Cancel

Open app

Search

Cecil Whittakers Pizza

3.7 (3 reviews)
ModeratePizza

Cecil Whittakers Pizza Photos

You might also consider

More like Cecil Whittakers Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Cecil Whittakers Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Mark G.
6
185
8

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Standard Cecil Whittaker style pizza. I've taken my family many times, always been consistent. Good service, decent place. Will visit again.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Coal Fire Bar & Tap

Coal Fire Grill & Tap

4.5(40 reviews)
16.2 mi

Wow! An amazing hidden gem in a small town that is sure to please any palate!…read more The service - 5 Stars! The staff treats you like family and are on it, no matter how busy. They are fun and made us want to keep coming back (which we did)! * Sammy - you are SPECTACULAR! The food - 5 stars! From the pretzel and yummy cheese to the pizza, absolutely spot on. The French onion soup had a depth of flavor and topped with an oversized piece of bread covered in cheese - heavenly! The salads are fresh and the dressings are on the top of the list I have tasted. The atmosphere - 5 stars! It's a lovely, yet smaller restaurant that is decorated to suite any person that walks in. Extremely clean and the patrons all know each other. The owners are welcoming and care about their customers. It's like dinner and a show with the entire interactions. I need to try the BBQ next time I'm in town!

A charming little bar & grill with standard pub fare. Service was quick on a busy Saturday…read moreafternoon. I had the "Best" French Dip, which was decent but far from the best I've ever had. Their fries are shoestring, almost similar to McDonald's, which isn't my favorite style at a sit-down restaurant. Next time I would probably order one of their specialities as they sound a little more exciting than what I got.

Photos
Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Bar and eating area by front door

Bar and eating area by front door

Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Delicious gyro! Big portions and the sweet potato fries were spot on

Delicious gyro! Big portions and the sweet potato fries were spot on

Coal Fire Grill & Tap - Big pieces of toasted raviolis for an appetizer

See all

Big pieces of toasted raviolis for an appetizer

Saucy's Pizzeria

Saucy's Pizzeria

3.5(47 reviews)
9.8 mi
•$

I've ordered from them twice now (both on Tuesdays for the buy one get one deal) and their pizza…read moremust have crack in it--it's that good. Hillsboro has very little, but the area has no shortage of pizza, but none of it is nearly as good as this! Unlike most places, it tastes completely like homemade and the herbs and the toppings make it a perfect experience for your taste buds. They're located in the same place where Pizza Junction was before it shut down (a seemingly cursed location). The staff seems very friendly and the pizza is ready in the average time (15-20 minutes). I haven't used their delivery yet, but we did carry out both times. On its own the pizza can be a little expensive, but they have lots of good deals during the week that make it cost-effective. We did Tuesday because of the Buy One Get One Free 14" or 16" deal they have on Tuesday (We got two 14" 2-toppings carry out for $14.13 with tax, making it very affordable if you use the deals!), and I know on Sundays they do a Family deal and if you order anytime after 9pm they have a late-night deal for one pizza for $9.99. They also have a gluten-free option--and I did call to ask since I have a friend whose daughter has severe Celiac's and if you ask them when you place the order they CAN prepare the gluten-free pizza in a separate area to avoid the cross contamination! A rarity in these parts.

We love coming here when we are dropping off our son at camp. We only wish it was closer to home…read more The pizza is 10/10. We love the deluxe and the chicken bacon ranch pizza. The staff is friendly and welcoming. There's a small game room for kids.

Photos
Saucy's Pizzeria
Saucy's Pizzeria - Side salad (I asked for no onion). Great size. Could use croutons. And that ranch tho!

Side salad (I asked for no onion). Great size. Could use croutons. And that ranch tho!

Saucy's Pizzeria - Daily Deals

See all

Daily Deals

Pedal ‘N Pi - Olive juice Pi

Pedal ‘N Pi

4.6(41 reviews)
16.6 mi

Another Thursday, another pizza passport stop! We ventured out to Festus again to Pedal 'N Pi…read more Part bike shop part pizza restaurant. We called ahead to let them know we were coming since we had 14 this trip and they don't take reservations. When we arrived we spoke to Jesse and let her know that there were 14 of us, it was already pretty busy and it's a pretty small space but she said she would make it work. We had arrived about a half hour earlier than everyone was meeting so we could secure seating and in the end, it all worked out! Jesse is a phenomenal asset to the restaurant! Not only did she figure out our seating, she was personable , upbeat, and on top of the whole room it seemed like. While waiting for the rest of our group we sat at the high-top tables and chatted with a couple of regulars. They gave us lots of good scoop on what to order and their recommendations were spot on. So friendly! We ordered wings, the Olive Juice Forever pizza, the BBQ chicken without onion, and a giant cinnamon roll for dessert. I loved the wings, good flavor, a good amount of sauce. We got them with ranch; it was good but very dill forward if you need to know. The Olive Juice Forever pizza was Olive Oil, mozzarella, kalamata olives, green olives, garlic, red onion, and a touch of sausage and pepperoni. I really enjoyed it, afraid it would be too salty =but it was perfect. The crust was puffy, charred perfectly, and had a good chewy bite. The giant cinnamon roll was giant! We would order it again, it was very good. I also had a beer; a Kona Big Wave or Mango Cart mixed with the Main and Mill draft. I and I really liked it. I am not a bike rider, but I do love pizza and this place was great from the service to the atmosphere to the food and drink.

I have been wanting to try Pedal'n Pi for the longest time. I don't get to Festus often, so I made…read morea special trip on a Friday. Tried the 4 Cheese (Baetje Farms Chevre goat cheese, garlic confit base, topped with mozzarella, provolone, & Parmigiano Reggiano DOP 24 months, garlic EVOO) and a bacon and green olive pizza. They get a big thumbs up for using Castelvetrano olives which are my very favorite. They are doing everything right here. Their dough is fantastic. Light and airy with the right amount of char and blistering. Cute place. I'll be back!

Photos
Pedal ‘N Pi - Kitchen

Kitchen

Pedal ‘N Pi
Pedal ‘N Pi - PNP HOUSE RED WINE

See all

PNP HOUSE RED WINE

Cecil Whittakers Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...