I'd never been to the commodore theatre before and I was excited to go with a friend. There was a lot to love and a lot to...not.
First impressions are fleeting and indelible. You only get one chance. The Commodore started off strong, with a genial older gent (I'm sorry I cannot remember your name) taking the money for tickets ($12 for an adult by plastic, $11 if you pony up cold hard cash). You even get a little paper ticket and are directed to stand by a beautiful old wooden...lectern? The ticket taker stands behind it and rips your ticket like in the days of yore before escorting you to your seats. The ticket seller was helpful in picking a perfect seat and was quite kind. The not so great part was being behind a larger party and waiting in a room that is very, very hot in summer without a lick of air flow (you go inside to purchase the tickets, but stand between the outside set of doors and the doors to the lobby, which does have ac.)
The ambiance of the place is exceptional. The seats and tables are not packed in like sardines, with generous paths to allow traffic. The table itself was a two seater and small, but between the lamp on the table and its decently sized marble base and the phone on the table - a honkin' multiline beast, that took up a good chunk of the 'real estate' so to speak, the tabletop was only just adequate.
Our escort, usher?, upon hearing it was our first time, gave very brief instructions. Basically, get your food order in before 7pm by dialing zero on the phone, after 7pm they only take refills on iced tea and water. We called in our order- I asked for an extra marinara with my mozzarella sticks and to have ketchup and a side of bbq for my (what boils down to) chicken tenders and fries. I also initially ordered a pitcher of soda (60 Oz for 10.50). When the pitcher arrived, it had ice in it - which, for me, is a bit of a no-no, I want ice in my glass, not melting into the pitcher. However, upon pouring a cup and trying it, I realized it was flat - completely and unpleasantly so. I was able to flag down a staff member and explain, could I please just get a glass of ice water and a pitcher of water? I would be happy to pay for both (they do charge a small fee of 40cents for ice water, free refills) He was nice and whisked it away. However, when he came back, it was with a single glass, saying I could call for refills. I had clearly seen another table with a carafe of water on it, not just glasses, so I'm not sure why they wouldn't give me the pitcher I asked for specifically (or a carafe, like the other table had). At that point, the movie had started, so I wasn't trying to have a long conversation and bother any other diners.
The reason that water is so important is because of a confluence of events that made me super thirsty- my normal gym was unbearable due to construction so I worked out at a friend's gym - small, hot and no airflow. I had just enough time to shower and head out with her to the commodore after. Between how thirsty I was already, being on a medication that also increases thirst and eating salty foods, I spent most of my time there super thirsty. The phone was placed in such a way I had to have my friend punch zero whenever I wanted to (try) to get another glass of water. I called for multiple refills, including one they clearly forgot (and I mean for a good 15-20 minutes). I finally stopped calling, because it was such a pain and the one time I flagged down a staff member that was already on the floor and was told 'to call' before they turned and left immediately, I decided it was better to deal with being uncomfortable and thirsty than try to get another glass.
They serve what seems to be standard frozen fare you fry/reheat and put together. Nothing the pair of us had was great, nor bad, it was just...meh. my extra marinara also came out with her sandwich, not with my mozzarella sticks, even though it was specified on my check, not hers. I ordered the brownie cake that came with a scoop of ice cream, like everything else it was...dazzingly....ok. not horrid, not great.
Gratuity is included in your bill, and they do not do tipping. I'm not sure if that's why the majority of staff seemed to be doing the bare minimum or if they were having an off night.
My friend and I both agree the atmosphere is way better at the Commodore than say, Cinema Cafe, but Cinema Cafe manages to have better food and better service.
Would we go back? Yes, probably at some point. However, we won't eat there again, and I will make sure I am well hydrated before I show up so I'm not desperate for water.
They do have a nice bathroom setup with an anteroom that has couches in case you're waiting for a friend to use the loo or need a moment out of the way.
Overall, I think this is a great place to catch a show every now and again. Definitely worth at least one showing to say you've been and to admire the history. read more