Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Coney I-Lander

    3.3 (47 reviews)
    InexpensiveHot Dogs
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Coney I-Lander Takeout or Delivery

    Coney I-Lander Photos

    Business Info

    CONEY I-LANDER ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Coney I-Lander

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    the front of the building
    Josh H.

    All reviews are correct! Love it or hate it, it's a chili dog. If you want to feel amazing, eat a light lunch, have a light salad with some bubbly water. If you want to go into a food coma and sleep it off for and few hours in your bed binge watching Netflix....just order 8 or 9 of these with everything on them. Last time I went here there was a miscommunication or hiccup in the assembly line . Be it my stutter when ordering or a lack of quality control and inspection before receiving my order, my dogs were cheese-less. No matter what happens I'm convinced I'll never stop eating here, it's a guilty pleasure, maybe a few degrees above Taco Bell but I don't care. Coneys are a gift from God.

    two hot dogs with mustard
    Ray N.

    The Tulsa metro has a TON of Coney I-Lander locations and this is one we get to enjoy in Broken Arrow. Upon entering to dine I was surprised at how clean this one was. Often times at a coney spot there is a 'welcoming' coat of grease on every surface you can see and a shine to match. Where the interior is basic, as it should be, it was CLEAN! The menu is limited also, as it should be which makes ordering simple. I always go with a cheese coney with onions and jalapenos. I also like a tamale with chile on the side too, because why not right? Overall very friendly service with a team of smiling faces behind the counter. Where I'm not a huge coney fan, if I get a hankering for one while in BA, I'll be coming back here.

    Regular Coney Small Regular 3-Way

    The lady behind the counter making food yelled at employees both on the clock and one trying to return from lunch. The food was a good value, but the chili was greasy and tasteless. Having seasoning and hot sauce on the table is a good choice.

    a table of food
    Jaime B.

    I really had high hopes, but I was unimpressed. Very greasy chili. Did not do great things to my stomach. Basic dine-in location. Should be good for anyone with a bullet proof stomach. Convenient location in BA off hwy 51. Excellent food presentation.

    Cheesy Coney (mustard, onion, chili, cheese)
    Liz T.

    Great Coneys! We got cheese coneys (mustard, onion, chili, and cheese). 3 of 'em, 2 chips, 2 small drinks. $10.00 even! Steal of a deal!! Pretty tasty, maybe a smidge heavy on the onions for my taste, but no complaints.

    3 cheese with everything. Don't forget the cayenne pepper!

    See all

    Photo of Jade G.
    41
    39
    11

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Jessica C.

    Jessica C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    We always love this place. Great coneys, great service, great prices. Will continue eating here as many times as we possibly can.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Jessica C.

    Jessica C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Coney I-Lander

    Review Highlights - Coney I-Lander

    First time I can and appreciated how clean it has been over other Coney Islanders I used to go to.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hot Dogs 681 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Shaky Jakes

    Shaky Jakes

    4.4(56 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    This is hands down one of the funnest and yummiest spots to find a meal and/or adult bevy in Broken…read moreArrow. A restaurant concept in an old church is amazing! They completely took over a 2 story area and made it something unique and interesting. There are essentially 2 restaurants in one here. During the day you get a menu from "The Bramble" which is breakfast and brunch type fair and at 3pm it switches to Shaky Jake's, which had more burgers, apps, wings etc. There's also a circle shaped full service bar in the middle of the building and seats all around. It already is a creative way to get folks in the door. The food though, always excellent!! I've yet to have had anything bad here, but would recommend the Philly cheesesteak egg rolls, any flavor of hot wing and the Philly burger. Seeing a trend here?

    My friends and I tried this for the first time and there was only one waitress so the service was a…read morebit slow, but it was still great. The food was wonderful and it was not their fault that they didn't have enough help. They were all decked out for the holidays. It was beautiful a waitress even volunteered to take our photos, which was super sweet. My burger was definitely a little dry and I did not need two patties, but that's how they all come. However, overall everything was good. I definitely wanna try other things on the menu. I appreciate they have daily specials. I tried the two dollar shrimp tacos and the shrimp was really good. Overall this is a really great place that I will go back to. It used to be a church and you can tell the space is big and beautiful and clean in the bathrooms were also nice.

    Photos
    Shaky Jakes - Christmas 2024

    Christmas 2024

    Shaky Jakes - Classic on gluten free bun with sweet potato wedges

    Classic on gluten free bun with sweet potato wedges

    Shaky Jakes

    See all

    Oh K-Dog - Avocado Egg Toast

    Oh K-Dog

    4.0(26 reviews)
    5.7 miEast Tulsa

    I first had a Korean corn dog when I was in Seattle Chinatown and now we have this option here in…read moreTulsa. I love that they have these incredible egg sandwiches as well as real deal Korean corn dogs. If you've never experienced a Korean corn dog it's very different than an American corn dog because you can get sweet potato or regular potato on the outside or you can just get the really crispy outside batter. then they have all these sauces or cinnamon sugar that you can sprinkle on your corn dog and it just makes it that much better. It's super affordable and a really great spot especially if you wanna try something different and yummy. Everything is made to order and doesn't take too long.

    My partner told me about this place & it came to mind when I was looking for something in the area…read more As many times as I looked up the menu, prepping myself for a moment like this, I wasn't ready as they're are so many options/ways the corndogs are served. I went with the classic, it gave me the idea of this spot & to try just about every option on the menu. The Classic was coated & fried to perfection. Light & crispy, made for dipping (you can get up to 3 cups for sauces). As I was waiting for the order to be ready, there were numerous condiments to choose from like chili, sriracha, garlic... I went with the sriracha & the chili. I enjoyed both sauces, I like to try chili sauces by the restaurant & theirs is the way I like it. The wait didn't take long at all, especially with me having a Mochinut to hold me over. I went with cinnamon sugar, which is something I'd usually go for anywhere to let me know how good to other flavors will be. All of the flavors caught my eye & there were plenty to choose from (like mango & blueberry to name a couple). Outside of those selections I made, there's another thing they're known for, they egg toast. The Teriyaki one is the one I might have to try first. The staff was nice. As if all that wasn't enough, they also have slushes.

    Photos
    Oh K-Dog
    Oh K-Dog - Avocado Egg Toast

    Avocado Egg Toast

    Oh K-Dog - Avocado Egg Toast

    See all

    Avocado Egg Toast

    Coney Island Original

    Coney Island Original

    4.4(24 reviews)
    6.4 mi
    $

    Rowdy is awesome! We've been eating here ever since Gus owned it. This is hands down the best coney…read moreplace in Oklahoma!!

    ATTENTION VETERANS!!!!! I AM A DISABLED VETERAN!!!! I WAS DISRESPECTED!!!! I WAS CURSED AT!!!! My…read morefirst visit I ordered two chili cheese coneys to go. When I got to the register to pay, I asked the lady working did they offer a military discount? She said no! I then presented her with my 100% DISABLED VETERANS TAX EXEMPTION CARD and asked her to take off the taxes. She got an attitude and said we don't do that! I explained it was mandatory. She angrily rang me up for my food. I took my food and left. I did not notice til I was already driving off she infact did not take the taxes off the receipt. So, today I was shopping near by and decided to give them another chance. I ordered the same two chili cheese coneys. When I got to the register it was the same lady. I presented her with my tax exemption card and asked that she make sure she take off the taxes, whereas the last time she did not. She said I didn't have to be rude. She then smarted off and said if you gave it to me last time she did remove the taxes. I said she surely did not. She then told me to STOP B.TCHING ABOUT IT. I asked the owner who was cooking did he hear what she said to me? He said it was my fault for talking about it and I could take my food and leave. I asked, so that's how you talk to VETERANS? He said he didn't care that I was a VETERAN. I asked him to refund my money. I said I couldn't believe their behavior and left. Its safe to say that's why there are never any customers inside!

    Photos
    Coney Island Original
    Coney Island Original - Cheese Coney, Pint of Chili

    Cheese Coney, Pint of Chili

    Coney Island Original - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Coney I-Lander - hotdog - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...