This is a solid thrift store but definitely still pricey for what they have. It was more organized than expected (given the pics) and they had a variety of things. It's on the smallish side but worth taking a look. Not a place I imagine finding a gem but maybe something interesting? If you have visited all the other places and need another to check out, add it to your list but I wouldn't go out of my way for this one. Staff was nice. read more

After downsizing our home, we had a lot of good-quality items we wanted to donate locally. But every time I've tried to drop things off, the experience has been frustrating and honestly disappointing. There's been no basic appreciation, no thanks, and no sense that donations are welcome. Instead, the only responses I've gotten from staff have been things like "don't walk into the donation area," "what are you donating," or "we don't take that" -- even when the item is clearly listed as accepted on their website. The overall attitude toward people trying to donate is rude and dismissive. I won't be bringing anything else here and will be finding another local charity that actually values donations and treats donors with respect. read more

They are quite selective on what they will accept for donations. Does not accept books, DVDs, or picture frames (even brand new). These items not listed on their web page "does not accept" list. Hope this avoids a wasted trip for someone. read more

Well organized, staff work hard. Items and holiday supplies are reasonably priced. I donate goods here often, staff are helpful with drop offs. read more

Saturday, 7/01/2023 - Stopped by Church Mouse Thrift. Address here is 16885 Sonoma Hwy, Sonoma, CA 95476. Small parking lot. But we found parking right away. It's right by the highway where we were driving, so we stopped by here. Cute little Thrift shop. read more

See all

Took some friends on tour in Sonoma, and we came upon the church mouse...it is a lovely, well-organized thrift shop...with many new things as well... great kitchen items and at times silver....the clothes racks have some fun jewels and vintage as well....worth a stop by for some fun! read more

Service is mediocre Selection is okay on household items Clothing used to be good, but not good for last 5 years Value is horrible, particularly clothing I can buy new for their prices I can buy clothing for a third the price at other charity thrift stores read more

Great deals on designer items, Warby Parker glasses for $1.99, and vintage milk glass tea cups and saucers for the same price per item. Staff is fun and kind. read more

Very disappointed by the service at the store. My fiancée purchased 4 items, including one in which the wrong item was rung up and included. Upon reviewing the receipt (whilst still in the store!) , my fiancée brought it to the cashier's (Krista) attention. Krista said 'No returns allowed, I don't know what to tell you'. Her attitude and behavior was short, rude and neither professional or helpful. Upon asked to speak to her manager, Krista informed my fiancée that she was unable to call her manager. The second sales clerk asked my fiancée what she would like to do. My fiancée asked for a refund, to which she responded You need to keep the shoes' . My fiancée left both the shoes & the receipt at the store for the manager to review. My fiancée is African-American and wonders if a Caucasian woman would have been treated the same. Note: proceeds of the Church Mouse go to the Catholic Church .. is this how the Church wants it's supporters and patrons to be treated? read more

Very helpful staff. Found 2 lovely paintings and a carafe. Glad the money goes to a school!!

Twice I've had interactions with male staff who is extremely rude. Seems like this same staff member subject of most complaints on Facebook too. Very unpleasant experience, will not donate here again. read more

I love this little tucked away gem. While the prices are higher than most secondhand stores, the clothing is generally high quality. read more

We went to this store today to enjoy our time in Sonoma. Unfortunately, the male employee behind the counter was very unkind and unapproachable. I don't think I will ever do business with them again because of him. read more

High priced secondhand store. If you find what you are looking for, congratulations. If you a browsing for a deal, you will not find one. I found an set of dishes and had sticker shock. $60 for a salt and pepper shaker! Crods checked other cites and it was overpriced. Upside, this place employs people and is for charity. read more

Church Mouse - Thrift Stores Near Me - Sonoma, California

Great prices! Lots of selection! The parking isn't the best but it is worth the store for sure. Definitely recommend!

This is the BIG Church Mouse store of the 3 in the Sonoma area. This is where you look for bicycles, old golf equipment, housewares. The larger items are piled outdoors. The interior store is rather musty. Pretty slim pickin's for the "good stuff" compared to the store across from the Sonoma town plaza. read more

I love this thrift store. Yes, about 50% of the items for sale are junk, but there are some real treasures to be found. I've found great toys (for $0.50 - $5.00), books ($.50 for paperback & $0.95 for hardcover), housewares, holiday decorations, and a few clothing items. I even bought crutches when my partner temporarily needed them, and was pleased to spend $10 instead of over $50 at a drug store. The staff is always polite, and they have a dressing room (unlike many other thrift stores these days). I'm a fan of the Church Mouse. read more

I like this thrift shop, prices are high on clothing, there's lots of linens and household goods, you have to dig a bit to find the gems like vintage wood picture frames and vintage leather purses. read more

This is one of the best Thrift Shops I've ever been in and the best in Sonoma Valley. I have been a loyal customer since I moved to Sonoma back in the early 90's. The dedication the employees put into the store shows they are always so helpful and keep the store organized and stocked in every department. The sales are always good and happen often which is amazing for the struggling locals in search for everyday goods. You will find brand names at great prices. It's always my go to place for the Holidays read more

See all

I visited this location after going to the downtown plaza location. One thing in common- this place is still expensive. It is the location where the items considered less desirable for the downtown location are displayed. Prices aren't much better. As far as the goods are concerned, this is the place to buy the plastic bowls that you saw at Dollar Tree for twice the price. I saw a router table that I had some minor interest in buying. It was worth 10.00, not at 20.00. There wasn't much at that place that interested me. By the way, the place doesn't have a restroom for customers. No exceptions. Same verdict as the last place- I walked out without a purchase. Besides, I had to find a restroom. read more

Somewhat organized but completely overpriced. Also, not enough mirrors to see how the clothes look. Only one mirror near the dressing room. I had stopped here about a year ago, so it's time not as if I didn't give them a second chance. I think I'll look for other places the next time I drive through the area. read more

The prices are high. Thely check the internet and price their items at the highest resale price they see. I imagine the goal for a thrift store is move sell as much merchandise they can, to keep from the overload! Anyway when they have a sale that is the time to go there. Check their fb page for the sales. I live close by, so I must admit I go there for items I need , ie a birthday card, computer paper, cause I dont want to drive down the highway. So this place has become my "dime store" "hardware store". So I love that,Ican usually find what I want, (wrapping paper) at a good price and it is convenient. The are over priced for a thrift store but still less than retail. And yes donating there is a challenge. So I do not donate there anymore. I take it to the goodwill. Goodwill has the resources and $$ ability to deal with all the garbage and excess sthey get. Most people try to donate garbage, take a look at your stuff if it looks like crap then dump it, no one wants it NO ONE. Even if it is useable. Drive to the dumps and pay to get rid of it. Even the goodwill is going to check your stuff out. BUT church mouse has the rudest people . I go there a lot and rarely do I encounter a friendly employee. That is just sad. read more

Always a good selection of items, but it can change quickly, so if you see something you like, grab it. Prices seem a little high, but not too much out of line. I got some good deals on towels, sheets, and utensils for a group home with a low budget. read more

This larger-than-life thrift store truly has everything you can possibly imagine. From crutches to canning jars, you'll be amazed at what you can find, and their prices will have you saying "Alleluiah" in no time. A great place to find sewing notions, housewares, party favors, beads, books and baskets. And, don't pass up the 'as is' area out back where the price is figured by staff and there's room to negotiate. You're sure to find a heavenly bargain here. Be sure to check out my other thrift store listings at http://www.thriftstorejunkies.com! read more

Wow. The other reviewers nailed it. The manager rudely refused to accept my donation of a brand new condition $800 wall oven. Don't waste your time. read more

This place is ridiculously overpriced. Don't call yourself a thrift store and then ask more than $20 for an old blanket! Not to mention it feels dirty & cluttered. Save your time & your money and go to Republic of Thrift instead. At least the ladies working will greet you with a smile! read more

Worst of three IMO. I can't ever seem to find anyone who is working when I've been in there. I had to stand around and wait for them to magically appear. The prices were pretty fair off IMO. I don't get it, its a second hand shop but it feels like they are trying for full price. It makes no sense. I went a few times to give it a shot but no plans to go back. I also took a donation there and the guy who was working gave me a really hard time and the whole process took 30 minutes and I didn't take that much. I was unamused and will not be donating here again, way too much of a hassle! read more

Prices are way too high for a thrift store. Once you show interest in any item , your told its not for sale. I have seen people walk away because they are unwilling to sell some items ? pricing is inaccurate read more

You can find some cool stuff outside, but inside is ugh! Plasticky 99 cent store quality stuff ( yet somehow overpriced because its new I guess) Then USED shoes for 15 to 20 bucks - you gotta be kidding !! They obviously get lots of donations but they tend to choose the lamest stuff to put on the floor. read more

This store used to be great. Now they turn their noses up at everything donation . The manager is rude. They say that they can't use something because it has a scratch but yet in the store there is broken down junk every where. I have taken what they have said no to, as a donation, and gone to consignment and made money. read more

I really have enjoyed this establishment. The prices are very low for the quality of the items. 100% recommend

There are better thrift shops in Sonoma that benefit better causes but I do stop here sometimes because it's close to my house. Their prices are pretty high for used items. The people who work here are always really nice. read more

I drop in on occasions and I have to admit...as a seasoned thrift store shopper I am not impressed. They want way too much and so the fun of the hunt for that real deal is taken away. Like it or not they sell donated items so screwing those of us who want to have fun and shop seems......money grabbing. I get the good cause ideas.....but its us folks who have the fun and pay and quite honestly I never expect to really have a good time there. read more

I have been in the store many times. Yesterday, I picked up some beautiful bone china decorative plates and a little gold handle purse mirror with a beautiful image on the back. It had the original gold sticker that I-Magins had on it. Currently the mirror is selling for $100.00 on ebay, I got it for less than $15.00. I enjoyed the collection and the volunteers who waited on me. It is nice to spend money knowing it is going for a good cause. I would love to see more Catholic parishes do the same thing. We could do that in San Francisco. Thank you Church Mouse for a lovely day and beautiful items. read more

The hierarchy for items donated to the Church Mouse is that the best stuff (name brands, complete sets, highest quality) goes to the Plaza location, furniture and OK stuff (but not high end) to the Boyes location, and the left overs stay in the Agua Caliente location. Got it? read more

Came here to donate some old picture frames, they took them without issue. They didn't have a lot of interesting things but I was able to find a glass lemon reamer for just $2, everywhere else I've looked they go for a minimum $10 so I thought it was a good deal. I'd come back here again. read more

About the size of a large Goodwill. Good variety of things, sports equipment, some furniture, toys, small appliances. Didn't notice prices on some things. Small selection of CD's and DVDs. VHS selection is pretty good and at 25 cents a good deal compared to a lot of other thrifts still charging a dollar. Well-lit store and spacious. I did notice they had a washing machine that was ON and washing clothes - first time I've seen a washing machine doing that at a thrift store and I am relieved! Books selection was a bit all over the place, no organization but all were on shelves at least. They did all seem to be older, mass-market titles though. Didn't notice the prices on clothes as I didn't find anything and left promptly. At least this Church Mouse was open and had parking, although only accessible from westbound lane I believe. read more