Cancel

Open app

Search

Casey's

2.7 (3 reviews)
Open • 5:00 am - 10:00 pm

Casey's Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Casey's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 1

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Casey G.

Casey G.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Clean, well stocked, very friendly and attentive employees. Obviously people are working hard to keep up standards.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Casey's

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 1,572 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Red Devil Pizza & Deli - Carolina gold chicken wings

Red Devil Pizza & Deli

(4 reviews)

Location: 18 S 2nd Street, Tipp City Ohio Website: find…read morethem on FB Hours: see site Parking: street parking Service: very good Stopped into this newly opened by new owner location on Saturday night to order a variety from their menu. (New owners bought DJ's Pizza Alley not long ago) Despite being busy, we were greeted quickly and our order was taken and the estimated wait (50 minutes) was right on - our order was ready when we returned. We placed our order and chose to go for a walk, returning just a few minutes before our promise time and they were just pulling together the last part of our order. Delightful! We ordered a small pepperoni pizza, beef-mushroom sub, and 10 garlic-parm chicken wings. The location's new owners updated the store to also offer a selection of deli food items, included various meats, cheeses, salads, and sides - as well as limited grocery items (bread, milk, eggs) - making this a great add for Tipp City. The food was good. The staff was working hard, and friendly. The chicken wings were my favorite - really crispy - perfectly cooked and the sauce was excellent. The sub is oven baked and the bread is soft and fluffy, with a great crust from being baked. Stop in!

This is my 1st review in years, but I had to write it. We wanted wings and pizza and gave Red Devil…read morea try and boy were we impressed! Pizza was amazing and the wings were cooked to perfection. I recommend requesting extra crispy with Buffalo sauce. Will be a regular customer here.

Tipp City Pizza - Salad and a beer

Tipp City Pizza

(56 reviews)

$$

Outstanding spot for pizza - including a nice selection of starters and salads!…read moreGenuine wood-fired thin crust pizza, several recipes to choose from - with a lovely mix of sauces and toppings. We ordered 5 pizzas and this fed 8 people with just a touch leftover for a lucky houseguest this week. This venue is just plain fun. You order at the counter and the staff delivers your order to your table number. The 8 of us shared 2 salads (plenty for 2-3 people each if you have your hearts set on eating lots of pizza or have 1 salad as your entree) .... We ordered 2 pepperoni (with hot honey), 1 butcher, 1 margarita, and 1 vegetarian pizza. All delightfully delicious and everyone was happy. Yep - it's that good!

Tipp City, Ohio OMG , where to begin with this one …read more.... walk- in , order your food at a counter, given a " number " for your table , self serve soda machine , reminding me of McDonald's in the children's play area , only darker . And it's like a " bar / tavern " vibe , but with kids running around. Ordered a "large" supreme pizza , when the pizza was delivered , it clearly was NOT large ..... it was more like a cheap version of Tostitos pizza , and was WAY too spicy...... I could only choke down 3 squares of pizza ....( what a way to spend my Valentine's Day ) ...... thank God for the garlic toast , which was French bread loaded with butter and garlic . * I'm a pizza fanatic ..... this place is on the very bottom of my list of pizza joints ..... I would have rather bought a frozen pizza and garlic knots and cooked it myself , instead of forking out about 45.00 for a tiny pizza and mediocre garlic bread . * New Year Resolution : I'll be visiting at least 1-2 restaurants a week that I've never been to , and putting my reviews on Yelp ....

Cassano's Pizza King - Hog Wild pizza

Cassano's Pizza King

(15 reviews)

$$

Good pizza…read more Location: 975 Main Street, Tipp City Ohio Website: www.cassanos.com Ordered on their online app. Estimate for delivery was spot-on, but absolutely no confirmation - neither email, nor text. I called to confirm my order, which was simple enough, but it was a call center and not entirely accurate. The information was helpful enough ...order was confirmed and arrived within the original window. The pizza is better than average. In fact, it is quite good. We ordered a large deluxe with no mushrooms on one half. The amount of toppings? Generous. Plenty of crumbled sausage is the predominant topping. Pepperoni, green pepper, onion, mushroom (on requested half) were nicely balanced. The crust is thin, but soft - edges are moderately crisp. The large pizza was cut into squares, making this very easy to eat. The sauce is sweet but not overpowering. The amount of cheese is perfect, although a bit more may have secured the toppings better. My only criticism is the toppings are very loose and a good portion ends up falling off onto your plate, table, lap... but honestly there is plenty to spare. Tips: 1) check out deals, coupons - the large was about $20 without a coupon 2) allow time for delivery, if in a rush consider picking up as carry out

Pizza was burned. While I waited for our order, the woman in front of me got her pizza after they…read moreburned the first one. This one was wrong as they forgot the extra cheese. When I got mine, I opened the boxes to see if they were right. Both were over cooked. I told the manager, he ignored me. I paid and call corporate to complain. Got no where. Not going back to that location.

Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...