A place like this sets an expectation before you even sit down. Between the name and the way it presents itself, you expect a certain level of care. We came in for breakfast, missed the cutoff, and ended up ordering lunch instead. That shift ended up defining the experience. **FOOD** At the table, we had three different sandwiches, and each one had its own issues, but they all pointed in the same direction. I ordered the Handcrafted King Burger. The name suggests something made in-house, or at least something with a bit of character. What came out looked like a prefab patty. Perfectly round, evenly flat, with the kind of surface you usually see from a frozen product. Flavor was fine, but it didn't match what you expect from a brisket burger. The toppings were standard, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, but the lettuce portion was skimpy and the tomato was sliced so thick it threw the balance off. I ended up cutting it down myself just to make it easier to eat. The fries were fine. Nothing wrong, just nothing memorable. My wife ordered the French dip. It came out dry, which is the one thing that sandwich really can't afford. It didn't seem like it had been dipped at all before serving, and the meat leaned overcooked. The au jus on the side helped once we started using it, but by then you're correcting something that should have been handled in the kitchen. We ended up swapping meals, which usually says enough. My mom went with the BLT, and that was the most disappointing of the three. The bacon was overcooked to the point where it broke down into small pieces instead of giving any real texture. It ate more like bacon crumbles than strips. The tomato had the same issue as mine, cut too thick, and needed to be adjusted at the table. She did like the house chips. Those were crisp, not oily, and easily the most complete item that came out. Across multiple plates, the Swiss cheese stood out, and not in a good way. It had the look and texture of a lower-end processed slice rather than something you'd expect from a deli. It showed up more than once, which made it feel like a standard shortcut rather than a choice. **SERVICE** Service was steady. Our waitress stayed on top of refills and checked in without hovering. Orders were taken correctly, food came out in a reasonable time, and nothing got missed. **AMBIENCE** The space is clean and organized, and it's clear they take care of it. It's a little smaller than it looks online, but it works. Nothing feels out of place, and it's comfortable enough to sit and eat without distraction. **CLOSING** This feels like a place that might do one part of the menu better than another. Based on this visit, lunch didn't hold up. Too many small things were off across multiple plates, and it adds up. We'll likely come back and try breakfast, but there's not much here that would bring us back for lunch. **RATINGS** Food: ** Service: **** Ambiance: **** Overall: *** Personal Disclaimer: I value small, independent restaurants and want them to succeed. This review reflects a single visit and may not represent every experience. EVERY RESTAURANT IS WORTH TRYING FOR YOURSELF. Go, see what you get, and be honest in how you evaluate it. I've worked as an executive chef, restaurant manager, and owner. I tend to hold places to a higher standard. Execution matters. Freshness matters. Effort shows. Cutting corners usually does too. read more

The food is good. Breakfast is pretty much like a diner experience. The biscuits are excellent however I do wish they expanded the breakfast menu. Dinner was above average however nothing to write home or say this place is a must try. read more

Good food and very friendly hosts. It's the only restaurant we drive near until we get to Charlottesville

Holy smokes. Why I haven't eaten here for dinner before, I'm not sure. I already knew their breakfast was awesome, and I should've known their dinner would be equally as amazing. I ordered our food to go- twin pork chops, mac and cheese and green beans..and also- hamburger steak and gravy with mashed potatoes and green beans (which I didn't catch a photo of before it was completely consumed by my other half..lol). The pork chops were perfectly seasoned, no hot sauce needed, and the mac was well salted, no need for additional S&P. His meal was also tasty, being as he went to town on it the second I walked in the door..haha When I need a good comfort food meal, this will be my go to from now on. I cannot recommend this place ENOUGH! 10/10. read more

Colonial Restaurant - Twin pork chops, mac and cheese, green beans - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

This is a real nice country breakfast place. It is very welcoming and warm setting. Plenty of parking. Once inside, I was very pleased with the setting, it was cozy and that "grandmas home kitchen" feel. There is a bar inside and appeared to be fully stocked of any and everything. I was greeted promptly and seated. It was just me so I decided to just sit at the bar and not take up a table that could be occupied by 4, they had a array of booths and tables to accommodate 4 or more folks. Once seated at the bar I was greeted by a super nice friendly waitress. I decided to order an omelette, toast. It was super fresh, hot, and tasty! Highly recommend stopping here for a good ol' fashion breakfast!!!! read more

The food was great, the people were friendly (even though they knew I wasn't a local), and very accommodating. I delivered to a business near hear and had to try it. I am very pleased I did! The pricing is reasonable and the portions we appreciate. I'll be back if I am ever in town again! Just had their apple pie ( made here!), excellent! I have to add: Tina was my server, she was efficient, always there right when I needed something with hovering. True professional! read more

Had breakfast here today early Sunday. Seated in a nice big deep booth. Coffee an sweet tea we're both very good. Western omelet was delicious, plenty of cheese an peppers. The potatos that came as a side should be a main really, there loaded with bacon an amazing. Wife's bacon an eggs she shared with baby we're perfect, good biscuits. The pancakes themselves we had without any syrup they were so good. We plan to come back asap. read more

Yum! Excellent catfish, veggies, and coffee! A real down home meal! Good music, famous artwork, and a comfortable atmosphere. Great for both, out-of-towners like me, and locals! And the strawberry shortcake amazing!!! read more

Colonial Restaurant - Fried catfish, okra, green beans, and sliced tomato. - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

See all

We were visiting Virginia for the weekend and stopped by this restaurant late Sunday morning/afternoon. It was pretty busy, but they got us seated right away (4 top) since it is such a large restaurant with lots of tables. The only complaint I have about the food is that we had some bad cucumbers in our salad, but other than that everything was good. No complaints about the service. This place is pretty average, nothing really stood out to me other than the eye catching/intriguing look of the place when you drive by which is what made us stop. I would go back to this restaurant if I was in the area, but it wouldn't be on my list of places I have to go if I came back. read more

See all

My family and I have breakfast every other weekend (sometimes every weekend) here, and we love it! Mrs. Pat and Mrs. Sheila makes us feel welcome and at home! The food is top-notch every visit and the atmosphere is peaceful! Thank you, Mrs. Keatts and family! - DesignzByDavis Photography & Family read more

See all

Loveeeeeee! This place is great! Right off the main road, & most definitely worth a stop!!! The decor is too fun, it's nice & clean,& the meals are very affordable. I got the chicken fried steak, mashed potatoes, & rice pudding.. all for $13! & you can get a dessert as a side?! Oh yeah!!! I will say though I wasn't impressed with the mashed potatoes, I tried a bite of the macaroni & it's way better though. Also the service was really fast. So all in all you gotta check it out if you're nearby. read more

See all

The food....(11/10) HOLY CRAP THIS IS HEAVENLY FOOD. The service...(9/10) The waitress was very nice and food came out shockingly fast. Ambiance/vibe...(8/10) I liked the many televisions but it's just a normal country bar setting. Final rating... 9.5/10 read more

Colonial Restaurant - Mac and cheese, deep fried catfish, fried okra, deep-fried pickles - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

See all

Food and service were excellent. I had the chicken tenders and really enjoyed them. Not over cooked and we're very juicy. My wife had the fish & chips and raved about how good they were. Good home cooked food. If you're in the area, it's a must to stop in!! read more

Colonial Restaurant - Fish & Chips - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

See all

The service was quick, polite and the food prepared well. Nice western paintings and very well maintained interior. We noticed it is popular with work crews and locals, which is probably owing to consistent good and hearty food served quickly in a friendly environment. read more

Anytime I venture back home (I live in the Washington DC area, but Campbell County is where I grew up) I always have to come here at least once... Stopped here for dinner Friday night (Sept 15) while visiting family this weekend around 6:30 Pm. It was PACKED! So much so, there were tons of people outside waiting...which I'm not surprised, the food is amazing! This place stays slammed, and, despite being slammed quite often, the waitresses are absolutely amazing! Amazing service, amazing food, and even amazing prices! Def recommend the hamburger steak! It's fantastic! Be sure to tip these hard working ladies, they really work hard here, and they deserve to be tipped well... read more

Stopped for a late lunch. Beyond pleased. Delicious and quickly made. Ribeye sandwiches were cooked perfectly to order. Bison burger was wonderful. Service was great. Looking forward to coming back many many more times. read more

Colonial Restaurant - Ribeye sandwich, rare - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

Great food, and good service. We always feel like family when we visit. We always eat here at least once when we are in town.

The food is pretty decent for the price. I think you can get better tasting breakfast/brunch at a place like Duke's diner downtown. The service here is usually good. It's a classic place to go and a local staple. Worth a visit. read more

Been going there for a few years, everytime we visit Lynchburg, we go to this restaurant multiple times. The food is delicious, the atmosphere is homey and the service is always fantastic. We haven't had a bad experience here and always leave with full bellies and good memories. We definitely recommend the cheese curds, those are always a big hit at the table, especially with marinara. Though, some other notables are the bison burger and their steaks. read more

Love this restaurant. One bad visit turned that around. I arrived at 3:20 not that busy. I was alone. There was a bald-headed gentleman and young lady behind the cash register. I counted over 5 different servers coming in and out of kitchen. I stood in front of the register for over 10 minutes. nothing. What really got me upset was a couple came in behind me that was waited on immediately. WOW I couldn't belive it. I am really mad but I like the restuarant so much I tried to calm down. I was seated finally no apologys or nothing. Wait another 10 mins to get wait on. I am so mad did not enjoy my meal. I will never return because of this incident. read more

It's a quiet place with friendly staff and people. I usually sit at the bar, and have the Salmon and a beer. People at the bat are usually chatty too. Overall there is a very nice atmosphere, and I return every one or two weeks. Bon Appetite! read more

Awesome restaurant just outside of Lynchburg, VA. with a great menu and friendly service. I really enjoyed the Oyster Stew and Bison Burger Steak. I knew that I was truly in the South with all the butter I received with my dinner. Lol I will be coming back the next time I visit the area. read more

Colonial Restaurant - Bison Burger Steak - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

A yummy breakfast spot just outside of Lynchburg - this is a perfect stop when you're looking for that home cooked, home feeling meal. It was probably one of the friendliest places I've ever been and I don't just mean the staff. It seemed every customer knew each other - I saw grandkids run into grandparents, students run into principals, and former athletes run into coaches. As an out-of-towner it was obvious that this is a hometown staple! read more

Very nice, clean, great home cooked food and great service! We will be back and encourage all to come on in.

This is one of the best places to eat for breakfast staff is great. I wrote a review a couple of months ago on the way I was treated from the dinner staff. I will only go there for breakfast. read more

Awesome food and service! Great coffee! Thanks for a great dining experience! I am a frequent repeat customer

LISTEN UP YALL this place is GREAT. The venue is super clean and spacious, all woodsy and, to be totally cheesy, quite "Colonial". The prices are fabulously reasonable and the staff are very attentive. If you have the absolute privilege of being served by Sheila, consider yourself blessed because this gal is such a sweetie and just the kind of warm face you'd like to be greeted by on a groggy morning. In conclusion, Colonial is your go-to breakfast joint in Lynchburg so check it out. P. S. Their apples are the essence of autumn in a bowl, so I 100% suggest you get that as your side read more

Colonial Restaurant - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

Great service. Good food. Most things are reasonable. Some apps are a little pricey for what you get.

First time for lunch with my son. I had the phillycheese steak and ot was delicious! The steak was so tender and moist -it was the best one i have ever ate! My som had the bbq brisket sandwich and he really enjoyed it and said it was also delicious . My husband and I will be having date night and we will be trying the dinner out tonight. Def recommend! read more

Colonial Restaurant - PhillyCheesesteak - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

See all

Overall, an interesting restaurant to stop at while traveling through town. Downsides were pretty pricey menu ($41 for 2 adults and 2 children for breakfast) and some delay when it came to getting seated. Only one staff member was allowed to seat guests and she was busy in the back or something - the very small entryway wound up getting backed up and there was a lot of jostling. eventually got resolved but we almost left. Food was OK, nothing to write home about. Staff was super friendly and so were the other patrons. Interior looked nice. Give them a shot. read more

The food was amazing and the service for being completely packed. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

How 2 people can sit at the same table and have completely different experiences baffles me. My husbands food was all cold and greasy while mine was hot and at least edible. When he told the waitress about the food being cold she said she would tell the kitchen...she didnt, she just walked back over to the bar to chat with customers shed been chatting with the entire time. My husband also ordered the seafood platter that shouldve had clam strips but they never said they were gonna sub it with more shrimp which made it so not worth the cost. We didn't say anything about that since no one seemed to care that the food was inedible on his plate anyway. We wont be giving this place another chance. read more

It was Sunday afternoon I was heading back home after visiting Rustburg. Looking forward to a late lunch but La Carreta, the Chinese restaurant, and the courthouse cafe were all closed at this time. My boyfriend said his grandparents used to go to the Colonial to hang out back in the day when they were in college, it was the only place around at the time really. My boyfriend also said he used to go here all the time after basketball games, that being back when he was in grade school. So I was really looking forward to trying this restaurant. He said it was like a Cracker Barrel, surely enough there were rocking chairs outside but in addition they had cute benches made out of wood to sit on. The hostess was friendly and we were seated promptly. Our server was also nice and quick with our order. I looked at the menu while on my way there and I already knew what I was going to get. The menu on their website needs to be updated because online it says the shank steak was a dollar cheaper than in the restaurant. My boyfriend and I ended up getting the same thing. Country fried steak, with a side of mashed potatoes and gravy, and green beans. The food came out surprisingly quick, we were glad of this since we were both starving. Unfortunately nothing on our plates had flavor. Everything looked amazing. It wasn't bad but it wasn't good. It was all texture no flavor. I added some salt to see if it would help but it didn't. I would normally add hot sauce to things without flavor but you can't do that to this type of food. I could barely finish the mashed potatoes and I guess the bacon was just decor in the green beans because it did nothing for it. It wasn't a great experience food wise but maybe it was just a bad day. This experience makes me hesitant to give it another try. Good luck to you and yours! read more

Colonial Restaurant - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

I started with the garlic parmesan bone-in wings and they were excellent and went with the chicken fried steak with white gravy some hush puppies on the side everything was excellent read more

Colonial Restaurant - Garlic parmesan Bone in wings - American Near Me - Rustburg, Virginia

One of my very favorite places to dine, whether it's breakfast, lunch or dinner. Delicious food and great service. Spacious parking area for your convenience. read more

Always an excellent experience! Hot food, waitresses, & cold drinks! Tell Sarah (bartender) that I sent you! TEN STARS read more

Honesty, this is an incredible restaurant. I went with a friend. The service was very good because the waiter was very attentive to our needs, kept our drinks full before they reached the bottom, and answered all of our questions. The food was amazing. We had two appetizers: the boneless wings (amazing) and the pretzel bites (also amazing). If you like burgers, get one of their burgers. I love burgers and especially big burgers so I got their double burger and it was one of the best burgers I have ever had. 10/10 recommend. read more

Our party of 12 chose this place for a brunch. It was a sibling and spouse brunch in conjunction with our annual Christmas celebration which is usually held in January. Our waitress was superb. The food was excellent and they put tables together so we could all be in the same room at the same table together. We ordered a variety of foods and there were no complaints. Plenty of offers on refills of beverages and coffee and attentiveness without being hovered over. This place does not take reservations and it would have saved some time if we could've called ahead to let them know we were coming. As it was, the waitresses had to stop what they were doing and get a place ready for us. We were fine with waiting, but they had to stop in the middle of their busy morning to get set up for us. I highly recommend this place for a small group or a larger crowd. read more

Country diner. We had driven past the Colonial many time before going in there and I'm glad to say that it is now on our regular rotation for breakfast. That being said - this review is only for breakfast as we have not yet tried it later in the day. It does appear to be open for lunch and dinner as well. Rustic looking from the outside - it has a log cabin kind of appearance with some tables and rocking chairs on the front patio. This is definitely a place that the locals can be found and you notice a lot of family and friends coming in. The interior is best described as country-ish. Wood walls and standard diner tables set the mood. Large seating area in both the front and in the rear there is another room, also large. Service goes from downright friendly to grumpy. The menu is not extensive but there is pretty much something on there for everyone. Breakfast items are solid if nothing creative. My favorite, though I have never and will never try it, is the "brains & eggs"... And yes, my wife asked and they are indeed brains. That being said, everything ordered is spot-on. Eggs come out the way you asked for them and the servings are decently sized so that you will be full and usually have left overs. Coffee is hot and tasty and they are very good with getting the cup topped off. Bathrooms are clean and the prices are very reasonable. All in all a solid breakfast place. Nothing fancy, but good food at reasonable prices. Large parking lot all around the perimeter. read more

There's a lot of choices in meals. Good service and location. Always busy. Good pricing.