This was my first time coming to this restaurant. We didn't realize is was The night of Valentine's Day but we were still seated quickly! Our food took a while to show up BUT our server, Matthew was amazing! He made sure we got our appetizers and bread to hold us off until our main entrees showed. He very friendly and personable, even with all of the chaos going on. Once we got our food we were very pleased. It tasted AMAZING and the steaks were cooked exactly how we had requested. With the good food and amazing service by Matt, I'm not even upset that we had to wait. Well worth it! read more

Got my order WRONG After I literally said 400 timesb give me a Coke, not Sprite. It took 3 hours for them two to get us rolls. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - I've wanted Coke, not Sprite. - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

Food was good, our server has improved greatly since he was hired and as always we like the restaurant!

It's nice to have a steak supper and not have to pay a lot. Food was good. Waitress was friendly. Nice place for a family.

Excellent food, good prices and nice ambiance and atmosphere. Our food came just as ordered. Our server was Lana and she was amazing! She made sure that we had everything we needed and made sure that our drinks never went dry. I highly recommend this establishment. Make sure you ask for Lana for your server! read more

For a number of years, the service and food at this Colton's was sub-par. Happy to report that it has recovered. 3 recent visits have all been great - great service and food. Love the Del Rio Ribeye! read more

First time here and it has a comfortable feel and reminds me of Texas Roadhouse.The staff is friendly and helpful and service was great. They are a family friendly establishment and they do serve alcohol. The menu is large and there is bound to be something for everyone, the rolls are melt in your mouth delicious and plentiful. I had the Coltons Chicken and it was a wonderful choice, juicy chicken breast smothered with mushrooms, bacon and cheese and a side of smashed potatoes.Definitely worth a visit !! read more

See all

I'm not normally a chain restaurant person, but this place is fabulous! We've come here a few times now, and every time we've come here the service has been great, the restaurant has been clean and the food has been wonderful. This is definitely one of our go to date night spots now when we're in west plains! read more

My family stopped here after visiting my dad at the cemetery. I'm not even sure where to start. The hostess was a nervous wreck at 2pm. Acted like she'd never done this in her life but she didn't have anyone tailing her like she was new, so I assume she wasn't. Our waitress was the best part of the experience. She was attentive, all while dealing with a table with an elderly couple who seemed to be giving her a VERY hard time. She was great. The food was eh. Okra was tossed in a small amount of batter which was made of approximately 85% SALT. It was so salty I, my mother, sister and husband couldn't eat it. I'm pregnant and didn't want to overload my system with THAT much salt. It immediately made your mouth dry. The chicken was overcooked and ALSO salted with the same amount of salt the okra had! Not palatable. The mashed potatoes were just fine as were the rolls, though they were a little dry. Not too bad though. Overall the best thing about this experience was our waitress, so you got that right. Sad overall. read more

Lunch of country fried steak today was very good. The service was quick, cordial & professional. We chose the after lunch time making for a nice peaceful lunch all around. read more

It was perfect tonight and Megan R was our server. No complaints. We had a Ny Strip and sirloin. Cook did an excellent job.

We had great service and our food was superb. The restaurant was clean and the music and atmosphere was very friendly and inviting!

We are passing through on our way to Kansas and stopped overnight in west plains and decided to try Colton's. It is very reminiscent of one of our favorite now gone restaurant, Logan's. The food and restaurant were just fantastic. Our server, Megan was great! She was extremely attentive, never let my sweet tea get low and constantly checking on us without being overbearing. We really liked our appetizer which was the queso dip. For my entree, I had the New York strip steak, it was a little fatty but still very good, the smashed potatoes was just yummy and the corn cobs were very good. It was all hot and never really seemed to cool down which was great! My partner had a salad with steak tips and he said it was very good. The ambience of the restaurant was nice and cozy, I loved looking at all the decor and it was clean and kept up. I wish we had a Colton's back home. read more

Colton's does have a decent atmosphere and service. Their food quality has gone down a little and that's from someone who used to frequently eat there as teen but now. read more

Customer service is not that great there was mouse I seen under a table. there was hair in my Alfredo. The table wasn't clean when I was seated. read more

This was to be a special Easter Lunch! Got there at 11:30 am, not completely packed yet. Sat right away. Took a few minutes to get water and we ordered out food. 1/2 hour later we got our rolls then 1/2 hr later we got our salad. Then maybe 45 minutes we received our meal. My wife ordered sirloin steak tips which were terrible! My full order of ribs were horrible to eat with all the fat! I brought more than a 1/2 rack home and had to through away.., fat. I don't know who the cook was but they should be held accountable for serving this terrible meal! We have had good racks there before but I guess that haste becomes waist! Please if you know your going to be busy then be ready for it! Truly fast food would have been better than what we were served. read more

Emma was our waitress. She was charming and helpful with our questions about the menu. We had the wedge salad, which was to die for, smothered chicken and the pork chop. The food came out hot and delicious. Emma worked hard to please everyone she served. I enjoyed our experience at Colton's. read more

Had a late lunch today feb 3. Best meal I've had out in some time. Good service, smoked sirloin and sides were perfect, including a very crisp salad. read more

I've eaten a number of times at Colton's. I give it five stars. The food is consistently very good. So is the service. Atmosphere is pleasant and the price is reasonable. read more

The food here was good but there were mice and the droppings of said mice in the dining area.

After traveling for hours without many choices on 63, we came to West Plains and decided to stop at Coltons. We were not disappointed. The staff was friendly, the food came fast and hot. We had two pastas, the Del Rio steak with shrimp, and cheesy fries. The best cheesy fries we've ever had anywhere! Steak was cooked perfect and pasta was fantastic. Something for everyone. Highly recommend! No photo of steak - it was covered with onion stings at first, then it was all eaten. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Alfredo Pasta - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

See all

Always a great meal and a good time! Cute country atmosphere. Friendly staff. I had the filet. So tender and flavorful. Best filet ever! Dinner salads are really good. Baked potato perfect. And the peanuts are always appreciated. Oh and we got the onion Tanglers. I don't eat onions, but the rest of the group enjoyed them. read more

The service was excellent. I had chicken fried chicken and it was as good as I have ever eaten. I'd stop again when traveling through West Plains. read more

Took the wife to Colton's for a nice steak dinner this evening, ordered an onion blossom and fried pickles which were good. My wife ordered the New York strip and i ordered the 16 oz ribeye. Both steaks were literally about 70% fat! Im not sure who does quality control but they are lacking in experience! I think the best thing for me and/or anyone else to do is buy and grill our own steaks. I wont be going to Colton's west plains again for a long long time! Needless to say, I am truly disappointed. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - J.t.'s Onion Blossom Fried Pickles Ribeye* New York Strip* - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

We ate lunch at Coltons today & 1/2 way thru lunch ( 6oz sirloin & salad), my gut started making weird noises, my friend couldn't eat all of his meal (chicken fried steak & fries). After sitting on 4 different thrones we made it home for a dose of baking soda & water then back to our personal thrones. Oh my body made noises like I never heard before:( read more

It's Colton's. Very predictable menu. Food is okay. Bourbon bacon salmon was the recommended dish. It's the waiters absolute favorite, he said. I highly doubt this young man eats much salmon but it was a good sales pitch. Lol It was ok for a frozen piece of fish but way to sweet for my liking. The broccoli was steamed. Nothing really to boast about this evening. Have a Yelptastic night read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - House Salad blue moon and rolls - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

See all

Decorated as an Old West Town, it was quite attractive as you walk in. Our party of 5 was seated very quickly and served by a fairly attentive wait staff. The country music in the background was not quite loud enough to be enjoyed, but too loud for normal conversation without raising your voice. The free bucket of roasted in the shell peanuts helped pass the time while waiting for our food. Decent Beef and Pork. One in our party ordered a Rib-eye and was delivered what looked more like a Sirloin. After a short visit with the manager, it was replaced. The Oriental Salad was a basic house salad (Iceberg Lettuce, Cheese, and Tomatoes) with a few Mandarin Orange sections, a few Sliced Almonds, and some crumbled Grilled Salmon, that was horribly over cooked. Based on previous experience elsewhere, I suspect that is a mid-west thing and not so much a fault of the restaurant. While part of our meal was graciously comped as a result of our concerns raised with management, the total for our meal (before adjustments) was rather high and I truly do not feel as I got the value for the money spent. Yes, I might eat here again, but honestly there is better, cheaper, elsewhere nearby. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

Went to dine here on a Sunday afternoon. The place wasn't very busy but there were a lot of people waiting to be seated at tables for some reason. After about 20 minutes, one from our party asked the hostess why we couldn't be seated in one of the many empty tables. He was told that section was closed. We were finally seated after a 30 minute wait. I ordered the Santa Fe Chicken with a caesar salad. The salads we all ordered were swimming in dressing, inedible. Our food sat in the pass for 10 minutes before being delivered to the table so of course the entrees were cold. There was nothing "Santa Fe" about this chicken. It was a grilled chicken breast covered in tomatoes, onions, bell peppers, and congealed cheddar cheese. I've never dined at a Colton's but have seen the billboards for years and was always curious. This was a low rent steak house, I for sure won't be returning. My husband says it was the most horrific and unpleasant experience in his life. His steak was ordered medium rare but it was rare and cold. The fat wasn't rendered whatsoever. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Disgusting caesar swimming in dressing. - Steakhouses Near Me - West Plains, Missouri

Colton's steakhouse produces a solid steak dinner for a very reasonable price. The restaurant is family-friendly and low cost considering the establishment offers several courses. The free bread is appetizing; however, the free peanuts are a perfect fit for low-carb seeking patrons. The house special is the strip steak, and it does not disappoint. I'm unable to speak to the desserts, given the generous portion size of my entree and my proximity to the peanut bowl. Stop in for a special event or a Tuesday night, this place is great. read more

The Burger King down the road has juicier burgers than this place, ordered a burger to only find a dried up hockey puck between buns. One star is for the fries, the other is for the customer service, though it seems they go through staff quite frequently. read more

I just visited the West Plains, Mo. Colton's..The food was good, but my issue is when I asked for a veteran's discount they said of course. I was insulted to find out that the discount was only 1 dollar on a 40 dollar bill. That was very insulting and disrespective to me. I would rather of been told that there is no discount for veterans. That's like leaving a penny tip... Shame on YOU! read more

Verry good food.Every time I go there I'm all ways happy with the food and service.Ill be back to Coltons every chance I get thank you.

Came here with friends and family for dinner and enjoyed the company. The location is convenient, the service was average, food was typical of a local restaurant. Generally when you get seated at this location your hostess or server brings you a bucket of peanuts and rolls. After we ordered our beverages we asked for the peanuts. I will also add if you order an alcoholic beverage be prepared to wait awhile for it. Not sure why but we did. As was the case with the appetizer., again not sure why. We all ordered rib eye steaks and everyone's steaks were not prepared as ordered. I'm not sure if we will be back anytime soon. read more

Our steak orders be it a ribeye, filet mignon or top sirloin are most always under cooked. Someone needs to show the cook/s the difference between medium rare and medium. read more

I do not recommend anyone eating here. They have both roaches and mice in the kitchen and I even saw a roach crawling on the wall in the dinning room. I'd give it no stars if I could! And what's really sad is they used to be one of my favorite restaurants. read more

This is my favorite place to eat at when I am in West Plains! Today when I came through they had a free petting zoo as well as kids eat free after 4 on Sunday's! I love that this gives families a special way to spend their Sunday afternoons together as a family. I almost always order trail potatoes because I can't get enough of them! So good! read more

In town for business and this place was recommended by another person in our business. Atmosphere was good. Always enjoy the peanuts in the shell on the table so you can munch while waiting on the real food. There seemed to be a utensil shortage on this slow week night. Our salads sat in front of us for a while before we got a napkin and fork. I noticed over the course of the evening that two of the waitress had friends or family dining....and they were distracted by visiting with them for long periods of time and neglected their tables. The Loaded Baked Potato soup was white gravy, with a few chunks of potato, and a little topping of cheese & onion. Yuck! I had one bit and stopped. The waitress noticed that I didn't eat it and offered to bring the French onion soup, but did not offer to take anything off the bill. She admitted that the base is gravy. Who wants to eat gravy with a spoon? The peanuts and rolls were essentially my meal tonight. The steak ordered by my spouse was good. The baked potato was not good enough to finish. We would probably eat here again after going through the rounds of places in this little town. But I wouldn't repeat otherwise. read more

Colton's would be better if the staff would up their game. On a recent visit: -It's noisy, which means wait staff should not stand at the head of the table and expect customers to shout their orders from the other end. - Silverware should be on the table when people are seated, not delivered after the appetizer is served. - Not related to service, but that horrid potato "soup" made from gravy should be shoved up someone's *ss at corporate. There aren't a lot of choices in West Plains, but there's no point in not delivering a better customer experience. The staff would probably get better tips. read more

Okay. Kind of old school in terms of looks and type of service. Seemed like heavy food with too much sauce. The tables and flat ware did not seem particularly clean. It was fine in a pinch since I didn't know the area but I probably would not go back. read more

The service was quite good and was the Sprite. Everything else was below average at best. The chicken fried steak was more akin to peppered cardboard with minimal gravy. The plain pertained were decent. read more