It's been years since I've been to a Turonis and never this one in Newburgh. We decided to have…read morelunch there recently. We started out with Garlic Cheez Toast - lots of cheese and crispy bread. Yummy. Then we each had a 9-inch pizza. I built my own with beef, mild pepper rings, spinach and mushrooms. I love the thin crust and it was crispy all over - no soggy crust here. I really couldn't taste the spinach or the sauce but it was good. I looked at the menu later and there is a 7-inch lunch pizza which I would have liked to have since this 9-inch was too much for me. I wish the staff would have mentioned that to us. Next time! It also was really dark in the restaurant. We had a hard time reading the menu. But I'm sure we'll be back.

I am in town for work and sat in the bar area…read more I had the Bearded Bulldog American IPA and the 9" Lots a Meat pizza. The pizza came out hot and the crust had a slight crunch to it, which was great. Pizza had a good flavor with plenty of meat. The service was very good. The bar area is 21 and over so it was couples in the booths/seating area and a few guys at the bar top. Cool decorations and lighting. I have been here a few times and will be back on my next visit.

I ordered fat boys pizza while staying in the area for work. This place is PICK UP ONLY!! No…read moredelivery, no dining in, only pick up. The pizza itself was excellent, thin crust and loaded with toppings! This is one of those pizzas that is actually better reheated the next day, hard to believe but it's true!! I will definitely get another pizza when I return to the area.

Ordered a pizza thru yelp delivered by grubhub and it was left on the porch in the freezing cold…read morewith notification it was there. Discovered two hours later. When ordering, I unchecked the box for contactless delivery but did not leave instructions for the driver to knock or ring a doorbell. Grubhub doesn't know how to deliver food and fatboys doesn't care what condition their food is delivered to you. I suggest using neither ever again, unless you prefer your food cold.​

Checked prices online... went there 3 hours later and ordered at the counter --- prices were now…read morehigher.... they had a menu card and what they charged matched, but were higher than their website. *** JUST FIGURED OUT THEIR PRICING PROBLEM: Their full website shows outdated prices, while their mobile website shows updated/higher prices ---- still the case as of January 6, 2026 ****

We dined in for lunch at the Newburgh location. The lady who helped us at the counter was very…read morenice. The dining room was clean, but the tables were a total 70s throwback, with giant faded photographs of pizzas on them. Like life size extra- large pizzas??? Well, it is a pizza place.... I guess. PK is known for their strombolis. We got a whole deluxe strom. A hot ham and cheese, and an order of wings, 2 bottled sodas ( fountain was broken). The wings were practically inedible, they had a mealy texture, the skin was soft, not crispy... eww . The sandwiches, while large, were quite dry. Nothing juicy or drippy or saucy..... just dry. The ranch dip from the wings did help a couple bites. So, 46 dollars and change later, sadly won't be back to PK.

The pizza wasn't bad, but there were a couple issues that made it difficult to order from them…read more First, they wouldn't accept any phone orders when I called. Second, the ordering ap is a little confusing and not very intuitive. It tries to push you to ordering a standard pizza design they offer. So, individual taste may be hard to get. The pizza wasn't bad cheap comparatively, but was also small and very thin. Last, it was delivered by a third party and was much longer than originally shown. All in, I'd give them another chance.

Writing this while still waiting for my online order pickup... I ordered online an hour and a half…read moreago. I got here a little over an ago & they are still unable to give me a time of when my pizza will be ready. EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED AND UPSET. My husband left to take our toddler home because she behave well for that long without being food & needed dinner. He had to go get her food somewhere else since she literally goes to bed in 15 minutes. I was told "its not looking good" when I asked how much longer. The line has cleared through 6 times. All online order people are fuming at this ridiculous process. Either turn off your online ordering or figure it out. We will not be returning for a while & we're regular customers.

On a recent work trip I stumbled into Archie and Clyde's since they were conveniently located close…read moreto my hotel. They are an all ages establishment with an over 21 only bar area. I love sitting at the bar rail, and their rail can sit at least 30 people, nice and big! The bartenders are very friendly and the service was excellent! My go to item was their large thin crust pizza. It's always excellently cooked and crispy edges! Next time I'm in the area for work, I'll be sure to stop by for more delicious pizza and cold beer!

Worst excuse for a stromboli. $14+ please do yourself a big favor and don't waste your moneyread more

This is not the first time I have requested certain items and not received them, and I always get…read morethe: it wasn't on the order which is crap. The latest I ordered 2 chicken alfredo and 1-8 piece regular and 1-8 piece honey barbequed wings (and 3 ranch dressings). I called after my boy woke up to eat them there was no dressing, so I called in and what did I get a very argumentive employee saying it wasn't part of the order which is B.S. He kept wanting to give to the manager which, why so I can hear the same crap. Look I paid over $ 40.00 for no more than what I ordered and have to put up with this crap over 3 ranch dips. I don't expect to hear anything back because I didn't the last time. You talk the talk, but don't walk the walk over 3 fricken ranch dressings. Facebook is next, and look my history up, I spend my share, or used to in Newburgh, last time heck with it, Just the little things. Have a wonderful weekend over 3 ranch dips and an argumentived employee. Greg M.

Really good pizza, and as long as they still have the $7 for 12 inch 2 topping coupon deal, it's…read morethe best value in the Evansville area. $7 will feed a hungry teenager.

Watering down drinks, I had 4 drinks and no buzz. My friend and I had several drinks and after the…read morefirst one there was nooo alcohol in the mixed drink. Only get a bottled drink.

Pizza tasted really good though it looked burnt. Went there for Drunksgiving because they…read moreadvertised a band and prizes. They never gave anything away :(

This place has consistently failed to be on time and/or messed up the order. They deliver pizzas…read morehours late and act like they have no control and don't really care. If the owner really cared, he would step in and fix the problem. Newburgh deserves better.

This place has no management. They are literally all teenagers. No one washes their hands, no one…read morefollows ticket instructions, no one gives a ****. I will NEVER give this location another dime.

Best bar in Newburgh, great local spot. Cheap drinks, delicious food, would recommend to anyone!!read more

Just very disappointing. We ordered the new York strip $30. It was the saddest, thinnest piece of…read moregray meat. It had absolutely no flavor, full of gristle. While we were still eating the waitress came up and asked how we were gonna pay. I said he is even finished eating yet. Her response...oh So yeah we won't be going back

I am so happy to have found MOD pizza in Evansville. I am from Indianapolis where we had one for…read moreseveral years near the fashion mall. Unfortunately they closed their doors about a year ago, so I was left without my favorite pizza joint. I found this location in Evansville when I was traveling with my kids to TN. I'm sooo glad we stopped. The staff was great, Kayla was our pizza artist for this meal, and the ingredients were awesome and just how I remember them. Kayla put together our pizzas and had them out to us in no time. She was super friendly and patient with my kids, and made the experience worth stopping for. The food was great and made to perfection, and the place was clean and inviting. This is now going to be a tradition any time we head south!!

Everything was great! I enjoyed my pizza, it was delicious! Fast service and great customer service!read more