Central Square is the center of the universe. I've been exploring this area for close to ten years and now live here, and I simply can't get enough of it.
Yes, it's dirty. Yes, there are homeless people. Yes, it's loud, and uncouth. But you know what? There's no place else I'd rather be.
The first time I visited Central Square was, I think, for the same reason a lot of people come here for the first time: The Middle East. 5 bars, 3 stages, and a whole lot of fun. That visit inspired a bar crawl the following week. The lineup has changed a bit since then, but here's the most comprehensive list of bars I can come up with (starting at the MIT end and moving toward the Harvard end)
Miracle of Science
The Middlesex Lounge ***
The All Asia Cafe
Asgard
Middle East ***
Zuzu (which is really just part of the Middle East)
Phoenix Landing
The Enormous Room ***
Green Street Grill
River Gods ***
The Field
Tavern on the Square
The Cantab ***
The Peoples' Republic
Plough and Stars ***
I'm probably missing a few, but with the exception of Tavern on the Square, which is a little too much like a poorly-run TGI Friday's for my taste, and the Enormous Room which has become sort of a scene, the bars in Central are entirely unpretentious and always a good time.
A note on drinking in Cambridge from the perspective of a whiskey drinker: Compared to Boston, your drink with cost roughly 2/3s as much and on average be twice as large.
But the nightlife (or daylife, depending on your schedule, I suppose) in Central Square is only the tip of the iceberg here. Because seriously, could I really call it the Center of the Universe if all there was to do here is drink?
You want coffee? We've got coffee: Andala Cafe, Cafe Luna, 1369, Mariposa.
Fine Dining? We've got Central Kitchen, Cuchi Cuchi (same people that own Dali in Somerville), Rendezvous, Craigie on Main (I still miss La Groceria though).
The beauty of Central is its central location. On one side you've got the quiet, family-centric neighborhood of Cambridgeport, on either end you've got the scholarly MIT and Harvard areas, you've got the rougher (but still safer than most urban projects) Area IV heading toward Lechmere, and you've got the bohemian artistic areas of Inman and Union just up Prospect Street. Central Square is the crossroads, so you've got a thriving art scene (Tom Tipton from Out of the Blue Gallery on Prospect Street hangs local artists' work at nearly every bar and cafe in the area), an amazing music scene, lots of good schools and parks and playgrounds for the kids (my nearly-9-year-old son loves the dodecahedron climbing structure at the Corner of Windsor and Harvard), great food markets (from Whole Foods on Prospect to Harvest Market on Mass Ave- and the fantastic farmers' market in their parking lot weekly in the Summer months), two great art stores right across the street from each other (I'm partial to Artist and Craftsman Supply myself, but some people don't seem to mind Pearl), and (until they finish renovating their location in Harvard Square) Cambridge's largest public library branch right on Pearl Street.
You've got Harvard and MIT grad students, low-income families in section 8 housing, the YMCA's rooming house, the homeless, the artists, and older established Cantabrigians all living within a few blocks of each other, making the neighborhood a prime people-watching melting pot.
In some ways, living in Central Square is like living in 3 or 4 different neighborhoods that are all simultaneously in the same place.
To those you think it's dangerous- you don't know what you're talking about. Go hang out in Roxbury, or Brockton, or any actually scary city, and then if you're still scared of Central, just hide in your house for the rest of your life because there's no hope for you.
In short, as I said, there's something here for everyone, and nowhere else I'd rather be.
Okay. I'm done rambling. Now who wants some whiskey? read more