We love Sandy's pizza! My parents used to come here when they lived in fort branch in highschool! So now it's a must go to every time we come to visit. I've been told you have to ask for the pizza coals fired but I love it either way. They cut the pizza into squares which is fun and yummy. They also have a salad bar if you eat in. read more

The service was great. Melissa was a real good and attentive waitress. I tried the jumbo wings, they are smoked and seasoned with 15 choice of sauce or dry rub. They were really tasty but not served hot. I also had a side salad. It was served in to go container. It would've been nicer if it would've been in a bowl instead of a clamshell container since I was dining in. The cheesy breadsticks were really good. Two sauces for a nice touch. They have Pepsi products. The dining room has a great field to a lot of nostalgic old store, signs and old grocery store signs and gas station signs. The wood walls are a nice touch to make it feel really homie and the dining room was really warm on a cold night. read more

See all

This is your stereotypical local food place that gets by on its former reputation. I literally just stood at the counter while 3 young kids were too concerned with packing things up to even acknowledge a customer. I know for sure two of them 100% knew I was there but didn't care. I finally had to ask can I get some help and If anyone was actually working tonight. I'm sure I was called some names but that was ridiculous. One went to get someone finally did she apologize no of course not. If it weren't for Toyota orders I can't imagine this place would ever make it. Now at one time probably around 10 years ago maybe not that long ago it was a great place. We never order from there just thought id give it a shot being so close but the service was just unreal. I'm sure they'll have a million excuses but that was blatant disregard. I recommend Bobes or Roscoes in Princeton. Follow-up, the owner claims they were training high school kids, last time I checked training involved instruction and mentorship. This wasn't a training issue this was a management issue it lack there of. Then recommended I buy a pizza place in princeton that closed and see how I do. If I were to own and run a business I wouldn't be making excuses for my incompetence and blaming high school kids for a customers bad experience in my establishment. As previously mentioned you would be in the same boat if it weren't for Toyota. read more

What a cute place and the memorabilia is awesome ! Wish I would have took more photos but if you like Coke , they have some items I have never seen before ! read more

See all

So I'll start off by saying it's not the same as when the old owners had it, but it has gotten much better in the past years. I think the lack of a buffet is a bummer, and the food can be very inconsistent. That being said, when it's made right, it's very good. I also tried their new smoked wings, and they were awesome. My word of advice if the owners see this is to be more stringent of their product, making sure they have good quality control, and stop with the stupid bbq plate lunches. I get you're trying to do something new but just stick to pizza, or open up the buffet again. Pizza is usually pretty good. Smoked wings were really good. Service is awesome. Way to go Sandy's. If you told me I would be writing a positive review of this place a couple years ago I'd think you were bs'ing me. But it has definently come around. read more

They deliver...but don't expect it to be delivered when you schedule it. Daughter called in an order during the day to be delivered at 6 that night for a birthday party...pizza was about 30 minutes late. Also, pizza was pretty pricey for the size and toppings. Don't know if I'd get them again. Will say, the sweet red peppers are definitely awesome though. read more

Great pizza, great breadsticks and great drinks. Staff is friendly and very helpful. But if anyone your group wants a salad, they are not good at all. Big chunk a of iceberg lettuce the stuff you throw away if you made it at home. Everything else on the menu is good. read more

Do not go here. Trust me. Loved this place growing up. There have been major changes in the last 5 years. They've changed their pizza, service was terrible, and the place has lost any charm it once had. This was a sad experience. read more

ordered food at 4:25 and they said it would be ready at 5:10. I set in the restaurant until 6:25 waiting for my food that I had already paid for. The manager was unapologetic and said it wasn't their fault. I will not be ordering from here again. read more

Yes we have always got Sandy's pizza in Ft Branch and it's usually delicious last night my kids and grandkids all came to see me as I haven't been well for a good while so I ordered pizza to feed everyone I ordered an all meat add pineapple large pizza and I also ordered an large pizza original from there with the red peppers and everything .....giving we live near elberfield so my son went to pick pizza up so by time the grandkids got to eat they was starving and unfortunately we had the worst pizzas ever it tasted like crust and no sauce at all completely DRY and very limited toppings on it I told them to put the perperchinnis not in the box touching the pizzas because of the little grands eating it everyone knows it's not very cheap to eat there and I actually thought about ordering pizza from two other places but talked myself outta it because we haven't ate their yet so I went with Sandy's and I regret every minute of it I can honestly say I'm not sure if we will be going back there for a good long time I mean who eats pizza with no sauce dry dry dry never again I also called about it today which we got it later last night and I asked for a manager and this guy said he was a manager but all he could say was someone ordered pizza last night with NO Sauce so I'm sure they got orders mixed up and all he could say was he was sorry about that .......,yeah I was too considering I was feeding my kids n grand kids needless to say a lot of the kids plates pizza got tossed in the trash I was so disappointed sending them home from Mimi's hungry that's not me at all!!! Sandys never offered to make those two pizzas over or even replacing them when I order them next time so this definitely has pushed me to not order from them again heck Pizza hutt is alot better then what we got at Sandy's!!!!!!! read more

Interesting interior & exterior. Definitely worth the drive off the beaten path. Full of memorabilia from the 30's through the 80's. Also, the pizza (square cut) is pretty good! read more

See all

Am from out of town and came for a wedding. Hardly ever leave yelp reviews but felt this place deserves it. We picked ir because it was close to where we had to be. I love local food establishments when traveling so decided to give it a try. The environment was great! Neat inside and our decorations of vintage advertising which was perfect. Pizza was outstanding. The waitress was friendly and on top of it as we were in a hurry. The root-beer was great and the beer probably the coldest I have ever had. Restrooms very clean. Told my wife that was a good experience and then on the way out ever single worker thanked us for coming and said to please come back. In this day and age I will give this five stars and if in Fort Branch or close again will be my food stop. Well done. read more

So much to say. First with many empty tables it took 15 minutes for anyone to come take our order. Then a 45 minute wait for the worst pizza I've ever had. It was unanimous. My sausage and onion pizza had no sausage, so I had a flavorless, spice-less, onion pizza. My son said it was the worst pizza he'd ever had and my grandson agreed. I've been hearing how good it is for a long time, but it's apparently gone downhill. The flavor was like those 99 cent frozen pizzas at Walmart. They deducted my meatless pizza because I took it back and showed them there was no sausage. But I'm out $42 for the other two. Cool looking inside, but avoid it. read more

I remember years ago this was the best place to get pizza in Gibson county. It has really went down hill since being sold. Tonight was the end for me. Ordered 2 stroms and a medium pizza. I should have checked before I left there with them, cause it was all burnt. I'm not talking well done. The cheese around the outside of the pizza was black. The buns on the stroms were also burnt an crunchy. They knew it was burnt an just chose to ignore it. read more

The lunch buffet is usually pretty good. I like the Stromboli. The sweet red peppers are my favorite. They make a pizza that's about 3 foot diameter. It's hilariously awesome. I love it. read more

See all

Ordered ham & cheese sandwich and a sweet BBQ sandwich. It took QUITE a long time before food came out, only to learn they made the wrong thing and so only one sandwich came out. No apologies. Some communication would've been nice as we say there very hungry wondering what was up. We could've asked server if she was around at all, but she wasn't. There are enough restaurant choices that I don't think there is a need to return here. read more

See all

This is hands down the best pizza around! The roasted red pepper pizza is the absolute best!!! My family and I went for dinner and we had an excellent experience here! Then food was all delicious, the server was attentive, and the atmosphere is fun! They were busy but we had a very short wait for a table. I actually would like to have them start to do catering for my offfice as they serve other Italian type pasta dishes. Again, you can't go wrong with the fools here ad my family will be back!!! A gem of a find! read more

Officially done with Sandy's. Haven't ordered in a while after being disappointed so many times, but was super busy today and thought I'd try it to save me some time. Big mistake!! Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and added mushrooms to half. There were literally 6 mushrooms on my half, I counted. My daughter also wanted spaghetti and it was ok, I guess. But the worst part is we are now both sick. 30 minutes after eating we were both running to the bathroom. Yep, never again. read more

Husband had the Stromboli sandwich and was very pleased! However; they asked if he wanted Lays chips or Grippos. He said Grippos and was given barbecue flavor, which he doesn't like. So, make sure you ask. I had a pizza, not knowing they put a lot of oregano on it. When I told them I didn't like the oregano, they made me a new pizza very quickly. Service was excellent and everyone was very friendly and welcoming. The restaurant and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely return when we are in the area! read more

I hate that I have to write this review but it deserves the attention. The food is good. The root beer is great. The staff and the service? Absolutely pathetic. It's a Sunday night there are maybe 2 people in the place and the waitress says "I'll be right with you" (after 15 mins of us sitting there without drinks) and then proceeds to bring out item after item to the other table for 10 more minutes. We hit the 30 minute mark and I gave up. I have absolutely quit this place. Not the first time, usually it takes at least 15 minutes to get service. I get it if it's busy but it was dead tonight. This is a place we usually try to go to before the races at Tri-State but not any longer. I will buy a meal at the track and continue to support local businesses that actually care about their customers like Dewig's. This place just lost 10-12 meals a year from us (occasionally with 10+ people in the party) and also big orders for takeout. Don't waste your time on this place, the staff will make you regret it. read more

The best hometown pizza I've had, period. Worth the trouble to get here. We order the PIZZA WITH STROMBOLI TOPPING AND SWEET RED PEPPERS, which is amazing. The sweet red peppers are marinated in house and it shows. The Stromboli topping is the perfect complement to the sweet red peppers. Seriously, you're missing out if you don't eat here. read more

Sandy's Pizza - Pizza with sweet red peppers and stromboli topping! You MUST try this! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Branch, Indiana

They serve a decent pizza, with extremely large sizes. The service is slow, but the food is worth the wait.

What a disappointment, again.. Having been a weekly regular of Sandy's Pizza since before '86, lately the quality has really been getting worse. Sad to say that I'm not sure if we'll be back. The menu hasn't changed since the business was sold, but the food quality has definitely suffered. On this visit (Tuesday night buffet), we had the buffet, which is pizza, stroms, spaghetti, breadsticks, salad, soft serve ice cream, and desert pizza. Every pizza had a form of veggie or peppers, with no cheese, pepperoni, or meat options. Had to ask the staff to make a kid friendly pizza (cheese, pepperoni, ham, etc). Took awhile after a staff member said there wasn't that much onion on one pizza, (seriously?) and they instead made a combo... Had to ask a second time to get a cheese (which was completely eaten before the previously made combo pizza)... Most of the ingredients seem to have changed, and the flavor has suffered. Cheese is different, as well as the strom sausage. The strom was cold, messy with hard bread, but the salad bar was clean this time, compared to last time. Not one person came around checking on guests, so expect to completely serve yourself. The place was really void of guests compared to the past, which used to be well worth the wait to get a table. Our last pizza ordered to go was unfit to eat, and was pitched away, so if we return, it will be awhile. Sad really... Great decor, but not nearly enough to make up for bad tasting food and lacking service... read more

1 pizza to choose from on the buffet, drinks were out, salad bar was low and ice cream was spoiled! Horrible experience

This place used to be great but the new owner has ruined it. We've tried it once a year since it sold and it just gets worse. This time the buffet had one old pizza, the pasta bar was ice cold, sodas were out, and ice cream tasted spoiled. Needs to close the doors. read more

Bad customer service . food is TERRIBLE. When I order everything is burnt . I know places get busy but it took 2 hours for delivery.

Good pizza but never answer phone for orders. Very lazy.need to hire more people if they can't keep up.going to Casey's pizza

The atmosphere and wonderful smell upon entering Sandy's was very welcoming. The seating is unique and eclectic (self seating btw) We ordered the family bread sticks, which were a little dry and not too exciting but the Combination Party Pizza was amazing. (Feeds 4 to 6 we had tons of leftovers) They took around 20 min to get the pizza out to our table. We noticed that the salad bar was dirty behind the glass ..not good. Sandy's also used paper plates and plastic forks but we pretty much ate the pizza with your hands anyway so the roll of paper towels on the table came in handy. I would definitely go back, as I said the party pizza was amazing fresh from the deck oven. read more

Sandy's Pizza - Combo Party Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Branch, Indiana

See all

Fantastic !!! The very best oven brick pizza! Epic! The red roasted peppers are amazing! Highly recommend them!

I love the decor of this place first off you have the blues brothers in one corner and Elvis in the next, not to mention they have an entire section devoted to coke memorabilia, the pizza was good but not spectacular it would been nice for more variety in the pizza, they also serve beer pitchers at a reasonable price. Bottom line: its worth a try if you want some pizza and beer at a decent price. read more

I can't believe how terrible the food is now. Used to be the best hidden gem in the tri state. Stop making bad food to save money.

Sensational pizza. Always worth the drive from Newburgh. Favorite topping: sweet red peppers.

We came here after a ball game. Everybody always raves about the pizza at Sandy's, so we thought we would try it out while in the are. They had a buffet. We had to request that they put a cheese pizza and a plain pepperoni pizza on the buffet as all the available pizzas were geared toward adults. They were happy to make it. They made one half and half . The pizza we requested was gone within 5 minutes because apparently we weren't the only people who wanted single topping pizzas. Our kids loved the smoothie machine but did not care for the pizza. The salad bar had lots of choices. The breadsticks were bland. My husband didn't care much for the Stromboli. I would return if we were in the area but would not make a special trip to this restaurant. read more

Very good Pizza at a Great price. Large pizza, two drinks for less than 20!

Surprisingly good pizza for a pretty reasonable price. Though it won't be mistaken for deep dish, the pizza actually has some crust, which makes it stand out from the ubiquitous Evansville cracker crust. One downside is that topping choices are fairly limited. The sweet red peppers are recommended. I'm not sure I'd drive out of my way to get to Sandy's, but if I were in the area, I wouldn't hesitate to drop in. read more

Sweet red peppers on pizza are the specialty and it tastes amazing. My family lives in Nashville, TN but my parents live in Elberfeld. We always go here when visiting. read more

Best pizza in the tri-state area! If you haven't been to Sandys Pizza it is well worth the trip. From the classic decor in the restaurant to the famous sweet red peppers Sandys Pizza will keep you coming back for more. Also, if you haven't seen a 30 inch pizza, you owe it to yourself to go and see the largest pizza in the tri-state. read more

See all

This pizza place has gone down hill in a big way. My last 3 times eating Sandy's has been a disaster. The pizza has little to no sauce, the grinder had little to no Mayo and on our last order they forgot our breadsticks. The driver was nice about it but the lady running the phones where rude. It's not the same since Sandy sold the place. They cut corners and Services is terrible. read more

Food was ok. Second time I have eaten there. Both times it took 10+min to get waited on and 30+min to get food. There was only two of us in our party. The place was not busy. It looked like to me lots of help in kitchen talking. read more

Great little local shop who does lots of business. Great pizza. You have to try the little sweet red peppers, they are known for this topping which is a "family secret". Always busy @ lunch during the buffet hours. They deliver to all of us folk in rural Gibson Co. Especially TMMI! Like most little hometown joints they also have beer on tap. Bud, BudLight & even AmberBock. read more