Checked prices online... went there 3 hours later and ordered at the counter --- prices were now higher.... they had a menu card and what they charged matched, but were higher than their website. *** JUST FIGURED OUT THEIR PRICING PROBLEM: Their full website shows outdated prices, while their mobile website shows updated/higher prices ---- still the case as of January 6, 2026 **** read more

We dined in for lunch at the Newburgh location. The lady who helped us at the counter was very nice. The dining room was clean, but the tables were a total 70s throwback, with giant faded photographs of pizzas on them. Like life size extra- large pizzas??? Well, it is a pizza place.... I guess. PK is known for their strombolis. We got a whole deluxe strom. A hot ham and cheese, and an order of wings, 2 bottled sodas ( fountain was broken). The wings were practically inedible, they had a mealy texture, the skin was soft, not crispy... eww . The sandwiches, while large, were quite dry. Nothing juicy or drippy or saucy..... just dry. The ranch dip from the wings did help a couple bites. So, 46 dollars and change later, sadly won't be back to PK. read more

See all

We are from Evansville, but have moved away. We have to have a stromboli when we are in town. It's one of our staples.

If I could put less stars I would. I ordered the food 3 days in advance and still waited over a hour for the food which needed to be ready at a certain time(which is why I ordered it online) . They were highly understaffed. and whoever the manager is should be fired. clearly you can't manage or logistically coordinate the meat to the bun. shit Ill come manage this place for $30 a hour in my free time. highly disappointed would not recommend if you have to have anywhere to be or ordered thinking it will be quick, cause it ain't. read more

Wow this place has went downhill used to go here and loved it don't even bother. Canned mushrooms on a Strom and disgusting like the ingredients came from some old crappy wak mart . So disgusting read more

Best Stroms anywhere in the tri-state area. I recently moved back to Evansville after being gone for over 30 years and the first meal that I had was a pizza King Strom. read more

Very unassuming place, that my husband has raved about for all the years while we lived in Oregon. Now that we have moved back, the first thing he wanted was....a Stromboli! I tried the Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli and I gotta tell ya- it was amazing. I want another one already! read more

Pizza King - a sandwich wrapped in tin foil - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

We called ahead for our Strombolis , not sure why we called ahead (about an hour and half) my husband went in to pick up...not only was it unavailable but then waited around for 30 minutes to get our food we will NOT be going to that location EVER!! I told my husband that I would call and talk to management, he said no point!! This was Friday early evening before we were going to drive in at Reo read more

Bread sticks and cinnamon-sticks were amazing!! Orders are quickly ready when we come to pick them up! A+

I haven't had Pizza King for YEARS AND YEARS because I moved out of the area. My dad has always liked it so we all grabbed a Texas BBQ Stromboli, and it's sooooo good. I wish there was one closer to me so I could get it more often and try the rest of the menu! read more

My favorite place for Stromboli is Pizza King. I always order the hot one. Not too spicy for my tastes. I also like their pizza. The decor here is so so. They have beer and a big screen in the dining area. I typically get it to go. Great local place. read more

See all

My dad is 77 and he likes his sandwiches extra toasted with extra sauce. I love him and like to get him what he likes whenever possible. We have been ordering from pizza king since i was a young child. Ordered the texas bbq today, xtra sauce, xtra toasted, same as always. No attempt was made to follow instructions, almost like they dont care hmmm. This happens about half the time, but today it made me mad. Maybe the one on weinbach will do better, we never had any problems at that location. Sandwich was dry and no evidence of toasting was present. How hard is it to give customers what they ask for?? read more

While visiting family in Newburgh during the summer, I placed my first order ever at Pizza King. Although I had seen Pizza King over years, I had never before tried it. So, at the end of a long day of driving from North Carolina, I decided that would be the day--it seemed like an easy solution to the question, "What's for dinner?". However, like Richard Marx used to sing, I should have known better--in this case, when no one would answer the phone when I called to place an order. Literally, no one answered. I even wondered whether the restaurant was open. In today's world of staff shortages, though, I decided to give Pizza King the benefit of the doubt and drive to the restaurant so I could place an order. While Howard Jones might be convinced that things can only get better, in this instance they never did. (Sorry, Howard.). When I walked through the front door, there was a man sitting at the counter, while a woman and an other man were handling the kitchen. They were doing all the work and payed little attention to my entry. Meanwhile, the man at the counter acted as though he could not care less about me as a customer, and he even struggled a little to take the order, despite my delivering it to him very plainly and directly. More determined than ever, though, I pushed through and completed the order . . . even though the entire time my Spidey sense was screaming at me to abort this mission. I was told that it going to take over half an hour before the food would be ready, so I went home to wait with family. When I returned, the man at the counter had not moved from his spot, although this time he now was struggling with a telephone conversation while eating a snack! (I felt sorry for the person at the other end of that phone call . . . and by then I absolutely was certain that I should have listened to my 30-minute younger self.) Initially, the total check amount struck me as high, and I certainly was convinced of that fact when I arrived at home and tried the food. Without a doubt, I had overpaid for what I received. The pizza itself was nothing less than a Hungry Howie's reject. And the chicken wings? Well, we had ordered the mild variety, but none of us--at least four different people tried them--could identify the flavor that was actually on the wings. We struggled through some of the food but threw away more than I care to admit. It was the equivalent of wiping your behind with dollar bills. Overall, this was an absolute horrific experience--I thought about calling it a dining experience but wisely changed my mind--and I can promise you that we never will return to this place. Long live the king? Meh. read more

Pretty delicious take out pizza place. I got some roasted wings and a veggie pizza. I waited a bit for the wings. They were made to order though, so it was worth it. The wings were tender and juicy and had a nice flavor. Pizza had a crispy crust and fresh toppings too. The building needs serious renovations though. read more

My Dad and Aunt came here a long time ago and divided to introduce me to it. The cheesy breadsticks are my favorite and the pizza is really good too. Satisfaction guaranteed. read more

Very disappointed. I hate posting negative reviews and always try to find something positive. This time nothing.... Their Website says open till 10. Walked in at 7 and were immediately told the dining room closed at 7 and the restaurant is closing at 8. We used to love this place but the lack of customer service is really making me think twice about where I take my family for dinner. read more

Best Stromboli's in the World! Not all Pizza King's are created equally, this one is the best.

Worst pizza king location ever. Delivery was quick. But, Oder takers don't listen, pizza was destroyed and they don't give refunds. read more

Pizza King - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Excellent Texas BBQ! I give it 5 Stars. The TV was so loud that it was difficult to hold a conversation. Employees who have time to watch TV would have time to clean. read more

The service is absolute shit! The food is decent but they just don't give a damn. I left this place beyond pissed off. Also I called ahead and had my order placed and they put me on hold for 5 minutes plus my order was late. Good food but shit workers! read more

Best strombolis ever! I like to add mushrooms to mine! Service is quick ! Pizza is average but good.

Pizza is great for a local shop, I would definitely suggest you try the Texas BBQ Stromboli.

I grew up in Newburgh eating pizza and Stromboli's and now that we live in another state, we always try to hit it up when in town.... Tonight we tried!! First, they answered and immediately asked if I could be put on hold. Really no choice but to hold because they don't wait for a response. They set the phone down and I just waited. Unfortunately, no one came back. And then it was disconnected. I called again, and AGAIN I was getting placed on hold. I sort of yelled, "no wait!" I tried to explain that I was not yelling at them but wanted to get his attention so that I would not be set aside and hung up on a second time , but he set it down again!! Really??!! He did finally come back but never acknowledging the fact that twice I was just put on hold. I began to order, but my mom in the backroad asked if I was going to complain about waiting for over ten minutes, I softly said ," no, I don't want them to spit on or do something to my food!" He yelled back into the phone, "Wow!" And then hung up on me. Omg!! I called a third time; this time it was not to order a yummy sandwich at all! I asked for a manager!! Would you believe that the person who had hung up on me twice Is the person running this place? I did not begin to raise my voice until he began telling me that I was rude and have no idea what is going on. I do know that I was not treated as a customer worth taking an order from. I do know that I was talked sassy too and extremely unprofessionally. I do know that if this person is not the owner, then the owner should know that I, who was planning on getting two pizzas and two large Stromboli's, went down the road to Turoni's and fed my family. Unfortunately, I will now go back to Georgia without getting my Stromboli fix and may never get one again, but I WILL NOT spend money at a place that has employees ( manager) that is so very rude. read more

here we are on a friday p.m.. yes we were told it would be 45 minuets to an hour. and it was exactly that. the food was still slightly warm, and everyones sandwich which was 4 footlong sandwiches were burnt, not only in one spot but all the way down the top and bottom of the bun.we have eaten at pizza king on the west side and newburgh. will we eat there again, i think not. read more