I was gonna give it 4... maybe 5 stars. But the Veterans Day event and then subsequent sub-par service made me drop it. First time, great steak and service. This time, great steak and that's it. The Veterans event, spelled wrong. Not clearly stated, so no discount. Slowest service anywhere on a Monday. Spelled Veteran wrong. Didn't even have a manager come out and offer maybe something. It happened to multiple tables. Forgot my salad. Forgot my salad dressing. Mac n cheese was flavorless. Put a slice of fat in a steak salad. Try harder. And don't have a discount if you don't advertise it well and end up angering a customer. Probably won't go back because TX roadhouse might be better. Although TX roadhouse burns well done steaks. Order medium well. Slow service. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Spelled wrong?!? - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

Food is consistently delicious, we always leave full and happy. Best place for a steak in Conway for the best price, and they have our favorite ranch dressing and rolls. read more

Enjoyed a delicious Hawaiian ribeye, loaded baked potato and side salad. The steak was cooked perfectly and was so flavorful. Service was great, and our drinks were kept full! read more

Well, the ribeye just wasn't good. It was tough , dry and not worth $25 +. I ordered it medium, and it came out as medium well on edge and well done for most of it ? No pink whatsoever except 1 or 2 bites on edge of meat. Usually, I enjoy the fried chicken salad , or shrimp when I frequent here, but was not rewarded tonight with trying the Steak. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

Very consistent food always tastes great every time I visit im always pleased with my food choice. Service is second to none , waiters are Great and then take care of your every need. The atmosphere is what you expect it to be relaxed and casual. read more

My experience here has varied from good to awful, most recently it's been on the awful side. Most recent visit... the meals took an extra long time to arrive and when they did my steak (ordered medium well) was very very rare, and the other meals were cold. My guess is they forgot to cook my steak with the other meals, then rushed it while the other meals sat around. The waiter came over and took my steak back while my dinnermates decided to tough it out and pick at their cold food. By the time my meal came back, they had given up, and were finished eating. I want my local restaurants to succeed, but this was a waste of money. Nobody enjoyed themselves. Bah. read more

Came in got appetizers pretty fast , food took a whole hour to get to us , i got the blackened salmon it came out ice cold , i have no clue how long it was sitting in the window , the fry's were the only good part about the plate. I am usually not one to complain, but this experience most definitely earned its one star. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - a plate of food - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

Let's start with this, it was dead on a Thursday evening. We got seated around other four tables with guests. One waitress, that was dressed like a Emo-Goth that is stuck in 1999. Dress appropriately for work. Now let's talk about service. Not that great. With only four tables of guest she never checked on us to see how the food was, only to give the check. The food was cold, not great at all. My wife had a sirloin that was so small, with fried shrimp that was over cooked. The smoked sirloin had was dry, I did ask for it rare but realizing you can't smoke something in 15 minutes. With my side of fried okra, I also got fried green beans. Come on clean out your fri baskets. Lazy people. Place is a joke, atmosphere is like being back in the 80's with decor. And please clean your floors. There were croutons under our table that I stepped on, and on the windows. It will be a long shot if we ever decided to go back there again. You're better off waiting the hour at Texas road house for great food and service. read more

My husband and I met with our son and daughter- in- law for lunch. It was the first time any of us had been to Coltons. Our server Stacie was awesome really added to our experience! We all enjoyed our food (there was so much of it) and will definitely return. read more

Wow - just had lunch here and super waitress Stacy is the bomb diggity! Seated us, waited on us and others and was super friendly. Colton's - you need to hold on to her! Other restaurant managers in town - you should try to steal her! May the best manager win. The food was excellent as well. read more

Service was great and food was delicious. They made sure me and my service dog were seated I had my order and was satisfied.

I love Colton's food but not their rolls. They used to be so good but they don't rise them properly any more so they're heavy and gummy now. Take my advice, ask for Texas toast or bring your own bread. read more

I eat there about every two weeks. Always been excellent experience. Fresh food, great service. Absolutely love their salads. Have tried many items. read more

The only thing we enjoyed here was the server. Everything else awful !l. Steaks were tough and overcooked ! Server was wonderful !

The food was absolutely delicious. Our sever Emmeline was fabulous, on top of our order, our drinks and just a precious person. We are from Louisiana passing through to Missouri and if we ever come this way again we will definitely be eating here. The restaurant and bathrooms are very clean. Definitely recommend! read more

Terrific food, great service, nice clean restrooms with complimentary mouthwash - first time I had ever seen that in a restaurant. This is one of our favorite places to eat when we are in the area. read more

We were so disappointed tonight at Colton's. Our waiter was amazing! He brought out our favorite rolls. Ya'll they were like hockey pucks. I as him nicely if we could have rolls a little less hard. He was so nice, he preceded to tell us all of the rolls were like that. He apologized letting us know he has mentioned to the baker maybe he needed to turn the heat down a little. We told him we didn't need the rolls anyway. Husband ordered the sirloin salad, cooked to perfection. I ordered beef tenderloins, salad and sweet potato. Cooked to perfection but it was so salty it burned my mouth. I thought it was just me, hubby took a bite and he admitted it was way to salty. I hated to tell our sweet waiter but I did. Of course he apologized again. Told him no problem, ask if he could just bring me another side salad. He told the Manager, she comped us 7.00 for the steak. Bottom line I paid 14.00 for a sweet potato and 2 side salads. The Waiter kept apologizing, not his fault! I really felt sorry for the him. I tipped as usual and also gave him a tip. read more

Someone needs to put Colton's out of its misery. They took our order. She then went to a neighboring table. She took their order. Half an hour later she comes out with their order. Ours is still in the kitchen. We asked to leave after an hour of waiting and the worst service I have ever experienced. I don't know what possessed me to give them another chance after the last awful visit. read more

On my way through the area I ate here for lunch. The restaurant was only moderately busy. The service was good. The food was average. I had the steak and it was average. It was a little pricey for what it was. read more

The food was great. Service was awesome. And no wait at 7pm. Nice steakhouse ambiance. I highly recommend it.

Awful experience. Most Colton's are standard fare and a good place to stop if nothing else is available. But not this Colton's. I wish I could figure out how to post pictures. Without a thousand words...burned New York strip shoe-leather. Rubber on the cobb that was inedible. Stringy sweet potato. Yikes! read more

Food was ok, but our waitress Dymond really didn't melt our butter. She literally threw food and drinks on the table. Didn't ask how things were once. Yes it was busy, but she maybe the worst waitress we have had since Rome Italy. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Chicken fried gristle - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

See all

In and sitting down in 2 minutes. Ordered after 4 minutes. Food arrived in 10 minutes. We had a rib eye and filet. Very good. Walking out the door with dinner for tomorrow after 40 minutes. We did eat a few peanuts. read more

The food was subpar at best. The ribeye I ordered was tough and full of gristle, to the point it was difficult to cut. The sides weren't much better. I won't be back. read more

This year I had to go on a trip, on the way back we stopped here. This was my first time and it was amazing, customer service was great "Stefanie" was are waitress. One of the best waitresses I have ever been helped by. Thank You stefanie for making sure I had a great meal and a good rest of my day. The food was great and I would definitely recommend!! read more

Service was very bad. The place was almost empty. They set a mother and her 3 kids right next to us. Very loud. They put a cheap ketchup in the brand name bottles. The server denied it. We ate at a different Colton's and the ketchup was the same brand and tasted great. They lied. We have eaten at 3 different Colton's and this one was the only one that I didn't like. Never again. read more

I've always really liked Coltons and never had an issue anytime I've gone there. Typical American food with a decent variety to select from. They bring around fresh rolls and butter while you wait so you don't actually need an appetizer, but they have some of the BEST cheese fries in town so we can never resist ordering some when we go. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Sirloin and sweet potato fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

See all

Food was just ok. Service was fine. Won't be back unfortunately

medium is nice. service was better than the food. ok is best i can say. My wife was happy with the chicken and vegetables.

Service was exceptional, the staff was very kind and always cheerful, they also take care of your dining needs and answer any questions you may have quickly, confidently, and accurately. The food is cooked and seasoned to perfection, and nothing was out of taste. Every flavor blended together seamlessly and you taste almost everything they put into the food. This Colton's Steak House is at the top of my dining list. When someone says "Let eat out," I say "Colton's Steak House" read more

I have always enjoyed dining at coltons. They staff is always quick and professional. I absolutely love the cheese fries and the southwest chipolte tips. Restaurant is always clean now that you can't throw peanut shells on the floor (bummer) kids were not happy about putting them in the bucket! read more

Busy atmosphere and good food. Went with a large group and in spite of that, service was timely and efficient. The Montana burger was great! The whole throwing the peanuts on the floor has never been a big thrill of mine but still was a pleasant experience and I would definitely go back... read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Montana Burger - Steakhouses Near Me - Conway, Arkansas

They don't have beer or any alcohol. Just FYI was little disappointed, after a long work day and couldn't get a cold one.

A great meal from start to finish. The appetizer Tumbleweed is delicious! The dipping sauce that comes with it is perfectly seasoned. Salads are plenty big, and have a lot of toppings. Try the house dressing. It's not a ranch-style dressing, it's even better! Entrees seem to have something for everyone. The Hawaiian Ribeye, Sirloin Tips, Grilled Shrimp, Pork Chops, and even the entree salads are all wonderful! I'm normally not a rib fan, but I love the ribs at Colton's. And the Montana burger is top-notch. Try the Bread Pudding with Whiskey sauce for dessert...you won't be disappointed! read more

We are traveling cross country and have eaten at different establishments and we came across Colton's Steakhouse. We were drawn to it because one of our son's name is Colton. We found the food delicious; the decor was fun and our waitress, Tottania excellent. Tottania was happy, friendly and knowledgable. Thank you for a good restaurant experience. read more

See all

Terrible service and the steak wasn't much better. I had to ask the server to bring me my salad because she forgot. The restaurant wasn't busy. The ribeye was tough and of low grade. Waited for about a half hour for the food to arrive. Didn't feel bad because no one else around me got their food either. At the end, the server cheerfully said "See you next time!". Unlikely. read more

We had 4 in our party and noticed the board out front displaying their specials had the 9oz sirloin with 2 sides for $9.99. Two of our party ordered this and with the exception of them forgetting to bring out 1 side it was good and the steak was cooked good. When we each got our bill they had charged us full price $13.29 for the special. We brought it to our waitresses attention to correct and the manager said the price written on the board was incorrect and the price was $13.29. This was the SAME price in the menu so how can it be the special??? They wouldn't budge off the price so we will not be a repeat customer here or any Colton's location. read more

The service was terrible here. We had a group of 7, including a toddler and an infant. Our side orders were messed up and to top it off, both my husband and father in law ordered ribeye steaks but when they arrived, the steaks were very obviously sirloin steaks exactly like my sirloin that I ordered. When we said something to the waiter, he argued and we asked for the manager. The waiter left and brought back the manager and the cook, who both argued with my father in law (who used to work in a butcher shop cutting steaks and eats rib eye on a regular basis) that the steaks were definitely ribeyes. Needless to say, my father in law ended up paying ribeye price for two sirloin steaks an all corporate did was give him a $15 gift card. read more

Not sure why my previous review was "filtered," maybe because it was negative? Anyway, I'm writing another review since apparently my "filtered" review isn't factored into the restaurant's star rating. VERY rude, unprofessional waitstaff here. As for the food, both baskets of rolls our waiter brought out were small, burned, and hard and the soda was watered down. The steak was below average and there was more fat on it than I usually get in a steakhouse. There are much better steakhouses in Conway! read more

No matter how good the food is, when both restrooms are dirty and smell worse than an outhouse the restaurant becomes unappetizing. Such was the case today. read more