It's interesting that Meduza feels more Tulum than Mediterranea, then again, Tulum is sort of just…read morea chic facade over an underlying eery energy.. I mean, spot on Tulum vibes otherwise; I loved it, place is cool af, I love the girl walking around playing the violin with the DJ over the top, but the DJ is WAY WAY too loud.
You absolutely cannot hear the person dining across from you. Not only that, but the four tables they have near the door is an absolutely absurd decision in a freezing New York to not have heat over the top like they do in every other area of the restaurant. Getting a $400 meal and being ice cold, screaming to talk, is a total disappointment of what's otherwise an amazing place, I knew I'd love.
The locations sick, the buildings sick, the vibes sick! The foods so on point and service was great. Most everything we had was bit over-salted but still somehow forgivable and exceptional, not so much that I'd complain and have to send it back or anything.
I ordered like I hadn't eaten in two days, and come to think of it, I hadn't. Straight off the bat was the hummus and dolmas, I would have done the carpaccio or even caviar but it wasn't the night for adventure and going broke. Then again, the price of the amazing rib eye top cap was excessive to say the least. Yes it's an amazing cut of meat and the execution is just so amazing with the perfect wine reduction... my god, heavenly crispy "skin-like" shell surrounding a perfffffectly red, tender, juicy and succulent center that melts in your mouth. It feels so perfect that I assume it's sous-vide and seared off, but what do I know. One of the best steaks around, the best bite of steak on the cow as they say, but 6-8oz at $120 is actually just salty pretension. No big deal, a night out is a night out, and price doesn't really matter, but I see you Meduza. Manageable, pretension-laced excellence, kinda like me!
The roasted garlic hummus looked so amazing we had to try it, no actual roasted garlic on top as expected and shown all over the internet, but definitely loaded with garlic flavor. It was light and tasty and NOT over salted, though a really nice olive oil and actual garlic would have been way better and the pita had to be in house, it was pillowy and phenom.
The dolmas however, were indeed over salted, but still great. I only ate one and gave the rest to the hot date!
The lamb chops were... absolutely superb. That lamb could easily be shared as an app or ordered as the main show. It was perfectly cooked without asking a temperature and all in all pretty reasonably priced compared other items. Paying for that vibe and execution at the end of the day anyway!
Last was my Dover sole, very photogenic as the rest of the place, but my picture isn't great, none of my pictures were great, I rushed to dive in.
Anyway, I hadn't had Dover sole before... maybe once many years ago, this was quite nice and easy to eat, very approachable with a beautiful sharp caper butter sauce that was again, a bit oversalted, and again manageable and delicious all the same. After all of our food though, most of that fish came home... I see now that they didn't give me the fkcing sauce... wtf honestly? It's now just dry fish and that really really sucks.
Overall great place and great night mixed with some rather unexpected and strange disappointments.. like just... why?
Why have that added salt to everything? Why keep my god damn sauce? Why have four tables that don't get any heat like the rest of the restaurant? Why why why is that DJ playing at that level when the violin should be shining a bit more and people can't hear themselves talk?
I saw a review that the menu is limited; I didn't feel that way at all, quite extensive in fact. I'd go back and sit at the bar alone to explore a new part of the menu, because there's a lot more salt I wanna try! Haha all jokes aside, the menu is Mediterranean inspired at best but it's sort of more... worldly let's say; I wish I was in the neighborhood and could casually drop in for a bite and cocktail (surprisingly we did not drink despite a few of those sounding quite delightful).
The things I didn't try all sound friggen fantastic and look good on camera. They did an awesome job nailing the lighting and Tulum vibes haha. I don't know if that's what they were going for but as the new kids say, "it's giving."
I'd still rather eat at Meze in Tulum come to think of it, but I digress.
Oh the mashed potatoes, they were mashed potatoes, not over-salted but nothing special, just straight forward which is perfectly fine, but the waiter did try to upsell us at every turn, always suggesting the more expensive thing, offering truffles on everything lol, don't get me wrong, I'm obsessed with truffle anything, but relax my guy, if we wanted it, we'd say so. Also the waiter was good, so like, play on bro, I get it, just don't make me think it's all a money grab.