Cancel

Open app

Search

Ciceros Pizza

4.0 (44 reviews)
ModeratePizza
Closed • 4:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Ciceros Pizza Photos

CICEROS PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Dogs allowed
Good for groups
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Ciceros Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Large pepperoni pizza
Dahlia J.

Food - Pizza & breadsticks were delicious! Pizza's crust was normal but on the thinner side, just the right amount of sauce & cheese! Also, baked just how I like it so that was amazing! Break sticks had so much flavor, very yummy! Service - Quick, kind & overall fantastic! Ambiance - inside was cute & quaint, you are also overwhelmed with the smell of pizza when you walk up which we loved! We ordered & it was ready within 15min! We wanted a quick bite to eat while on vacation & this did not disappoint, we love this local place- it's definitely a must if you're visiting interlochen & we will absolutely be back!!

Large pizza with bacon, pepperoni and banana peppers. Also got it well done and was perfect :) not overly saucy or cheesy
Jessica B.

My family and I came for a quick vacation and Cicero's Pizza really hit the spot for dinner! The staff was incredibly friendly, the restaurant was very nice inside and the pizza was very well made. Overall, I definitely recommend if you're in the Interlochen, MI area!

Pizza - large pepperoni, sausage, onion, black and green olive.
Chelsey H.

Not bad but not good.... service was fast and friendly. The crust was a tad over cooked. Ate the entire pie but I doubt I'll be going back again.

Mediterranean pizza
Z S.

Excellent friendly customer service and great pizzas. We were late on dinner plans and decided on pizza because this one was on of the few places open. We ordered the Mediterranean pizza, a custom pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza. Each one was delicious and my kids had a great time eating them. I highly recommend this independently owned pizzeria!

a pizza in a box

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Ciceros Pizza

Review Highlights - Ciceros Pizza

“We've lived in traverse city for years and never knew of this place.”

Mentioned in 4 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Two Sons Pizza - This is why you never tip carry out

Two Sons Pizza

4.2(52 reviews)
10.6 mi

We ordered takeout from Two Sons Pizza. It was ready by the estimated time and our order was…read morecorrect. We felt the pizza had too much pepperoni for our liking. We enjoyed the garlic knots!

This New York style pizzeria is located inside Silver Spruce Brewing, which is a fun,…read moreindoor-outdoor venue. Frontage on Eighth Street, but it feels like a neighborhood joint once you are in there. I apologize to Two Sons Pizza, for not writing a five star review, when the pizza was five stars. I mean, we've got The Filling Station for the real thin but still chewy crust. Excellent. Charles and Reid for Detroit style, which is life altering delicious (and I generally hate thick pizza). And Two Sons completed the power triangle with big New York style slices and pies. But what the F happened? They've always had a little bit of that dismissive hipster kind of vibe, where they try to make you feel like you're not important, or possibly not cool enough to enjoy how amazing their pizza is, or was. But now it's like the one or two employees who are there at a time, don't want to be there at all. And that's what the pizza tastes like now The slices used to be massive, like cutting an extra large pizza into six slices. They were priced accordingly, $7-8+, but well worth it. Delicious. Now the pies are old sitting around for hours, and they don't perk up when reheated like they used to. I don't have a problem with proper New York style slices, being reheated, that's part of the tradition. But the attitude I get is, if they aren't slammed busy, they don't care about having fresh food, and you just get what you get. It seems the employees don't care, they are like robots now, and unhappy robots at that. They've got the NY magic and the special sauce, they just aren't using it anymore. Maybe the chef quit, maybe it got sold, I have no idea. The last slice I had, I threw it in the garbage, and went to Toby's dog house, the hot dog trailer outside. But it was closed on a day it was supposed to be open. The guy behind the bar at Silver Spruce brewing has the same dismissive/dumb attitude. I wouldn't be surprised if all three places closed after summer 2026 ** since they are capable of making a good New York style pie, at least in theory now, just order a whole pizza. That way, it will be fresh. The slice game is dead there. **

Photos
Two Sons Pizza - All three pizzas mentioned in the review

All three pizzas mentioned in the review

Two Sons Pizza - Shame on you, fire this guy

Shame on you, fire this guy

Two Sons Pizza - Outside Patio

See all

Outside Patio

Ciceros Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...