Service is horrible. And the bathroom was dirty ask one of the employees for napkins for my 2 year old son he just threw them at me.

carter is the best employee there! so kind to my friends and i. would def recommend. the icecream was great and not as expensive as i thought. read more

I heard from multiple people that there was cockroaches, wasn't believing them until i saw one myself. actually so unsanitary

I was so surprised seeing all the bad reviews for this cold stone so I had to write my own. I love this cold stone. The service I get here is always the best whoever I get. I will say they do leave the front unattended sometimes but that's usually because they're in the restroom, or in the back freezer. Just call out a "Hello" and they'll be right with you. They always give an abundance of ice cream in my cup unlike other locations. I can no longer go to the Central Ave Yonkers Coldstone because I am always just so disappointed with the amount I get, they've spoiled me here at Pleasantville. As I write this I have gotten out of bed on a rainy day to drive 30 mins just to get Cold Stone here. read more

Horrible service once they give the ice cream to the Uber or DoorDash they relieve themselves of the responsibility they make you call Uber or DoorDash and take it up with them. No customer service no follow up pretty nasty on the phone. We're trying to explain to them what happened don't bother us call Uber or DoorDash, then try to lie that the driver was on his way and just left and we tracked the driver and he had left 40 minutes before and DoorDash driver wound up going to Chappaqua New York instead of my local address read more

- no samples: lame - ice cream left on the cold stone. It was a small amount do I asked the server if he could put in the cup. He said no, would make cup too full then after we paid he put ice cream back in the tub (not sanitary) - no kids sizes - server not friendly Ice cream is supposed to be fun. This place definitely is not read more

After ordering the non dairy ice cream, which was labeled backwards with the chocolate and non-dairy chocolate, the worker scooped the regular chocolate. After asking once again whether the ice cream was non/dairy, the worker got upset and said that we had to get the regular chocolate anyway. We then ordered a second ice cream in order to get the non-dairy which we already did not want to have to do. Terrible customer service, and we left with a bad taste in our mouths. overpriced and bad service. would not go to again. This is coming from a previous employee of this cold stone and having worked there I would've never done this to a customer. Completely uncalled for, unhelpful and just not nice. read more

My roommate worked at this location when I went to undergrad at Pace University, so I got a lot of free ice cream. However, when I did pay for it, it was definitely pricey. The smallest size - "like it" - runs for a little over $5. You could get a gallon of ice cream from the supermarket for that price. It's overpriced, but which ice cream shop isn't? I got the apple pie apple. Surprisingly, it resembled an apple pie. The brown sugar and cinnamon outer layer tasted very similar to an apple pie crust and it was simply delicious. The white confection was just added to give another layer of sweetness and displayed a contrast of color. And of course, the first layer is caramel and who doesn't like caramel? This was pretty expensive too, but I wouldn't go out of my way to make caramel apples at home so this was my splurge for the day and it was well worth it. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Apple Pie Apple - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Ice cream was delicious. I can't deny that. But the service was two star. She was nice enough, but didn't say hello or acknowledge us for a minute. Then we picked the special anniversary cones. She said what size? I said a cone. She said cones are extra. I said, no problem. Then she said oh, we are out of cones! What kind of ice cream store runs out of cones? And the door is disgustingly filthy. They need to clean it. read more

all I can say is "Meh" I found the sweet cream too sweet and lacking in the proper ice crystal ratio. The scoopers were courteous but I am sad to report that Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream does not suit my palate. read more

The staff here is great. Typically high school or college kids. They work hard and are very nice. Make sure you tip them. I love the peanut butter perfection ice cream. I love peanut butter and chocolate. My suggestion would be to add gram crackers to the perfection. It is great. read more

I ordered an ice cream photo cake for my son's 21st birthday. It was absolutely delicious and wonderful. I could not be happier.

Mediocre ice cream, and at $8+ for two small sugar cones it's an absolute rip-off. Let's see, pistachio ice cream, without a single pistachio in it? You will do much better by buying a pint of Ben & Jerry's for that price and get far superior ice cream and much more for your money. But I guess when you're the only game in town in sleepy Westchester county, people just don't know any better. read more

The girls working tonight spent more time talking rather than helping customers. There were two working and only one helping customers. The other appeared to be doing closing work. I waited on line for 45 minutes with about 8 people (4 parties) in front of me. They were regularly pausing making ice cream and helping customers to talk to each other. I've never waiting in such a long line here before. read more

Would give it four stars if the staff improved their attitude a bit... and the place seems a bit on the dirty side but has that strong cheap cleaning solution mixed in... could do better with the overall set up within this place, cleanliness, and staff morale. For example, asked about waffle cones they said they had one left and the shop was not set to close for another hour or so. They didn't want to be bothered with and couldn't even help with finding a box of pre-made ice cream that's in the fridge. Could go on, but I'm sure you get the gist. read more

Our son's birthday cake wasn't ready on time and we wound up having to go to Carvel for a last minute cake. It wasn't ready yesterday and when we showed up to pick it up today after 1 pm the store was closed. No one answers the phone. read more

This place is great to go to all year! The service is wonderful and we already know how good the ice cream is...

Went here to get fudge from Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory, no fudge!! Really unfair of RMCF to advertise this as one of their locations when they don't have anything available. read more

Was extremely excited to find out that they are having later summer hours :) love the place! Ice cream is great, staff was friendly. Wish there was a bench or seating outside so you could enjoy the nice weather. read more

I usually never make reviews but this was beyond terrible. My boyfriend and I went to get a simple ice cream order. When the women made my ice cream she didn't bother to clean off the station so my chocolate ice cream with brownies now became a vanilla bean ice cream with chocolate chips and best of all walnuts (I'm allergic to tree nuts). It's overall ridiculous that I had surprise mix in that could have been very dangerous for me but she didn't fill up the ice cream to even the rim of the cup it was below what it should have been or what it usually is a bit of a cheap rip off. Lastly we pay for our ice cream when she gives my boyfriend back his change she picks up the tip jar and then slams it down infront of him(very aggressive) It was a bit shocking since I've worked in food service for years and that was not a way to get a tip and how slow she was going (which usually doesn't bother me) she didn't really deserved a tip. A bit shocked and I'm defiantly going to carvel for now on. Please clean you work station before serving new food. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - a piece of food on a table - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

I really love this place! The way they make their ice cream is great because they mix the toppings all throughout the ice cream. Then when you're eating it you don't have to worry about your ice cream being dull at the bottom because the toppings are there! If you're looking for some dessert to have when you are stressed Cold Stone is definitely the place for you! read more

they left out a big chuck of brownie from my ice cream then threw it out! what a waste! my friend had the same issue! the ice cream was fine though. read more