I really wish I could give more than 1 star to City Cab because I've had pleasant conversations with many of the drivers, at times even offering me a personal business card so that I could call a driver directly.
Now for the bad: This is the WORST cab company I have ever attempted to use, (and that includes living in San Francisco where cabbies ask you where you are headed before you get in the car and will drive off, leave you in a trail of dust if they don't feel the drive is worth it).
The problem with City Cab is their penchant for either never showing up, or telling you that you'll need to wait an hour an a half.
If I call City Cab, I'm usually told there will be an hour wait, so I've learned to try and call them with time to spare (don't ever have a car emergency because you'll never make any deadline). Usually, you have to call back after the hour is up to remind them that they are a cab company and are supposed to pick people up. Once I called them because I had a 7am flight the next day from Arcata/McK Airport, and could not make it to the airport by bus that early in the morning. I called City Can the night before, around 6pm, and asked for a pick up in the morning. Guess what? City Cab NEVER showed, despite calling them early in the morning to confirm the pick up. Thanks to City Can, I missed my flight and had to re-book it for an extreme fee. I called the dispatcher, trying to be civil because I've worked phones before and understand dealing with irate customers, but I was basically told that "s*** happens" and there was nothing he could do.
I understand that NorHum is sparsely populated and CC can't afford a fleet a la Yellow Cab in SFCity, but I grew up in a taxi driver home and City Cab is the WORST run cab company I've ever dealt with.
As I dump on the company, I feel that I should at least share one good story. Last December, a day or so before Christmas, I was going to get picked up by a friend an driven from Arcata to Garberville to stay with family, but the their car couldn't make the trip. I was told Garberville was impossible by the dispatcher, so I asked him to have someone drive me as close to Garberville as possible. At first the driver who picked me up said it was close to his shift ending and he could only take me to the cabbie's garage on 7th st, but he took pity on me and drove me from Arcata to Garberville so that I could see my family for Christmas. Ride and tip set me back almost $300, but he did go far out of his way to help me see my family.
Mostly, my story explains my opinion of this company: The drivers are wholly good, kind people who dont try to scam you by taking detours, but unfortunately the company itself can not be relied upon to get you anywhere you need to go, and one of their dispatchers seems to have some kind of anger disorder.
The Humboldt/Arcata area really needs reliable cab companies for those of us who need more than a drunken ride back from the bar. read more