ConMigos! I look forward to the welcoming smiles along with the delicious food since during the week I only get to order takeout. I enjoy the ambiance and of course the amazing drinks! Unfortunately, I observed that reviewer who complained about her short water glass and poor service. One word sums this all up... disgusting! I wouldn't be surprised if she did this freeloading all over town. Lady, if that's your way of getting free meals, you and your husband are pathetic! If you were so unhappy with the service and the meal why did you consume the rest of your meal with such urgency when the manager dismissed your bill? The manager did a fantastic job deescalating your shenanigans. ConMigos you ROCK!!! read more

Conmigo Madison - The best combo always! - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I've been here several times. The drinks are usually good, and the food tends to be decent. However, my last visit was disappointing because they got my order wrong despite my specific diet restrictions. Today, I decided to try again. I ordered a cheese quesadilla that costs $13, but I was surprised to see an $8 excessive charge added to the bill after it was already presented. It seemed very unreasonable and like a bit of a shakedown. This might be my last visit here. The bartender who worked this afternoon gets 1 star . read more

My husband and I came in here for the first and last time today. When we walked in, it felt like we were intentionally ignored by the staff. The coldness was palpable. In retrospect, that should have been enough for us to walk ourselves back out but as it so happened, we requested to see the takeout menu. Seeing the high prices of everything ($6.50 for ONE taco or $19 for a burrito), we figured we just try a chicken burrito and see if the food was worth the cost and snobby vibes. As we sat and waited for our order, a new customer walked in the door and was given a glass of water while she ordered. Where was that treatment when we walked in?! Was it skin color? Did we look poor? Maybe we just didn't carry enough haughtiness in our entrance? All this aside, I was still open and ready to eat an outstanding burrito. This proved to not be the case as it was NOT a good burrito. Very mushy and not much flavor. Chipotle actually has better burritos but at least with Chipotle you don't feel like you're getting got. This spot gets a boo rating from me. A waste of time and money and stomach space. read more

Placed an order for pickup online and when arrived the bar tender said they didn't have one of the items ask I asked for them to cancel the order. They marked it as delivered so that I would be charged despite not getting ANY food when I told them to cancel even though they didn't have the food. AVOID this place. read more

Walked in with my wife and went to the bar. Bartender seemed too busy or too uncomfortable to serve me. He never made eye contact or said hello, welcome or 2 for lunch? We stood for almost a minute at the bar unnoticed before I then walked to the end of the bar and asked the other server, a pleasant gentleman with vitiligo if we would be able to order to-go. He said yes and handed us a menu. We ordered the very expensive but uninteresting burrito. My wife and I were initially drawn to the restaurant by the colors and the minimalism but after the treatment I can see that appearances are deceiving and the coldness and lack of heart are all this restaurant serves. IMO you should not eat here if you are used to experiencing racism or cultural insensitivity. We will never return. Conmigo-No! M read more

What a lovely spot for dinner! We lucked out with a quiet evening and the food and service were excellent. The guacamole was freshly smashed and the corn chips lightly salted. The well-blended salsa was more green chili than red and quite mild - a hit if texture with the guacamole on a chip. The shrimp fajitas were a hit although heavy with onion, many of which were left on the plate. The veggies were cooked to have a slight crunch, confirming freshness. The tortilla soup - I opted for added chicken - was silky smooth. Big chunks of avocado added texture and taste as did the cheese. I enjoyed what I didn't finish for lunch the next day. We had the house margaritas which were traditional and delicious. Salt covered half of the rim of the glass, which was a nice look. I didn't run out of salt. Happy hour is supposed to be fun but too loud to share a conversation. We lucked out on a quiet night at the end of the year to enjoy all the gems this restaurant has to offer. read more

Conmigo Madison - Fajitas with shrimp - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

shrimp tacos for 15 dollars thats not very nice!!!! can you lower the prices pleaseeeee

Food was fantastic and they let us linger and chat....i spent several hours there catching up with a friend ....no pressure!

Came here with my daughter before heading up to Yankee stadium for the game. She said it was new and I said let's grab a quick drink and appetizer. We both had margaritas which were good I had a single taco for $5 ( I thought the price was dam cheap in todays world ) she had the elote corn. They take the niblets off the Cobb in a bowl with the cheese. It was really good. Service was good somewhat attentive. The place looked brand spanking new well lit, clean. I'll go back if I'm ever up near Mt.Sinai again meeting her. read more

Terrible service! I went once waited at the bar for 20 minutes to get a drink and asked for water and was given a cup of water in a shooter glass. Decided to come back again to give it another chance which was a mistake. Waited at more than 15 minutes to place a drink order at the bar. No one even said hello that entire time. Then we ordered appetizers and Fajitas and an order of there Brussels sprouts to split with my husband. All good came out at once when we specifically asked appetizers to come and then fajitas and Brussels sprouts. When Nachos came they were cold and chips tasted stale. I sent them back and I be er do that. Calamari tasted like it was leftover and attempted to heat in microwave but was also cold. We never ate the fajitas bc we were told they would take them back to keep them warm. Then we were told by Bartender he would just cancel them and we have to reorder them if we want them. Never was served napkins or silverware until we asked for a manager which we never do. We were berated by the bartender saying all we needed to do was ask. In the meantime we have been in restaurant for 45 plus minutes trying to get attention to ask for silverware and napkins and attempting to eat woth serving spoons in hope of our food not getting more cold. Also we asked twice for more water bc we were served shooter glasses (see picture) smaller than my regular mixed drink glass. While everyone else who was getting water had bigger glasses. When we asked a 3rd time we had a bottle of water shoved our way and said here. Then we were approached and asked what the problem was and we explained everything and was told that what do we won't them to do. I said nothing. I just won't be coming back. Then they preceded to argue with my husband and said we have complained enough and kicked us out. It was the most unprofessional and worst service I have ever in my life experienced. I definitely plan to tell everyone. Good luck to them bc never have I seen someone be so rude when the bartenders and servers when they are 100% in the wrong. It deserves no stars but that's not an option! read more

Conmigo Madison - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I LOVE THIS PLACE! I have worked in this neighborhood for many years and was so pleasantly surprised at the service AND food at Conmigo! I have had George as my server for 3 times now, and he has been AMAZING! He is attentive, helpful and customer service centered! I can't imagine how anyone would see him as anything other than stellar. He clearly takes time to consider the needs of his patrons! I will come back and recommend others to do so as well! THANKS GEORGE!!' read more

Food is Amazing, fresh, delicious, and consistent. Beautiful atmosphere, they can do better with the music list though; great service. We have been there like 10 times so far. read more

Always the BEST customer service!!! They never fail to make you feel welcomed. Our office orders lunch at least 3-4 times a week, and without fail they ALWAYS provide excellent food with a smile! I would highly recommend this establishment for lunch, dinner, office functions, and neighborhood watering hole! The staff is AMAZING!!; they treat you like family and with the utmost respect! We always have a great time at this location! Come for a drink, and leave with new friends! HIGHLY recommend Conmigos for great food and even GREATER SERVICE!! Shout-out to the AWESOME bartenders and servers!!! read more

Conmigo Madison - Bartenders made sure we were well hydrated on this sweltering day!!! - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I had low expectations, but this exceeded them! Our waiter service was a little slow, but everyone has an off day. Now, the food. We had the empanadas, which I thought were very well fried but not great--but my dining companion thought they were great. The nachos, however, were the standout super star. We added chicken for a super reasonable upcharge, and they were fantastic. More than enough for two, probably enough for three as an appetizer. Came for lunch on Tuesday, pretty empty around one, but there still new so I can see them finding a groove. I'll be back for chicken tacos! read more

Stumbled on this place for breakfast and had a huevos rancheros. Homemade everything, including hot sauces and tortillas. A really good addition to the Mt. Sinai neighborhood. read more

This restaurant was recommended by our favorite Mount Sinai doctor. I think Mount Sinai loves this place too, lots of people from the hospital there enjoying their lunch when we were there. George our waiter was as great as the food! He was making rounds for his many tables and kept food coming out of the kitchen constantly for the two hours we were there. Our food was amazing , we couldn't stop eating and ordered several "rounds" ourselves. We even brought home the chocolate cake for later ! This place seems a good for a fast lunch as it is for a longer meal. read more

Delicious margarita and Moscow mule, (virgin), friendly service and lovely decor- a delightful little treasure! read more

Conmigo Madison - Lovely and muy delicioso! - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

In NYC for drs appointment.. was starving so popped in here because nurse told me it was good. I ordered fish taco, chicken taco and short rib taco with a side order of street corn. Well, what I got was NOT short ribs.. it was a dried up steak that was way too hard to chew! Short ribs are saucy with meat so tender it falls off the bone.. and the street corn.. I always get it and it's a bit charred... not this it was in some sauce and cold!! Sorry not a fan.. read more

I am a black person, who sat at the bar and was ignored. I said hello and excuse me as the bartender walked right by me. I would excuse the behavior if the bar was crowded, but there were only three patrons at the bar. I watched as the bartender walked past me repeatedly and did not make eye contact, then as soon as a fourth white female patron walked up to order he immediately looked up and said hello, what would you like. I normally do not leave reviews, but I felt like something needs to be said. Do not go to this establishment. read more

My wife and I made a reservation for Valentine's Day. We were really excited to see a new place open in the neighborhood. We were clearly on a date but were sat in the middle of several of what seemed to be happy hour work parties where everyone was drunk and loud, when there were obvious open tables in the back for two which would have been way more appropriate for a romantic valentines date, and other couples coming in with reservations as well were all sat in the back. George was our waiter and we received minimal service from him throughout the meal. Our drinks came out after our meal was served and he offered no refills on our drinks or water throughout the meal and never asked how everything was. My wife's steak was chewy as well. We were planning on a lovely evening out as this was our very first Valentine's Day as a married couple, but we couldn't wait to leave. The food was otherwise good and the bussers were great, but the ambiance and service were severely lacking. We got a bag for our food, stacked our plates, had finished our drinks, and just sat there. No one offered to top off our drinks or show us a dessert menu (which we were planning on ordering before we got there). The staff hung out together and talked. We eventually interrupted them to ask the manager for the check. If you are looking for a place to hang out with friends at happy hour it seems like a good spot but this is not a place to have a date night. read more

Went here with family yesterday and had terrific experience. All staff very friendly and accommodating. I had chicken flautas that came with a mountain of fresh guacamole. The others shared the taco flight-8 for $42. We also has drinks and dessert. Never felt rushed. Definitely recommend. read more

authentic street tacos! food is so good and comes out really quickly. excellent service. love the vibe in here, the decorations are so cute. perfect spot for lunch or dinner. especially if you work close to the hospital and need a quick lunch. they also offer order ahead take out!! 10/10 love it here, staff is so nice and attentive. read more

Conmigo Madison - a blue room with a bar and a potted plant - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

The food was great the taco flight is a great idea for a group to try a bunch of great tasting variations

This is the best bottomless brunch in the city. $39 for an amazing entree and 2 hours of unlimited margaritas (flavored, spicy, etc.) with all the other standard brunch drinks is unbeatable. Also the service is incredible and Stephanie is the MVP of the team. They're all incredibly welcoming and take great care of you. read more

Had brunch here today and everything was top notch. This spot has had at least 5 different restaurants over the past 20 years but Conmigo's redesign is clearly the best. Great staff, fast service and very good food.....huevos rancheros are best I've had in quite some time. Hope Conmigo makes it here where others have failed! read more

Food was just Eh, nothing special. Now to the drinks- worse than the food . Hardly any Tequila In the margarita were mostly juice . Will never go back read more