We had supper at the Cattleman's planned our trip around eating there. Once again the steak, filet and prime rib were excellent. Love the margaritas they serve. Look forward to anther evening there. read more

If you plan to go early, if you plan to wait in line, if you plan to go with the flow, this is your place. It's always packed. Never a dull moment. read more

Prime rib and Porterhouse was fabulous . Very relaxing ambiance. Once seated service was great. read more

Cattleman's Club - Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

Let me paint a picture for you: I took my family out for a nice dinner, ordered a steak for my son medium rare, just how he likes it. What we got looked like it had been cooked in the fiery pits of Mordor. It was so overdone, I thought they were pranking us with a piece of roof shingle. No big deal I sent it back politely. You know, like a normal person who doesn't enjoy chewing on boot leather. Fast forward through our entire meal. We're done. Plates cleared. Dessert menus offered. And guess what never showed up? That's right: The mythical replacement steak. At this point, I'm convinced it either never existed or it went to college and started a new life in another state. So I tell the server, "Hey, since we never got the steak, just take it off the bill, cool?" Apparently not cool. Because out stomps the manager like she's auditioning for an episode of Cops: Steakhouse Edition, threatening to call the actual police if I didn't pay for the steak we never received. I don't know what's more disturbing the fact that someone thinks this is a reasonable business practice or that they're willing to waste 911's time over a piece of imaginary meat. Anyway, I paid. Because I didn't want to get arrested over a phantom filet mignon. But you can bet your gristle I'll never be back. If you enjoy overcooked meat, undercooked service, and the thrill of being criminalized for asking not to pay for food you never got, this is the place for you. read more

I was in Pierre for work and I wanted to grab something to eat before I had to drive to Sioux Falls. I went around 530P on a Wednesday so less than half the tables were full. I'm not normally a fan of Prime Rib but it seemed like it was their specialty so I gave it a shot. I got a house salad with raspberry vinaigrette and Buffalo chips as my sides. The salad came out as a bowl of lettuce with dressing. They bring a caddy with shaved carrots, chopped red onion, chopped cabbage and shredded cheddar cheese. It hadn't seen that in a while. The prime rib was cooked perfectly. It is served on a plate by itself in a pool of au jus. The Buffalo chips are their version of seasoned fries. They have a little spice but it's not strong at all. I think al dinners also come with homemade Texas toast. The staff was very friendly and they recommended the best route to Sioux Falls to avoid traffic. I don't make it to Pierre often but I will definitely come back the next time I'm in town. read more

The steaks were fabulous. Cooked to perfection. The Service couldn't have been better. Holly was very attentive even though the place was packed. The Cowboy ambiance is everywhere. Fr9m the wood chips on the floor to rodeo on the is a keeper. read more

Cattleman's Club - 24oz Porterhouse with mushrooms and a baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

Fabulous steaks. Incredible service. Seasoned perfectly and great cocktails highly recommended to anyone!

Previous visits in 2010 and 2013, and reconfirming after my 2023 visit--this is STILL the best, most fun steakhouse in the Dakota's! read more

See all

They have a rely good medium rare steak. The service was really nice. if you ask for something you That people don't get they will get if for you. You can joke around with them. read more

Having been in Pierre for 4 nights pheasant hunting we were looking for some better places to eat. With some places closed due to Covid our options were more limited than usual. We did a quick search and found Cattleman's Club and I am glad we did. It will certainly become a regular place for us each year. We had a group of 10 guys, and we were hungry! We did not have to wait very long on a Tuesday night, but the parking lot was full. The appetizers we ordered were the fried mushroom, fried avocado slices, fried pickles and the Cowboy bites. All of them were really good. The Cowboy bites were labeled as "hot" but they were not at all, at least to me. Several order the prime rib, which was huge and very tasty, as were the ribeye steaks. I ordered "Ron's Pile" and it was fantastic. The picture doesn't show the actual size and height of the food on this plate. All of us were completely stuffed when we left there. This place has an interesting story which you can read about while waiting for your food. The staff took excellent care of us and they were very friendly. This will be an annual stop for us at least once, if not twice while we are in town. read more

See all

This location has a beautiful setting next to the water. Try to get a table next to the windows. The four of us split a 20 oz. prime, the 24 oz. bone-in ribeye, a few extra sides, and a fried dill pickle chips app. The pickle chips were yummy, but note they have a bit of spice to them. You could tell the meats were quality. Texas toast wasn't anything speciWe ate everything and were satisfied. read more

Cattleman's Club - Menu 8/3/20 - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

See all

The best. Can't believe Mad Marrys is still going as expensive as it is and the steaks aren't even close to the Cattlemans quality.

Awesome place! Food was delicious and the service was outstanding. We had dinner on a Tuesday night and the place was full! If you are looking for a fun night out, this is the place. read more

When here with a rather large group. Place was already packed. But they worked us in and we all had a great time. Food was warm and fresh. Service was great! read more

Fun place good steaks with an authentic country feel. Service was good despite being busy.

We had never been here, and from Yelp reviews we decided to give it a try. We ere promptly greeted at the door, she asked if there was two of us we said no for the other two were behind us. She said OK. The next gentleman walked up and said how many we at the same time as the hostess, Status to with the other to close behind. He then stated, "well I hope so" to which I replied "me too". Honestly that comment kept me from giving them 5 stars as I did not think that was professional. There were many empty tables and no one waiting to be seated. That being said, our waitress was awesome, took our appetizer order of fried avocado which was excellent, and my New York State was top notch! My wife's prime rib was OK, giving it roughly 3 out of five, my steak was five out of five. The sides were very good as were the drinks. I will try this again and suggest you visit as well. read more

Cattleman's Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

Cattleman's serves a *great* steak. It is almost always busy there, but is not a 'white tablecloth' steakhouse. It's a casual place-- sawdust on the floor, busy wait-staff. There can be a wait; we had a large group as well as reservation, so were seated after having a round of drinks at the bar. I had a bone-in ribeye and it was much better than a steak costing twice the price at some well-known chain steakhouses seen in bigger cities. [you know the types of places I'm talking about :) ] The sides are good but not over-the-top. Get the great cut of meat, baked potato & you're off to the races read more

Cattleman's Club - Bone-in Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

Great food! Great service ! Great atmosphere! If the juiciest most flavorful streak to grace my plate wasn't enough, then the friendliest service was! Also, who cannot help but fall in love with the beautiful scenery that is displayed out the windows of this very nice establishment. read more

Great food. Efficient service. Awesome atmosphere & vibe. Beautiful view. Will be back!

After a great day of hunting the Cattleman's Club was a perfect choice for dinner. I had the prime rib with loaded baked potato which was done to perfection. To top is off our table ordered pitchers of Brandy Alexander's, which filled in the cracks. The Cattleman's Club is a must visit, and I am already looking forward to next year. read more

Traveling through a few midwestern states for vacation( we are from LA, Calif) we stopped to have dinner on our last night here in SD. The staff is really nice. They have a great selection of local beers. A fav was Wasatch Apricot Hefeweizen. I had the tomato bisque soup. Soooo delicious! We ate top sirloin steaks and they were awesome! Very tender. We also had the beer sampler before dinner. We met a local Kevin who knew the family and we had a very pleasant conversation I definitely recommend this place. It's the best steak I have ever eaten! read more

Cattleman's Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

See all

Great food, quick friendly service. Lucky enough to catch the sunset off the river. Can see why it's a locals favorite

Nice place, friendly staff and manager but came for the steak! Had the ribeye and flavor was very good but very tough. 6 of us all had different cuts and all said same. We didn't try the Prime but next time i will. Nothing special but a real nice place and people. Thanks read more

Best steak I've ever had. Party of 10 and had great service. Not a long wait. Highly recommend read more

Cattleman's is a staple in the Pierre community. If you want a seat you better arrive early because there's already a line waiting at the door. It's the epitome of a western steak joint, busting at the seams with cowboys, ranchers, and saw dust. They have a great assortment of beer and spirits. The atmosphere is noisy, so it's not a place to eat if your looking for a lengthy chatter! In terms of food it can't be beat, my wife swears it's the best burger she has ever had! Personally I am partial to the Prime rib. Make sure you get a side of horseradish, it's the real deal and it's exceptional. I also always get mushrooms and onions, and it really elevates the prime rib. In addition, with the prime rib you get two side. The salads are good, and the bake potato's never disappoint. I'm not sure there's a meal here you can go wrong with. I always leave satisfied and with a heavy container of leftovers. read more

The food is always good and the people that work there are always so polite and wonderful; however, with the small dining room it's very loud with all the people talking. Also, it's a very popular spot so it fills up fast. Make sure you have plenty of time to sit, relax, and enjoy your food. read more

Popular with locals and busy right after opening. We shared an order of fried breaded green beans with a wasabi sauce; very tasty! Good selection of beers. I enjoyed an Alaskan Amber and my wife had a shandy with her nice filet, yam and side salad. I had a 10oz slice of medium rare prime rib with baked potato and steamed broccoli. We enjoyed our meal, the service was friendly and the prices were in line with the quality and quantity of the food. It's a few miles out of town, but worth the drive if you are looking for a restaurant with local vibe and decent food. read more

Most amazing steakhouse in Pierre Sd. Their steaks and prime web were out of this world. You will need more than a regular appetite to clean your plate here. Expect a little wait to be seated because this is a local Mecca and it's worth the wait. Our waitress was on her toes and provided exceptional service along with a personal touch to make this one of our favorite stops in Pierre. One particular item caught our attention and approval - along with our fresh salad came a tray with additional add ons - cheese, onions, cabbage, and shredded carrots. If you only have time for one Restuarant in Pierre, this is a must stop. Prime rib was perfectly prepared, as was their ground sirloin. Flavor abounds in every item. Like we used to say growing up - try it, you will like it. read more

We enjoyed this place. It's got a pretty view of the lake and nice, friendly service. We both had the 6 oz filet and they were good but not great. Sweet potato fries were delicious. The portions of food were quite large. We probably could have split a meal. read more

Killer steaks. Get there early to have more choices, they sell out of some kinds each night. Fun rustic sawdust floor and 5 star food.

This place has the burgers #1 in Pierre $wasn't expensive and the staff was excellent look for the lady at counter super nice

I was on a cross country road trip with my boyfriend, and as we neared the eastern half of the country we realized that we had not taken the time to get a great steak! Instead of keeping with our planned route, we ventured up to Pierre in hopes of finding just that. We found the Cattleman's Club on yelp and decided that was our destination. Everything we had was amazing and just what we were looking for. I don't remember the last time I had such a great steak. The boyfriend got an enormous cut of steak, and my smaller portion was excellent. This was definitely one of the highlights of our road trip! If you ever happen to be in the area, give this place a try! read more

Cattleman's Club - 24 oz bone in ribeye :) - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

First time in Pierre, so I looked for somewhere to eat and the Cattleman's Club sounded perfect. Drove out there and was seated by owner Cindy at the bar and received a Shiner Bock quickly. Ordered the ribeye with sautéed mushrooms and onions, which was excellent. Very tender and tasty, would definitely order again. Cold beer, great steak and service by Brian the bartender as well. I just wish it wasn't so far from Minnesota! The river view is something to see as well. read more

Cattleman's Club - Boneless ribeye, sautéed onions and mushrooms - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

Over-hyped. Service was pretty good, not great. Servers had a lot to do. Steak was good. Sirloin, I thought could have been tenderized more. Pretty close to outback. Salad was small and all iceberg (no nutrients, taste, roughage or appeal). Spicy corn soup was very good. CANNED green beans.... soggy, tasteless crap! read more

Cattleman's Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

By far the best steakhouse I have ever been to. This is a diamond in the rough. I wish I lived closer so I could come back once a month. Prices are amazing, but more importantly; so is the food! It's set on the Missouri River with the perfect view point. The steak I had was cooked perfectly and the chicken and rice soup was the best I've ever had. The staff is extremely friendly as you would expect for pierre hospitality. Can't wait to come back here! read more

Cattleman's Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

As of today, I have written 554 reviews. Of any/all reviews I have written about prime rib, please disregard. Why? Because tonight I just ate the best prime rib I have ever eaten!! Here's the deal: We arrived at Cattleman's Club at 5pm. The parking lot was filling up fast. We went in and sat at the bar (most of their patron's wanted tables since it was Saturday night). Ordered a bottle of Zinfandel wine. Then had a dinner salad with French & blue cheese dressings. The lettuce tasted as if it had just come from the field, truly fresh. For my entrée, I had the 24oz prime rib, medium rare. OK folks, this meat was unbelievable! Not just the size, but the texture, flavor, taste, everything. It was so good, I cannot find the best description!! Forget the east coast or west coast. You need to come to Pierre, SD for this steak! Oh, and the staff are great too! read more

Cindy and her family have been doing this better than anyone else for years! If you're in Pierre, there is only one place to eat. Myril's place. It's the best for miles and miles around! Sirloin done right! read more

There may not be a lot of activities to do in Pierre, SD but eating a good steak is one of them. Cattleman's is outside of town and very authentic ranch feel to the restaurant. The recommendations I were given in the menu were spot on and the amount of meat I ate put me in a meat comma for days. The steak was so flavorful I couldn't stop myself from eating the whole thing. read more

Cattleman's Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Pierre, South Dakota

WOW, I eat steak all over the US and this is one of the best steaks I have ever eaten. I had the ribeye. It was perfect. Here on a business dinner. Service was outstanding and the view over the river was perfect. Meet the owners. The bar is cool and they have saw dust all over the floor, This is a must eat at while in town. read more

Yummy steaks. Wow. Fantastic views also. The wait staff were very friendly. The only minor thing was the small baked potato.