I walked into Chicago's Pizza like I was entering the Arena... and that deep-dish pizza dropped like a LEGENDARY CARD. The crust? Mega Knight-level defense. The cheese? Absolutely stacked. The toppings? Full elixir bar. The flavor? RAGE SPELL ACTIVATED. One bite and my taste buds got 3-crowned. This wasn't just pizza... this was a 12-elixir push straight to the King Tower. The deep dish was AMAZING, and honestly felt like the kind of card you'd instantly max out. Flavor: 10/10 Deep Dish: 11/10 Cheese: LEGENDARY Overall: 3 CROWNS Chicago's Pizza Columbus = S-tier pizza. Would absolutely defend this restaurant with my entire deck. -Dreamybull read more

Chicago's Pizza - Empty plate - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

Great service, great ambiance, and even better food. Also the peppadew is really good

We got a large CBR deep dish & it was probably the best pizza we've had around here. I'd give it a 9/10, just needed more ranch! We will definitely be ordering again soon (: read more

Chicago's Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch (Deep Dish) - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

Really good pizza buffet at lunch time that's very affordable. Their deep dish buffalo chicken pizza is my favorite. Never eaten there outside of the buffet so I can't speak to the regular service, but the bar is always full of food read more

Chicago's Pizza is great! The staff is friendly and the food is always delicious. The salad bar is fresh and well stocked. It's our favorite pizza in Columbus! read more

Food was good the staff was slow waited 15 minutes before I could check out its sad th read more

Chicago's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

So I used to come here regularly when I was a teenager. I always loved the lunch buffet! It used to be cheaper, but for an updated price when I went there the other day I believe it was $12.50. Or somewhere around that. (Salad bar, pizza bar, and soda/tea or lemonade.) However if I'm being honest, I did get "sick to my stomach". It wasn't fun. When I told my Mom I got sick from eating lunch there she said the last time she went she also got sick. The service is great tho the workers are all so sweet. But yeah. I guess my review is only towards the lunch buffet because perhaps the pizza I had was out a while or someone touched it or I don't know. So perhaps if you're just ordering a regular pizza it's different. If it was based off staff service though it would have been a 5! Also it was busy but it's not too loud. read more

This is one of my favorite pizzas in town. I love the Chicago-style deep dish. The buffet is amazing. You won't leave hungry.

We love this place! It's so nice to have a pizza place that serves gluten free! They also have cauliflower crust-which is good too! My family and I have made it a tradition to go on Friday nights. The waitresses are very attentive, even when they're busy. Our drinks are always half full or above. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Gluten free chicken bacon ranch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

See all

Great food, service & ambiance! We love going there & even have a lot of family get togethers there too.

We were seated right away and our drink order taken immediately. We like "supreme" pizzas so we ended up ordering the Magnificent Mile deep dish pie. It came out in about 10 minutes and was delicious! Great service and great food and reasonably priced! We would eat there again! read more

If I could give no stars I would. Servers were very busy talking to each other instead of serving. My husbands spaghetti took over 30 minutes and then we had to ask for it. The cook hadn't even started it yet. I could see him from where we were and he put the noodles on the plate with his bare hands and the wiped his hands on his jeans. My husbands meal was cold and we had to ask for it to be heated up. One of the servers came and apologized but she was not our server and she was at the drink station chatting w the other servers. The first time we were here it was great but not sure we will be back read more

Not quite what one expected after having the same pizza from another location. "Magnificent Mile pizza"

My niece and I had a medium thin crust pizza. It was amazing and the server was great. We ate outside and was a very wonderful experience. Highly recommend. read more

Our to-go order was ready at the promised time. We tried traditional and gluten-free crusts and both were pretty good. For GF, that's saying something. Sauce was really tasty and the best part of these pizzas. The facility was obviously well managed, clean and with adequate staffing for a busy Friday night. read more

We were very disappointed with the 12" traditional pizza. Honestly, we have had better frozen pizzas. The pizza and breadsticks had very little flavor and were somewhat dry. It may of been a bad night as we have never been disappointed in our previous visits. read more

Service is great and food is even better! Friendly staff, very clean facilities, comfortable seating, and it typically doesn't take too long to get your food. A family favorite!Highly recommend! read more

Brand new place, and I am impressed. Their lunch buffet is a-ma-zing! Probably a dozen different pizzas to choose from, breadsticks, dessert pizza, a couple pasta options, and a salad bar. They are quickly becoming popular at lunch, which means super-fresh pizza and limited seating. Possibly the only issue I've experienced so far is that they do get a little behind is busing tables during lunch rush. Pizza is deep-dish Chicago style, but not Giordano's crazy-deep-it-might-as-well-be-a-pie-Chicago-style. Since I frequent their lunch buffet I've had multiple pizza flavors and haven't had one I didn't like yet. Interior is nicely decorated, and includes a banquet room that I'm sure can be reserved for parties and meetings. Staff is friendly. Have not had dinner there yet so I cannot comment on that. Carry-out or dine-in only, no delivery. Serves some beer. Will have an outdoor seating option when it gets warm again. Also next door to a great fro-yo place for an alternate to their dessert pizza option in case you have any room left after inhaling your pizza. Definitely like this place and definitely recommend. I expect it will put a few of the surrounding pizza places out of business. read more

Chicago's Pizza - store front - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

The food on the buffet is still good, but don't count on service. I reserved the small room at the restaurant two weeks ago for June 30 at 12:30. When my group arrived we found the room filled with other people and management did nothing to solve this problem. read more

Very good. Great pizza. And sandwiches. Great location if you live in Tipton lakes. Right off IN 46, so convenient location. The Stromboli is good as well as the skyline pizza. read more

There pizza may be the best tasting on the west side of Columbus, but the lady I talked to on the phone Tuesday October the 16th at 5:44. Was a rude ass! Maybe you couldn't hear me very well as you said, but maybe you should hang on to the phone and not drop it...I couldn't change my volume but you could certainly change that nasty attitude! Just picked up my pizza and miss sunshine was working the cash register, and still rude. Save your money and go somewhere where people can say thank you. read more

After a long day in Nashville we stopped in to have dinner... it was a beautiful day to sit on the patio and enjoy the breeze and fresh air! The menu didn't have as many variations so we were kind of limited on what we ordered but we made it work and it was good for a small town. read more

I wish I had two ratings, one for the food, one for the service. 4 stars for the food, 1 star for the service. My original thought was to walk in an order are pizza to go but I decided to sit in the restaurant since it was quiet (4:30p on Saturday afternoon). I ordered a Chicago Fire pizza and had them add Pineapple. I didn't know it was 2x the price to add an ingredient. The 'za was delicious as was the beer that I paired it with. The menu indicated it would be $0.60 per ingredient added but it was $1.20 for the pineapple on a large deep dish. I can buy a full jar or two of chunked pineapple for $1.00 - this seemed expensive. The $14 for the large deep dish seemed reasonable. Service - a whole different story. I asked about the beers on tap and she could name them but not described them. Ok, not the end of the world but when I got a taste of one, it came in a PEPSI cup! Really? Not even in a glass? Then, my pizza got delivered to my table - way cool, 15 minutes, awesome. Um, hello, is there a plate that I can eat off or a utensil available? I ate my pizza using the platter it came on as my plate. Glad it was only me. Duh, Kelly - could you please offer a plate and utensils to your customers? The folks next to me had regular "how is the food, how are you doing, can I get you anything" visits from another waiter and the couple across from me were offered several refills of their fountain drinks and ice tea by Kelly. All I got was a "do you need a box" and "you can pay up front when you are done" comment. And the only way I knew her name - it was on the ticket that I received to go pay. Can you please atleast say "Hi, I'm Kelly, I'll be your awesome server tonight" or something? If I was rude or impolite, I can understand the cold shoulder but nope, nada, no way. I was in their on a Saturday afternoon before the dinner rush, intending to just enjoy my booth, me myself and I. My recommendation: watch a few episodes of Restaurant Impossible and learn how to be a server. A plate? I shouldn't have to ask for it! read more

Had their pizza lunch buffet yesterday and it was very good! Had the barbeque chicken pizza, sausage pizza and supreme and they were all delicious. Also had some breadsticke with cheese which I can't pass up! I can't eat enough pizza to be worth the $8.50 for the buffet but I like being able to have all different kinds of pizza choices. Great time to try a kind you've had your eye on but werent sure of :) their cheese bread is also phenomenal! Piece of crispy french bread with thick melty cheese on top! Mmmmm! My favorite thing about Chicago's! !! read more

Strap on the feed bag for the lunch pizza buffet and salad bar. My favorite pizza is the BBQ bacon cheeseburger - all the food groups on one pizza! It's a large buffet typically serving more than a dozen pizzas plus breadsticks. The cinnamon dessert pizza is not to be missed. I always have a plate of salad before I start into the pizza and the salad is fresh and nicely chilled. Outdoor seating in the summer months! read more

I would drag my genitals through a mile of broken glass for an order of pepperoni breadsticks.

Yummy!! Skyline pizza is my favorite without the mushroom of course. Service is great and not to badly priced either. read more

Chicago's Pizza - Skyline pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Indiana

I'm obsessed with pizza and I've definitely tasted better. The place is very nice and the staff is friendly. Service is great but i just wish the pizza was better. It tasted like gas station pizza to me. The breadsticks were tastier. read more

The service here is terrible. Not only did we wait 50 mins for our bread sticks but two tables that sat down after us received their bread sticks first and we all had the same waitress. The food is average and the customer service is lousy. read more

Love going for lunch to the lunch pizza & salad buffet! Delicious! But usually very crowed from 12-130pm. No buffet for dinner though. I wish they did... read more

Really great gluten free pizza option, friendly staff, nice patio. Salad bar could use a few more choices. Convenient to highway and hotels, glad I found it! read more

Pizza is really good. But vegetarians should be cautious before eating. They must check the contents. I visited this place with a couple of vegetarians and their pizza had pepperoni.. I have visited this place twice and the same thing happened both the times. read more

Great place! Great deep dish aswell as regular. My favorite combo would be the big hurt with breadsticks and nacho cheese dipping sauce! Staff treats you like family and food makes you feel like one. 10/10 tasty and great. Only downfall is the free wifi only works partially. read more

Pizza was good, service so-so I am only around this area once or twice a year. Waited to long for refills 5min son had to wait for 10 min. On milk that the server forgot about. When appitizer came out server just set on the side closet to her for and didn't say or ask if anything was needed. 6 people split at 2-4 top tables. read more

Pizza is awesome, beer is good. Music is terrible. There's just something odd about eating pizza and enjoying a beer while Christian rock is blaring in the background. If that's your thing, you'll enjoy it. Otherwise, order take out. read more

This place has a great lunch buffet! There are always around 8-10 different pizzas hot and ready. I love the cheeseburger pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza. They keep an eye on it and replenish when one is low. They also have a decent salad bar. Great place for lunch. read more

We tried Chicago Pizza for the first time today. It was not like a true "Chicago Pizza" but their deep dish sausage and pepperoni pizza was still great. It is definitely better than any other pizza in town. However, we would have liked to try the buffet but it is not offered on weekends. I would suggest they add the buffet for lunch on the weekends. We definitely will be back and we received fast and courteous service and the place was new and super clean! read more

Walked in and stood waiting to be seated for 10 minutes. My husband and I seen prob 10 employees in back and 10 in front and the front ones at least 5 walked by not saying a word. We left! Now seated at a neighboring restaurant. read more

Ate at the buffet lunch at the Chicago's Pizza in Columbus Indiana. Lots of selection, but most of the pizzas were lukewarm or downright cold. This is probably a health code violation. I left several slices unbeaten on my plate. Only the most recent pizzas were anything like hot. I won't be going back. read more

Nice clean pizza joint, the service was great and the chicago style deep dish pizza was very tasty, maybe a little to much. My wife and I both started getting a headache within an hour, then the yucky bloated feeling I sometimes get after eating chinese food that is full of monosodium glutimate (MSG). Is this what it takes to make a good pizza? Quality ingredients make for great pizza, not MSG. My son also had a seizure later that night, always a dead giveaway that it was full of MSG! read more