Stopped in for dinner around 4:30. Nice and quiet on a Thursday. We tried the appetizer pepperoni rolls dipped in sauce and stuffed banana peppers. Both amazing. My son got the pepperoni pizza with extra cheese- great as usual! I got the Italian beef sandwich mini- it is a pretty big sandwich on a hoagie bun toasted perfectly with melty cheese and juicy Italian beef. My husband tried the steak sandwich mini-also served on that perfectly toasted cheesy roll. He said the meat was soft and tasted great. Our waitress was so sweet and happy to help. We will be back to try something else for sure. read more

See all

Poor value for the money. Poor customer service . Unable to resolve issue. House Salad with pepperoni has 3 pcs of pepperoni for $8.95. I thought it was just a mistake. They confirmed it was correct. They said don't you have anything better to worry about. I said I don't like getting ripped off. read more

Ordered via "Slice" for a family friend. Specifically wrote NO cheese on one of the pizza I ordered, it came with cheese! I LOVE their pizza but this was a REAL disappointment that my order was not correct! read more

Truly didn't disappoint. This was Baked on a whole love of italian bread, Plenty of meat in dressing. Definitely worth the price!!! read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - So I decided to try Conforti's for the first time. Well they definitely did not disappoint!! The picture does not do it justice. - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

The worst Italian food ive ever had. Ive never been so pissed at a meal in my life. my pasta was extremely unpleasantly watery

Shameful Business Practice... Service was good. Food was fine. Ambiance was appropriate. Overall though, I'll NEVER go back and I will NEVER recommend anyone to them or suggest them because for $8 that they were aware of they CHOSE to deceive and steal. I ordered two pieces of lasagna and they took one piece and separated it into two. My friend had two layers of pasta with cheese on top, i had two layers of pasta, no cheese on top. It was obvious. Then drown with sauce to hide the pathetic con job. I asked my server to ask the manager that instead of full price for each, $17, that I'd pay half price each. They vut the price in half for one piece, the one without cheese on top aka the bottom but charged full price for the top. I NEVER ever give reviews but the short-term quick buck attitude of whomever made the rip off decisions last night was exceptional. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Uneaten, $17 piece of COMFORTI'S lasagna. April 4th 2025. Female manager hung up on me when I called - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

Let me tell you - if you are hungry go here and get a whole hoagie! We got an Italian and the steak and the amount of meat on both is impressive! I love spicy stuff so I wish they had a spicy Italian but that's here not there. The cost of a whole hoagie was definitely worth the price! I had lunch and dinner the next day and lunch the following day! The staff was extremely friendly and even offered to help when I had my daughter with me realizing that the two whole hoagies were a hand full on top of making sure my daughter walked safely to the car. I highly recommend going here as they also have seating like a restaurant plus they are conveniently located near big name stores Target, Kohls, Walmart, and Sam's club to name a few. See pictures below of the whole hoagie for size... picture taking skills aren't the best. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Whole Steak Hoagie - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

See all

Got 3 large pizzas to go. There are no deals to be found. I paid a hefty price for them. The website made it easy to order. They gave an accurate ETA for the order. Only real complaint is the fact they didn't have a pizza box big enough for their own large pizza. They put a brown bag over the pizza put on a cardboard slab. Luckily my suv was empty so I could place 3 pizzas in it. read more

Love the pizza--maybe my favorite pizza place on the planet--but the Slice driver delivered it 10 minutes early, but cold, cold. We live 1/2 mile away. Go figure. read more

Ordered a pizza with a few toppings. It was saturated wet with water. Used 5 napkins to sop up the water. The end result was soggy wet pizza. There was very little sauce if any. On the positive side, the crust that wasn't soggy tasted good. Waitress never came to see how pizza was. read more

The food was tasty, the ingredients were fresh and the cheese was delicious!!! Conforti's has thick crust and savory sauce. Worth the try!!!

Fabulous pizza! Great service! We each got a different small pizza, and both were delicious. The crust is amazing! Prices are good, especially for pizza of this quality. Our first time being there, since we're from a different county and were passing through. We will definitely make sure to stop again when we're in town next! read more

Made a quick stop here on a road trip up to Ohio after seeing the poor reviews for the local Pizza Hut, and BOY was it a good choice! We ordered the garlic bread to start, which was delicious and very cheap! Then we ordered the large pizza as a meal - when they say large, they mean LARGE! Ended up taking half the pie to go with us, and it will be well enjoyed at home. Delicious, crunchy crust and a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. If I could give it 6 stars, I would. Service was fast and friendly, we seated ourselves and the server was quick to check on us and refill our drinks. Overall, will definitely be stopping here again on our next trip up! Absolutely give it a try, I haven't had a pizza this good in a minute! read more

Not sure what my deal is but I have easily driven past this clearly displayed restaurant on Route 30 a thousand times. Absolutely never thought about stopping in until I needed to purchase a gift card for a friend. Apparently this is one of her favorites. After my first visit, I think I will make it the same. I had no idea they had a very cute, and inviting dining area. From the outside, it looks like a typical pizza and hoagie spot so it was a nice surprise. Menu looks terrific, prices are quite reasonable for the size of orders. They also have a cooler with a nice assortment of beers and other beverages. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Mini Italian hoagie! - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

This is definitely the best pizza I've ever had! Their pepperoni is amazing and I don't even like pepperoni. Everyone who works here is super friendly. read more

We took a huge travel baseball team in on very short notice on a busy Friday evening and they treated us like royalty. Great food and thanks for the hospitality Conforti team!! read more

I have had the pleasure of knowing about this gem for a long time now and it has literally never disappointed. I have had pizza from all over the country and world and literally nothing touches this! But beyond the quality of ingredients and style of pizza they have crafted, they are a locally family run business that has always been good to our family and treated us well! Everywhere I go I always tell people about Conforti's! read more

Peak pizza. Ordered pepperoni pizza and large salad, delish and great portions. Workers were polite and timely. Intimate interior but comfortable read more

It's not the same overly puffy bottom and plastic cheese that everyone is used to. The pizza here is greasy and delicious. You eat more toppings than dough. The pizza itself is huge too. Never really ate inside so I can't speak on that but it looks like an old school pizza parlor. The people who ring you up are all part of the Conforti family and have been nothing but polite. read more

Dude! Eat here! Really good pizza that I look forward to even though I'm from the far side of pittsburgh. Crust is great, sauce and cheese are the real deal. Pizzas are a huge amount of food. So good! read more

First time in the area. Such a cute little place, got a medium pepperoni pizza and I love crust and this pizza did not disappoint me. It had a bunch of pepperoni. Crust underneath was nice and crispy. My first time in this area and it was delicious. read more

Amazing place!!! I'm originally from PA and love the pizza so decided to try this on my Christmas trip. Omg the pizza was GIGANTIC!!! And awesome!!! Soooo tasty. Our waitress was quick to take our order and we were served drinks in a flash. Next up was our cheese pizza and it was amazing!!! Awesome tomato sauce and lots of cheese. The crust was so very tasty too!! All this for $22? Unheard of!! I'll be back!!! read more

See all

Pizza was loaded with ingredients and perfectly distributed which was excellent, crust was a bit soggy for my liking however overall it tasted good. Hoagie served on Italian loaf of bread filled! Definitely get your moneys worth. read more

See all

Best pizza in the Pittsburgh Sports Nation area. Our pizza was enormous. Then we heard a guy & his lady friend order a hoagie. Then the waitress said that hoagie will feed 3 to 4. So he got the half sized hoagie instead. When it came out, it was still to big for one person. It feeds up to 2 people. WOW! You will definitely get your money's worth. Same happened for another couple ordering salads. Enormous! Everytime we visit Pittsburgh, we will be at Conforti's first night, for sure. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - WOW This pizza is giant size! - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

Best place to get a meal. Have gone since Vincents. Husband is a fan of the Friday night steak special. Always leave happy.

If you are searching for a homemade pizza that is "out of this world", look no further! Conforti's pizza is sure to be a crowd pleaser for even the most experienced pizza critics. The process begins with a colossal homemade and hand tossed, thick pizza crust. And when I say colossal, I mean some of the biggest pizzas I have ever seen in my life. You really have to see it to believe it. The pizza then gets topped with the tastiest sauce and an enormous amount of fresh, quality tasting cheese. Let me tell you, when it comes to toppings, they do not skimp! You can expect to get what you pay for with a plenthora of toppings. Imagine, peperoni, sasuage, mushrooms, olives, onions, or whatever your heart desires, piled high on a gigantic pizza base. The pizza then finishes its journey in the kitchen by being cooked to perfection, adding just the right amounts of crispy and bubbly to the oversized pizza. The cheese is always the right combination of chewy and stringy, making every bite mouth watering. One thing I love most about confortis (other than the amazing food) is the fact you can watch the chefs create their masterpieces from behind the counter as you order. It's always a great feeling to be able to see what is happening to your food in a restuarant before it brought to your table. Which brings me to the service! Inside is a very adorable, italian themed dining room with tables. Outside is a row of picnic benches, which are always extremely clean. Every single person I have encountered here has went above and beyond to make our dining experience excellent. Whether we sit inside or out, we know we will get the same great service and consist meal each time. We have made conforti's a monthly stop for a family night out! read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

See all

This definitely a different style of pizza than you will typically find anywhere in the area. It is served in a paper bag. Yes I said a paper bag. It is quite good and ingredients seem pretty fresh. However when we order the veggies such as onions or peppers as toppings, they are not always throughly "cooked" (we like ours cooked well). I will say that even though this place is small and can be easily passed up, they have the BEST crab stuffed mushrooms. Something you would probably never expect because you're thinking it's just a pizzeria, but so worth the try. It's actually my favorite menu item. Now, I must be honest and mention that my last experience with my call in order wasn't as great as usual. It was 50 minutes before closing and the one who answered the phone was accommodating but the tone in his voice was "I'm ready for the day to be done". When I went to pick it up, I believe I could have pointed out who answered the phone when I called. They became frustrated with the cashier about the order. I believe everyone has long days. I certainly won't let that one experience keep me from ordering anything else. That was the first and only time that has happened. Plus, the food was still delicious. read more

Best pizza ever. Fridays have good specials. Love the new BBQ they added. Wish they would expand a little. The place does get a bit crambed. But worth the wait and lack of chair space. read more

Excellent pizza! Their sausage topping is especially good and homemade tasting . Hoagies look amazing, staff is friendly and nice.

Well this use to be my go to . Not anymore. Pizza is not the same. Not as many toppings as it use to. I understand prices went up . Raise your prices. I'd pay more for quality. Just very disappointed read more

Pizza is some of the worst I've ever had. Ordered a medium cheese and medium pepperoni/ham for take out. The cheese pizza wasn't terrible, but it wasn't good either. Had no flavor and hardly any sauce. It was way too greasy for being just cheese. The pepperoni/ham was absolutely awful. There was hardly any sauce on it. The ham looks like it's sliced for lunchmeat. The pizza was so greasy they had to put two cardboard bases under it because was soaking through the first. The ENTIRE bottom of the pizza was mush from laying in grease. I guess if there was any positive, it was the thick crust. For $37 I would've thought the pizza would've been somewhat decent. And for the people leaving 5 star reviews raving it's the best pizza they've ever had, they've obviously never had good pizza. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Greasy cheese pizza. - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

See all

Slipping away is best you can say. Vinnie started a great thing and was right not to trust others too much by offering a lot of franchises. Average food would not be the Vinnie way. That is all you will get now....average. read more

I am originally from PA but now live on the west coast. This was always my go to place when returning home. it's all about the food for me. This trip, I ate here twice, once dine in and once order out. The pizza, even though only a medium recommended by the waiter as large and Xtra large ran wet in the middle, this one was supposed to not be flooded but it was very wet in the center and was lacking in toppings. We chalked it up to an off day and ate soggy dripping pizza. Next to go order was a calzone. My friend ordered on from Luciano's which was thick with luscious insides and $7.50. Mine, from here, was all thick bread, little innerds of pepperoni and mushrooms, and acted as if they could care less that I was unhappy with my $14.79 loaf of bread lacking pepperoni and mushrooms, thin as could be in the center! Don't waste your time here. There are other businesses that appreciate their customers and prove it with great service and don't want to rip them off skimping on quality. read more

Conforti's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Mushroom calzone with little to no filling in it! All bread! - Italian Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

This is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. They load it with toppings, if you worry about cholesterol, the pepperoni is very plentiful and great. My only suggestion is for them to use boxes for takeout instead of bags as you can't stack multiple pizzas. Perhaps they don't have the space. Having said that I plan on being very much a repeat customer read more

Outstanding Food, Outstanding Family. Look I need 85 characters to explain the food. Delicious.

This place was good when it was Vincent's but is better as Conforti's. A solid pizza option that is sort of it's own thing, it's not New York style, or deep dish, and has more flare than your typical cookie cutter local pizza places. You can tell it's a pizza from Conforti's just by looking at it, you won't confuse it for someplace else. Try it out for yourself read more

We haven't been to Conforti's since last June & decided to go last evening. we always order the SAME pizza: Large Pepperoni & Sausage. Last night, we ordered and when we got our pizza; it had MAYBE 50% of the toppings on it that it used to. I don't mind paying almost $27.00 for a fully topped pizza. We were very disappointed and won't be returning. It seems, as happens in a lot of business; when they get to a 2nd generation: Things go downhill. Very Sad :( read more

The food was too much money, not a fan of the pizza I got. I hope others beg to differ

This is absolutely the best pizza in the Pittsburgh area....this who remember what Vincent's in Forest Hills used to taste like , this is that flavor without the cigarette ashes...very good people as well. For a different delight try their barbecue. You can't beat this pizza you will sop up the soup with the pizza "bones" read more

best pizza ever.that's it,that's the review. i haven't tried anything else but excited to try the bbq.